Sport Shifting
#1
Sport Shifting
It's definitely more fun using SS. So, just wanted to get the expert drivers tips on what is the best way to shift.
I know shifting from 1st to 2nd is automatic. But from 3rd on, we have more control. Is it best to shift at around 4500 rpms or more? Seems when I shift at 4500 rpm, the car "lags" a bit before shifting into the higher gear.
Also, am I supposed to let off the gas or just keep it down as normal?
Thanks for any inputs.
I know shifting from 1st to 2nd is automatic. But from 3rd on, we have more control. Is it best to shift at around 4500 rpms or more? Seems when I shift at 4500 rpm, the car "lags" a bit before shifting into the higher gear.
Also, am I supposed to let off the gas or just keep it down as normal?
Thanks for any inputs.
#2
I find it works better (less Lag) if you don't let off the gas. As far as shift point it depends on your driving, you figure vtec dosent engage until about 4200rpms or so....so I usually shift between 5000-5800.
#3
Instructor
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: lala land
Age: 41
Posts: 121
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i like to shift at around 4500+ with the VSA off, and i always give a nice boost when shifting (eases the lag). My favorite is hitting 4th gear around 50 mph -- i usually keep my rpm's below 2500 when possible during normal driving.
#4
Team Anthracite Member
Originally Posted by Anubus12
It's definitely more fun using SS. So, just wanted to get the expert drivers tips on what is the best way to shift.
I know shifting from 1st to 2nd is automatic. But from 3rd on, we have more control. Is it best to shift at around 4500 rpms or more? Seems when I shift at 4500 rpm, the car "lags" a bit before shifting into the higher gear.
Also, am I supposed to let off the gas or just keep it down as normal?
Thanks for any inputs.
I know shifting from 1st to 2nd is automatic. But from 3rd on, we have more control. Is it best to shift at around 4500 rpms or more? Seems when I shift at 4500 rpm, the car "lags" a bit before shifting into the higher gear.
Also, am I supposed to let off the gas or just keep it down as normal?
Thanks for any inputs.
#5
2004 SSM/EB/5AT/Navi/RSB
Originally Posted by TerminaderTL
Don't let up on the gas like a manual. Just keep your foot where it is and tap the SS. For better MPG (and less excitement), shift to 3rd at 30 mph, 4th at 40 mph, 5th at 50 mph. For more excitement (and less MPG), don't shift into 3rd until just before the rev limiter at 6500 rpm (about 70 mph) - great for freeway on-ramp acceleration!!!
#6
2nd + redline is fun.
3rd + high rev is still fun with less gas consumption.
Just a little side story.
Two minutes ago on the way home, an old BMW X5 4.4i was driving like it was gonna kill me after I merged from dead stop to 40MPH traffic. I had to floor gas so the woman doesn't honk at me. I filled up tank with regular 87 octane and I felt less power coming out. I would of gone all the way up to 100MPH and left that heavy old X5 in dust if it was open road.
3rd + high rev is still fun with less gas consumption.
Just a little side story.
Two minutes ago on the way home, an old BMW X5 4.4i was driving like it was gonna kill me after I merged from dead stop to 40MPH traffic. I had to floor gas so the woman doesn't honk at me. I filled up tank with regular 87 octane and I felt less power coming out. I would of gone all the way up to 100MPH and left that heavy old X5 in dust if it was open road.
Trending Topics
#8
when i was test driving it..i didnt even need to shift. it just went into the next gears for me :\
do i have to take VSA off to control my shifts? or does it just automatically shift?
do i have to take VSA off to control my shifts? or does it just automatically shift?
#9
Pro
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Vaughan, ON
Age: 36
Posts: 566
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by empathy
when i was test driving it..i didnt even need to shift. it just went into the next gears for me :\
do i have to take VSA off to control my shifts? or does it just automatically shift?
do i have to take VSA off to control my shifts? or does it just automatically shift?
#10
Pro
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Henderson, NV
Age: 49
Posts: 672
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Mike05TL
I find it works better (less Lag) if you don't let off the gas. As far as shift point it depends on your driving, you figure vtec dosent engage until about 4200rpms or so....so I usually shift between 5000-5800.
The TL needs an SMG type of tranny. No torque converter to rob power.
#11
Registered User
Originally Posted by Precision Crafted
I guess my perception is off. I notice a lag if I try to shift from 2nd to 3rd at 30 mph unless I let off of the gas, shift then go back on the gas. To me my TL has that old fashion shift jerk and I'm pushed back into my seat as I step back on the gas as soon as the gears change.
The TL needs an SMG type of tranny. No torque converter to rob power.
The TL needs an SMG type of tranny. No torque converter to rob power.
#13
Originally Posted by black321
what about deccelerating? do u drop down gears or just brake and let the SS downshift for u?
#14
Instructor
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Northern Virginia
Age: 54
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Are you suppose to be putting premium gas in your TL as Acura recommended?
Originally Posted by Actuary
2nd + redline is fun.
3rd + high rev is still fun with less gas consumption.
Just a little side story.
Two minutes ago on the way home, an old BMW X5 4.4i was driving like it was gonna kill me after I merged from dead stop to 40MPH traffic. I had to floor gas so the woman doesn't honk at me. I filled up tank with regular 87 octane and I felt less power coming out. I would of gone all the way up to 100MPH and left that heavy old X5 in dust if it was open road.
3rd + high rev is still fun with less gas consumption.
Just a little side story.
Two minutes ago on the way home, an old BMW X5 4.4i was driving like it was gonna kill me after I merged from dead stop to 40MPH traffic. I had to floor gas so the woman doesn't honk at me. I filled up tank with regular 87 octane and I felt less power coming out. I would of gone all the way up to 100MPH and left that heavy old X5 in dust if it was open road.
#15
Originally Posted by black321
what about deccelerating? do u drop down gears or just brake and let the SS downshift for u?
#16
Pro
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Henderson, NV
Age: 49
Posts: 672
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by rbf351
the car has an automatic tranny, not a manual, so there is no need to let off the gas pedal unless you are trying to slow down.
With that said, if I drive aggessively then gear changes are "right now" cause I guess the computer swithes to a "sport" mode.
On comparison when I test drove the new 325i and GS is that their "manual" mode changed gears when I called for them.
So, what I personnally have noticed is that when I let off the gas, change gears, then go back to the throttle my gear selection was not only made when I wanted it but the TL accelerates better then if I kept on the throttle, waited for a gear change that may or may not happen depending on what speed I am driving at a given time, and kept on accelerating.
#17
Pro
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Henderson, NV
Age: 49
Posts: 672
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by DFBRL8R
If I'm driving aggressively, I usually blip the throttle as I downshift manually so the downshift is not so harsh on the tranny. If I just so happen to be in SS mode and come to a stop sign, I'll brake and let the tranny downshift itself.
#18
Shift_faster
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Queens, NY
Posts: 1,965
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by DFBRL8R
If I'm driving aggressively, I usually blip the throttle as I downshift manually so the downshift is not so harsh on the tranny. If I just so happen to be in SS mode and come to a stop sign, I'll brake and let the tranny downshift itself.
How?
#19
Pro
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Henderson, NV
Age: 49
Posts: 672
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by PoochaKannInc
Wait. It's possible to blip the throttle in an automatic if you are not in Neutral?
How?
How?
#20
Shift_faster
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Queens, NY
Posts: 1,965
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What I meant was that I don't think the driver can manually blip the throttle since you are not disconnecting the tranny from the engine. If you do "blip" the throttle, you will end up accelerating.
#21
Pro
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Henderson, NV
Age: 49
Posts: 672
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by PoochaKannInc
What I meant was that I don't think the driver can manually blip the throttle since you are not disconnecting the tranny from the engine. If you do "blip" the throttle, you will end up accelerating.
#22
2004 SSM/EB/5AT/Navi/RSB
When downshifting in SS mode, I apply a little gas to make the shift smooth. I only need to apply as much as I would to hold the speed constant.
#23
Originally Posted by bluenoise
When downshifting in SS mode, I apply a little gas to make the shift smooth. I only need to apply as much as I would to hold the speed constant.
you will end up accelerating. you cant really drive the SS mode like a manual tranny. it just dosent work that way.
#25
Pro
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Vaughan, ON
Age: 36
Posts: 566
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by empathy
you will end up accelerating. you cant really drive the SS mode like a manual tranny. it just dosent work that way.
