Car battery keeps dying
#1
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Car battery keeps dying
Hey guys
i have a 2008 A6 w 65k miles. The battery had died on me twice in the past couple months and shutters on most start ups. Winter has been tough here and the car is rarely driven. I basically keep it around for emergency second car use and drive it maybe every three weeks.
I made a habit to recharge the battery once a week. Basically start it up and rev it in the garage to 2k-3k RPM for 15 minutes until the engine is at temperature (there is no battery meter gauge). It used to go fine for a week at a time doing this, but now it seems like it’s struggling to go for 4 days. And it’s now dead
the battery is maybe 3 years old. Do I simply need a new battery? Or could it be something else? What should I do going forward if I only need to drive it every few weeks? Don’t know much about trickle chargers, but maybe that’s an option.
i have a 2008 A6 w 65k miles. The battery had died on me twice in the past couple months and shutters on most start ups. Winter has been tough here and the car is rarely driven. I basically keep it around for emergency second car use and drive it maybe every three weeks.
I made a habit to recharge the battery once a week. Basically start it up and rev it in the garage to 2k-3k RPM for 15 minutes until the engine is at temperature (there is no battery meter gauge). It used to go fine for a week at a time doing this, but now it seems like it’s struggling to go for 4 days. And it’s now dead
the battery is maybe 3 years old. Do I simply need a new battery? Or could it be something else? What should I do going forward if I only need to drive it every few weeks? Don’t know much about trickle chargers, but maybe that’s an option.
#2
Moderator
Trickle charger was my first though, for a rarely driven car.
Any electronics that might be remaining on?
Any electronics that might be remaining on?
The following users liked this post:
TylerT (04-05-2018)
#4
Safety Car
Thread Starter
thanks. I keep the headlights on auto mode, bluetooth is active, and there is an ipod charger cord through the cigarette lighter (but not connected to a device). I doubt any of those have a draw, but maybe i should turn off the bluetooth function and disconnect the cord. the battery is never 100% dead, but the headlights and interior lights flicker when i try to turn on the car. even when i go to start it once a week for recharging purposes, you could tell the car is struggling even when it does turn on. now the engine wont turn on.
i think ill pick up a Duralast Gold ~180, do a self install, and look into a trickle charger
i think ill pick up a Duralast Gold ~180, do a self install, and look into a trickle charger
#5
Moderator
Regional Coordinator (Southeast)
Regional Coordinator (Southeast)
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Mooresville, NC
Age: 37
Posts: 43,475
Received 3,661 Likes
on
2,494 Posts
Definitely a trickle charger would be your best bet. They make waterproof ones for outdoors and you can hardwire them to the battery so it makes unplugging it eash as a single cable quick disconnect when you want to drive the car.
#6
Safety Car
Thread Starter
thanks. the battery is actually in the trunk. Do they have battery powered trickle chargers that i could power up in the house every now and then. ideally, something i could charge in the house once a week over night, and then hook it up in the car and leave it in the trunk. This would be a time saver, so i dont have to rev the car once a week for 20 minutes. The car may spend most of its life in the driveway, and there isnt immediate access to a power cord.
Any reccs would be helpful
Any reccs would be helpful
#7
Moderator
Regional Coordinator (Southeast)
Regional Coordinator (Southeast)
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Mooresville, NC
Age: 37
Posts: 43,475
Received 3,661 Likes
on
2,494 Posts
I am not aware of any battery powered trickle chargers.
The battery in the trunk shouldn't be an issue. You should be able to hook the trickle charger leads up to the positive on the alternator as it should have a direct line back to the battery and then just use any major ground point. It is actually normally suggested not to hook the trickle charger directly to the battery.
The battery in the trunk shouldn't be an issue. You should be able to hook the trickle charger leads up to the positive on the alternator as it should have a direct line back to the battery and then just use any major ground point. It is actually normally suggested not to hook the trickle charger directly to the battery.
