New York Times story about Oil Changes
#1
Instructor
Thread Starter
New York Times story about Oil Changes
I know it ain't news to US, but still interesting to see that some people are beginning to catch on...
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/11/yo...cuts.html?_r=2
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/11/yo...cuts.html?_r=2
#2
Team Owner
Some people remain attached to the 3,000-mile oil change and have a hard time trusting the recommendations in the owner’s manual. If you’re one of those skeptics, you can send your engine oil out to be analyzed. Blackstone Laboratories in Fort Wayne, Ind., one of the best-known places for engine oil analysis, will send you a free kit.
You send back an oil sample and for $25, they’ll tell you all sorts of things about your car.
“We would compare what your oil looks like compared to the average Mazda5 of that year,” said Kristen Huff, a vice president at Blackstone. If there is a lot more lead in my oil than in a typical Mazda5, for example, it means I have a bearing problem, she said.
Her lab runs about 150 samples a day and a fair percentage of those are consumers looking to find out how often they need to change their oil, Ms. Huff said.
Not a bad article until they put this plug for Blackstone in there. I actually hate this company because it has been at the front of the oil analysis wear metal myths for years. You can't determine engine wear from a freaking spectrographic analysis period, the end.
All you can determine by a $20 analysis is the oil life remaining. I'll go 5,000 miles but that's it even on my Redline. The oil is good for more than double that but there's the contaminate load to think about.
You send back an oil sample and for $25, they’ll tell you all sorts of things about your car.
“We would compare what your oil looks like compared to the average Mazda5 of that year,” said Kristen Huff, a vice president at Blackstone. If there is a lot more lead in my oil than in a typical Mazda5, for example, it means I have a bearing problem, she said.
Her lab runs about 150 samples a day and a fair percentage of those are consumers looking to find out how often they need to change their oil, Ms. Huff said.
Not a bad article until they put this plug for Blackstone in there. I actually hate this company because it has been at the front of the oil analysis wear metal myths for years. You can't determine engine wear from a freaking spectrographic analysis period, the end.
All you can determine by a $20 analysis is the oil life remaining. I'll go 5,000 miles but that's it even on my Redline. The oil is good for more than double that but there's the contaminate load to think about.
#6
Team Owner
I can see why the 3K interval is still around besides the Jiffy Lubes of the world being greedy.
3K is safe for any car on any oil under any conditions....well almost.
I have no problem with 5K either, that's what I usually do. It's when people have to to take it to the extreme like 12-30K that it gets crazy.
Of course, 12K is not extreme for some of the larger sumped BMWs and Mercedes that hold twice the oil of our TLs.
Electronic Fuel Injection with feedback control was the largest contributor to longer change intervals along with much better modern oils.
Today's EFI with factory widebands and ultra fast cold start closed loop operation is even better at reducing engine wear and extending oil life.
PCV systems on old cars were a nice advancement to longer intervals as well even though that was not the original intention.
One of the problems with the longer change intervals is people automatically assume if the car is supposed to go 10k in between changes that the oil level does not have to be checked. It's surprising how many modern cars have an oil pressure warning light/guage but no oil level indicator besides the dipstick. At 3K, unless you have a big leak or major mechanical issues, the oil level is not going to get dangerously low in that time.
3K is safe for any car on any oil under any conditions....well almost.
I have no problem with 5K either, that's what I usually do. It's when people have to to take it to the extreme like 12-30K that it gets crazy.
Of course, 12K is not extreme for some of the larger sumped BMWs and Mercedes that hold twice the oil of our TLs.
Electronic Fuel Injection with feedback control was the largest contributor to longer change intervals along with much better modern oils.
Today's EFI with factory widebands and ultra fast cold start closed loop operation is even better at reducing engine wear and extending oil life.
PCV systems on old cars were a nice advancement to longer intervals as well even though that was not the original intention.
One of the problems with the longer change intervals is people automatically assume if the car is supposed to go 10k in between changes that the oil level does not have to be checked. It's surprising how many modern cars have an oil pressure warning light/guage but no oil level indicator besides the dipstick. At 3K, unless you have a big leak or major mechanical issues, the oil level is not going to get dangerously low in that time.
#7
Racer
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: West Hartford, CT
Age: 40
Posts: 451
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I change my oil twice a year regardless of mileage, it's just a good habit to have, and I think oil doesn't matter the mileage would be pretty darn contaminated in 1/2 a year....
Trending Topics
#10
Senior Moderator
Doesn't change my strategy. I'm at the Acura service department for fresh 5W30 every 3,000 on the dot and I'll continue to do so. 440,850 miles (of which I can claim 345k) and not one drop burned or leaked between changes. I'm not about to start pressing my luck with longer intervals at this point.
#12
Senior Moderator
I used to think I would retire it from daily driving status at 300k. Then 400k. At this point, the car has paid for itself multiple times and I just keep driving it without any end in sight. It currently needs motor mounts, a tranny mount, new brakes, and has a leaking power steering pump, but it starts up every day without fail and rolls down the road as straight and smooth as a new car. If you didn't look at the odo you'd never know.
#13
In the Mid-South meow
iTrader: (2)
^ That's so awesome. I remember your thread and I'm still amazed at that mileage. Your Legend is a truly a legend.
