2021 Acura TLX vs The Competition
#121
Burning Brakes
Found this excellent article comparing Acura's SH-AWD to other luxury manufacturers' implementations:
https://www.automoblog.net/2020/11/2...awd-explained/
Apparently Acura gives you torque vectoring standard whereas other companies force you to add as an option or upgrade to performance models (ie. AMG, etc.).
https://www.automoblog.net/2020/11/2...awd-explained/
Apparently Acura gives you torque vectoring standard whereas other companies force you to add as an option or upgrade to performance models (ie. AMG, etc.).
Thank for sharing the link. I will reserve the judgment once I drive TLX Type-S, but outside of that car, the SH-AWD in TL, RDX, and MDX is front biased and not all that great in normal driving conditions. You almost have to drive your car as you stole it and under throttle to experience the rear-wheel bias and torque vectoring - something counter intuitive in everyday driving or cornering for many people.
Every so often, I have fun in our TL because I understand it. however, my wife on the other hand, will never accelerate in a corner, so for her, our TL drives like Accord, and she prefers the handling of Q50 due to the natural rear-wheel bias that you don't have to enforce.
I would rather have AWD with permanent RWD bias like an Audi or BMW, over SH-AWD, but I am curious to experience what Type-S offers. On the other hand if Acura starts making SH-AWD RWD bias that would change the game for sure in their favor.
The following 2 users liked this post by mlody:
justnspace (11-21-2020),
YEH (04-23-2021)
#122
Thank for sharing the link. I will reserve the judgment once I drive TLX Type-S, but outside of that car, the SH-AWD in TL, RDX, and MDX is front biased and not all that great in normal driving conditions. You almost have to drive your car as you stole it and under throttle to experience the rear-wheel bias and torque vectoring - something counter intuitive in everyday driving or cornering for many people.
Every so often, I have fun in our TL because I understand it. however, my wife on the other hand, will never accelerate in a corner, so for her, our TL drives like Accord, and she prefers the handling of Q50 due to the natural rear-wheel bias that you don't have to enforce.
I would rather have AWD with permanent RWD bias like an Audi or BMW, over SH-AWD, but I am curious to experience what Type-S offers. On the other hand if Acura starts making SH-AWD RWD bias that would change the game for sure in their favor.
Every so often, I have fun in our TL because I understand it. however, my wife on the other hand, will never accelerate in a corner, so for her, our TL drives like Accord, and she prefers the handling of Q50 due to the natural rear-wheel bias that you don't have to enforce.
I would rather have AWD with permanent RWD bias like an Audi or BMW, over SH-AWD, but I am curious to experience what Type-S offers. On the other hand if Acura starts making SH-AWD RWD bias that would change the game for sure in their favor.
I've had Quattro and 4MATIC in the past as well and I honestly can't say it made a difference since I don't do a lot of spirited driving.
#123
Thank for sharing the link. I will reserve the judgment once I drive TLX Type-S, but outside of that car, the SH-AWD in TL, RDX, and MDX is front biased and not all that great in normal driving conditions. You almost have to drive your car as you stole it and under throttle to experience the rear-wheel bias and torque vectoring - something counter intuitive in everyday driving or cornering for many people.
Every so often, I have fun in our TL because I understand it. however, my wife on the other hand, will never accelerate in a corner, so for her, our TL drives like Accord, and she prefers the handling of Q50 due to the natural rear-wheel bias that you don't have to enforce.
I would rather have AWD with permanent RWD bias like an Audi or BMW, over SH-AWD, but I am curious to experience what Type-S offers. On the other hand if Acura starts making SH-AWD RWD bias that would change the game for sure in their favor.
Every so often, I have fun in our TL because I understand it. however, my wife on the other hand, will never accelerate in a corner, so for her, our TL drives like Accord, and she prefers the handling of Q50 due to the natural rear-wheel bias that you don't have to enforce.
I would rather have AWD with permanent RWD bias like an Audi or BMW, over SH-AWD, but I am curious to experience what Type-S offers. On the other hand if Acura starts making SH-AWD RWD bias that would change the game for sure in their favor.
