Any manual transmission owners?
#1
Any manual transmission owners?
I'm wondering if this is just the way the car is, or if I should consider looking into it more. The manual trans has two mild, but strange, things going on.
1. Third gear at lower RPMs (1,400 to ~2.700) the car will bog/pulse as it accelerates. Its hard to explain but its almost like being in a gear at too low of rpms. The car kind of rocks back and forth during this process. It doesn't seem to be a problem of clutch work in my opinion. This also slightly happens in fourth gear. Does not happen in any other gears. The solution? Go into 3rd at higher RPMS (3K). Because of the very annoying rev hang, I generally find myself driving slower and shifting slowly to avoid the RPMs raising during shifts, thus shifting into gear at a lower RPM.
2. The clutch behaves different as it warms up. I've made very minor adjustments to the nut in the clutch assembly to remedy this (didnt fix it). I soppose I could get more aggressive on the adjustment. When cold, I love the way the clutch grabs. The beginning of its biting point is pretty much dead center of the clutch pedal throw. As the car warms up, it only bites in the first 20% of the throw. It's manageable, but I find the more center of the clutch pedal easier/confortable on my leg.
Does anyone have similar experiences? These are very small concerns and most likely normal operation., but since they came to mind on my lunch break, I wanted to ask the community what they thought
1. Third gear at lower RPMs (1,400 to ~2.700) the car will bog/pulse as it accelerates. Its hard to explain but its almost like being in a gear at too low of rpms. The car kind of rocks back and forth during this process. It doesn't seem to be a problem of clutch work in my opinion. This also slightly happens in fourth gear. Does not happen in any other gears. The solution? Go into 3rd at higher RPMS (3K). Because of the very annoying rev hang, I generally find myself driving slower and shifting slowly to avoid the RPMs raising during shifts, thus shifting into gear at a lower RPM.
2. The clutch behaves different as it warms up. I've made very minor adjustments to the nut in the clutch assembly to remedy this (didnt fix it). I soppose I could get more aggressive on the adjustment. When cold, I love the way the clutch grabs. The beginning of its biting point is pretty much dead center of the clutch pedal throw. As the car warms up, it only bites in the first 20% of the throw. It's manageable, but I find the more center of the clutch pedal easier/confortable on my leg.
Does anyone have similar experiences? These are very small concerns and most likely normal operation., but since they came to mind on my lunch break, I wanted to ask the community what they thought
#2
Moderator
iTrader: (1)
i have owned my 6MT TL for almost 7 years now.
I know you own the TSX, but just wanted to relate to you, that my clutch is VERY inconsistent. I have the same thoughts as you, when cold it grabs nice! and then from there, the engagement point is different as I drive more throughout the day
I know you own the TSX, but just wanted to relate to you, that my clutch is VERY inconsistent. I have the same thoughts as you, when cold it grabs nice! and then from there, the engagement point is different as I drive more throughout the day
#3
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Dirty H-Town, Amerikkka
Posts: 28,432
Received 7,772 Likes
on
5,045 Posts
The change in bite point sounds like it could be air in the system.
The following users liked this post:
justnspace (01-12-2017)
#4
ROTAREDOM
Im trying to think the last time I was in third gear at 1400rpm........
The following users liked this post:
justnspace (01-12-2017)
#5
#6
I don't have a solution but I'll share my experience. I have a manual 2010 with around 42,000 miles on it that I bought new.
There are times where I will grind my 3rd gear for whatever reason but I've not experienced anything like you are describing above in number 1.
My clutch engagement is also inconsistent but opposite of what you or Justn are describing. Back when the car was only a year or 2 old I drove through some flooded streets in my neighborhood on the way to work. The water was deep and I remember thinking I made the wrong choice trying to drive through it. Luckily I didn't stall but the clutch engagement felt like it was slipping the rest of that day on every shift. For example I could over rev the shift from 3rd to 4th to induce the shuddering. I imagined that I had let water seep into the case that houses the clutch plate and flywheel and that was the cause of what I diagnosed as a slipping clutch. It did disappear in the upper gears within a day or 2 but to this day during cold startups the first few 1st gear shifts are accompanied with a shudder as if the clutch is slipping making it impossible to make a smooth 1st gear take off from a stop. It completely goes away after a few minutes though and shifts as expected so it was never a big enough problem for me to have it checked out. Now that I'm out of warranty its just a characteristic I've gotten used to.
