View Poll Results: PC vs Mac Debate
I own a PC and plan to upgrade to Vista



15
27.78%
I own a Mac and plan to upgrade to Leopard



25
46.30%
I own a PC and may switch to Mac



12
22.22%
I own a Mac and may switch back to PC



2
3.70%
Voters: 54. You may not vote on this poll
PC vs Mac Debate
PC vs Mac Debate
I currently own a Dell and bought an iMac for Christmas and returned it. Why?
Because Vista and Leopard are being released almost back to back and want to compare the pros/cons of each before making a final decision. I'm still leaning toward the mac since what I've read about Vista is not encouraging so far.
Anyone thinking the same thing?
Because Vista and Leopard are being released almost back to back and want to compare the pros/cons of each before making a final decision. I'm still leaning toward the mac since what I've read about Vista is not encouraging so far.
Anyone thinking the same thing?
From what I've seen and read of Vista it has nothing that isn't already in Tiger. That and the "requirements" to get the eye candy and other goodies out of Vista is a joke.
I found this to be a good read.
http://online.wsj.com/public/article..._20080118.html
I found this to be a good read.
http://online.wsj.com/public/article..._20080118.html
Vista vs Leopard?
WTF
Not even a comparison. Adding some ooey-gooey eye candy to Windows does not OSX make.
Strip away the shabby copies of OSX effects from Vista and it's still just cruddy ol' over-bloated out-of-date Windows.
WTF

Not even a comparison. Adding some ooey-gooey eye candy to Windows does not OSX make.

Strip away the shabby copies of OSX effects from Vista and it's still just cruddy ol' over-bloated out-of-date Windows.
MS is crap, but it is the future. Sucks for us all. I haven't been a mac guy but I do hate windows a great deal.
I setup a few Macbook's the last few weeks & I must say they are really easy to use & work well. If I need a notebook in the future it will be a Mac.
I setup a few Macbook's the last few weeks & I must say they are really easy to use & work well. If I need a notebook in the future it will be a Mac.
Originally Posted by Scrib
Yah, pretty much reinforces my decision.
I'd rather wait for Leopard to come installed on the Mac out of the box. I love electronic gadgets, but I'm an admitted technotard.

If you and Soopa swear by Macs - the Gods have indeed spoken. About time to kick my PC to the curb.
Trending Topics
Originally Posted by Fibonacci
Yah, pretty much reinforces my decision.
I'd rather wait for Leopard to come installed on the Mac out of the box. I love electronic gadgets, but I'm an admitted technotard.
If you and Soopa swear by Macs - the Gods have indeed spoken. About time to kick my PC to the curb.
I'd rather wait for Leopard to come installed on the Mac out of the box. I love electronic gadgets, but I'm an admitted technotard.

If you and Soopa swear by Macs - the Gods have indeed spoken. About time to kick my PC to the curb.

Upgrading OSX is not the heart transplant that is upgrading to Vista.
Upgrading OSX is literally ONE button click with almost no consequence or side-effects. It took under 15 minutes to upgrade from Panther to Tiger on my ol' Powerbook.
Originally Posted by soopa
Upgrading OSX is literally ONE button click with almost no consequence or side-effects.
If I only have to wait a few months to save a $100 bucks, no biggie. My Dell is 4 yo and still working fine, albeit slower to boot up than it used to be.
Originally Posted by soopa


Mac fan here, will never go back. I was a die hard PC guy until a year ago, now it pains me to use windows. Couldn't even bring myself to buy a Blackjack for my cell since it runs windows.
Last edited by BEETROOT; Jan 21, 2007 at 07:54 PM.
Originally Posted by Fibonacci
Is it really that easy?
If I only have to wait a few months to save a $100 bucks, no biggie. My Dell is 4 yo and still working fine, albeit slower to boot up than it used to be.
If I only have to wait a few months to save a $100 bucks, no biggie. My Dell is 4 yo and still working fine, albeit slower to boot up than it used to be.
Leopard should be available in June.
I own a PC that will have Vista on it at some point.
I own a PC that is running Windows 2003 will be getting rid of and installing Longhorn when it comes out.
I own a PC that will stay a MacDell OSX 10.4.8
I own a PC that is running Solaris 10 1106
I own a laptop that is running Ubuntu
My work laptop will be getting Vista this week when I get my new HD. I will swap them out for now so I can go back and forth.
I own a PC that is running Windows 2003 will be getting rid of and installing Longhorn when it comes out.
I own a PC that will stay a MacDell OSX 10.4.8
I own a PC that is running Solaris 10 1106
I own a laptop that is running Ubuntu
My work laptop will be getting Vista this week when I get my new HD. I will swap them out for now so I can go back and forth.
Originally Posted by BEETROOT

