When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Did Acura fix this for you? The exact same thing happened to me yesterday - 9-13-2020 in a 2019 RDX. They're trying to tell me I have to go through insurance.
I read about people discussing "glass coverage" as being different than "comprehensive". That must be limited to certain states. Here in Texas, all glass is covered under comprehensive through every insurance company.
In some states windshield glass is covered with no deductible, by law. Otherwise, it's covered under comprehensive with the applicable deductible.
In IL it's covered under comprehensive, which I have always had $0 deductible on. I wonder if the states that require it have higher premiums.
It is certainly possible. However, it is very hard to compare insurance rates, as they vary by so many different criteria. Zip code, driver's credit rating, how many miles the owner drives, driver's age, make and model of car, insurance company, etc.etc.etc.
In AZ it is called "safety glass" coverage, I believe, and it is not mandatory that drivers have that coverage, it is mandatory that insurance companies offer it, and it is usually a very low premium addition.
It is certainly possible. However, it is very hard to compare insurance rates, as they vary by so many different criteria. Zip code, driver's credit rating, how many miles the owner drives, driver's age, make and model of car, insurance company, etc.etc.etc.
In AZ it is called "safety glass" coverage, I believe, and it is not mandatory that drivers have that coverage, it is mandatory that insurance companies offer it, and it is usually a very low premium addition.
your right about that, my insurance rate double when I moved to Colorado from Minnesota, just more drivers, more vehicle thefts, more accidents, road debris, etc
Looks like the perfect time to swap it out for a carbon fiber panel to me. When I bought my ILX I asked if I could get one without a big hole in the roof
Looks like the perfect time to swap it out for a carbon fiber panel to me. When I bought my ILX I asked if I could get one without a big hole in the roof
Does it replace the entire roof or just the section where the glass is? How much does it cost? Any photos?
Does it replace the entire roof or just the section where the glass is? How much does it cost? Any photos?
To my knowledge, no one makes one. It's something someone would have to either make their own or have it made custom.
I don't know that anyone would buy a glass roof then replace it with carbon fiber shrug
Had to work on my day off, was just leaving my client and turned onto the highway and there was a loud explosion. It scared me and I could immediately hear stuff flying off my roof. I thought someone had shot my car. I couldn’t safely pull over for a mile. Found a hole in my front moonroof. Filed a claim with my insurance and had to park in the garage. Waiting to see when I can get it fixed. Damage looks identical to others on here. Glad I had the shade closed. I am NOT happy. Just got this car.
Would this be an issue for your insurance (deductibles...increase in rate...etc) or Acura? I know nothing, but if this is an issue with the car (some) is there a glass or design issue? I know this issue has been covered...but.
I would prefer no sunroof anyway. In 3+ years we have opened it once, and closed it right back up. You can guess how I feel about convertibles anymore as well! But does any premium car come without a sunroof any more?
Would this be an issue for your insurance (deductibles...increase in rate...etc) or Acura? I know nothing, but if this is an issue with the car (some) is there a glass or design issue? I know this issue has been covered...but.
I would prefer no sunroof anyway. In 3+ years we have opened it once, and closed it right back up. You can guess how I feel about convertibles anymore as well! But does any premium car come without a sunroof any more?
Many of the MB SUVs do not come with a sunroof standard.
While this is probably due to a design defect from Acura, until it's proven to be so through multiple reports to NHTSA, owner has to cover it through insurance. I think this would be covered under "glass" or "comprehensive". It shouldn't affect one's rates.
Many of the MB SUVs do not come with a sunroof standard.
While this is probably due to a design defect from Acura, until it's proven to be so through multiple reports to NHTSA, owner has to cover it through insurance. I think this would be covered under "glass" or "comprehensive". It shouldn't affect one's rates.
Thanks.I know when we bought our last BMW the sunroof was an option but didn't know if that was a choice with anyone anymore. There is an MB on our list to test drive hopefully later this year (if there's any cars left) so will keep that in mind. On that BMW it was just one more thing to go inoperative (It did, wide open in Bullhead City, AZ summertime heat, which take my word for it, is quite a hellish hot place, 90 miles and a whole other city from where we lived to the dealer, so needless to say, we had an open roof for about a week.) and it was one more thing to air leak (it did) and water leak and rattle, which rattle it did.
Many of the MB SUVs do not come with a sunroof standard.
While this is probably due to a design defect from Acura, until it's proven to be so through multiple reports to NHTSA, owner has to cover it through insurance. I think this would be covered under "glass" or "comprehensive". It shouldn't affect one's rates.
