Removing Resonator on Stock exhaust (Summary Post #1 & #1811)
#1841
Racer
iTrader: (4)
I don't quite understand your question? Are you asking that if you don't have an intake, then doing a stage 1-3 mod WON'T sound any different? If that is your question, then my anwser is to listen to the videos in the first post of this thread. None of those people have intakes and it sounds plenty different.
#1842
Just removed 3rd Muff
I have been holding back from doing anything to my TL-S being that it's my daily. I removed the intake shenanigans from the resonator down the day after I got the car but stopped at that. Well last week I had an impulse to do the 3rd muffler delete and man I am kicking myself for not doing it sooner. Just gives it a little tone as compared to the stock, anemic sound...or lack there of. Definitely recommend it to others.
Nothing major, just a 'stage 1' exhaust mod but I am loving it. Now I wonder how long it will be till I have a J-pipe on it...
Nothing major, just a 'stage 1' exhaust mod but I am loving it. Now I wonder how long it will be till I have a J-pipe on it...
#1843
BANNED
iTrader: (33)
how much hp did you gain?
#1846
BANNED
iTrader: (33)
right on.
#1847
Intermediate
Has anyone done this with a J-pipe? I am doing my stage 3 today, and Im going to get a J-pipe either way for the power gains and want to know if it sounds any different or not
#1848
I just did the stage 3 on mine yesterday, along with a test pipe. I think it depends on the j-pipe, for example, where they "Y", which might change the note a bit. I am curious tho myself.
#1849
AZ Community Team
Join Date: May 2007
Location: N35°03'16.75", W 080°51'0.9"
Posts: 32,488
Received 7,771 Likes
on
4,342 Posts
Yes it sounds different. But not much.
Stage 3 has a slight drone. With J-Pipe, the drone is reduced and the tone is a little deeper. Then, with test pipe added, you get a little drone back.
The "drone" is slight/minor and really only in high gear (5th on an AT) and low(er) speed, say, ~40 mph or so.
Stage 3 has a slight drone. With J-Pipe, the drone is reduced and the tone is a little deeper. Then, with test pipe added, you get a little drone back.
The "drone" is slight/minor and really only in high gear (5th on an AT) and low(er) speed, say, ~40 mph or so.
#1850
Under construction
iTrader: (3)
Hey all, just got my mid-muffler removed a couple of hours ago and last night I removed the intake box. Heres a little clip I took, let me know what you think....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tRAYzsg8yao
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tRAYzsg8yao
#1851
Intermediate
I just got mine done yesterday too. Holy shit does it sound soooooooooooooooooooooo good. I am ordering a j-pipe today. So hopefully by next week I will have an answer for you guys. This is a great mod. Seriously. I'm so impressed
#1852
Intermediate
Yes it sounds different. But not much.
Stage 3 has a slight drone. With J-Pipe, the drone is reduced and the tone is a little deeper. Then, with test pipe added, you get a little drone back.
The "drone" is slight/minor and really only in high gear (5th on an AT) and low(er) speed, say, ~40 mph or so.
Stage 3 has a slight drone. With J-Pipe, the drone is reduced and the tone is a little deeper. Then, with test pipe added, you get a little drone back.
The "drone" is slight/minor and really only in high gear (5th on an AT) and low(er) speed, say, ~40 mph or so.
Just saw this, thanks man.
#1853
Definitely keep us updated, thats the next mod on my list as well.
#1854
Instructor
Thanks man, I really love it. If I drive like a grandma, you wouldn't even be able to tell that I changed anything, but if I push it a little so it shifts at about 3.5 or 4k, it has a very nice purr like a g35 but a lot deeper.
I don't see myself going any further than this as it is a luxury car and IMO anything more than stage 1 starts to get raspy and i dont get why you would want such a beautiful car to sound that way.
I don't see myself going any further than this as it is a luxury car and IMO anything more than stage 1 starts to get raspy and i dont get why you would want such a beautiful car to sound that way.
#1855
A6 and TL
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: New York/Brampton Canada/SoCal
Posts: 1,597
Received 145 Likes
on
123 Posts
Good price for stage 1 exhaust?
I heard people getting quotes of $30-$50 but I called two shops and both said $110. Maybe I am describing the process wrong?
Stage 1=Mid Muffler delete. Am I correct? Whats a good shop to go to do this? Any muffler shop like Monike/Midas?
Stage 1=Mid Muffler delete. Am I correct? Whats a good shop to go to do this? Any muffler shop like Monike/Midas?