Trending Topics
#8
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Hmm. Maybe i am better off getting a jump starter that could be charged up in the house, and then used for whenever the battery craps out. Hopefully with a new battery, i could space out my recharging sessions closer to 10+ days or so.
#9
Senior Moderator
iTrader: (5)
it's not healthy for the battery to be jumped and drained... if you get a battery tender/trickle charger, they have dedicated wires you can hook onto the car... that will allow you to just plug the charger into those wires... i do that with the vagon and the spyder that get limited driving during the winter...
#10
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Not sure what to do then. There is no easy access to an exterior power outlet where the car will sit in the driveway, and the electrical in the detached garage is too dated to be trusted for this type of 'absent' use.
i am seeing there are solar trickle chargers, but there is a canopy of trees over the driveway
i am seeing there are solar trickle chargers, but there is a canopy of trees over the driveway
Last edited by ThermonMermon; 04-05-2018 at 11:42 AM.
#11
Ex-OEM King
You definitely need a trickle charger. Jumping it all the time is a great way to need a new battery. The battery being in the trunk isn't a problem, just run the lines out of the trunk. The one I have for my S2000 has a quick disconnect so you can wire it only once and leave the leads attached to the battery and then disconnect the charger itself in about 10 seconds.
I have this tender:
And these quick disconnects:
I have this tender:
And these quick disconnects:
#12
Moderator
Another option, though more work, would be to pull the battery & keep on a trickle outside of the car?
At least then, you always have a charged battery & just have do deal with occasional installation.
At least then, you always have a charged battery & just have do deal with occasional installation.
#14
Ex-OEM King
Not sure what to do then. There is no easy access to an exterior power outlet where the car will sit in the driveway, and the electrical in the detached garage is too dated to be trusted for this type of 'absent' use.
i am seeing there are solar trickle chargers, but there is a canopy of trees over the driveway
i am seeing there are solar trickle chargers, but there is a canopy of trees over the driveway
#15
Safety Car
Thread Starter
wont work. wife wont be able to physically lift the battery into the car if she needs it in an emergency when im out with the other car.
#16
Senior Moderator
iTrader: (5)
they make 25' extension wires for the battery tender...
https://smile.amazon.com/Battery-Ten...nsion+cable+25
https://smile.amazon.com/Battery-Ten...nsion+cable+25
#17
Senior Moderator
iTrader: (5)
Not sure what to do then. There is no easy access to an exterior power outlet where the car will sit in the driveway, and the electrical in the detached garage is too dated to be trusted for this type of 'absent' use.
i am seeing there are solar trickle chargers, but there is a canopy of trees over the driveway
i am seeing there are solar trickle chargers, but there is a canopy of trees over the driveway
you have a 100 yr old house... so you will just have to make due with some extension cords for now until you decide to run a more permanent outlet... if you think this will be more of a long term occurrence then i would consider running the outlet now...
Last edited by KaMLuNg; 04-05-2018 at 11:55 AM.
#18
Safety Car
Thread Starter
I would need a 75' foot cord to wrap around the house, and it would need to be water proof (it will be sitting in snow). and then worry about the dog running across it.
man, why does this have to be so hard. what the heck do people do that live in apartments and have their cars sit in a parking structure with no access to power?
man, why does this have to be so hard. what the heck do people do that live in apartments and have their cars sit in a parking structure with no access to power?
#20
Senior Moderator
iTrader: (5)
I would need a 75' foot cord to wrap around the house, and it would need to be water proof (it will be sitting in snow). and then worry about the dog running across it.
man, why does this have to be so hard. what the heck do people do that live in apartments and have their cars sit in a parking structure with no access to power?
man, why does this have to be so hard. what the heck do people do that live in apartments and have their cars sit in a parking structure with no access to power?
this is what you would need for now...
https://smile.amazon.com/Outdoor-Lig...+outdoor&psc=1
https://smile.amazon.com/NOCO-G750-U...%2Btender&th=1
#22
Safety Car
Thread Starter
thanks. this is helpful.