1) It can send more power to the rear when the situation demands, even though it doesn't do so at steady state
2) Cuz Acura marketing materials calls it rear-biased
None of which actually makes it true, though. I agree with your assessment; unless you really give it the beans through the corners to break traction and force the system to send more power rearwards, dynamically it's no different from a regular FWD car.
The following users liked this post:
BEAR-AvHistory (11-21-2020)
#124
Suzuka Master
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Raleigh, NC - USA
Age: 82
Posts: 7,674
Received 2,600 Likes
on
1,581 Posts
Think one of the issues is its counter-intuitive to the average USA driver. The road to my house has a lot of turns & elevation changes. 9.9 out of 10 drivers that I am behind, regardless of car make, are on the brakes IN every turn & MOST downhill sections. A down hill section with a curve in it is pure panic time for them.
#125
Idk why no one is mentioning Genesis G70. I learned about it recently and saw reviews. It seems that for the MSRP of 2021 TLX SH-AWD Advance, you can
1) Get a better performing car (maybe like what the Type-S will be from what we know so far)
OR
2) Get a nicer car with more features.
Anyone has personal experience comparing the two?
1) Get a better performing car (maybe like what the Type-S will be from what we know so far)
OR
2) Get a nicer car with more features.
Anyone has personal experience comparing the two?
#126
Suzuka Master
Idk why no one is mentioning Genesis G70. I learned about it recently and saw reviews. It seems that for the MSRP of 2021 TLX SH-AWD Advance, you can
1) Get a better performing car (maybe like what the Type-S will be from what we know so far)
OR
2) Get a nicer car with more features.
Anyone has personal experience comparing the two?
1) Get a better performing car (maybe like what the Type-S will be from what we know so far)
OR
2) Get a nicer car with more features.
Anyone has personal experience comparing the two?
G70 is on my short list. Did a test drive a while back of Twin Turbo Sport. My biggest eat issue is it seems a little tight inside. I wanted AWD, it in GA I have a better chance or finding a unicorn. They offered me great money for my 19 TLX ASPEC with 13K miles and still took a boat load off the G70.
Problem is also these dealers are mornings, the best car on the lot seems to always be in use by the sales manager so it has miles on it. They get a rare config then use it themselves.
#127
Idk why no one is mentioning Genesis G70. I learned about it recently and saw reviews. It seems that for the MSRP of 2021 TLX SH-AWD Advance, you can
1) Get a better performing car (maybe like what the Type-S will be from what we know so far)
OR
2) Get a nicer car with more features.
Anyone has personal experience comparing the two?
1) Get a better performing car (maybe like what the Type-S will be from what we know so far)
OR
2) Get a nicer car with more features.
Anyone has personal experience comparing the two?
This G70 Sport would probably be a better buy when compared to the Type S that will be missing many of the Advance trim's features. Fuel economy is a weak point for Genesis as the 3.3T only manages 17/25/20 for city/hwy/combined. I think the Type S should do better than that!
#128
Racer
Strongly considered a G70. MPG/range numbers seemed notably weak and I have read the dealership experiences are pretty bad. Was coming from Lexus so felt like it would be a significant step-down. Ultimately, I also just think the '21 TLX is a better looking car by a slim margin.
#129
iWhine S/C 6MT TL
iTrader: (1)
Idk why no one is mentioning Genesis G70. I learned about it recently and saw reviews. It seems that for the MSRP of 2021 TLX SH-AWD Advance, you can
1) Get a better performing car (maybe like what the Type-S will be from what we know so far)
OR
2) Get a nicer car with more features.
Anyone has personal experience comparing the two?
1) Get a better performing car (maybe like what the Type-S will be from what we know so far)
OR
2) Get a nicer car with more features.
Anyone has personal experience comparing the two?
I really like the refresh G70 and Stinger. Here's a video of the G70
The following users liked this post:
ELIN (11-30-2020)
#130
I really like the refresh G70 and Stinger. Here's a video of the G70
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFD8kh7fO1Q
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFD8kh7fO1Q
If trunk space is not high priority and the fuel econ on the Type S is comparable, the 3.3T is a clear winner since the Type S will lose much of the Advance's options. I'm expecting pricing to be similar on both cars.
