Okay guys i want your opinon, would you rather get a 95 automatic m3 or an 2000-2001 tiptronic S4. And it has to be automatic for various reasons, please just give me your opinon on which you would rather have. Also which car would have more mods available for it.
Thanks alot

 

i would get the s4, im not a big fan of older bmws, they look like the body pannels sag or something, not sure what it is. not sure about the performance (dont follow old cars well) but the s4 will give you triptronic compared to an old automatic. plus your gettin alot less mileage on the s4.

 

well is this an everyday car? then i say for winters the s4 might be a better way to go. The 95 m3 doesnt have traction control... so that wouldnt be fun in snow.

 

yes everyday car

 

Simple: why would you want an 8 year old car when you could have a comparable 2 year old car?

 

S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4S4 ..............does that answer ur question , besides BMW's brake down too much and the S4 will still be under warranty if the mileage is O.K

 

Actually, the M3 is very reliable. More so than the S4. No turbos to blow on the M3

I prefer the driving experience of the M3 more, it would be my preference

 

S4

Quattro, and a bi-turbo engine that can be tuned AMAZINGLY

http://www.goapr.com/Audi/vehicles/s4.html

for 599 dollars you can get the S4 to 318hp/382lb-ft

get the exhuast and u can add some to that too...

but thats as fast as u can go with Tip

for more info and questions hit up www.audiworld.com


if u get 6-speed u can take that AWD beast all the way to 452hp/495torque

 

M3= Lots of electrical problems. Engine is great and is a workhorse becareful with electrical and AC problems.

 

BMW's have alot of electrical problems , especially the power window motors and sunroof motors . It would drive him nuts not to be under warranty.

 

Amir said it perfectly...HANDS DOWN THE S4!!! Just my 2 pennies...

-Shane :P

 

Among the choices you gave us, get the S4, no doubt, simply because it's 5-6 years newer.

 

The S4 would be the better buy. Since they both are automatics. Also its nice to have a turbo car. I heard you can get like 400 or 500hp from an S4.

 

A S4 has so much potential. I would get the M3 if it were a little newer.

 

s4

 

I'd go with the S4.

 

S4

 

Which ever way you go, both are high maintenance. Just be certain to go the certified used route to play it safe(r). Also keep in mind a few things about the E36 M3:
- the auto model performs nothing like the 5speed and is NO quicker than the CL-S (though it'll handle better)
- wont have the superior ergonomics of the S4
- the 1995 model was the first year for the E36 M3 (so bugs aplenty)
- smaller interior than the S4

Peace

 

S4! But BAG the auto idea, and learn to drive a sticK! :p