Comparing the 3.2TL to the 3.5RL ....
#1
Comparing the 3.2TL to the 3.5RL ....
Hey guys what's up? My name's Ricardo and I've sold my old rustbucket integra and am ready to move up a little (despite gas prices!)
I understand that the 3.2TL has transmission issues... but they look and drive is superb!
But... I've also test driven the 3.5RL, and those cars are incredible as well. They don't handle as well, but are MUCH smoother.
I'm not too concerned about handling, as I live in a congested city with no mountain passes to carve, just a TON of potholes to encounter
__________
So here's the deal:
I've been to a local ACURA dealership. They had 2 cars on the lot that interested me. BOTH are 1 owner cars, full maintenance records only at that dealership since day 1 and were trade-ins for new Acuras.
Option 1:
2001 Acura 3.5RL- black interior and black exterior. Premium package- electric steering column, htd/memory seats, bose 8 speaker, 6 cd changer sound system. Has a dealer installed remote starter Looks like new, premium package. New ball joints, new rad, good hydoedge tires, newer timing belt and waterpump, 7 month old battery. Mint overall. No accidents. 1 lady owner who apparently travels alot as a manager of some tax company. Clean carfax. Has 179K miles, but drives amazing. Has 2004 tail lights (clear)- I was surprised! A few door dings though. Price: $3400
Option 2:
2002 Acura 3.2TL-P- black with beige leather. Premium package. Memory seats. Transmission replaced by Acura 2 years ago. It has 159K miles. Alpine aftermarket usb headunit. Body is mint! No door dings like the RL. Drives well and smooth transmission. Has a remote start too! No electric steering, but bose stereo, sunroof, and heated leather. Timing belt is due in 30K miles, and has had no other work done but routine maintenance. Previous owner was a man, haha but it's stock besides the stereo. Tires are michelin harmony and are in great shape! Again, clean carfax, no accidents. $3000
Which would you pick if you had the chance? Here are a few pics (not actual) for comparision.
TL:
RL (this is an 04, but mine has the newer style tail lights with no yellow)
The RL seems a little mature for me, but its a helluva ride for sure. It seems less common than the TL too. Which would you pick??
Help!! lol thanks for reading my long post and helping this n00bie
I understand that the 3.2TL has transmission issues... but they look and drive is superb!
But... I've also test driven the 3.5RL, and those cars are incredible as well. They don't handle as well, but are MUCH smoother.
I'm not too concerned about handling, as I live in a congested city with no mountain passes to carve, just a TON of potholes to encounter
__________
So here's the deal:
I've been to a local ACURA dealership. They had 2 cars on the lot that interested me. BOTH are 1 owner cars, full maintenance records only at that dealership since day 1 and were trade-ins for new Acuras.
Option 1:
2001 Acura 3.5RL- black interior and black exterior. Premium package- electric steering column, htd/memory seats, bose 8 speaker, 6 cd changer sound system. Has a dealer installed remote starter Looks like new, premium package. New ball joints, new rad, good hydoedge tires, newer timing belt and waterpump, 7 month old battery. Mint overall. No accidents. 1 lady owner who apparently travels alot as a manager of some tax company. Clean carfax. Has 179K miles, but drives amazing. Has 2004 tail lights (clear)- I was surprised! A few door dings though. Price: $3400
Option 2:
2002 Acura 3.2TL-P- black with beige leather. Premium package. Memory seats. Transmission replaced by Acura 2 years ago. It has 159K miles. Alpine aftermarket usb headunit. Body is mint! No door dings like the RL. Drives well and smooth transmission. Has a remote start too! No electric steering, but bose stereo, sunroof, and heated leather. Timing belt is due in 30K miles, and has had no other work done but routine maintenance. Previous owner was a man, haha but it's stock besides the stereo. Tires are michelin harmony and are in great shape! Again, clean carfax, no accidents. $3000
Which would you pick if you had the chance? Here are a few pics (not actual) for comparision.
TL:
RL (this is an 04, but mine has the newer style tail lights with no yellow)
The RL seems a little mature for me, but its a helluva ride for sure. It seems less common than the TL too. Which would you pick??