#131
As for the options, I think putting Sport package on exceeds TLX2 Advance because of features like turn cameras, self open/close trunk, rear heated seats, etc.
I think the one under might be more comparable (prestige or elite or something?)
I think the one under might be more comparable (prestige or elite or something?)
The following users liked this post:
04WDPSeDaN (11-30-2020)
#132
Advance has rear heated seats and 360 camera, but not the power trunk.
The following users liked this post:
04WDPSeDaN (11-30-2020)
#133
I really like the refresh G70 and Stinger. Here's a video of the G70
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFD8kh7fO1Q
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFD8kh7fO1Q
The following users liked this post:
04WDPSeDaN (11-30-2020)
#134
I really like the refresh G70 and Stinger. Here's a video of the G70
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFD8kh7fO1Q
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFD8kh7fO1Q
The following users liked this post:
04WDPSeDaN (11-30-2020)
#135
iWhine S/C 6MT TL
iTrader: (1)
- Includes 3.3T Standard plus:
- Power trunk
- Microfiber suede headliner
- Heated rear seats
- Nappa leather seating surfaces with luxury quilting
- Surround View Monitor
- Heads-up Display
One example without looking for the best deal.
2021 Kia Stinger GT Limited AWD - $37,490
https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/new/searchresults.action?zip=01057&showNegotiable=true &sourceContext=untrackedExternal_false_0&distance= 200&entitySelectingHelper.selectedEntity2=c30938&e ndYear=2021&entitySelectingHelper.selectedEntity=c 29209&startYear=2019#listing=282117446Nice video and sharp looking car! Reviewer didn't mention it but the trunk on the G70 is 3 ft3 smaller than the TLX at 10.5 ft3. The rims on that G70 look just as uninspired as on the TLX. A stopping distance of 123+ ft is quite long no, especially on Brembro's? Might have something to do with the rain...
If trunk space is not high priority and the fuel econ on the Type S is comparable, the 3.3T is a clear winner since the Type S will lose much of the Advance's options. I'm expecting pricing to be similar on both cars.
If trunk space is not high priority and the fuel econ on the Type S is comparable, the 3.3T is a clear winner since the Type S will lose much of the Advance's options. I'm expecting pricing to be similar on both cars.
The following users liked this post:
bilirubin (12-01-2020)
#136
User Awaiting Email Confirmation
I'll give it more time, but the new look of the G70 really isn't doing it for me. The lights are just too small that it throws off the aesthetic proportions of the car IMO. Then again, the M3/M4 grilles are growing on me too, so maybe I've just gone mental ...
The following users liked this post:
04WDPSeDaN (11-30-2020)
#137
iWhine S/C 6MT TL
iTrader: (1)
I hated the M3/M4 grilles but as more time has passed, it's grown on me. The loaner BMW gave me is a 2021 4 series coupe. The front plate kills the grille IMO. I've seen another 2021 M440i in my town, pearl white with the shadow-line package and it looks way better. If I had the funds, I would rock an isle of man green M3.
The following users liked this post:
leomio85 (12-01-2020)
#138
I hated the M3/M4 grilles but as more time has passed, it's grown on me. The loaner BMW gave me is a 2021 4 series coupe. The front plate kills the grille IMO. I've seen another 2021 M440i in my town, pearl white with the shadow-line package and it looks way better. If I had the funds, I would rock an isle of man green M3.
The following 5 users liked this post by Carnage719:
04WDPSeDaN (12-01-2020),
BEAR-AvHistory (12-01-2020),
ELIN (12-01-2020),
Flapjackura (12-01-2020),
pyrodan007 (12-14-2020)
#139
User Awaiting Email Confirmation
I hated the M3/M4 grilles but as more time has passed, it's grown on me. The loaner BMW gave me is a 2021 4 series coupe. The front plate kills the grille IMO. I've seen another 2021 M440i in my town, pearl white with the shadow-line package and it looks way better. If I had the funds, I would rock an isle of man green M3.
Yep, I was repulsed by it at first too. Then I thought it wasn't so bad. Then I went back to hating it. Now, I'm back to thinking it looks decent.
