View Poll Results: Your TL: 6spd or Auto?
6 Speed



99
54.70%
Automatic



82
45.30%
Voters: 181. You may not vote on this poll
POLL: 6spd or Auto
Originally Posted by XtraKrispy
Dealer told me that they don't sell too many 6 spds. Just curious as to how the Acurazine community falls out.
If I want to throw gears, I'll drive my old Vette. The TL's is a great everyday car with lots of toys. I love my AUTO TL.
JMO...
Trending Topics
Originally Posted by hogan64
This forum is NOT a very good indication of who is buying TL's. Most buyers are much older than people on this forum and want AUTO. I THOUGHT I wanted a 6SP for my everyday driver when I was 25 years old too. Now that I'm in my 40's and you could not pay me to drive a 6SP everyday. No F...ing way. Based on how many 6SP TL's I see in dealerships, I have to believe I'm not alone.
If I want to throw gears, I'll drive my old Vette. The TL's is a great everyday car with lots of toys. I love my AUTO TL.
JMO...
If I want to throw gears, I'll drive my old Vette. The TL's is a great everyday car with lots of toys. I love my AUTO TL.
JMO...
This forum convinced me to look at the 6MT and after I took a test drive, I was hooked. Fun factor is what this car is all about. The 6MT adds greatly to that.
It's really a personal decision. If you are a car enthusiast and you enjoy driving the car instead of having the car drive you (and you enjoy shifting), then look at the 6MT. If you want a great car with ease of use and comfort and don't live a heavily urban area (and you don't enjoy shifting), get the 5AT.
BTW, if you use a cell phone a lot, then you need to get a Bluetooth phone. The HFL is great and almost a requirement if you have the 6MT.
Originally Posted by hogan64
This forum is NOT a very good indication of who is buying TL's. Most buyers are much older than people on this forum and want AUTO. I THOUGHT I wanted a 6SP for my everyday driver when I was 25 years old too. Now that I'm in my 40's and you could not pay me to drive a 6SP everyday. No F...ing way. Based on how many 6SP TL's I see in dealerships, I have to believe I'm not alone.
If I want to throw gears, I'll drive my old Vette. The TL's is a great everyday car with lots of toys. I love my AUTO TL.
JMO...
If I want to throw gears, I'll drive my old Vette. The TL's is a great everyday car with lots of toys. I love my AUTO TL.
JMO...
The wife is over 50 and would not get anything else.
The auto trans TL was nothing special to us, rather get something else if we
were stuck with an automatic.
Except on the acurazine, I think the manual is quite rare, out of the 100? cars we see on the road, at malls, etc, 3 were manual trans cars.
We look for the brembo's...
Brett
Originally Posted by hogan64
This forum is NOT a very good indication of who is buying TL's. Most buyers are much older than people on this forum and want AUTO. I THOUGHT I wanted a 6SP for my everyday driver when I was 25 years old too. Now that I'm in my 40's and you could not pay me to drive a 6SP everyday. No F...ing way. Based on how many 6SP TL's I see in dealerships, I have to believe I'm not alone.
If I want to throw gears, I'll drive my old Vette. The TL's is a great everyday car with lots of toys. I love my AUTO TL.
JMO...
If I want to throw gears, I'll drive my old Vette. The TL's is a great everyday car with lots of toys. I love my AUTO TL.
JMO...
In the end I just wanted to see what the TL drivers in this forum were driving. The rep told me that they only sell about 5% of the TL's in 6spds and most of them without NAVI. I think that this forum has a higher amount of 6 spd drivers and people with NAVI. Maybe another poll..who has NAVI and who doesn't have NAVI.
In my area, the higher end mid-size performance sedans are a VERY popular commodity, and manuals are generally prized. So you tend to see quite a few of them. We I bought my '04 TL, the dealer was averaging 25-27% manual TLs in his inventory. The day I bought mine, they had three Anthracite/Ebony/6MT/Nav TLs on the lot.. I got one of them; the one that had been pulled off of the trailer 2 days before I got it.
Everyone one that says there's a disproportionate share of MT owners here versus the general population is right. In person, I think I've seen one MT.
https://acurazine.com/forums/showthr...highlight=poll
https://acurazine.com/forums/showthr...highlight=poll
I guess we are just a bunch of gearheads. 