Help!! lol thanks for reading my long post and helping this n00bie
#4
Moderator
IMHO
The TL is a Faster and parts are more Available and the Trans Sucks.
But
The RL is a Hell of a Sexy car everytime reminds me a Benz, I dunno if they have wierd Problems I would check it out first in the RL side.
If you dont travel enough The RL will feel Slow, Clumsy and BIG.
If Daily Driving is in City the TL is the choice for you ALSO the Price is Incredible coming from the dealer.
But Rememer with Great Power, Comes the Big Responsability of Changing the Trans every now and Then.
The TL is a Faster and parts are more Available and the Trans Sucks.
But
The RL is a Hell of a Sexy car everytime reminds me a Benz, I dunno if they have wierd Problems I would check it out first in the RL side.
If you dont travel enough The RL will feel Slow, Clumsy and BIG.
If Daily Driving is in City the TL is the choice for you ALSO the Price is Incredible coming from the dealer.
But Rememer with Great Power, Comes the Big Responsability of Changing the Trans every now and Then.
Last edited by Skirmich; 06-02-2011 at 01:22 PM.
Trending Topics
#8
Three Wheelin'
TL is rated 17-27 city/hwy and RL is rated 16-22 city/hwy. The RL is a gas guzzler IMO and i would stay away from it. The TL is ok but has some maintainance issues (transmission, crappy tires and paint chipping/flaking).
#9
Moderator
FYI: The 1st Gen of RL is FWD ONLY, You are Mistaking it Vs the Newer Gen that had Optional AWD.
Who Stays with OEM Tires anyway?? Chipping/Flaking Paint? Never heard of it.
Last edited by Skirmich; 06-02-2011 at 03:23 PM.
#10
Three Wheelin'
Who Stays with OEM Tires anyway?? Chipping/Flaking Paint? Never heard of it.
or this:
#11
Moderator
Yeah I now about that but I forgot the Red Line, Dumb 5 Minutes edit screw it.
But adding Up I have my OEM Painting and Its a little toasted by the Sun but it has never Flake, Other than that with a Good Polish it looks brand new.
Rolling on Yokohamas S. Drive or YK520 put those michelins out of their misery.
But adding Up I have my OEM Painting and Its a little toasted by the Sun but it has never Flake, Other than that with a Good Polish it looks brand new.
Rolling on Yokohamas S. Drive or YK520 put those michelins out of their misery.
#12
Three Wheelin'
ya well I'm hoping to get these yokohoma trz just have the convince the woman of the family and justify the expense. this is the hardest part, I rather rim up install those tires myself than bring it up to her. The tl will be taking a nice long nap in the garage until then.
#13
Thanks for the feedback all!
I'm pretty sure both are FWD, and that the 05 and newer RL has all wheel drive as standard.
The RL is built in japan, so it's quality should be higher, no?
I'll be honest, I'd be pretty upset if the transmission took a crap on me.
Will 159K on the TL and 179K on the RL, a difference of 20K miles make a huge difference, given regular maintenance, and RL was 50 yr old lady driven lulz
Crazy how expensive the RL was new (rip off!), but it does feel higher quality I feel and is solid feeling.
But the TL is nice to toss around, as per my test drive, the on ramp was a lot more thrilling- more steering feedback.
I'm taking the plunge this weekend, since I'm without a car right now The only thing I see is that the RL has a newer timing belt.
Would you buy your 3.2TL again? I'm a skeptic after reading these forums, especially the trans failure thread..... is it really THAT bad?!
By contrast, the 1g RL forums seems to point towards a more bulletproof platform, minus egr issues. hmm
Everyone I've talked to says the RL is more ballin. I just want tint. I'd keep both of them stock, given the mileage
I'm pretty sure both are FWD, and that the 05 and newer RL has all wheel drive as standard.
The RL is built in japan, so it's quality should be higher, no?
I'll be honest, I'd be pretty upset if the transmission took a crap on me.
Will 159K on the TL and 179K on the RL, a difference of 20K miles make a huge difference, given regular maintenance, and RL was 50 yr old lady driven lulz
Crazy how expensive the RL was new (rip off!), but it does feel higher quality I feel and is solid feeling.