Last edited by leomio85; 12-01-2020 at 12:48 AM.
#140
iWhine S/C 6MT TL
iTrader: (1)
Generally, I prefer running no front plate on cars, but the M3/M4 seems to look way better with a front plate, albeit, the only ones I've seen have been Euro plates. With US plates, I'm not 100% sure ... I'll have to see it and then pass judgment. And 100% agree that that Isle of Man Green is a stunning color. It would be a a tough decision between that, white and that ///M silver that has a bluish tint that I love. All just a pipe dream until maybe 10+ yrs down the road.
Yep, I was repulsed by it at first too. Then I thought it wasn't so bad. Then I went back to hating it. Now, I'm back to thinking it looks decent.
Yep, I was repulsed by it at first too. Then I thought it wasn't so bad. Then I went back to hating it. Now, I'm back to thinking it looks decent.
Rumors are, there's already an aftermarket bumper w/grille being produced which will look similar to the 8 series https://www.thedrive.com/news/37132/...y-in-the-works
Last edited by 04WDPSeDaN; 12-01-2020 at 05:56 AM.
The following users liked this post:
ESHBG (12-01-2020)
#141
Here is the loaner BMW gave me vs the M440i in town.
Rumors are, there's already an aftermarket bumper w/grille being produced which will look similar to the 8 series https://www.thedrive.com/news/37132/...y-in-the-works
Rumors are, there's already an aftermarket bumper w/grille being produced which will look similar to the 8 series https://www.thedrive.com/news/37132/...y-in-the-works
The replacement bumper makes the car look closer to the i3, which I had predicted would look like the pigs from Angry Birds if the car was green!
The following 2 users liked this post by ELIN:
04WDPSeDaN (12-01-2020),
Flapjackura (12-01-2020)
#142
Any idea on G70's AWD vs SH-AWD in common driving scenarios?
I know it's not active torque vectoring. But is it noticably worse in everyday driving?
I know it's not active torque vectoring. But is it noticably worse in everyday driving?
#143
iWhine S/C 6MT TL
iTrader: (1)
Last edited by 04WDPSeDaN; 12-01-2020 at 11:50 AM.
The following 2 users liked this post by 04WDPSeDaN:
Neoforever (12-01-2020),
nist7 (12-14-2020)
#144
Thank for sharing the link. I will reserve the judgment once I drive TLX Type-S, but outside of that car, the SH-AWD in TL, RDX, and MDX is front biased and not all that great in normal driving conditions. You almost have to drive your car as you stole it and under throttle to experience the rear-wheel bias and torque vectoring - something counter intuitive in everyday driving or cornering for many people.
Every so often, I have fun in our TL because I understand it. however, my wife on the other hand, will never accelerate in a corner, so for her, our TL drives like Accord, and she prefers the handling of Q50 due to the natural rear-wheel bias that you don't have to enforce.
I would rather have AWD with permanent RWD bias like an Audi or BMW, over SH-AWD, but I am curious to experience what Type-S offers. On the other hand if Acura starts making SH-AWD RWD bias that would change the game for sure in their favor.
Every so often, I have fun in our TL because I understand it. however, my wife on the other hand, will never accelerate in a corner, so for her, our TL drives like Accord, and she prefers the handling of Q50 due to the natural rear-wheel bias that you don't have to enforce.
I would rather have AWD with permanent RWD bias like an Audi or BMW, over SH-AWD, but I am curious to experience what Type-S offers. On the other hand if Acura starts making SH-AWD RWD bias that would change the game for sure in their favor.
Rear-biased AWD alone doesn't result in the kind of performance advantages you're expecting. Most rear-biased AWD cars understeer off throttle (most RWD cars understeer off throttle). An STI with its LSD is notorious for it. Comparing the feel of a TLX vs a rear-biased STI, the TLX has much more neutral cornering than the STI. Power on oversteer is easier to induce in a TLX. Moving to a system like xDrive isn't a solution either. The problem with xDrive is that whenever the system intervenes, it does so to increase understeer. The computer is making educated guesses about the traction limit of the front tires and constantly engaging the front clutch pack as a precaution. The opposite is true with a FWD-biased torque vectoring system. The system is being invoked to introduce oversteer. The priority is performance first, traction second.