Mac fan here, will never go back. I was a die hard PC guy until a year ago, now it pains me to use windows. Couldn't even bring myself to buy a Blackjack for my cell since it runs windows.

I was a die-hard Windows fan for years. Once I finally got fed up and switched to OSX simply LOOKING AT Windows became painful.
Every now and then I switch to my Window's PC to play a game or do some QA/Testing and I literally feel sick to my stomach. Once you grok OSX, using Windows is painful. Dreadful.
I'm probably going to get a 20" iMac when Leopard comes out. Although something in me needs to have a Mac Pro. But that thing might as well be called a server. I'm also assuming that iLife 07 will ship at the same time as Leopard.
I'll give my mini to my kid.
Oh and about the OS X upgrades. I also had no problem going from Panther to Tiger. When you also make the hardware that the OS is running on, there better not be any problems.
I'll give my mini to my kid.
Oh and about the OS X upgrades. I also had no problem going from Panther to Tiger. When you also make the hardware that the OS is running on, there better not be any problems.
Originally Posted by soopa

I was a die-hard Windows fan for years. Once I finally got fed up and switched to OSX simply LOOKING AT Windows became painful.
Every now and then I switch to my Window's PC to play a game or do some QA/Testing and I literally feel sick to my stomach. Once you grok OSX, using Windows is painful. Dreadful.
I've always been the 'tech support' guy for all of my friends, everyone calls me with their computer problems. Networking, virus stuff, whatever. When I had a pc also, I used to enjoy it... I got some satisfaction out of my ability to 'fix' windows. Now that I am used to OS X, I can't do that stuff anymore. This may or may not make sense, but the whole time I'm just thinking 'why do I have to deal with this? On a mac it just works'
There are some windows things I like better. I like the folder view in XP better for browsing files for example.
I have Vista on my homebuilt PC and OSX on my Mac Mini.
I like both
Each has their pluses and cons.
Vista has not given me any problems like some reviewers claim, it runs faster than XP in some cases. It seems to be just as stable, meaning no crashing. Networking seems to be better, especially with bittorrent.
I like both

Each has their pluses and cons.
Vista has not given me any problems like some reviewers claim, it runs faster than XP in some cases. It seems to be just as stable, meaning no crashing. Networking seems to be better, especially with bittorrent.
Originally Posted by soopa
Oh, and btw, if you must have Windows... you can run it on your Mac too.
Mac it shall be!

Now, do I spring for the Mac 20" cinema screen or go with a Sony XBR, decisions, decisions, hmm....
Originally Posted by BEETROOT
I wish Mac versions of games didn't cost 2-3x the cost of their PC counterparts.

Not to mention, they release them sometimes 2 or 3 years LATER. If at all.
Originally Posted by Fibonacci
Now, do I spring for the Mac 20" cinema screen or go with a Sony XBR, decisions, decisions, hmm....
What kind of stuff are you using it for? A mac mini and a 22" samsung lcd ($329 @ Costco) would be a nice set up.
Originally Posted by Ken1997TL
I have Vista on my homebuilt PC and OSX on my Mac Mini.
I like both
Each has their pluses and cons.
Vista has not given me any problems like some reviewers claim, it runs faster than XP in some cases. It seems to be just as stable, meaning no crashing. Networking seems to be better, especially with bittorrent.
I like both

Each has their pluses and cons.
Vista has not given me any problems like some reviewers claim, it runs faster than XP in some cases. It seems to be just as stable, meaning no crashing. Networking seems to be better, especially with bittorrent.
Am I wrong to tell people, that pay me money to fix their machines, to keep buying windows machines? If I tell them to buy a mac they will never call me again. 
You have no idea how much $ the spyware installer named IE has made me.