There are times where I will grind my 3rd gear for whatever reason but I've not experienced anything like you are describing above in number 1.
My clutch engagement is also inconsistent but opposite of what you or Justn are describing. Back when the car was only a year or 2 old I drove through some flooded streets in my neighborhood on the way to work. The water was deep and I remember thinking I made the wrong choice trying to drive through it. Luckily I didn't stall but the clutch engagement felt like it was slipping the rest of that day on every shift. For example I could over rev the shift from 3rd to 4th to induce the shuddering. I imagined that I had let water seep into the case that houses the clutch plate and flywheel and that was the cause of what I diagnosed as a slipping clutch. It did disappear in the upper gears within a day or 2 but to this day during cold startups the first few 1st gear shifts are accompanied with a shudder as if the clutch is slipping making it impossible to make a smooth 1st gear take off from a stop. It completely goes away after a few minutes though and shifts as expected so it was never a big enough problem for me to have it checked out. Now that I'm out of warranty its just a characteristic I've gotten used to.
#7
ROTAREDOM
Yeah man too early, you are prolly bogging down the engine. I just glanced at where I am shifting on my way home, and just normal driving I shift between 3-5k from 2nd to 3rd. You can shift lower, but you should not expect any type of acceleration... I mean you idle at 1500 on a cold start, just think about being in 3rd gear at that low of rpm. Manuals are different in their Rev operation than automatics, you need to rev higher so that you can properly disengage from the engine, and re-engage smoothly once the RPM drops. Just my
Trending Topics
#8
Manual owner here as well, 2010 Bought brand new, 99,000 miles on her now. On the first problem absolutely. The acceleration under light acceleration is anything but a smooth arc. it's done this since new. And like you said not the clutch, seems to be an issue with the DBW or perhaps just the maps of the PGMFI.
The second issue, at high RPM's it will not go into second if you aren't slow to shift, and third will do the same, but less of not being able to get into it. Usually just a grind. Acura tells me my clutch needs to be replaced. Ironically I had a 1993 Accord that I put 364,000 miles on and replaced the clutch once. So before you go and say it's my driving, I doubt it, and I definitely beat on the Accord more because It didn't grind into gears.
And just a FYI the manual suggests the following shift points:
The second issue, at high RPM's it will not go into second if you aren't slow to shift, and third will do the same, but less of not being able to get into it. Usually just a grind. Acura tells me my clutch needs to be replaced. Ironically I had a 1993 Accord that I put 364,000 miles on and replaced the clutch once. So before you go and say it's my driving, I doubt it, and I definitely beat on the Accord more because It didn't grind into gears.
And just a FYI the manual suggests the following shift points:
#10
Manual owner here as well, 2010 Bought brand new, 99,000 miles on her now. On the first problem absolutely. The acceleration under light acceleration is anything but a smooth arc. it's done this since new. And like you said not the clutch, seems to be an issue with the DBW or perhaps just the maps of the PGMFI.
The second issue, at high RPM's it will not go into second if you aren't slow to shift, and third will do the same, but less of not being able to get into it. Usually just a grind. Acura tells me my clutch needs to be replaced. Ironically I had a 1993 Accord that I put 364,000 miles on and replaced the clutch once. So before you go and say it's my driving, I doubt it, and I definitely beat on the Accord more because It didn't grind into gears.
And just a FYI the manual suggests the following shift points:
The second issue, at high RPM's it will not go into second if you aren't slow to shift, and third will do the same, but less of not being able to get into it. Usually just a grind. Acura tells me my clutch needs to be replaced. Ironically I had a 1993 Accord that I put 364,000 miles on and replaced the clutch once. So before you go and say it's my driving, I doubt it, and I definitely beat on the Accord more because It didn't grind into gears.
And just a FYI the manual suggests the following shift points:
The following users liked this post:
ssjoeboe9 (01-13-2017)
#11
ROTAREDOM
yeah, new clutch fixes lockout issue.
The following users liked this post:
wrayman (10-11-2019)
#12
I'm wondering if this is just the way the car is, or if I should consider looking into it more. The manual trans has two mild, but strange, things going on.