#145
Nice video and sharp looking car! Reviewer didn't mention it but the trunk on the G70 is 3 ft3 smaller than the TLX at 10.5 ft3. The rims on that G70 look just as uninspired as on the TLX. A stopping distance of 123+ ft is quite long no, especially on Brembro's? Might have something to do with the rain...
If trunk space is not high priority and the fuel econ on the Type S is comparable, the 3.3T is a clear winner since the Type S will lose much of the Advance's options. I'm expecting pricing to be similar on both cars.
If trunk space is not high priority and the fuel econ on the Type S is comparable, the 3.3T is a clear winner since the Type S will lose much of the Advance's options. I'm expecting pricing to be similar on both cars.
The following users liked this post:
ELIN (12-01-2020)
#146
I think my mid-life crisis will include a fancy car with a set of summer tires as well as winter tires. I'm not quite there yet...
#147
Anyway, I guess I meant to ask if hard/powered cornering on streets would be noticably worse in G70's AWD than TLX's.
#148
Suzuka Master
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Raleigh, NC - USA
Age: 82
Posts: 7,674
Received 2,600 Likes
on
1,581 Posts
Idk why you make that assumption. And to clarify, it's me who does regularly break traction on turns with my 1G TLX SH-AWD. Yes, I drive spirited. Also, I'm on the shitty LS2 tires.
Anyway, I guess I meant to ask if hard/powered cornering on streets would be noticably worse in G70's AWD than TLX's.
Anyway, I guess I meant to ask if hard/powered cornering on streets would be noticably worse in G70's AWD than TLX's.
C&D
G70
Michelin Pilot Sport 4, Size F: 225/40R-19 (93Y) Extra Load R: 255/35R-19 (96Y) Extra Load
Braking, 70–0 mph: 160 ft
Roadholding, 300-ft-dia skidpad: 0.92 g
C&D
TLX AWD
Michelin Primacy A/S, 255/40R-19 96W M+S
Braking, 70–0 mph: 177 ft
Roadholding, 300-ft-dia skidpad: 0.87 g
The following 2 users liked this post by BEAR-AvHistory:
04WDPSeDaN (12-01-2020),
ELIN (12-01-2020)
#149
Idk why you make that assumption. And to clarify, it's me who does regularly break traction on turns with my 1G TLX SH-AWD. Yes, I drive spirited. Also, I'm on the shitty LS2 tires.
Anyway, I guess I meant to ask if hard/powered cornering on streets would be noticably worse in G70's AWD than TLX's.
Anyway, I guess I meant to ask if hard/powered cornering on streets would be noticably worse in G70's AWD than TLX's.
The G70 uses the same Magna Actimax AWD system as the BMWs with xDrive. It should feel more RWD but there is no torque vectoring. The RWD only models will feel more sporty. The AWD is only a traction assist, not a performance enhancer. You'd have to drive them back to back to find out which passes the feel test.
The following users liked this post:
04WDPSeDaN (12-01-2020)
#150
I didn't make that assumption. That's what the poster wrote: "my wife on the other hand, will never accelerate in a corner, so for her, our TL drives like Accord."
The G70 uses the same Magna Actimax AWD system as the BMWs with xDrive. It should feel more RWD but there is no torque vectoring. The RWD only models will feel more sporty. The AWD is only a traction assist, not a performance enhancer. You'd have to drive them back to back to find out which passes the feel test.
The G70 uses the same Magna Actimax AWD system as the BMWs with xDrive. It should feel more RWD but there is no torque vectoring. The RWD only models will feel more sporty. The AWD is only a traction assist, not a performance enhancer. You'd have to drive them back to back to find out which passes the feel test.
#151
Hmm . . . for me torque vectoring is nice in low traction. You still get a little steering authority even if the front wheels have little to no traction. It's fun on on-ramps or any other long radius turn where you have partial throttle input. I've never taken the TLX on a track (too fat and heavy) but I imagine it would be fun to use the throttle to clean up a racing line (I can't do that in a Civic SI or STI). U-turns with traction control off are also fun.
