Driveline Vibration. Possible fix now? (3G Garage# A-010)
#281
Moderator Alumnus
It's not worthy to hack their networks yet...
Originally Posted by RBallman
...Isn't there a transportation safety site where we can access all TSBs for any and all recalls? I seem to remember hearing about one........
#282
Moderator Alumnus
Dunno why only 04TLs... they look "identical" to me...
04TL
Aluminum-alloy front subframe
Besides its low mass, the TL aluminum-alloy front subframe reduces "starting boom" (resonance noise) without the use of additional dampers.
05TL
Aluminum-alloy front subframe
Besides its low mass, the TL aluminum-alloy front subframe reduces "starting boom" (resonance noise) without the use of additional dampers.
04TL
The TL with 6-speed manual transmission includes the following features
Rear engine rocking damper
05TL
The TL with 6-speed manual transmission includes the following features:
Rear engine rocking damper
Aluminum-alloy front subframe
Besides its low mass, the TL aluminum-alloy front subframe reduces "starting boom" (resonance noise) without the use of additional dampers.
05TL
Aluminum-alloy front subframe
Besides its low mass, the TL aluminum-alloy front subframe reduces "starting boom" (resonance noise) without the use of additional dampers.
04TL
The TL with 6-speed manual transmission includes the following features
Rear engine rocking damper
05TL
The TL with 6-speed manual transmission includes the following features:
Rear engine rocking damper
#283
Advanced
Can anyone who gets this dealer fix done please report on the results and exactly what the new dynamic damper is? I was planning to wait for my next scheduled service to get the fix done at the same time, but I'd like to hear what others think of it.
#284
Moderator Alumnus
rvmeush, welcome back.
Obviously, you're the 3rd person talking about this issue since ACuraR posting it. I was wondering where those people who dislike this vibration, they should all talk about this. Dealers should receive tons of calls about this, shouldn't they? I guess guys in CA would be able to taste this first.
#285
CEO, Team Anthracite
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Bear Territory
Posts: 2,899
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Isn't there a member on this forum (Randy, was it?) who worked at a dealer and can get us TSBs? I would love to see a copy of the actual TSB. I've noticed the problem -- between 40-50 mph in 5th gear -- but mine is fairly slight compared to what you guys must be noticing.
That said, I'd still like to get the fix if it's officially sanctioned by Acura, and would like to see the TSB to see how I can best "inform" the dealer of the problem.
That said, I'd still like to get the fix if it's officially sanctioned by Acura, and would like to see the TSB to see how I can best "inform" the dealer of the problem.
#287
an Acura has-been
It's about time!
Finally, 18 months later, Acura finally find's a fix for the 1500rpm vibration.
I guess they are tired of us bitching at them, and on this site about it.
As I understand it, it is a rubber damper placed at the rear of the lower sub-frame. It is placed just behind the rear engine mount, near the cat.
13 months earlier and I would have kept my car, it can't be that hard to find, and boy did the NVH boys at Acura/Honda miss this in their design and test mule stage.
All I can say is 18 months.
Congrats to all you who stuck with it, and can finally get a fix.
Funny, I also had it in 4th gear at 30-35mph at 1500rpm, but maybe mine was just one of the realy bad ones.
Will I buy another TL now, all I can say is I am on the fence.
I guess they are tired of us bitching at them, and on this site about it.
As I understand it, it is a rubber damper placed at the rear of the lower sub-frame. It is placed just behind the rear engine mount, near the cat.
13 months earlier and I would have kept my car, it can't be that hard to find, and boy did the NVH boys at Acura/Honda miss this in their design and test mule stage.
All I can say is 18 months.
Congrats to all you who stuck with it, and can finally get a fix.
Funny, I also had it in 4th gear at 30-35mph at 1500rpm, but maybe mine was just one of the realy bad ones.
Will I buy another TL now, all I can say is I am on the fence.
#288
CEO, Team Anthracite
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Bear Territory
Posts: 2,899
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Still waiting to see the actual TSB, so if anyone has it please share! I want to make sure the dealer I go to won't try to weasel out of making the fix.
need4spd: If that was the only reason you got rid of the TL, time to buy it again!
need4spd: If that was the only reason you got rid of the TL, time to buy it again!
#289
The Oracle of Acurazine!
alright, I've noticed this vibration sometimes, so now its time to take the car to dealer. What TSB# should I get them? I don't my dealer to give me some like dealers do.
#291
Originally Posted by need4spd
Finally, 18 months later, Acura finally find's a fix for the 1500rpm vibration.
I guess they are tired of us bitching at them, and on this site about it.
As I understand it, it is a rubber damper placed at the rear of the lower sub-frame. It is placed just behind the rear engine mount, near the cat.
13 months earlier and I would have kept my car, it can't be that hard to find, and boy did the NVH boys at Acura/Honda miss this in their design and test mule stage.
All I can say is 18 months.
Congrats to all you who stuck with it, and can finally get a fix.
Funny, I also had it in 4th gear at 30-35mph at 1500rpm, but maybe mine was just one of the realy bad ones.
Will I buy another TL now, all I can say is I am on the fence.
I guess they are tired of us bitching at them, and on this site about it.
As I understand it, it is a rubber damper placed at the rear of the lower sub-frame. It is placed just behind the rear engine mount, near the cat.
13 months earlier and I would have kept my car, it can't be that hard to find, and boy did the NVH boys at Acura/Honda miss this in their design and test mule stage.
All I can say is 18 months.
Congrats to all you who stuck with it, and can finally get a fix.
Funny, I also had it in 4th gear at 30-35mph at 1500rpm, but maybe mine was just one of the realy bad ones.
Will I buy another TL now, all I can say is I am on the fence.
They treated me like an idiot. I have owned many cars and imagine most on this forum have. I recognize something was wrong with the design, either the engine or a power train issue. ACS just kept lying about it. Instead of telling us that they were working on a fix, they lied about it. I did not want to spend my time filing complaints w/ NHS and stuff. It is not worth it.
It was my first and will be last Acura/Honda buy. I am going back to old reliable Nissan who at least treat customers like customers. I have had to fix rattles myself, you name it I have done it. Door glass holders, squeaky ceiling and moonroof, etc...I paid 35k large for 270 crippled horses.
Good luck to all TL owners on this forum.
#292
Advanced
Originally Posted by Lore
Still waiting to see the actual TSB, so if anyone has it please share! I want to make sure the dealer I go to won't try to weasel out of making the fix.
need4spd: If that was the only reason you got rid of the TL, time to buy it again!
need4spd: If that was the only reason you got rid of the TL, time to buy it again!
#293
CEO, Team Anthracite
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Bear Territory
Posts: 2,899
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by rvmeush
I spoke with the service rep at my dealer today and he read the TSB to me, so it's definitely in the hands of the dealers. There was even some language in the TSB about not confusing the 50-60 mph vibration with vibrations caused by tire flatspotting. I still have a way to go before my next scheduled service, so I'd really like to hear some feedback from someone who gets this fix in the next few weeks.
I'm glad Acura is finally responding to the problems we've noted so consistently since the car came to market.
#294
Moderator Alumnus
I cannot get the copies, either.
Originally Posted by Lore
Still waiting to see the actual TSB, so if anyone has it please share! I want to make sure the dealer I go to won't try to weasel out of making the fix....
#295
Moderator Alumnus
Originally Posted by rvmeush
I spoke with the service rep at my dealer today and he read the TSB to me, so it's definitely in the hands of the dealers. There was even some language in the TSB about not confusing the 50-60 mph vibration with vibrations caused by tire flatspotting. I still have a way to go before my next scheduled service, so I'd really like to hear some feedback from someone who gets this fix in the next few weeks.
#296
auto or 6mt?
i've watched this thread grow from 2+ to 10+ pages...and was hoping i would not have to re-read... is this an AUTO trans only problem?
i just had my 16k Turanzas and wheels replaced w/ new Turanzas. i still have the vibration-
i just had my 16k Turanzas and wheels replaced w/ new Turanzas. i still have the vibration-
#298
an Acura has-been
Originally Posted by LORE
need4spd: If that was the only reason you got rid of the TL, time to buy it again!
Not sure if I trust them still, too many problems with the 2005's
Originally Posted by TomN
Mine too moan and groan at 30-40 then 50-60 but was told by ACS and my dealer that it was characteristic of a high performance TL. yeah right.
They treated me like an idiot. I have owned many cars and imagine most on this forum have. I recognize something was wrong with the design, either the engine or a power train issue. ACS just kept lying about it. Instead of telling us that they were working on a fix, they lied about it. I did not want to spend my time filing complaints w/ NHS and stuff. It is not worth it.
It was my first and will be last Acura/Honda buy. I am going back to old reliable Nissan who at least treat customers like customers. I have had to fix rattles myself, you name it I have done it. Door glass holders, squeaky ceiling and moonroof, etc...I paid 35k large for 270 crippled horses.
Good luck to all TL owners on this forum.
They treated me like an idiot. I have owned many cars and imagine most on this forum have. I recognize something was wrong with the design, either the engine or a power train issue. ACS just kept lying about it. Instead of telling us that they were working on a fix, they lied about it. I did not want to spend my time filing complaints w/ NHS and stuff. It is not worth it.
It was my first and will be last Acura/Honda buy. I am going back to old reliable Nissan who at least treat customers like customers. I have had to fix rattles myself, you name it I have done it. Door glass holders, squeaky ceiling and moonroof, etc...I paid 35k large for 270 crippled horses.
Good luck to all TL owners on this forum.
However, I still love the look of the car!
#300
Moderator Alumnus
I called my dealer 2nd time today, no part yet, although TSB is there. It's been a week since my first call... still waiting for the parts from Acura.
#304
just had this done
Last week when i had my leather seats swapped out for 05 seats they also did this damper and it seems to be smoother but i think there is still slight vibrations. Maybe something else needs to be adjust or fix..someone else get this done and confirm my finding..dont want to get everyone hope down
#305
Moderator Alumnus
Originally Posted by xedap1998
Last week when i had my leather seats swapped out for 05 seats they also did this damper and it seems to be smoother but i think there is still slight vibrations. Maybe something else needs to be adjust or fix..someone else get this done and confirm my finding..dont want to get everyone hope down
https://acurazine.com/forums/showthread.php?t=116913
#306
05 WDP/Ebony/5AT/NaviLess
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Toronto
Age: 43
Posts: 210
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just got an '05 5AT and I've noticed a vibration at idle, upto about 1500rpms at any speed. Is this the same issue that others are noticing? I find it is most apparent at lower speeds rather than the 50-60mph that most users are talking about.
Anybody have success with any fixes?
Anybody have success with any fixes?
#307
Harvest day sucks....
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Metro Detroit
Posts: 55
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by mbwmn
i've watched this thread grow from 2+ to 10+ pages...and was hoping i would not have to re-read... is this an AUTO trans only problem?
i just had my 16k Turanzas and wheels replaced w/ new Turanzas. i still have the vibration-
i just had my 16k Turanzas and wheels replaced w/ new Turanzas. i still have the vibration-
#308
Intermediate
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: New York
Age: 58
Posts: 34
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Corn
I've got a 2004 6 speed that has suffered a driveline vibration from day one. It's not the "drone" felt by the Auto's, but was a persistant vibration from 75+ MPH in the steering wheel, felt like the tires were out of balance. New tires (toyo proxes 4) at 30,000 didn't cure the problem. But a brake job at 35,000 did! The really odd thing is that if there was a hotspot in the rotors, I never did feel the wheel pulsating when applying the brakes that would have been an indication of warped rotors. New pads and resurfacing the rotors and now my car rides smooth as glass at any speed. I'm shocked.....and finally happy. It's only been 2 years..........
#309
Intermediate
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: New York
Age: 58
Posts: 34
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by pvansh
I just got an '05 5AT and I've noticed a vibration at idle, upto about 1500rpms at any speed. Is this the same issue that others are noticing? I find it is most apparent at lower speeds rather than the 50-60mph that most users are talking about.
Anybody have success with any fixes?
Anybody have success with any fixes?
#310
an Acura has-been
#311
Originally Posted by Corn
I've got a 2004 6 speed that has suffered a driveline vibration from day one. It's not the "drone" felt by the Auto's, but was a persistant vibration from 75+ MPH in the steering wheel, felt like the tires were out of balance. New tires (toyo proxes 4) at 30,000 didn't cure the problem. But a brake job at 35,000 did! The really odd thing is that if there was a hotspot in the rotors, I never did feel the wheel pulsating when applying the brakes that would have been an indication of warped rotors. New pads and resurfacing the rotors and now my car rides smooth as glass at any speed. I'm shocked.....and finally happy. It's only been 2 years..........
hhhmmm...
thnx for the heads-up. i'm due for front pads soon (24k) and wasn't going to cut straight rotors, but....
i'm getting some vibes from the rear too. 2 sets wheels and 3rd set tires. i have another set of take-off wheels i'll be putting snows on. i'll bet those vibrate too.