But the TL is nice to toss around, as per my test drive, the on ramp was a lot more thrilling- more steering feedback.
I'm taking the plunge this weekend, since I'm without a car right now The only thing I see is that the RL has a newer timing belt.
Would you buy your 3.2TL again? I'm a skeptic after reading these forums, especially the trans failure thread..... is it really THAT bad?!
By contrast, the 1g RL forums seems to point towards a more bulletproof platform, minus egr issues. hmm
Everyone I've talked to says the RL is more ballin. I just want tint. I'd keep both of them stock, given the mileage
#17
Moderator
I Would Buy my Car Again 2G TL-S anytime of the Year blindfolded....
I really dont consider that the Tranny outweights the Good things of the Car, BUT If you arent prepared (BECOUSE IT WILL) for a Tranny Failure dont buy it...
ALSO: If you swap (Another 1.5Kish) the Accord V6 tranny from a 05-07 you wont have to worry about a Tranny Failure ever Again and you will have a REALLY Reliable Car, Cuz aside from the Tranny Failure? The car is Flawless for Me.
My 2 Cents.. L8ters.
I really dont consider that the Tranny outweights the Good things of the Car, BUT If you arent prepared (BECOUSE IT WILL) for a Tranny Failure dont buy it...
ALSO: If you swap (Another 1.5Kish) the Accord V6 tranny from a 05-07 you wont have to worry about a Tranny Failure ever Again and you will have a REALLY Reliable Car, Cuz aside from the Tranny Failure? The car is Flawless for Me.
My 2 Cents.. L8ters.
#19
I'm a thrill seeker in my
My TL-S has been fantastic to me with no problems thus far, and only regular maintenance needed. She has been always good to me and a great all year driver. I think that generation of RL is ugly, bland and nothing special. I personally think the 2G TL (especially with the kit) can still look phenomenal 10 years later (look at my car as an example). And if you're interested at all in adding to your car at all down the road the TL does have some aftermarket support where as the RL will have none.
Ultimately it's your choice, but my vote clearly would go to the TL.
Ultimately it's your choice, but my vote clearly would go to the TL.
#22
2006 NBP TL MT6/ 02TL-S
I don't see many RLs and never paid any attention to them. The affluent side of this town is just covered up with Lexus, BMWs, Mercedes, 3rd & 4th gen TLs, Audis, Jags, , Porsches, etc., but I rarely see an RL.
I thought the RLs were Acura's answer to the RWD Mercedes for some reason........
I thought the RLs were Acura's answer to the RWD Mercedes for some reason........
#24
So I bought the RL today.
Reasons for purchase:
1) Timing belt + wp were MUCH newer
2) much nicer interior IMHO (quality of materials, and build quality/sturdiness)
3) New rad + ball joints
4) elderly lady driven (actually met her at the dealer lol)
5) Manly styling haha (if I debadged, ppl would think I drive a benz, my friends called the TL a fancy accord)
6) MAJOR: a reliable transmission design, similar to the 1G 3.2TL and tried and true from back to 1996 in the RL.
Thanks for all your help guys. I'm happy with my choice, and that's all that matters ahaha.
Reasons for purchase:
1) Timing belt + wp were MUCH newer
2) much nicer interior IMHO (quality of materials, and build quality/sturdiness)
3) New rad + ball joints
4) elderly lady driven (actually met her at the dealer lol)
5) Manly styling haha (if I debadged, ppl would think I drive a benz, my friends called the TL a fancy accord)
6) MAJOR: a reliable transmission design, similar to the 1G 3.2TL and tried and true from back to 1996 in the RL.
Thanks for all your help guys. I'm happy with my choice, and that's all that matters ahaha.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
saberlove
2G TL Performance Parts & Modifications
12
03-11-2021 09:29 AM
mlody
5G TLX (2015-2020)
85
12-04-2019 02:11 PM
Medinak12
3G TL Audio, Bluetooth, Electronics & Navigation
2
09-23-2015 07:11 PM