The following users liked this post:
ELIN (12-01-2020)
#152
Hmm . . . for me torque vectoring is nice in low traction. You still get a little steering authority even if the front wheels have little to no traction. It's fun on on-ramps or any other long radius turn where you have partial throttle input. I've never taken the TLX on a track (too fat and heavy) but I imagine it would be fun to use the throttle to clean up a racing line (I can't do that in a Civic SI or STI). U-turns with traction control off are also fun.
#153
iWhine S/C 6MT TL
iTrader: (1)
I didn't make that assumption. That's what the poster wrote: "my wife on the other hand, will never accelerate in a corner, so for her, our TL drives like Accord."
The G70 uses the same Magna Actimax AWD system as the BMWs with xDrive. It should feel more RWD but there is no torque vectoring. The RWD only models will feel more sporty. The AWD is only a traction assist, not a performance enhancer. You'd have to drive them back to back to find out which passes the feel test.
The G70 uses the same Magna Actimax AWD system as the BMWs with xDrive. It should feel more RWD but there is no torque vectoring. The RWD only models will feel more sporty. The AWD is only a traction assist, not a performance enhancer. You'd have to drive them back to back to find out which passes the feel test.
#154
AZ Community Team
Join Date: May 2014
Location: Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Posts: 3,469
Received 1,619 Likes
on
976 Posts
Once again, SG nailed it. Watch the G80 review. He is super honest and praises the car but at the same time he confirms that it lacks identity and the resale value is bad.
Or now people will say SG is not reliable as he praised the new TLX 🤣
Or now people will say SG is not reliable as he praised the new TLX 🤣
The following users liked this post:
ELIN (12-12-2020)
#155
Last edited by Honda430; 12-12-2020 at 11:24 AM.
The following 4 users liked this post by Honda430:
#156
Very fair review. I'm glad I didn't wait for the G80 as the "fat suit" comment would not sit well with me.
#157
The following users liked this post:
Neoforever (12-14-2020)
#158
Suzuka Master
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Raleigh, NC - USA
Age: 82
Posts: 7,674
Received 2,600 Likes
on
1,581 Posts
Nothing unusual there. Test groups, magazines, YouTubers are gods until their review does not conform to your world view. That's why there are so many different brands, nameplates & models of cars available. Different people like different things. Its also outside of the raw numbers why I take them as a grain of salt. Or as the sergeant said "Lighten up, Frances".
The following users liked this post:
Legend2TL (12-12-2020)
#159
AZ Community Team
Join Date: May 2014
Location: Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Posts: 3,469
Received 1,619 Likes
on
976 Posts
Everyone was waiting for his review and once the review is out, I barely saw any comments or feedback.
All of a sudden, it looks like he isn’t the cool kid anymore among Acurazine members 🤣
That said, even AoA second review is awesome. He definitely provided some Great feedback (positive and negative) but he was honest and on point.
To conclude, as I always say, don’t listen to me or to some members who are here to just point the negatives. Go test drive and feel the car before writing a check of $50K. Of course watch some review and learn a few things beforehand.
The following users liked this post:
Pens Fan (12-13-2020)
#160
iWhine S/C 6MT TL
iTrader: (1)
100%!
Everyone was waiting for his review and once the review is out, I barely saw any comments or feedback.
All of a sudden, it looks like he isn’t the cool kid anymore among Acurazine members 🤣
That said, even AoA second review is awesome. He definitely provided some Great feedback (positive and negative) but he was honest and on point.
To conclude, as I always say, don’t listen to me or to some members who are here to just point the negatives. Go test drive and feel the car before writing a check of $50K. Of course watch some review and learn a few things beforehand.
Everyone was waiting for his review and once the review is out, I barely saw any comments or feedback.
All of a sudden, it looks like he isn’t the cool kid anymore among Acurazine members 🤣
That said, even AoA second review is awesome. He definitely provided some Great feedback (positive and negative) but he was honest and on point.
To conclude, as I always say, don’t listen to me or to some members who are here to just point the negatives. Go test drive and feel the car before writing a check of $50K. Of course watch some review and learn a few things beforehand.
The following 3 users liked this post by 04WDPSeDaN: