'04 to '08 front lower control arm bushing failure - please read and look
#601
So I found out this morning that my right side is torn too. It is just ALOT less torn than the left side.... Here are some pics (first 2 are of the right bushing... And the last 1 is of the left bushing):
Here is the right side from the top of the bushing:
And just for reference, here is a pic of the left side from the top of the bushing:
So considering that I have been having progressive steering issues since last summer, and considering that I have taken my car to Honda NUMEROUS TIMES to diagnose the steering problem (while the car was under warranty too), and considering that I have had NUMEROUS alignments as a result of my steering problem...... AND bought 2 different sets of tires in a year's time, and NOW my car is out of warranty, I called the Honda dealer when I found out both bushings were bad.
I laced into the service advisor who has taken care of me everytime I have gone there. I expressed my disgust with their ability to diagnose and even attempt to look properly, and then he said, "well lets see, you came here in February with 57,000 miles..... That's weird because it says they checked your front end and all was good."
I then said, "I now have 62,000 miles.... You mean to tell me one bushing is torn completely through and that happened in 5,000 miles?"
Then he said, "No that generally takes some time to do."
I said, "EXACTLY... You guys dropped the ball.... I have been complaining about this for over 15k miles and you are NOT going to tell me that I'm paying to fix this! You better find some goodwill somewhere!"
I then threatened to go to Honda America with all my reciepts of the several alignments I did over the past 8 or so months, and the 2 sets of new tires, and my records of having gone to Honda SEVERAL times for front end checks.
We then continued exchanging words.....
He put me on hold for about 20 minutes... Then came back on and told me that he spoke to his manager and seeing how many times I have come in complaining of a front end problem and since they didn't diagnose it, they will replace the bushings for me without charging me for labor. I just have to supply the bushings.... 2 new compliance bushings from Honda are $46-ish for the pair....
So come Tuesday I am bringing my car into Honda and paying $46 or so to get my front compliance bushings replaced!!!! That is sooo much better than paying several hundred! I'm soo happy that they are doing this with my car being 14k miles out of bumper to bumper warranty!
At the end of the day though, in all actuality, its the least they can do for missing the problem for soooo long.... But I am thankful it is going to get fixed and for so little cost to me all things considered!
Here is the right side from the top of the bushing:
And just for reference, here is a pic of the left side from the top of the bushing:
So considering that I have been having progressive steering issues since last summer, and considering that I have taken my car to Honda NUMEROUS TIMES to diagnose the steering problem (while the car was under warranty too), and considering that I have had NUMEROUS alignments as a result of my steering problem...... AND bought 2 different sets of tires in a year's time, and NOW my car is out of warranty, I called the Honda dealer when I found out both bushings were bad.
I laced into the service advisor who has taken care of me everytime I have gone there. I expressed my disgust with their ability to diagnose and even attempt to look properly, and then he said, "well lets see, you came here in February with 57,000 miles..... That's weird because it says they checked your front end and all was good."
I then said, "I now have 62,000 miles.... You mean to tell me one bushing is torn completely through and that happened in 5,000 miles?"
Then he said, "No that generally takes some time to do."
I said, "EXACTLY... You guys dropped the ball.... I have been complaining about this for over 15k miles and you are NOT going to tell me that I'm paying to fix this! You better find some goodwill somewhere!"
I then threatened to go to Honda America with all my reciepts of the several alignments I did over the past 8 or so months, and the 2 sets of new tires, and my records of having gone to Honda SEVERAL times for front end checks.
We then continued exchanging words.....
He put me on hold for about 20 minutes... Then came back on and told me that he spoke to his manager and seeing how many times I have come in complaining of a front end problem and since they didn't diagnose it, they will replace the bushings for me without charging me for labor. I just have to supply the bushings.... 2 new compliance bushings from Honda are $46-ish for the pair....
So come Tuesday I am bringing my car into Honda and paying $46 or so to get my front compliance bushings replaced!!!! That is sooo much better than paying several hundred! I'm soo happy that they are doing this with my car being 14k miles out of bumper to bumper warranty!
At the end of the day though, in all actuality, its the least they can do for missing the problem for soooo long.... But I am thankful it is going to get fixed and for so little cost to me all things considered!