I have only seen 2 other 6MTs in CT. One right next to me at every day work and one other one the road (once).
Hey ! I resemble that remark and I can't can't imagine an AT unless my left knee/leg fails me. I also have a wonderful spouse that can't drive an MT yet never suggested I get an AT.

I have only seen 2 other 6MTs in CT. One right next to me at every day work and one other one the road (once).
Originally Posted by hogan64
Now that I'm in my 40's and you could not pay me to drive a 6SP everyday. No F...ing way. Based on how many 6SP TL's I see in dealerships, I have to believe I'm not alone.
Originally Posted by bonanza829t
This forum convinced me to look at the 6MT and after I took a test drive, I was hooked. Fun factor is what this car is all about. The 6MT adds greatly to that.
BTW, if you use a cell phone a lot, then you need to get a Bluetooth phone. The HFL is great and almost a requirement if you have the 6MT.
BTW, if you use a cell phone a lot, then you need to get a Bluetooth phone. The HFL is great and almost a requirement if you have the 6MT.
When I get the loaner AT TL, I immediately miss my 6MT - it is the FUN FACTOR!!!
And yes, a bluetooth phone is a must for the 6MT.
I've never owned an automatic. I love driving manual. I told myself that as long as I have a healthy left foot, I'm driving a manual car. I'd rather have total controll of the TL but it seems the drive by wire throttle is not as precise as I'd like it to be-it delays sometimes. Oh well, at least I can determine what gear I'd like to be in. When I bought my car, there were only two manuals sitting on the lot, one after I left. For sure the auto sells more. To each their own.
ull find that there are a lot of the 6-speed owners on the forums....because mostly car enthusiasts will drive a manual tranny car....unfortunately....i couldn't wait the 5-6 months for the car....so i jumped the gun and got my perfect color combo
well, I have the 5AT and after I found this site I wanted the 6spd...and even my wife said she would drive it....I really think I am done with mods....because I don't have the 6spd. Maybe a set of Ronjon wheels and I done.
Originally Posted by XtraKrispy
Thanks for your thoughts. BTW - I'm not 25 and I have a couple of friends that have 6 or 5 spds that are not 25 either. I actually have both a manual car and a automatic car (the wife's). I see the benefits of automatics but I just get bored driving them. I feel more engaged when I'm driving manuals.
In the end I just wanted to see what the TL drivers in this forum were driving. The rep told me that they only sell about 5% of the TL's in 6spds and most of them without NAVI. I think that this forum has a higher amount of 6 spd drivers and people with NAVI. Maybe another poll..who has NAVI and who doesn't have NAVI.
In the end I just wanted to see what the TL drivers in this forum were driving. The rep told me that they only sell about 5% of the TL's in 6spds and most of them without NAVI. I think that this forum has a higher amount of 6 spd drivers and people with NAVI. Maybe another poll..who has NAVI and who doesn't have NAVI.
GET THE NAVI !! It's part of the appeal of the car if you ask me. You will not regret it.
hogan64 asks, "Would a clutch even last very long with 10 hours of stop and go driving each week?"
Absolutely, as long as the driver knows how to proper knows how to operate a manual transmission.. and frankly, most don't.
Absolutely, as long as the driver knows how to proper knows how to operate a manual transmission.. and frankly, most don't.
Originally Posted by jchcmax
I've never owned an automatic. I love driving manual. I told myself that as long as I have a healthy left foot, I'm driving a manual car. I'd rather have total controll of the TL but it seems the drive by wire throttle is not as precise as I'd like it to be-it delays sometimes. Oh well, at least I can determine what gear I'd like to be in. When I bought my car, there were only two manuals sitting on the lot, one after I left. For sure the auto sells more. To each their own.
Every other car I've owned has been a new one and has had a manual transmission. Even my bought-used 2001 Ford Ranger pickup (only had 1960 miles on it when I got it) has a manual transmission, though for such a utility vehicle, I could go with an automatic.
My personal driving machine MUST be a manual. I'd go nuts if it were not.