#1860
Pro
Resonator Delete...
So, about 3 month ago, I got my mid-muffler replaced with a straight up. After looking at threads/pics on here about this.. I've come to realize it was my resonator that was replaced, and not my mid-muffler. Do muffler shops really not know the difference between a resonator and a mid-muffler? And now, what should I do? take it back and tell them? Or keep it the way it is? I mean, it sounds good...
#1861
Racer
Interesting. Did you tell them which is which? Some mufflers are round so I can see how they messed it up. It shouldn't be hard to put the resonator back on and take out the right thing.
#1862
Pro
Yes. Yeah, I'm gonna go and talk to them tomorrow. Should I get stage 2 or 3?
#1863
Keeping it simple
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Katy/Sugarland, TX
Age: 42
Posts: 185
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I did the mid muffler delete yesterday for $30. Love the sound. Not to loud, yet noticeable. I love it. I wanted a full exhaust but at the end of the day. This is a my luxury car so I'm not going to make it uncomfortable with drone and what not. Thanks for all the info in this thread. Very helpful.
#1866
Moderator
iTrader: (1)
So, about 3 month ago, I got my mid-muffler replaced with a straight up. After looking at threads/pics on here about this.. I've come to realize it was my resonator that was replaced, and not my mid-muffler. Do muffler shops really not know the difference between a resonator and a mid-muffler? And now, what should I do? Take it back and tell them? Or keep it the way it is? I mean, it sounds good...
you should have done a little more research and pointed out to the shop, which one is the mid-muffler.
#1867
Pro
#1868
AZ Community Team
Join Date: May 2007
Location: N35°03'16.75", W 080°51'0.9"
Posts: 32,488
Received 7,771 Likes
on
4,342 Posts
So, about 3 month ago, I got my mid-muffler replaced with a straight up. After looking at threads/pics on here about this.. I've come to realize it was my resonator that was replaced, and not my mid-muffler. Do muffler shops really not know the difference between a resonator and a mid-muffler? And now, what should I do? take it back and tell them? Or keep it the way it is? I mean, it sounds good...
Personally, I'd go back and put an aftermarket (Dynomax) resonator in and delete the mid-muffler.
#1869
AZ Community Team
Join Date: May 2007
Location: N35°03'16.75", W 080°51'0.9"
Posts: 32,488
Received 7,771 Likes
on
4,342 Posts
DatDereTL - please don't post the same question, twice, in different threads. Tks.
Threads merged.
Threads merged.
#1871
Hey guys, been reading up on this thread for a while, I wanted louder sound coming outta my 07 Tl-S so i took it to a shop on monday and removed mid muffler and resonator, and got it straight piped stock size (2.25) knowing the risks of getting that rasp i hear with this stage 4 mod.. ..
im on the fence with this mod.. when im cruising around 2-3000 rpms, that raspiness bugs the shiet outta me, but once i punch it pass that, that raspiness is gone and it roars!
i also forgot to mention i have a takeda cai so that in combination with the stwage 4 mod rocks! but only after i throttle past 3k rpm.. im strongly thinking about goin back with stock resonator and leaving mid muffler off, like what most people tend to enjoy, or get an aftermarket resonator (dynomax, flowmaster) any suggestions?
im on the fence with this mod.. when im cruising around 2-3000 rpms, that raspiness bugs the shiet outta me, but once i punch it pass that, that raspiness is gone and it roars!
i also forgot to mention i have a takeda cai so that in combination with the stwage 4 mod rocks! but only after i throttle past 3k rpm.. im strongly thinking about goin back with stock resonator and leaving mid muffler off, like what most people tend to enjoy, or get an aftermarket resonator (dynomax, flowmaster) any suggestions?
#1872
AZ Community Team
Join Date: May 2007
Location: N35°03'16.75", W 080°51'0.9"
Posts: 32,488
Received 7,771 Likes
on
4,342 Posts
^^
If you add a resonator back, do Dynomax. Not Stock. IMHO.
If you add a resonator back, do Dynomax. Not Stock. IMHO.
#1874
#1876
thanks for the tip, i wanted to get get it done today, hard to get dynomax parts in vancouver here so i went with a flowmaster instead.. part 10416, hopefully datll be aight.. i guess thats stage 2.
#1879
BANNED
iTrader: (33)
no it won't add anything, it'll just make it louder. you/people will think it's faster bc it's louder, but it's not.
IMO, an utter waste of money. save up for a catback.
IMO, an utter waste of money. save up for a catback.