#602
Came across this thread searching this exact issue I am having with my '06 TL. I just figured I would join so I could rant (but there is great information and I wish I found this forum sooner!!) - car is on a lift now getting the lower control arm replaced. - Driver side.
It currently has 104k miles on it.
YUCKely, I had no idea that this was happening and being the bushing is gone and worn out, it decided to crack the plate on the frame that holds the lower control arms itself. *grouchy*
The control arm with the bushings were about $325 just for the part. Though I don't mind light maintenance I didn't want to get in over my head with this.
Thanks for the good information - I just wished I found this sooner (both the forum and the bushing BS).
It currently has 104k miles on it.
YUCKely, I had no idea that this was happening and being the bushing is gone and worn out, it decided to crack the plate on the frame that holds the lower control arms itself. *grouchy*
The control arm with the bushings were about $325 just for the part. Though I don't mind light maintenance I didn't want to get in over my head with this.
Thanks for the good information - I just wished I found this sooner (both the forum and the bushing BS).
#603
Good you found out...
My car is currently on the alignment rack at the Honda dealership right now... And I'm here using their WIFI lol... Took them about 2 hours to replace both front bushings, and once the car is off the rack and I have specs, I'll post them
My car is currently on the alignment rack at the Honda dealership right now... And I'm here using their WIFI lol... Took them about 2 hours to replace both front bushings, and once the car is off the rack and I have specs, I'll post them
#604
Well I have good news and bad news... Good news is the bushings are in and the steering is MUUUUUCH tighter!!!!
Bad news is: When they gave me back the car the alignment was off... So I brought it back and the alignment is STILL off. Turns out their machine must be messed up because two alignment sheets printed out within 20 mins of each other gave front toe readings of -.6 and 0.0 (Left/right)...... And then -.6 and 1.2 (Left/right)..... They didn't adjust the right side between printouts they only adjusted the rear.
Also the readings for my caster and camber fluctuated between all 3 printouts I got... So NOW, my alignment is worse than it was when they initally finished the first alignment... Even though according to the printout, its in alingment now... SMFH!
Anyway, tomorrow I'm going to swing by Firestone (lifetime alignment) and see if they can align it for me after school. I'll keep posted
Bad news is: When they gave me back the car the alignment was off... So I brought it back and the alignment is STILL off. Turns out their machine must be messed up because two alignment sheets printed out within 20 mins of each other gave front toe readings of -.6 and 0.0 (Left/right)...... And then -.6 and 1.2 (Left/right)..... They didn't adjust the right side between printouts they only adjusted the rear.
Also the readings for my caster and camber fluctuated between all 3 printouts I got... So NOW, my alignment is worse than it was when they initally finished the first alignment... Even though according to the printout, its in alingment now... SMFH!
Anyway, tomorrow I'm going to swing by Firestone (lifetime alignment) and see if they can align it for me after school. I'll keep posted
#605
Well since replacing my bushing yesterday the steering is much tighter. They also did an alignment so that seems OK. I've also noticed that the "wobble" seems to be much less when cruising. I did ask them to rebalance the wheels and they told me they did the best they could, but the rims were slightly bent. This is the second person to tell me this.
I guess I'll be researching rims now ;-)
I guess I'll be researching rims now ;-)
#606
So after 16 months of back and forth with Acura they finally good willed my bushings today along with front and rear sway bars! They are also installing my aspec suspension! So it should handle like new when I get her back today!! Thanks to all who posted on this tread it's been very helpful!!
#608
I took my 2008 TL in today and the guy said Acura probably wouldn't replace it under warranty because it was 'normal' wear. They'd only replace it if it was hitting the frame, which seems stupid to me.
I guess I'll see when they call later today about it. Fingers crossed! I rolled it in at 61920. 80 miles to go
I guess I'll see when they call later today about it. Fingers crossed! I rolled it in at 61920. 80 miles to go
#609
Moderator
Chapter Leader (South Florida Region)
Chapter Leader (South Florida Region)
iTrader: (6)
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 78,016
Likes: 20,033
I did it myself. Very easy to do...get yourself a balljoint separator, the kind that screws up and pushed it out...then just unbolt everything and take out the control arm.