Originally Posted by acurasofla
Resale is higher on the automatic and they're easier to sell since they're less likely to have been romped. 
I bought an auto only because I will be moving to DC later this year and I didn't want to deal with the manual in heavy traffic. I did test drive one before the purchase but didn't care for the touchy clutch. It was hard to pass on the Brembos too.
[QUOTE=XtraKrispy]Dealer told me that they don't sell too many 6 spds. Just curious as to how the Acurazine community falls out.[/QUOTE
Dealer told me the same thing.....they only had one on lot and it had been there a LONG time. Could tell from the sticker as well as I had been tracking their lot for many months.
Dealer told me the same thing.....they only had one on lot and it had been there a LONG time. Could tell from the sticker as well as I had been tracking their lot for many months.
Originally Posted by Abnmarine
I bought an auto only because I will be moving to DC later this year and I didn't want to deal with the manual in heavy traffic. I did test drive one before the purchase but didn't care for the touchy clutch. It was hard to pass on the Brembos too.
But living in DC.. you're a brave man.
For those of you on this thread who might think that age has anything to do with transmission choice, I submit you are completely wrong with this assessment. While I will certainly admit that there are older people who much prefer an automatic transmission over a manual, unless they are arthritic or have some other physical problems, their choice is mostly one of preference.. no different than someone in their twenties or thirties.
Since I tend to be a bit sensitive about my age, suffice it to say that I would imagine I'm ollder than most of you on this thread. But that don't mean squat in my opinion. I still like the same things I did when I was in my twenties (Rock 'n Roll, guns, and cars), still tend to act pretty much the same, still have all of my hair and no real wrinkles and no gut,and still have this mental image of my age at 24. Years are only time and as long as all the parts work (which mine do), time is largely a physical thing.
As long as I can drive and as long as I am physically able, I will chose a manual transmission over an automatic for my personal driving machine. It's been this way since I was 18 and it will remain this way into my seventies and up (not there, yet).
Since I tend to be a bit sensitive about my age, suffice it to say that I would imagine I'm ollder than most of you on this thread. But that don't mean squat in my opinion. I still like the same things I did when I was in my twenties (Rock 'n Roll, guns, and cars), still tend to act pretty much the same, still have all of my hair and no real wrinkles and no gut,and still have this mental image of my age at 24. Years are only time and as long as all the parts work (which mine do), time is largely a physical thing.
As long as I can drive and as long as I am physically able, I will chose a manual transmission over an automatic for my personal driving machine. It's been this way since I was 18 and it will remain this way into my seventies and up (not there, yet).
My black on black 05 TL 6 speed was hard to get. I had to special order it and it took 3 months. If i have the option i will choose manual all the way. i just love the control of my car and the fun that a 6 speed puts into a car. I think since manual Tls are harder to find that the resale value of manuals might be better then auto's, but i dont plan on selling mine anytime soon.
Originally Posted by hogan64
I guess it really also depends on what kind of drive you have everyday. I've had a few jobs close to home and driving a manual would be just fine. Don't get me wrong, I love driving manual cars. I've had many. You feel more part of the car. I understand that and agree. I just spend 3 hours on the road each day driving 100 miles. It works out to around 2 hours of stop and go each day. I'll bet a few people on this forum would hate the manual after a few months of that. I find other things to do in the car and I don't have to push in that stupid clutch every 15 seconds for 2 hours a day. Would a clutch even last very long with 10 hours of stop and go driving each week?
Originally Posted by flvol77
well, I have the 5AT and after I found this site I wanted the 6spd...and even my wife said she would drive it....I really think I am done with mods....because I don't have the 6spd. Maybe a set of Ronjon wheels and I done.
Originally Posted by phatbastard
My black on black 05 TL 6 speed was hard to get. I had to special order it and it took 3 months. If i have the option i will choose manual all the way. i just love the control of my car and the fun that a 6 speed puts into a car. I think since manual Tls are harder to find that the resale value of manuals might be better then auto's, but i dont plan on selling mine anytime soon.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
blacktsxwagon
5G TLX (2015-2020)
42
Oct 27, 2015 10:12 PM
detailersdomain
Wash & Wax
3
Oct 9, 2015 10:13 PM