1. Third gear at lower RPMs (1,400 to ~2.700) the car will bog/pulse as it accelerates. Its hard to explain but its almost like being in a gear at too low of rpms. The car kind of rocks back and forth during this process. It doesn't seem to be a problem of clutch work in my opinion. This also slightly happens in fourth gear. Does not happen in any other gears. The solution? Go into 3rd at higher RPMS (3K). Because of the very annoying rev hang, I generally find myself driving slower and shifting slowly to avoid the RPMs raising during shifts, thus shifting into gear at a lower RPM.
2. The clutch behaves different as it warms up. I've made very minor adjustments to the nut in the clutch assembly to remedy this (didnt fix it). I soppose I could get more aggressive on the adjustment. When cold, I love the way the clutch grabs. The beginning of its biting point is pretty much dead center of the clutch pedal throw. As the car warms up, it only bites in the first 20% of the throw. It's manageable, but I find the more center of the clutch pedal easier/confortable on my leg.
Does anyone have similar experiences? These are very small concerns and most likely normal operation., but since they came to mind on my lunch break, I wanted to ask the community what they thought
1. Third gear at lower RPMs (1,400 to ~2.700) the car will bog/pulse as it accelerates. Its hard to explain but its almost like being in a gear at too low of rpms. The car kind of rocks back and forth during this process. It doesn't seem to be a problem of clutch work in my opinion. This also slightly happens in fourth gear. Does not happen in any other gears. The solution? Go into 3rd at higher RPMS (3K). Because of the very annoying rev hang, I generally find myself driving slower and shifting slowly to avoid the RPMs raising during shifts, thus shifting into gear at a lower RPM.
2. The clutch behaves different as it warms up. I've made very minor adjustments to the nut in the clutch assembly to remedy this (didnt fix it). I soppose I could get more aggressive on the adjustment. When cold, I love the way the clutch grabs. The beginning of its biting point is pretty much dead center of the clutch pedal throw. As the car warms up, it only bites in the first 20% of the throw. It's manageable, but I find the more center of the clutch pedal easier/confortable on my leg.
Does anyone have similar experiences? These are very small concerns and most likely normal operation., but since they came to mind on my lunch break, I wanted to ask the community what they thought
1.) 4cyl NA engines often don't respond well to lower revs. This one has drive by wire and adjustable cam and ignition timing. Instead of allowing knocking like an older ECU would, the ECU will back off the throttle input gain momentarily, in order to adjust for existing available AFR and timing. Then it will adjust the AFR and timing in order to give you your throttle position without knocking.
Bog it if you want. The car will adjust for it. 1400RPM probably isn't ideal...but I wouldn't sweat it too hard. Drive like you want.
2.) The clutch engagement position shouldn't change too much. Honda specs an initial pedal freeplay of 6mm or so. 6mm usually just accounts for the movement of the master cylinder piston til it uncovers the port. So 6mm is "zero" freeplay.
Don't adjust tighter than 6mm (or whatever the manual says) or you'll wear the clutch very quickly.
If you like the clutch to engage with the pedal closer to the floorboard...use MORE freeplay. But don't over do it or you'll wear the synchros very quickly.
I have more issues with the lazyassed throttle response than I do with clutch engagement point. Are you perhaps confusing these two parameters? It may feel like the clutch is responding differently...but its actually the throttle response difference that puts your feet out of rythm.
#13
ROTAREDOM
^ for low low cost of $690 you can fix the throttle response with flashpro ahaha
#14
i have owned my 6MT TL for almost 7 years now.
I know you own the TSX, but just wanted to relate to you, that my clutch is VERY inconsistent. I have the same thoughts as you, when cold it grabs nice! and then from there, the engagement point is different as I drive more throughout the day
I know you own the TSX, but just wanted to relate to you, that my clutch is VERY inconsistent. I have the same thoughts as you, when cold it grabs nice! and then from there, the engagement point is different as I drive more throughout the day
This is on the to do list along with a brake fluid flush this spring. Regardless if this fixes the issue I want it done for piece of mind. I'll use basic Honda dot 3 for the clutch and nice ATE dot 4 for the brake lines.
Yeah man too early, you are prolly bogging down the engine. I just glanced at where I am shifting on my way home, and just normal driving I shift between 3-5k from 2nd to 3rd. You can shift lower, but you should not expect any type of acceleration... I mean you idle at 1500 on a cold start, just think about being in 3rd gear at that low of rpm. Manuals are different in their Rev operation than automatics, you need to rev higher so that you can properly disengage from the engine, and re-engage smoothly once the RPM drops. Just my
I know that these engines are stout. Even when warm I generally don't go past 3K. Of course sometimes I do, but it's pretty rare unless I'm late for work.
Manual owner here as well, 2010 Bought brand new, 99,000 miles on her now. On the first problem absolutely. The acceleration under light acceleration is anything but a smooth arc. it's done this since new. And like you said not the clutch, seems to be an issue with the DBW or perhaps just the maps of the PGMFI.
The second issue, at high RPM's it will not go into second if you aren't slow to shift, and third will do the same, but less of not being able to get into it. Usually just a grind. Acura tells me my clutch needs to be replaced. Ironically I had a 1993 Accord that I put 364,000 miles on and replaced the clutch once. So before you go and say it's my driving, I doubt it, and I definitely beat on the Accord more because It didn't grind into gears.
And just a FYI the manual suggests the following shift points:
The second issue, at high RPM's it will not go into second if you aren't slow to shift, and third will do the same, but less of not being able to get into it. Usually just a grind. Acura tells me my clutch needs to be replaced. Ironically I had a 1993 Accord that I put 364,000 miles on and replaced the clutch once. So before you go and say it's my driving, I doubt it, and I definitely beat on the Accord more because It didn't grind into gears.
And just a FYI the manual suggests the following shift points:
Thanks for sharing those shift points! I'll give that a shot tonight.
For giggles, what does a new clutch installed run at the stealership? I looked up how to replace them on the TSX and it looks like a total PITA.
1.) 4cyl NA engines often don't respond well to lower revs. This one has drive by wire and adjustable cam and ignition timing. Instead of allowing knocking like an older ECU would, the ECU will back off the throttle input gain momentarily, in order to adjust for existing available AFR and timing. Then it will adjust the AFR and timing in order to give you your throttle position without knocking.
Bog it if you want. The car will adjust for it. 1400RPM probably isn't ideal...but I wouldn't sweat it too hard. Drive like you want.
2.) The clutch engagement position shouldn't change too much. Honda specs an initial pedal freeplay of 6mm or so. 6mm usually just accounts for the movement of the master cylinder piston til it uncovers the port. So 6mm is "zero" freeplay.
Don't adjust tighter than 6mm (or whatever the manual says) or you'll wear the clutch very quickly.
If you like the clutch to engage with the pedal closer to the floorboard...use MORE freeplay. But don't over do it or you'll wear the synchros very quickly.
I have more issues with the lazyassed throttle response than I do with clutch engagement point. Are you perhaps confusing these two parameters? It may feel like the clutch is responding differently...but its actually the throttle response difference that puts your feet out of rythm.
Bog it if you want. The car will adjust for it. 1400RPM probably isn't ideal...but I wouldn't sweat it too hard. Drive like you want.
2.) The clutch engagement position shouldn't change too much. Honda specs an initial pedal freeplay of 6mm or so. 6mm usually just accounts for the movement of the master cylinder piston til it uncovers the port. So 6mm is "zero" freeplay.
Don't adjust tighter than 6mm (or whatever the manual says) or you'll wear the clutch very quickly.
If you like the clutch to engage with the pedal closer to the floorboard...use MORE freeplay. But don't over do it or you'll wear the synchros very quickly.
I have more issues with the lazyassed throttle response than I do with clutch engagement point. Are you perhaps confusing these two parameters? It may feel like the clutch is responding differently...but its actually the throttle response difference that puts your feet out of rythm.
How can I measure the 6mm spec for the clutch?
Great to know that bogging isn't necessary a guarantee for knock like it was on older cars. I honestly didn't think under light acceleration I was bogging the car down. I'm going to avoid enterering gear this low.
Oh not to mention, when the engine is cold, above 2k rpms I get the lovely VTC actuator squeel. I just had the damn thing replaced too.