#312
Instructor
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Flagstaff, AZ
Posts: 117
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Corn
I've got a 2004 6 speed that has suffered a driveline vibration from day one. It's not the "drone" felt by the Auto's, but was a persistant vibration from 75+ MPH in the steering wheel, felt like the tires were out of balance. New tires (toyo proxes 4) at 30,000 didn't cure the problem. But a brake job at 35,000 did! The really odd thing is that if there was a hotspot in the rotors, I never did feel the wheel pulsating when applying the brakes that would have been an indication of warped rotors. New pads and resurfacing the rotors and now my car rides smooth as glass at any speed. I'm shocked.....and finally happy. It's only been 2 years..........
Starting at about 80 to 85 mph upto 90/95 mph I could feel the vibrations thru the floor board into my steering column, and it wasn't like I was accelarating hard or nothin, just a smooth climb. The vibrations I notice would be there during accelaration as well as smooth decelaration around the same speed.
The first things that came to mind was "shoot, the foo's didn't balance my tires right or it could be the suspension." The next day morning I had to go for another 30 mile drive - same thing.
A week later though after about 3 more days of street driving I had to go for another 30 mile drive on the freeway -- hmmm- the vibrations r a bit more milder; I can still feel em but not as bad.
So then now I am thinking maybe cause the A-spec kit tires were new they just had to get evened out / broken - in / smoothened out who knows. I know it shouldn't be like that but then again ya never know I am going to keep an eye out for the vibrations.
I haven't done my first oil change yet so I don't want to take the car upto those speeds too often so we'll see. Maybe after my first oil change I'll give more focused test drives.
I seriously hope it's not the suspension or nothin!
#313
Cruisin'
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Chicago Suburbs
Age: 71
Posts: 20
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Vibration at lower speeds
Originally Posted by pvansh
I just got an '05 5AT and I've noticed a vibration at idle, upto about 1500rpms at any speed. Is this the same issue that others are noticing? I find it is most apparent at lower speeds rather than the 50-60mph that most users are talking about.
Anybody have success with any fixes?
Anybody have success with any fixes?
However, I never noticed a few months ago in warmer weather....and....After warm up of about 3 miles, the vibration seems to diminish. It also seems to idle rough on a cold morning start.
Is there not some special Exhaust recirculation that goes on during warm-up? I've read about (not this forum) it long ago, but cannot recall. Seemed to reduce pollution during the rich high idle if I remember right.
I don't notice any vibration at higher speeds or RPM's. Someone on the thread said the MDX had similar problem. My Pilot (same essential driveline) is smooth as silk.
At first I am thinking "The TL exhaust is set up to sound like a Mutang V8". But it is just not what I expect in a Luxury Sedan.
Any thoughts on the cold/warm theory?
#314
05 WDP/Ebony/5AT/NaviLess
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Toronto
Age: 43
Posts: 210
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by mikmax1
I have a late 2005 AT. Mine sounds same as yours. At slow neighborhood speeds, my car feels like I am driving a farm tractor. From about 1100 to 1500 rpm. A rumbly vibration, when the engine is lugging at low RPM.
However, I never noticed a few months ago in warmer weather....and....After warm up of about 3 miles, the vibration seems to diminish. It also seems to idle rough on a cold morning start.
Is there not some special Exhaust recirculation that goes on during warm-up? I've read about (not this forum) it long ago, but cannot recall. Seemed to reduce pollution during the rich high idle if I remember right.
I don't notice any vibration at higher speeds or RPM's. Someone on the thread said the MDX had similar problem. My Pilot (same essential driveline) is smooth as silk.
At first I am thinking "The TL exhaust is set up to sound like a Mutang V8". But it is just not what I expect in a Luxury Sedan.
Any thoughts on the cold/warm theory?
However, I never noticed a few months ago in warmer weather....and....After warm up of about 3 miles, the vibration seems to diminish. It also seems to idle rough on a cold morning start.
Is there not some special Exhaust recirculation that goes on during warm-up? I've read about (not this forum) it long ago, but cannot recall. Seemed to reduce pollution during the rich high idle if I remember right.