You have no idea how much $ the spyware installer named IE has made me.
Originally Posted by doopstr
Am I wrong to tell people, that pay me money to fix their machines, to keep buying windows machines? If I tell them to buy a mac they will never call me again. 
You have no idea how much $ the spyware installer named IE has made me.

You have no idea how much $ the spyware installer named IE has made me.
Firefox FTW
Originally Posted by BEETROOT
What kind of stuff are you using it for? A mac mini and a 22" samsung lcd ($329 @ Costco) would be a nice set up.
Originally Posted by BEETROOT
I've always been the 'tech support' guy for all of my friends, everyone calls me with their computer problems. Networking, virus stuff, whatever. When I had a pc also, I used to enjoy it... I got some satisfaction out of my ability to 'fix' windows. Now that I am used to OS X, I can't do that stuff anymore. This may or may not make sense, but the whole time I'm just thinking 'why do I have to deal with this? On a mac it just works'
There are some windows things I like better. I like the folder view in XP better for browsing files for example.
There are some windows things I like better. I like the folder view in XP better for browsing files for example.
Alot of people are hoping it goes away altogether in Leopard.
Personally, I almost never use Finder or navigate files in the traditional way. I use Spotlight or Quicksilver for most navigation.
Originally Posted by doopstr
I'm probably going to get a 20" iMac when Leopard comes out. Although something in me needs to have a Mac Pro. But that thing might as well be called a server. I'm also assuming that iLife 07 will ship at the same time as Leopard.
I'll give my mini to my kid.
Oh and about the OS X upgrades. I also had no problem going from Panther to Tiger. When you also make the hardware that the OS is running on, there better not be any problems.
I'll give my mini to my kid.
Oh and about the OS X upgrades. I also had no problem going from Panther to Tiger. When you also make the hardware that the OS is running on, there better not be any problems.
iMac's are no slouches.
Originally Posted by soopa
iMac's are no slouches.
The best you can do with a mini is the 1.83 core duo and Intel GMA 950... which should be fine for photos and normal stuff, might not be enough for serious video editing or video games.
You could run an external monitor in extended desktop mode on the iMac.
You could run an external monitor in extended desktop mode on the iMac.
Originally Posted by Fibonacci
Is there much difference in capabilities between iMac and Mac Mini? Now, I'm leaning toward the Mini because of the monitor flexibility.
if you want flexibility just get a MacBook. you'll get iMac speed in a smaller form factor.
Where's the option for both OSs?
I've got multiple computers with multiple OSs, and they each have their use.
OSX on the macbook, and I think it's a superior OS for being on the go and for development.
XP Pro on one desktop and I think it's great for personal/home office stuff.
XP Home on another desktop and I think it's fine for email, web browsing, etc.
You can always dualboot Vista/Leopard on Macs
I've got multiple computers with multiple OSs, and they each have their use.
OSX on the macbook, and I think it's a superior OS for being on the go and for development.
XP Pro on one desktop and I think it's great for personal/home office stuff.
XP Home on another desktop and I think it's fine for email, web browsing, etc.
You can always dualboot Vista/Leopard on Macs
All of my business computers have Window's, my personal computer is a macbook and I get pissed off using window's at work at least once an hour. I never thought I would be so happy using a computer as I am with my macbook, for me its damn near perfect.
Originally Posted by Tireguy
All of my business computers have Window's, my personal computer is a macbook and I get pissed off using window's at work at least once an hour. I never thought I would be so happy using a computer as I am with my macbook, for me its damn near perfect.
Originally Posted by soopa
If I had to use Windows for work I would stab myself in the eyes with a spork.
Your work and my work are very different. Two of my window's computers have window's 98 on them because its the only operating system that works with the fucking retarded programs that I need for work