#26
2004 SSM/EB/5AT/Navi/RSB
Originally Posted by massr1
you wont accelerate. he is trying to say that when he downshifts, instead of the rpms rising because of the load on the tranny, he gives a little gas to ease the load and match rpms
#27
Shift_faster
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Queens, NY
Posts: 1,965
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by massr1
you wont accelerate. he is trying to say that when he downshifts, instead of the rpms rising because of the load on the tranny, he gives a little gas to ease the load and match rpms
A driver cannot manually rev-match in an automatic transmission. If you can, please feel free to run me through the process.
#28
Moderator Alumnus
For those who like to try on their 6MTs... Double Clutching -- Necessary or not?
#29
2004 SSM/EB/5AT/Navi/RSB
Originally Posted by PoochaKannInc
People. It is an auto tranny. There is no clutch to disengage the engine from the transaxle. How are you matching rpms for the next gear if you are not really disengaging the engine & the transaxle? It is impossible unless the car automatically does it (as in the case of the G35).
A driver cannot manually rev-match in an automatic transmission. If you can, please feel free to run me through the process.
A driver cannot manually rev-match in an automatic transmission. If you can, please feel free to run me through the process.
You're in fifth gear at 2200 RPM and you want to shift to third. If you let your foot off the throttle, the RPM is still pretty much 2200 RPM because there is no clutch to disengage. Now you shift down to third, but the engine wants to be at idle (no throttle still), so it resists the sudden increase in RPM due to the transmission trying to drive it faster. Clunk!
Now do the same, but don't take your foot off the gas. Consider the throttle position when you're cruising in fifth compared to when you're cruising in third. It's roughly the same, so keep it there during the shift and it will be very smooth.
At least take a drive and try it before saying it won't work. Obviously, there are some of us that do this regularly.
#30
Moderator Alumnus
Originally Posted by Anubus12
It's definitely more fun using SS. So, just wanted to get the expert drivers tips on what is the best way to shift.
I know shifting from 1st to 2nd is automatic. But from 3rd on, we have more control. Is it best to shift at around 4500 rpms or more? Seems when I shift at 4500 rpm, the car "lags" a bit before shifting into the higher gear.
Also, am I supposed to let off the gas or just keep it down as normal?
Thanks for any inputs.
I know shifting from 1st to 2nd is automatic. But from 3rd on, we have more control. Is it best to shift at around 4500 rpms or more? Seems when I shift at 4500 rpm, the car "lags" a bit before shifting into the higher gear.
Also, am I supposed to let off the gas or just keep it down as normal?
Thanks for any inputs.
If... if I use SS mode for the regular drive, I'll upshift gears before 3k RPM... If I like to get the "spirited" ride, I'll only upshift after 6k RPM.
#31
Cruisin'
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Morgan Hill, CA
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have an auto and I rarely use the sport shift. I only use it to maintain gears going up and down hills. For the rest of the time, if I want a downshift, I know how much gas to give to get it to kick down a gear or two (since I usually only want it to downshift when I want to poke around other cars). With autos its a matter of knowing how to use your right foot to coax it where you want it.
#32
2004 SSM/EB/5AT/Navi/RSB
Originally Posted by ekumar
I have an auto and I rarely use the sport shift. I only use it to maintain gears going up and down hills. For the rest of the time, if I want a downshift, I know how much gas to give to get it to kick down a gear or two (since I usually only want it to downshift when I want to poke around other cars). With autos its a matter of knowing how to use your right foot to coax it where you want it.
1. Going around a cloverleaf onramp quickly. I lock into 2nd so I can use the throttle to balance the weight between the front and rear wheels.
2. In slow-and-go traffic. I leave it in a relatively-low gear again to regulate my speed without using the brakes. It also gives me more pick-up should I see someone about to rear-end me.
3. Going down a long hill without riding the brakes.
For virtually every other situation, I leave it in auto mode.
I am disappointed about the lag, too. It's not what I was expecting as I've never driven SS before. It seems no different than any other AT where there is "D321" on the selector.
#33
Pro
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Henderson, NV
Age: 49
Posts: 672
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
We'd be better off prehaps with an SMG/ DSG type of tranny with an electronic clutch. But that may be more of an NSX thing. Unless the new tranny in the RDX is one as Justin once indicated that a new tranny would appear in that before anyother Acura.