Not worth the headache of pressing, trust me. Pay the $20 to your local machine shop and have them press them in for you. Pay attention to the side facing up and orientation as that does matter. I filled all the empty slots with 3M window weld poly for a tighter fit and to give some extra support.
Good luck.
Not worth the headache of pressing, trust me. Pay the $20 to your local machine shop and have them press them in for you. Pay attention to the side facing up and orientation as that does matter. I filled all the empty slots with 3M window weld poly for a tighter fit and to give some extra support.
Good luck.
#610
I did it myself. Very easy to do...get yourself a balljoint separator, the kind that screws up and pushed it out...then just unbolt everything and take out the control arm.
Not worth the headache of pressing, trust me. Pay the $20 to your local machine shop and have them press them in for you. Pay attention to the side facing up and orientation as that does matter. I filled all the empty slots with 3M window weld poly for a tighter fit and to give some extra support.
Good luck.
Not worth the headache of pressing, trust me. Pay the $20 to your local machine shop and have them press them in for you. Pay attention to the side facing up and orientation as that does matter. I filled all the empty slots with 3M window weld poly for a tighter fit and to give some extra support.
Good luck.
#611
I took my 2008 TL in today and the guy said Acura probably wouldn't replace it under warranty because it was 'normal' wear. They'd only replace it if it was hitting the frame, which seems stupid to me.
I guess I'll see when they call later today about it. Fingers crossed! I rolled it in at 61920. 80 miles to go
I guess I'll see when they call later today about it. Fingers crossed! I rolled it in at 61920. 80 miles to go
Well, just got the word that they won't replace them under warranty, and that it would be $500 if I still wanted to do it.
Bummer.
#612
Chapter Leader (New England)
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 998
Likes: 21
From: W. Hart, CT & Amelia Island, FL
Why $500?? The bushings themselves are about $50 for both and an experienced tech can have the car on the lift and remove the LCA's, press the old bushings out, press the new ones in and reinstall the LCA's pretty quickly. You're probably talking about 1.5 - 2 hours labor MAX for this job.
#613
Why $500?? The bushings themselves are about $50 for both and an experienced tech can have the car on the lift and remove the LCA's, press the old bushings out, press the new ones in and reinstall the LCA's pretty quickly. You're probably talking about 1.5 - 2 hours labor MAX for this job.
#615
Could someone please let me know.....where I could purchase bushing? or the control arms?.....I believe I have the exact issue....having vibration pull to sides in the road....did both kind of alignment and balancing and same issue...
So I am supposed to go to the dealer next week to diagnose the issue....if I tell them front just check the bushing....do they still have to charge me with diagnostic fee of $50? I guess not....please let me know your advise.....
So I am supposed to go to the dealer next week to diagnose the issue....if I tell them front just check the bushing....do they still have to charge me with diagnostic fee of $50? I guess not....please let me know your advise.....
#616
Moderator
Chapter Leader (South Florida Region)
Chapter Leader (South Florida Region)
iTrader: (6)
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 78,016
Likes: 20,033
oemacuraparts.com
there are some vendors on here too that may be able to give you a decent price. with balljoint separator...some time...and a machine shop to press in, you're talking 2 hours of your time total. git er done...
there are some vendors on here too that may be able to give you a decent price. with balljoint separator...some time...and a machine shop to press in, you're talking 2 hours of your time total. git er done...
#617
How could I find these vendors....also could you please let me know the part number.
#618
Oddly enough I have been surfing this forum for a few years and only when I noticed that metal on metal noise going over pot holes or ridges in the road did I start looking. Even stranger I stared at that bushing going that doesn't look right, came inside and pulled up this forum and here this thread is.
So instead of replacing my whole suspension with some Tein Basics, all I have to do his get a new lower control arm and bushings... Spose that would be cheaper.
Glad/Pissed that I'm not the only one with this issue...
So instead of replacing my whole suspension with some Tein Basics, all I have to do his get a new lower control arm and bushings... Spose that would be cheaper.
Glad/Pissed that I'm not the only one with this issue...
#620
Sick of honda and acura, they lost me as a customer!!!
To set the record straight and cap on this thread that I'm subscribed for about almost 4 years, I think; here is my take:
I own a 2004 TL also previous Honda Prelude owner!!!