for the garage, i have the entire box flipped off unless i am physically present to make sure nothing catches on fire (ie using the power for outdoor equipment).
let me ask you - if i have the car in the garage only during the winter, could i set the trickle charger to a higher charge for 10, 20, 30 minutes once a week? I could watch over to make sure it isnt a fire hazard, and it would be a better situation that sitting in the car for 20 minutes running the engine. would that create more of a charge than running the car?
for the garage, i have the entire box flipped off unless i am physically present to make sure nothing catches on fire (ie using the power for outdoor equipment).
let me ask you - if i have the car in the garage only during the winter, could i set the trickle charger to a higher charge for 10, 20, 30 minutes once a week? I could watch over to make sure it isnt a fire hazard, and it would be a better situation that sitting in the car for 20 minutes running the engine. would that create more of a charge than running the car?
#23
Ex-OEM King
thanks. this is helpful.
for the garage, i have the entire box flipped off unless i am physically present to make sure nothing catches on fire (ie using the power for outdoor equipment).
let me ask you - if i have the car in the garage only during the winter, could i set the trickle charger to a higher charge for 10, 20, 30 minutes once a week? I could watch over to make sure it isnt a fire hazard, and it would be a better situation that sitting in the car for 20 minutes running the engine. would that create more of a charge than running the car?
for the garage, i have the entire box flipped off unless i am physically present to make sure nothing catches on fire (ie using the power for outdoor equipment).
let me ask you - if i have the car in the garage only during the winter, could i set the trickle charger to a higher charge for 10, 20, 30 minutes once a week? I could watch over to make sure it isnt a fire hazard, and it would be a better situation that sitting in the car for 20 minutes running the engine. would that create more of a charge than running the car?
Also, that wiring situation looks like a prime candidate to just rip that box out and replace with a proper breaker panel. If the rest of the wiring is good, it shouldn't be too big of a job to get that up to current.
#24
Moderator
Regional Coordinator (Southeast)
Regional Coordinator (Southeast)
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Mooresville, NC
Age: 37
Posts: 43,475
Received 3,661 Likes
on
2,494 Posts
So since a trickle charger doesn't seem to be an easy option for you and you can't easily remove the battery as it would not be easy for your wife to drive in an emergency then I only have one idea left. How about a quick disconnect battery terminal. You install it and then you don't need tools afterwards to disconnect battery power. You just unscrew the knob and the power is disconnected. You would obviously need to use a key to get into the trunk each time and you would lose your clock and radio presets. It would however probably be the easiet solution at this point.
#25
Senior Moderator
iTrader: (5)
So since a trickle charger doesn't seem to be an easy option for you and you can't easily remove the battery as it would not be easy for your wife to drive in an emergency then I only have one idea left. How about a quick disconnect battery terminal. You install it and then you don't need tools afterwards to disconnect battery power. You just unscrew the knob and the power is disconnected. You would obviously need to use a key to get into the trunk each time and you would lose your clock and radio presets. It would however probably be the easiet solution at this point.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01IH4JT5W...019RVVSHG?th=1
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01IH4JT5W...019RVVSHG?th=1
#26
Safety Car
Thread Starter
oh, that makes a ton of sense. i need to see how that would work with the battery cover though. there is a top plastic cover with a strap that wraps around the battery. the strap keeps the cover tight to the battery, and the battery in place. the leads are totally concealed in the trunk, and there are additionally exposed leads under the hood. but i would have to make remove the cover, or cut holes in it, to install this.
this is more motivation to do this garage project next year, which includes updated electric. when the audi bites the dust i am replacing it with something more fun / weekend use, and that will absolutely require a trickle charge.
putting the whole trickle charger topic aside, and i get a new battery, how often should i run the car? 1x a week, 2,000-3,000 rpm, 15 minutes? I heard leaving it longer at idle actually could drain the battery.
this is more motivation to do this garage project next year, which includes updated electric. when the audi bites the dust i am replacing it with something more fun / weekend use, and that will absolutely require a trickle charge.
putting the whole trickle charger topic aside, and i get a new battery, how often should i run the car? 1x a week, 2,000-3,000 rpm, 15 minutes? I heard leaving it longer at idle actually could drain the battery.