#34
Cruisin'
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Morgan Hill, CA
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
yeah, the SS lags a bit. I'm not saying I don't like the tranny though. Just I have limited use for that feature. Plus, I'd rather leave it in auto mode versus shifting w/o a clutch. It just seems odd.
#35
Make MyTL Great Again
Originally Posted by bluenoise
Now do the same, but don't take your foot off the gas. Consider the throttle position when you're cruising in fifth compared to when you're cruising in third. It's roughly the same, so keep it there during the shift and it will be very smooth.
At least take a drive and try it before saying it won't work. Obviously, there are some of us that do this regularly.
At least take a drive and try it before saying it won't work. Obviously, there are some of us that do this regularly.
#36
Originally Posted by PoochaKannInc
What I meant was that I don't think the driver can manually blip the throttle since you are not disconnecting the tranny from the engine. If you do "blip" the throttle, you will end up accelerating.
#37
Originally Posted by rets
For those who like to try on their 6MTs... Double Clutching -- Necessary or not?
if u want to run a 30 seconds 1/4 mile time, go ahead and double clutch and not make use of ur synchronizers.
you had to double clutch in older cars because they did not have synchronizers.
you must of had watched the fast and the furious a little too much.
powershifting..all that bs..
the only thing you will need is to clutch fast and shift fast. the IRL, indy, F1, nascar, jgtc, and more do not powershift. their mechanics will stab the drivers after a race. imagine replacing the transmission after every race.
#38
Shift_faster
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Queens, NY
Posts: 1,965
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by bluenoise
Correct, but the torque converter is also not as direct a connection as a clutch, so there is some amount of play. What we're describing is not true rev-matching. It just helps to give a little throttle when downshifting. Consider this (I don't know the real numbers offhand, so bear with me):
You're in fifth gear at 2200 RPM and you want to shift to third. If you let your foot off the throttle, the RPM is still pretty much 2200 RPM because there is no clutch to disengage. Now you shift down to third, but the engine wants to be at idle (no throttle still), so it resists the sudden increase in RPM due to the transmission trying to drive it faster. Clunk!
Now do the same, but don't take your foot off the gas. Consider the throttle position when you're cruising in fifth compared to when you're cruising in third. It's roughly the same, so keep it there during the shift and it will be very smooth.
At least take a drive and try it before saying it won't work. Obviously, there are some of us that do this regularly.
You're in fifth gear at 2200 RPM and you want to shift to third. If you let your foot off the throttle, the RPM is still pretty much 2200 RPM because there is no clutch to disengage. Now you shift down to third, but the engine wants to be at idle (no throttle still), so it resists the sudden increase in RPM due to the transmission trying to drive it faster. Clunk!
Now do the same, but don't take your foot off the gas. Consider the throttle position when you're cruising in fifth compared to when you're cruising in third. It's roughly the same, so keep it there during the shift and it will be very smooth.
At least take a drive and try it before saying it won't work. Obviously, there are some of us that do this regularly.
Hey, if you auto guys think it helps...I can't argue. I have no experience using the SS in any car.
In a stick when you disengage the clutch, you let off the gas, downshift, then blip the throttle while quickly engaging the clutch. I still don't think it is the same thing, but at least I understand what you guys are referring to...
#39
Shift_faster
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Queens, NY
Posts: 1,965
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by empathy
if u want to run a 30 seconds 1/4 mile time, go ahead and double clutch and not make use of ur synchronizers.
you had to double clutch in older cars because they did not have synchronizers.
you must of had watched the fast and the furious a little too much.
powershifting..all that bs..
the only thing you will need is to clutch fast and shift fast. the IRL, indy, F1, nascar, jgtc, and more do not powershift. their mechanics will stab the drivers after a race. imagine replacing the transmission after every race.
you had to double clutch in older cars because they did not have synchronizers.
you must of had watched the fast and the furious a little too much.
powershifting..all that bs..
the only thing you will need is to clutch fast and shift fast. the IRL, indy, F1, nascar, jgtc, and more do not powershift. their mechanics will stab the drivers after a race. imagine replacing the transmission after every race.
#40
Advanced
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Yonkers N.Y
Age: 46
Posts: 50
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Was just curious tonight and found out that in ss, you can upshift to 2nd gear while at a stop. When u take off you will still be in second. If that can be done, then why cant we control the 1st to 2nd gear change when we are on the move?