Good point too, it certainly could be lazy throttle response. It's has a mind of its own sometimes, so it certainly could be influenced/caused by my throttle position. I've had a few pros (one Honda speed shop owner and one Acura tech) drive the car, and both got out of the car and handed me the keys and said your car is fine haha. Getting used a 4cyl is really different than the American V8s I am used to. Still love the car for what it is though
#15
As a car engineer I would like to comment on Honda/Acura 4-cylinder engines, particularly the TXS engine (K24). Honda engines with VTEC are by design high-revving engines producing max. power at 7K (K24) or 8K (K20 in Civic Si). It is to the credit of their designers that such engines will kinda "pull" (or tolerate running) from low revs below 2K but it needs to be remembered that at such low revs these engines produce just a fraction of their full power. They are much happier to spin at 3K or above and fuel consumption and exhaust emissions are calibrated to be low at these revs. I personally believe that running them at low revs under partial or full load will not do them any good in the long run.
Of course, there are car engines designed to produce lot of power at lower revs (e.g. older V8s or diesels) but typically they have larger swept volumes (cubic inch capacity) or turbos and such. I do not quite understand why people buy powerful small engines with 7 or 8K redlines and run them in a way that gives them no more than 15-25 % of full usable power. No wonder acceleration is well below par. When this happens, try dropping 2 gears, get in the power band and let the engine activate VTEC and start singing to redline. This is how their designers expected them to be run.
The chart at the bottom of this post shows the relationship between revs and road speed for Honda Accord Euro/Acura TSX (K24, 6MT). It is easy to find revs for various road speeds at given gear, eg. 17 mph (27 kph) in the first gear makes the engine run at 4500 rpm and this is recommended by Honda for usphifts to second gear as I can see from the table in post 8 above. Full size chart is here (takes a while to load).
I was able to solve the inconsistent clutch feel by the simple removal of the CDV (clutch delay valve) - Web search shows how to do it. The more serious and to me the most annoying issue of rev hang where revs dropped way to slow when upshfting at high revs I was able to solve by the install of a small electronic circuit of my own design I called QREVS. I spend some time investigating the rev hang and published my findings here.
Of course, there are car engines designed to produce lot of power at lower revs (e.g. older V8s or diesels) but typically they have larger swept volumes (cubic inch capacity) or turbos and such. I do not quite understand why people buy powerful small engines with 7 or 8K redlines and run them in a way that gives them no more than 15-25 % of full usable power. No wonder acceleration is well below par. When this happens, try dropping 2 gears, get in the power band and let the engine activate VTEC and start singing to redline. This is how their designers expected them to be run.
The chart at the bottom of this post shows the relationship between revs and road speed for Honda Accord Euro/Acura TSX (K24, 6MT). It is easy to find revs for various road speeds at given gear, eg. 17 mph (27 kph) in the first gear makes the engine run at 4500 rpm and this is recommended by Honda for usphifts to second gear as I can see from the table in post 8 above. Full size chart is here (takes a while to load).
I was able to solve the inconsistent clutch feel by the simple removal of the CDV (clutch delay valve) - Web search shows how to do it. The more serious and to me the most annoying issue of rev hang where revs dropped way to slow when upshfting at high revs I was able to solve by the install of a small electronic circuit of my own design I called QREVS. I spend some time investigating the rev hang and published my findings here.
The following 6 users liked this post by aquasurf:
cu2wagon (01-13-2017),
icu2tsx (01-16-2017),
kixo (01-14-2017),
princelybug (01-13-2017),
TSX1012m6 (01-14-2017),
and 1 others liked this post.
#16
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Dirty H-Town, Amerikkka
Posts: 28,432
Received 7,772 Likes
on
5,045 Posts
Wow. Great input. I can't speak to the validity per se, but that seems consistent with what I've heard in the past and what I've experienced.
Since you mentioned it, I'm curious who/what your automotive background is. Did/do you work for Honda or another manufacturer? Very cool to get first hand knowledge. Thanks!
Since you mentioned it, I'm curious who/what your automotive background is. Did/do you work for Honda or another manufacturer? Very cool to get first hand knowledge. Thanks!