Mobil1 oil/filter every 5k miles in the Accord . The wife's Corolla gets regular 'ole dino Penzoil every 3k miles, and in most cases is getting an extra quart or two in between changes. 125k miles on the odometer so it's consuming oil somewhere, but still generally runs like a champ. Neither one of us will be looking for a new car probably in a very long time, unless I stumble upon a 70s Skylark for a weekend car.
Mobil1 oil/filter every 5k miles in the Accord . The wife's Corolla gets regular 'ole dino Penzoil every 3k miles, and in most cases is getting an extra quart or two in between changes. 125k miles on the odometer so it's consuming oil somewhere, but still generally runs like a champ. Neither one of us will be looking for a new car probably in a very long time, unless I stumble upon a 70s Skylark for a weekend car.
#14
I Skydive, Therefore I Am
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: At your right shoulder, no your left!
Age: 54
Posts: 781
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
^^ 1970 Buick GS would be my recommendation, it was the best looking IMHO.
Back in 1989 I bought an 85' Corolla GT-S, with the 4A-GE engine, same one as in the MR-2. I autocrossed it for nearly 4 years, put over 140,000 miles on it and changed the oil every 5k. Never had a problem, never used synthetic, and the head still looked factory clean when I adjusted the valves at 120k. That car saw some hard miles too. I would go through a set of Hoosiers just about every season.
Every car since then I change the oil around 5k to 6k, although the last change on the TL was at 7500.
Back in 1989 I bought an 85' Corolla GT-S, with the 4A-GE engine, same one as in the MR-2. I autocrossed it for nearly 4 years, put over 140,000 miles on it and changed the oil every 5k. Never had a problem, never used synthetic, and the head still looked factory clean when I adjusted the valves at 120k. That car saw some hard miles too. I would go through a set of Hoosiers just about every season.
Every car since then I change the oil around 5k to 6k, although the last change on the TL was at 7500.
#18
Instructor
I used to think I would retire it from daily driving status at 300k. Then 400k. At this point, the car has paid for itself multiple times and I just keep driving it without any end in sight. It currently needs motor mounts, a tranny mount, new brakes, and has a leaking power steering pump, but it starts up every day without fail and rolls down the road as straight and smooth as a new car. If you didn't look at the odo you'd never know.
#20
Oderint dum metuant.
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Lake Wylie
Age: 46
Posts: 12,496
Likes: 0
Received 534 Likes
on
446 Posts
I follow the MID, so somewhere in the 5k - 6k mile range. That works out to about every nine months for me. Came due in July/August this year . I love working on the car, but not in the summer.
#21
Prior to my BMW and Audi, I'd always owned cars with 4-cylinders. So oil changes usually required 4-5 quarts. What is the oil capacity in the TL? My BMW needs 6.5 quarts, and the Audi needs 7.25 quarts. However, I still change the oil every 5k miles.
#25
S E L L
I change the oil on my TL every 7500 miles and it doesn't burn/leak a drop. I use 5W30 Valvoline synthetic and a Bosch filter.
I'd get those mounts replaced ASAP. Neglecting those can do some damage.
I used to think I would retire it from daily driving status at 300k. Then 400k. At this point, the car has paid for itself multiple times and I just keep driving it without any end in sight. It currently needs motor mounts, a tranny mount, new brakes, and has a leaking power steering pump, but it starts up every day without fail and rolls down the road as straight and smooth as a new car. If you didn't look at the odo you'd never know.
Last edited by Gfaze; 09-15-2010 at 02:06 AM.
#26
5K-6K on regular dino. That's usually when I'm at 15% on the maintenance minder.
Max I've ever done was about 7.5K on synthetic. I'd push it more if I wasn't concerned about the filter.
Max I've ever done was about 7.5K on synthetic. I'd push it more if I wasn't concerned about the filter.
#27
Team Owner
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Kansas City, MO (Overland Park, KS)
Posts: 36,545
Received 6,470 Likes
on
5,162 Posts
#28
Team Owner
With all else being equal which it rarely is, double the oil capacity and you can almost double the change interval.
#31
B A N N E D
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Westchester/NYC
Age: 40
Posts: 295
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
I just follow the MID. I can notice the car being "sluggish'" around 30% left on the oil life. I read someone on here who goes to Autozone gets whatever special they have and gets that. I've been doing that for the last 2 years. Saves me money and time.
#32
S E L L
#33
Team Owner
You know that's impossible, right?
#37
Senior Moderator
I go when the MID on my Cadi reaches about 20%. So far that's about 6k miles. Mobil 1 is mandated by Cadillac. I say, good choice.
#39
Your Friendly Canadian
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Toronto, Ontario
Age: 32
Posts: 17,433
Received 1,492 Likes
on
1,050 Posts
Mobil 1 synthetic, 5k here.
FTR, I don't see why you should go over a reporter's assessment over the people who designed and developed the car. Yes, they're probably very experienced, but I'll stick with what the people who built the car tell me
FTR, I don't see why you should go over a reporter's assessment over the people who designed and developed the car. Yes, they're probably very experienced, but I'll stick with what the people who built the car tell me
#40
Team Owner
I've got an engineer on the Ford Modular engine design team saying he would never follow Fords's oil recommendations on his personal Ford car. He said basically what I said above. They saw more wear with the specified weight but it was deemed acceptable to get the CAFE blessing.
You're always safe following the manufacturer's recommendations. I just believe you can improve on them a little in some areas.