I did change both control arms for about $800 or so about close to 2 years ago, the bushings where cracked all the way, that time they couldn't replace just the bushing, NOW I REGRET IT BADLY!!!
Now I'm back at it, they started to crack and the tech said that now they can stamp the bushing for about 350+tax for both!!!
So if u think is worth it changing this every 2 years or so and shelling out $350+ u will not get much difference in handling to be honest not much at all and the worst that can happen is u'r tires not threading straight, the control arms or the bushing will not fall out!!!
The handling in this car is not that good to start with, u get all the feedback in the steering wheel, even brand new!!
DON'T TAKE MY WORD FOR IT JUST GO TO A PRIVATE SHOP AND GET A SECOND OPINION FROM A REAL MECHANIC (NOT A ACURA TECHNICIAN) IF IT'S WORTH SHELLING OUT $500 EVERY 2 OR SO YEARS FOR 2 BUSHINGs ON AN ACURA that should not have issues like this.
RELIABILITY MY ASS!!!!
I own a 2004 TL also previous Honda Prelude owner!!!
I did change both control arms for about $800 or so about close to 2 years ago, the bushings where cracked all the way, that time they couldn't replace just the bushing, NOW I REGRET IT BADLY!!!
Now I'm back at it, they started to crack and the tech said that now they can stamp the bushing for about 350+tax for both!!!
So if u think is worth it changing this every 2 years or so and shelling out $350+ u will not get much difference in handling to be honest not much at all and the worst that can happen is u'r tires not threading straight, the control arms or the bushing will not fall out!!!
The handling in this car is not that good to start with, u get all the feedback in the steering wheel, even brand new!!
DON'T TAKE MY WORD FOR IT JUST GO TO A PRIVATE SHOP AND GET A SECOND OPINION FROM A REAL MECHANIC (NOT A ACURA TECHNICIAN) IF IT'S WORTH SHELLING OUT $500 EVERY 2 OR SO YEARS FOR 2 BUSHINGs ON AN ACURA that should not have issues like this.
RELIABILITY MY ASS!!!!
#621
To set the record straight and cap on this thread that I'm subscribed for about almost 4 years, I think; here is my take:
I own a 2004 TL also previous Honda Prelude owner!!!
I did change both control arms for about $800 or so about close to 2 years ago, the bushings where cracked all the way, that time they couldn't replace just the bushing, NOW I REGRET IT BADLY!!!
Now I'm back at it, they started to crack and the tech said that now they can stamp the bushing for about 350+tax for both!!!
So if u think is worth it changing this every 2 years or so and shelling out $350+ u will not get much difference in handling to be honest not much at all and the worst that can happen is u'r tires not threading straight, the control arms or the bushing will not fall out!!!
The handling in this car is not that good to start with, u get all the feedback in the steering wheel, even brand new!!
DON'T TAKE MY WORD FOR IT JUST GO TO A PRIVATE SHOP AND GET A SECOND OPINION FROM A REAL MECHANIC (NOT A ACURA TECHNICIAN) IF IT'S WORTH SHELLING OUT $500 EVERY 2 OR SO YEARS FOR 2 BUSHINGs ON AN ACURA that should not have issues like this.
RELIABILITY MY ASS!!!!
I own a 2004 TL also previous Honda Prelude owner!!!
I did change both control arms for about $800 or so about close to 2 years ago, the bushings where cracked all the way, that time they couldn't replace just the bushing, NOW I REGRET IT BADLY!!!
Now I'm back at it, they started to crack and the tech said that now they can stamp the bushing for about 350+tax for both!!!
So if u think is worth it changing this every 2 years or so and shelling out $350+ u will not get much difference in handling to be honest not much at all and the worst that can happen is u'r tires not threading straight, the control arms or the bushing will not fall out!!!
The handling in this car is not that good to start with, u get all the feedback in the steering wheel, even brand new!!
DON'T TAKE MY WORD FOR IT JUST GO TO A PRIVATE SHOP AND GET A SECOND OPINION FROM A REAL MECHANIC (NOT A ACURA TECHNICIAN) IF IT'S WORTH SHELLING OUT $500 EVERY 2 OR SO YEARS FOR 2 BUSHINGs ON AN ACURA that should not have issues like this.
RELIABILITY MY ASS!!!!
#622
What are these shops? I would like to do mine....and I have no idea where I could get these done.