#18
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Dirty H-Town, Amerikkka
Posts: 28,432
Received 7,772 Likes
on
5,045 Posts
Cool! I'm a die hard Toyota guy myself. I've always owned at least one, only recently having begrudgingly come over to the dark (Honda) side.
#20
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Dirty H-Town, Amerikkka
Posts: 28,432
Received 7,772 Likes
on
5,045 Posts
Just so there's no confusion, I wanted to make sure you understand that if you are intending to offer anything for sale, you must make a post in the black market (For Sale section of this site) and that any sales that are commercial in nature would require a vendor account.
I'm not accusing or implying anything, as you seem knowledgeable and interested to share your findings. But we've had issues in the past with folks/vendors coming in and doing similar, but more subversive solicitation and it usually ends with a ban.
As we welcome your knowledge and participation, I don't want to see you banned erroneous. Please feel free to PM me if you need more info.
Thanks.
I'm not accusing or implying anything, as you seem knowledgeable and interested to share your findings. But we've had issues in the past with folks/vendors coming in and doing similar, but more subversive solicitation and it usually ends with a ban.
As we welcome your knowledge and participation, I don't want to see you banned erroneous. Please feel free to PM me if you need more info.
Thanks.
#21
Thanks for taking the time to write up this excellent information. I am very interested in your product. I have seen your product/web page in the past. Where can I find more information on the installation of this device? I looked at the wiring diagram, but I couldn't seem to find information on if there is a plug and play harness, or if the end user is required splice/solder wires. Coincidentally, I also have a 2012.
#22
Just so there's no confusion, I wanted to make sure you understand that if you are intending to offer anything for sale, you must make a post in the black market (For Sale section of this site) and that any sales that are commercial in nature would require a vendor account.....
At present I seek opinions about the usefulness or otherwise of my QREVS module to confirm my personal findings that it, indeed, works to remove/significantly reduce rev hang in all three vehicle makes, including Honda, I tested it in so far.
#23
Install is in 2 parts: connection to fuel injectors is handled by easily removable plug-and-play extension harness and connections to engine sensors are most easily accessible near the ECM and must be soldered. No original wires get cut.
#24
ROTAREDOM
lol this thread definitely had a plot twist!
Anyways... who is gunna trust a Toyota engineer :lesigh:
Anyways... who is gunna trust a Toyota engineer :lesigh:
#26
Latent car nut
iTrader: (2)
#27
I think the pedal mod. It's 2019, still love my tsx but the throttle lag is annoying. I've gotten used to it/the gearbox/clutch over the years but every once in a while I wonder if I just suck at driving manual due to inconsistency...
Also quick note. As silly as it sounds a K&N drop in air filter makes a huge difference in low RPM engine bogging. I pulled the one I put in for a paper filter and it was terrible.
Also quick note. As silly as it sounds a K&N drop in air filter makes a huge difference in low RPM engine bogging. I pulled the one I put in for a paper filter and it was terrible.
#28
Latent car nut
iTrader: (2)
Yup, sounds silly; I'm betting there is another explanation.
#29
I think the pedal mod. It's 2019, still love my tsx but the throttle lag is annoying. I've gotten used to it/the gearbox/clutch over the years but every once in a while I wonder if I just suck at driving manual due to inconsistency...
Also quick note. As silly as it sounds a K&N drop in air filter makes a huge difference in low RPM engine bogging. I pulled the one I put in for a paper filter and it was terrible.
Also quick note. As silly as it sounds a K&N drop in air filter makes a huge difference in low RPM engine bogging. I pulled the one I put in for a paper filter and it was terrible.
#30
My car bogs if I stay in second gear (not changing down too 1st) and give it too much gas. This only happend after I used a Hondata Flashpro. Thhis helped reduce the above mentioned rev hangs as well as the 1st to 2nd gear lockout when banging gears. I do concur with a better air filter giving more help on low rpm engine pickup. I have an AEM CAI, routed to the fender-well.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
pkarandi
3G TL Problems & Fixes
5
10-03-2017 10:36 AM
Russell Peters
3G TL Problems & Fixes
17
12-05-2016 10:50 AM
maddogtheta
4G TL Problems & Fixes
5
12-01-2010 04:17 PM
403 UA6
3G TL (2004-2008)
76
07-16-2010 11:35 AM