Thanks. At 65 I have yet to file an auto or home insurance claim in my life so don't really know how they work (it surprises me to even type that). We have our insurance, including a large umbrella policy which I would recommend everyone look into, through Costco for the last 35 or so years. I will say, even though they change companies from time to time, it has been terrific (at least sending them money has!) with low rates and low deductibles...until....now. They recently switched to American Family Insurance, which has been a ...shit show. Rates exploded, deductible is sky high just to handles those rates, and their arrogance has been frustrating. One of my many things to do is start searching around. Let's see....who has the best commercials!?
Thanks. At 65 I have yet to file an auto or home insurance claim in my life so don't really know how they work (it surprises me to even type that). We have our insurance, including a large umbrella policy which I would recommend everyone look into, through Costco for the last 35 or so years. I will say, even though they change companies from time to time, it has been terrific (at least sending them money has!) with low rates and low deductibles...until....now. They recently switched to American Family Insurance, which has been a ...shit show. Rates exploded, deductible is sky high just to handles those rates, and their arrogance has been frustrating. One of my many things to do is start searching around. Let's see....who has the best commercials!?
The nature of the economy is such that getting knowledgable, helpful customer service in any business is next to impossible. Not sure what your ZIP is, but depending on where you are the increase in theft and vandalism may be to blame with the increase in rates. In my case, my house insurance went up like 20 or 30 percent because I'm in CA near wildfires and I guess insurance has had to pay out a lot in claims over the last few years.
Thanks.I know when we bought our last BMW the sunroof was an option but didn't know if that was a choice with anyone anymore. There is an MB on our list to test drive hopefully later this year (if there's any cars left) so will keep that in mind. On that BMW it was just one more thing to go inoperative (It did, wide open in Bullhead City, AZ summertime heat, which take my word for it, is quite a hellish hot place, 90 miles and a whole other city from where we lived to the dealer, so needless to say, we had an open roof for about a week.) and it was one more thing to air leak (it did) and water leak and rattle, which rattle it did.
Thanks.I know when we bought our last BMW the sunroof was an option but didn't know if that was a choice with anyone anymore. There is an MB on our list to test drive hopefully later this year (if there's any cars left) so will keep that in mind. On that BMW it was just one more thing to go inoperative (It did, wide open in Bullhead City, AZ summertime heat, which take my word for it, is quite a hellish hot place, 90 miles and a whole other city from where we lived to the dealer, so needless to say, we had an open roof for about a week.) and it was one more thing to air leak (it did) and water leak and rattle, which rattle it did.
My TSX moon roof got stuck open and of course it happened right before a thunderstorm. I quickly learned that unlike past Honda products it was a real pain to get to the manual crank but I eventually got it closed. I haven't opened it since because I know it's the motor and I'm not taking a chance on it happening again. Outside of missing the option to crack it to let some heat out I barely miss it. Also, no moon roof typically gives you more headroom so another added bonus to choosing a model that doesn't have one.
Had to work on my day off, was just leaving my client and turned onto the highway and there was a loud explosion. It scared me and I could immediately hear stuff flying off my roof. I thought someone had shot my car. I couldn’t safely pull over for a mile. Found a hole in my front moonroof. Filed a claim with my insurance and had to park in the garage. Waiting to see when I can get it fixed. Damage looks identical to others on here. Glad I had the shade closed. I am NOT happy. Just got this car.
2019 Acura RDX.
This is truly horrifying. I typically drive with my shade completely down (but pull it up when parking anywhere). I don't know if I can feel safe doing that again!
That stinks. This is my concern with the panoramic roof, even before seeing this thread. Is cold/icy/snow/rainy etc where I live and my driveway is off camber so the RDX roof creaks and moans Leaving in morning for work or when coming home after work. I always keep the roof shade closed because of this lol. What are you guys using to clean the snow off the roof. Fingers crossed it’ll stay intact
Where tempered glass is concerned the problem exists in all brands. Tempered glass is considerably stronger than laminated and can withstand thermal extremes much better as well. The tempering process puts the glass in a state of compression while the core of the glass stays within tension. A small number of tempered lites will randomly explode and when they do they do so spectacularly.
As a manufacturing engineer for an oem window manufacturer I was involved in testing hundreds of tempered window designs for FMVSS 217 certification. Part of that process involved destructive testing.
The suspense during this process was always high due to the unpredictability of the glass. It could explode at 300 psi of applied force or it could go beyond 1200 psi. and hold.
Being a unibody, the roof is a stressed member. If it takes too much stress, pop goes the glass. Because the roof is weaker, if there is a large side load, it will flex the door and pop goes the glass. When I saw one, I was like, hmmm. When I saw it only comes in glass roof, I was like, um, nope, nope, nope. If they continue, they need to add reinforcements, which adds weight. Do they handle hail very well?
09-14-2020, 07:03 PM