#623
Well, add me to the growing list of those subscribing to this thread. Went in for a free brake check recently and mechanic noted both LCA bushings torn through. He said don't bother fixing until it affects steering/handling. With 109,000 miles (one-owner), I'll consider myself lucky. Time to study up on LCA removal...
#625
Honestly though...if you have a machine shop locally...pay the $20 to have the new ones pressed in. Serious...take the arms out yourself and drop them off...come back in and hour and reinstall. Wasn't worth the headache IMO. That said, if you have a MONSTER press or vice, you can press them out pretty easily.
J.
J.
#626
Moderator
Chapter Leader (South Florida Region)
Chapter Leader (South Florida Region)
iTrader: (6)
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 78,016
Likes: 20,033
^^^because they don't break every 20K. And I don't have the room to house a 20 ton press in my garage and put the car in it. I'd rather go to a machine shop and have them press it for me for $20 every 3 or 4 years.
Either way...this is something that is not leaving the car stranded, so if you're questioning Honda reliability etc because you're angry you got swindled out of $850 for LCA's, I don't know what to tell you. Things on cars wear and tear, nothing you can do about that. I have had a lot of little things go on this car and it's a 1st production year model...most of which have been caused by my modding, none of which have left me stranded ever. Including battery dying...clutch slave cylinder. You guys need to set realistic expectations for your cars. Do they make them like they used to...NO...that's why it's a saying. With more power and lighter weight and bells and whistles and technology there's a LOT more to go wrong and stop working...so it will.
Either way...this is something that is not leaving the car stranded, so if you're questioning Honda reliability etc because you're angry you got swindled out of $850 for LCA's, I don't know what to tell you. Things on cars wear and tear, nothing you can do about that. I have had a lot of little things go on this car and it's a 1st production year model...most of which have been caused by my modding, none of which have left me stranded ever. Including battery dying...clutch slave cylinder. You guys need to set realistic expectations for your cars. Do they make them like they used to...NO...that's why it's a saying. With more power and lighter weight and bells and whistles and technology there's a LOT more to go wrong and stop working...so it will.
#628
The thing comes apart in about 2 min and can be stored in pieces. Its consists of a 6 ton bottle jack and some steel beams.
Mine are ripped like the rest in the pictures posted although I'm not sure I'm concerned about it. Had no one pointed it out I probably would have never noticed.
#629
Just found this thread.... ever since i got snow tires last year the car pulled to the right a little and has wobble in it at higher speeds. I have had countless alignments (free since i exchange cnc machining for service i dont have the tools for) and changed tires thinking it was a directional tire issue. Tomorrow i will be checking the bushings i hope the are not ripped but i bet they are..... this puts a delay on my slotted rotors and pads i wanted to get....
#632
My TL has 87,000 miles and always pulled to the right slightly, no matter the alignment or old/new tires installed. I checked my bushings and they were split as others see. I purchased new bushings and did the job in my garage using only my vise with inserts to push the bushings out. No shop press needed.
I purchased a $12 dollar pitman puller from Harbor Freight and had to grind the jaws open a bit to clear the ball joint shoulder. It was somewhat hard to get the puller around the lower part of the control arm but it worked out OK.
The control arm comes out easy enough as do the bushings. My vise is a 6" heavy duty from Harbor Freight also.
Just wanted to say this job can be done at home with few special tools.
I purchased a $12 dollar pitman puller from Harbor Freight and had to grind the jaws open a bit to clear the ball joint shoulder. It was somewhat hard to get the puller around the lower part of the control arm but it worked out OK.
The control arm comes out easy enough as do the bushings. My vise is a 6" heavy duty from Harbor Freight also.
Just wanted to say this job can be done at home with few special tools.
#633
^^ is your alignment fixed now? Mine are torn and I have similar alignment issues, just dont wanna spend the money if it doesnt fix it....I barely notice the wobble in my steering wheel at higher speeds anymore.
#634
I've been following this thread for a while and I'm starting to get some uneven wear on the inner edge of my front tires even though the alignment is in spec. Had it checked out by a local shop and they think it is caused by the bushings in the LCAs. They said they just recently replaced the LCAs on an 06 TL and the guy showed me the old parts from the 06. He said they can't just press in bushings and quoted me $1000 to replace the LCAs ($720 in parts, $210 in labor, $95 for an alignment).
Rather than tell him off, I instead decided to ask him if I could have the old LCAs. He sold them to me for $20 and I figure I'll just buy some bushings and get them pressed in.
Now one problem is that one of the LCAs is missing a sleeve. He said it was damaged when they removed the LCA:
Is that going to be a problem?
Also, why did they cut these off?
Rather than tell him off, I instead decided to ask him if I could have the old LCAs. He sold them to me for $20 and I figure I'll just buy some bushings and get them pressed in.
Now one problem is that one of the LCAs is missing a sleeve. He said it was damaged when they removed the LCA:
Is that going to be a problem?
Also, why did they cut these off?
The following users liked this post:
glennjr15 (01-06-2017)
#636
Not sure if anyone is tracking but there is a recall for the ball joint failure NHTSA notified me of this via email... just an FYI to the ones that didnt/dont know...
SUSPENSION:FRONT:CONTROL ARM:LOWER BALL JOINT
Summary:
AFFINIA IS RECALLING CERTAIN AFTERMARKET FRONT SUSPENSION LOWER BALL JOINTS, NAPA PART NO. 2601662, THAT MAY HAVE BEEN MISTAKENLY INSTALLED IN CERTAIN MODEL YEAR 2004 - 2008 ACURA TL VEHICLES DUE TO A MISTAKE IN A NAPA AND NAPA DEALERS' PARTS APPLICATION CATALOGUE.
So in other words don't buy your stuff at napa for now!
SUSPENSION:FRONT:CONTROL ARM:LOWER BALL JOINT
Summary:
AFFINIA IS RECALLING CERTAIN AFTERMARKET FRONT SUSPENSION LOWER BALL JOINTS, NAPA PART NO. 2601662, THAT MAY HAVE BEEN MISTAKENLY INSTALLED IN CERTAIN MODEL YEAR 2004 - 2008 ACURA TL VEHICLES DUE TO A MISTAKE IN A NAPA AND NAPA DEALERS' PARTS APPLICATION CATALOGUE.
So in other words don't buy your stuff at napa for now!
#637
I did it myself. Very easy to do...get yourself a balljoint separator, the kind that screws up and pushed it out...then just unbolt everything and take out the control arm.
Not worth the headache of pressing, trust me. Pay the $20 to your local machine shop and have them press them in for you. Pay attention to the side facing up and orientation as that does matter. I filled all the empty slots with 3M window weld poly for a tighter fit and to give some extra support.
Good luck.
Not worth the headache of pressing, trust me. Pay the $20 to your local machine shop and have them press them in for you. Pay attention to the side facing up and orientation as that does matter. I filled all the empty slots with 3M window weld poly for a tighter fit and to give some extra support.
Good luck.
#638
Here are the bushing options:
2004-2006 bushing 51394-SEP-A01 $26.18 firmer
2007-2008 bushing 51394-SEP-A11 $13.86 softer for ride-comfort
Looks like all 2007-2008, base and Type-S, use the newer bushing.
From what I understand, the lower arm is the same so either bushing with fit into either model and vice versa. If I have a 2004, but would prefer ride-comfort over performance, then it seems I should purchase the 2007-2008 bushing. Any issue with doing this? It will save me a little money too, which is not a big deal, but an added bonus.
2004-2006 bushing 51394-SEP-A01 $26.18 firmer
2007-2008 bushing 51394-SEP-A11 $13.86 softer for ride-comfort
Looks like all 2007-2008, base and Type-S, use the newer bushing.
From what I understand, the lower arm is the same so either bushing with fit into either model and vice versa. If I have a 2004, but would prefer ride-comfort over performance, then it seems I should purchase the 2007-2008 bushing. Any issue with doing this? It will save me a little money too, which is not a big deal, but an added bonus.
Last edited by jhumbo; 07-15-2011 at 11:53 AM.
#640
I took my 2006 TL to Acura for AC not cooling enough; They gave me an estimate of $2600 for ac valve leaking repair, lower control arm, power steering leak and a bunch of other things needed. the only problem with my car was ac valve leaking; I tested myself the lower control arm and seems to be ok. these guys are there just to rip people off.