I don't notice any vibration at higher speeds or RPM's. Someone on the thread said the MDX had similar problem. My Pilot (same essential driveline) is smooth as silk.
At first I am thinking "The TL exhaust is set up to sound like a Mutang V8". But it is just not what I expect in a Luxury Sedan.
Any thoughts on the cold/warm theory?
#315
Cold means stiff rubber, stiff motor mounts, sub frame bushings, stiff tires, stiff exhaust hangers.
EGR only worked after the engine was hot, and not at idle, or full throttle. I was used to reduce NOX by reducing combustion temps, exhaust is inert, no fuel, no oxygen, so that lowers nox when running on the hiway under light to moderate load. For cold start, some cars have air injection, to get the cats warmed up fast by burning the unburnt fuel in the exhaust and cats.
Some cars used a pump, belt or electic motor driven, some used a one way valve and pulses in the exhaust to draw air in.
Brett
EGR only worked after the engine was hot, and not at idle, or full throttle. I was used to reduce NOX by reducing combustion temps, exhaust is inert, no fuel, no oxygen, so that lowers nox when running on the hiway under light to moderate load. For cold start, some cars have air injection, to get the cats warmed up fast by burning the unburnt fuel in the exhaust and cats.
Some cars used a pump, belt or electic motor driven, some used a one way valve and pulses in the exhaust to draw air in.
Brett
#316
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: SF bay area
Posts: 914
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
FOr the cold start-ups, my TL vibrates also but it was really bad when i first got the car. It was literally shaking but im glad it went away but it still vibrates. i have all the 1500 rpm, 30-35 mph, 50-60 mph, etc vibrations. I also have the 2000-2500 rpm vibration but it isnt as bad as the 1500 rpm vibration. The car is super smooth above 2500 rpm, just wish i can say that for below 2500 rpm.
#317
05 WDP/Ebony/5AT/NaviLess
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Toronto
Age: 43
Posts: 210
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by whatjones911
FOr the cold start-ups, my TL vibrates also but it was really bad when i first got the car. It was literally shaking but im glad it went away but it still vibrates. i have all the 1500 rpm, 30-35 mph, 50-60 mph, etc vibrations. I also have the 2000-2500 rpm vibration but it isnt as bad as the 1500 rpm vibration. The car is super smooth above 2500 rpm, just wish i can say that for below 2500 rpm.
#318
Cruisin'
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Chicago Suburbs
Age: 71
Posts: 20
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Anything new?
I get in mine this morning in Garage. Garage is like 50 degrees. Car drives to work smooth as silk. At 25 mph, it is running over 2000rpm for first mile or two, so the engine never lugs. Tranny must stay in lower gear when cold? Or does Torque converter not lock up?
At noon, temp is 30 degrees outside. Drivetrain is like a farm tractor.
Someone mentioned somewhere about an Acura Tech claiming they were blaming Torque converter lockup. Was he on to something?
Anyone ever got this fixed? I never took mind back to dealer yet for anything.
Car is perfect except for the driveline vibration and a small left headliner crackle.
At noon, temp is 30 degrees outside. Drivetrain is like a farm tractor.
Someone mentioned somewhere about an Acura Tech claiming they were blaming Torque converter lockup. Was he on to something?
Anyone ever got this fixed? I never took mind back to dealer yet for anything.
Car is perfect except for the driveline vibration and a small left headliner crackle.
#319
I think either the engine is bad or the exhaust hitting against something....I need someone help me test my method...some day when it is really quiet out side...i can hear something weird my the exahaust system...some thing like a "thumping" sound and if you stand behind the car when really quiet u can really hear it...so...if you have a ramp to drive your car on...park your car on it...and have someone start up the car while you are under the car looking at what causes this vibration and noise....not only i have this problem but i have the hard shake thumping when the engine turn over...start up....say it the car doesnt start the first time...the second time i shake hard....the 06 is much smoother...even when cold...just much better...but lets not get into that...cause i try to told my damn dealer that and they said ....2 yrs of technology different...BS...anyways...i want a fix..my car is lowered so i can no longer get on the ramps
#320
1500 - 2500 Ping/Rumble/Hum
Check this thread to see if this will resolve your issue.
https://acurazine.com/forums/ramblings-12/owned-131221/
https://acurazine.com/forums/ramblings-12/owned-131221/