Last edited by ThermonMermon; 04-05-2018 at 12:53 PM.
#27
Moderator
Alternatively, why not just drive the car 1x a week?
That was my plan prior to the F150, when I was going to keep the Civic & buy an ND Miata.
That was my plan prior to the F150, when I was going to keep the Civic & buy an ND Miata.
#28
Safety Car
Thread Starter
I commute to work via train, and work long hours. our driveway is also a single lane, with no overnight street parking. so the last thing i want to do at 8/9pm is jockey my wife's car to the street, to take out the second car and drive around for 30 minutes aimlessly. thats a decent % of my free time for that given evening. although, i should probably drive it during the weekends more often.
the thought is to fund this garage project next year, then the following year gift the A6, and get a 997 Targa S / S5, or something to that effect (fun dad car w/ emergency baby seat accommodation). then i will have no problem driving 1x a week
the thought is to fund this garage project next year, then the following year gift the A6, and get a 997 Targa S / S5, or something to that effect (fun dad car w/ emergency baby seat accommodation). then i will have no problem driving 1x a week
Last edited by ThermonMermon; 04-05-2018 at 01:24 PM.
#30
I drive a Subata.
iTrader: (1)
I don't care about your battery issue but your place looks awesome!
#32
Safety Car
Car batteries get permanently damaged from being depleted too deeply. The thin lead plates become coated in lead sulfate as they get discharged. This is the chemical reaction that generates electricity. If you let the sulfate get too thick, or stay too long, it crystallizes and will not reverse itself even with a charge. A new battery will sort of help this because you're starting with fresh lead plates, but if you continue to let the car sit with just occasional startups, you won't get the full lifespan out of the battery.
I would personally try to make a battery tender work.
The following users liked this post:
00TL-P3.2 (04-11-2018)
#33
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Actually the alternator of most cars is not really meant for recharging a depleted battery. The SL55 is a battery destroyer. If I don't drive it every two weeks, or keep it on the tender, it will go flat. Even if I can squeeze an ignition out of it, driving it at highway speeds for 30-45 minutes is not enough to charge it fully.
Car batteries get permanently damaged from being depleted too deeply. The thin lead plates become coated in lead sulfate as they get discharged. This is the chemical reaction that generates electricity. If you let the sulfate get too thick, or stay too long, it crystallizes and will not reverse itself even with a charge. A new battery will sort of help this because you're starting with fresh lead plates, but if you continue to let the car sit with just occasional startups, you won't get the full lifespan out of the battery.
I would personally try to make a battery tender work.
Car batteries get permanently damaged from being depleted too deeply. The thin lead plates become coated in lead sulfate as they get discharged. This is the chemical reaction that generates electricity. If you let the sulfate get too thick, or stay too long, it crystallizes and will not reverse itself even with a charge. A new battery will sort of help this because you're starting with fresh lead plates, but if you continue to let the car sit with just occasional startups, you won't get the full lifespan out of the battery.
I would personally try to make a battery tender work.
#34
Summer is Coming
CTEK makes some chargers that can work off a DC source like a solar panel....
https://smartercharger.com/battery-chargers/
https://smartercharger.com/battery-chargers/
#35
Three Wheelin'
#36
Safety Car
Thread Starter
yeah. for many in the outer boroughs / suburbs, that commute to work via train, a family could EASILY get by with one car. It seems like most in my neighborhood that have two cars, a newer/nicer car on lease, and then an older car for emergency duty that never gets used. But truthfully, most could easily get away with 1 car and an uber ride here or there.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
UA6 Baller Status
3G TL Problems & Fixes
9
09-18-2013 10:22 AM