Esotar 1200 should I pull the trigger?
#1
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Esotar 1200 should I pull the trigger?
I'm seriously sick in the head but I've been thinking of doing a trio of these subs IB for a while now. I love my IB15s and probably won't sell them but I get the itch for change once in a while and it would be neat to run a complete Dynaudio setup. I found one for $850 on DIYMA which is half retail cost.
I'm torn because with the 3 of them I would lose a little displacement, especially in the linear range and they may or may not sound better than what I have. The IB15s would be very hard to beat. I think I'm going to have a listen to a pair of 1200s IB in a TL this coming weekend if everything works out. Hopefully that will help to make my decision.
Any opinions? On the pros I would have a complete matching set of speakers, arguably the best SQ sub on the planet with good output as well. Not that important to me but it's very good looking, especially the part you will see in the trunk.
The cons are the price and the fact that I've never been so satisfied with a sub as I have been with the IB15s, no need to change other than I'm bored. Two IB15s will have significantly more output in the linear range and more total output as well. Right now I hardly ever push them anywhere near the limit though.
Even if I sell both IB15s for the same price I paid new (which is easy) it would pay for less than 1/4 of an e1200.
After writing this I'm leaning more toward not buying the 1200s. BTW, this one would be put away until I collect the trio.
I'm torn because with the 3 of them I would lose a little displacement, especially in the linear range and they may or may not sound better than what I have. The IB15s would be very hard to beat. I think I'm going to have a listen to a pair of 1200s IB in a TL this coming weekend if everything works out. Hopefully that will help to make my decision.
Any opinions? On the pros I would have a complete matching set of speakers, arguably the best SQ sub on the planet with good output as well. Not that important to me but it's very good looking, especially the part you will see in the trunk.
The cons are the price and the fact that I've never been so satisfied with a sub as I have been with the IB15s, no need to change other than I'm bored. Two IB15s will have significantly more output in the linear range and more total output as well. Right now I hardly ever push them anywhere near the limit though.
Even if I sell both IB15s for the same price I paid new (which is easy) it would pay for less than 1/4 of an e1200.
After writing this I'm leaning more toward not buying the 1200s. BTW, this one would be put away until I collect the trio.
#2
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Just did the math. I would be losing 11% total displacement and 60% displacement at xmax. I can live with 11% but the 60% bothers me.
#3
Suzuka Master
Put the money into a retirement fund and thank me later.
Your illness is progressing
Your illness is progressing
The following 2 users liked this post by pohljm:
eggyhustles (04-03-2012),
Mug (04-03-2012)
#4
Matt, as your "dealer", I think I'll stay out of this one....lol! You know the reviews and you know the price (and your budget). Although I would be able to do an extra special deal, it will still be a lot.
#7
Instructor
Do not get the Dyn. It's not worth the coin and I think matching a sub with speakers is overrated. You're better off swapping that MS8 for a BitOne and going to tune town.
err... I mean... by all means go for it and sell me the IB15's!
err... I mean... by all means go for it and sell me the IB15's!
Trending Topics
#8
Racer
iTrader: (1)
I'm seriously sick in the head but I've been thinking of doing a trio of these subs IB for a while now. I love my IB15s and probably won't sell them but I get the itch for change once in a while and it would be neat to run a complete Dynaudio setup. I found one for $850 on DIYMA which is half retail cost.
I'm torn because with the 3 of them I would lose a little displacement, especially in the linear range and they may or may not sound better than what I have. The IB15s would be very hard to beat. I think I'm going to have a listen to a pair of 1200s IB in a TL this coming weekend if everything works out. Hopefully that will help to make my decision.
Any opinions? On the pros I would have a complete matching set of speakers, arguably the best SQ sub on the planet with good output as well. Not that important to me but it's very good looking, especially the part you will see in the trunk.
The cons are the price and the fact that I've never been so satisfied with a sub as I have been with the IB15s. No need to change other than I'm bored. Two IB15s will have significantly more output in the linear range and more total output as well. Right now I hardly ever push them anywhere near the limit though.
Even if I sell both IB15s for the same price I paid new (which is easy) it would pay for less than 1/4 of an e1200.
After writing this I'm leaning more toward not buying the 1200s. BTW, this one would be put away until I collect the trio.
I'm torn because with the 3 of them I would lose a little displacement, especially in the linear range and they may or may not sound better than what I have. The IB15s would be very hard to beat. I think I'm going to have a listen to a pair of 1200s IB in a TL this coming weekend if everything works out. Hopefully that will help to make my decision.
Any opinions? On the pros I would have a complete matching set of speakers, arguably the best SQ sub on the planet with good output as well. Not that important to me but it's very good looking, especially the part you will see in the trunk.
The cons are the price and the fact that I've never been so satisfied with a sub as I have been with the IB15s. No need to change other than I'm bored. Two IB15s will have significantly more output in the linear range and more total output as well. Right now I hardly ever push them anywhere near the limit though.
Even if I sell both IB15s for the same price I paid new (which is easy) it would pay for less than 1/4 of an e1200.
After writing this I'm leaning more toward not buying the 1200s. BTW, this one would be put away until I collect the trio.
In all honesty, if I were to change anything to try, I would swap processors.
#11
Team Owner
Thread Starter
They're down to $800! I was really hoping someone would buy this sub before payday. Too late. I might go for it but it's going to be a paper weight for several months at least.
My brakes are supposed to have been shipped today making the car road worthy again, would it be possible to hear yours for a few minutes next week (if the sub hasn't sold yet)?
My brakes are supposed to have been shipped today making the car road worthy again, would it be possible to hear yours for a few minutes next week (if the sub hasn't sold yet)?
#12
Team Owner
Thread Starter
You answered your own question that is in BOLD. What you said yourself would be the deciding factor (to me). I'd keep the 15's you have in IB and leave the rest of the system the way it is. You did a lot more work to mount speakers/subs.
In all honesty, if I were to change anything to try, I would swap processors.
However, I've been wanting this sub for a while now and it's getting worse lol. I will buy one of these this year even if it's not this one.
#14
I'm sort of in the same boat as you, but the other way around. I currently have one esotar 1200 running IB...but it's just and it's not enough output for me. I just bought (and finally received) two AE IB 15's (now the SPB 15's). But now that I have them, not even sure that I can fit them and still have a solid frame around them.
Bigger issue is that I just don't know if IB can give me the "kick" that I'm looking for that sealed boxes afforded me. The esotar is stupid smooth and organic and you can hardly tell it's there, in a good way. But I want the ability to get my ass kicked by the sub as well. I want to know if that's still possible while going IB. Do you feel that you can find that style of output with your two IB 15's? Any input you can give would be great, as I'm totally at a loss for what to do next with my install. Thanks!!!
PS Was it you that ended up buying that 1200 for $800? I was eyeing it too. Just tried PMing you, but I'm a new member, so don't think it went through.
Bigger issue is that I just don't know if IB can give me the "kick" that I'm looking for that sealed boxes afforded me. The esotar is stupid smooth and organic and you can hardly tell it's there, in a good way. But I want the ability to get my ass kicked by the sub as well. I want to know if that's still possible while going IB. Do you feel that you can find that style of output with your two IB 15's? Any input you can give would be great, as I'm totally at a loss for what to do next with my install. Thanks!!!
PS Was it you that ended up buying that 1200 for $800? I was eyeing it too. Just tried PMing you, but I'm a new member, so don't think it went through.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Jamus22
2G TL Problems & Fixes
24
06-11-2023 10:08 AM
Eggs999bacon
2G TSX (2009-2014)
10
09-24-2015 10:08 AM