View Poll Results: Worth swapping bell housings?
Yes
0
0%
Voters: 3. You may not vote on this poll
07 BAYA Swap
#1
10th Gear
Thread Starter
07 BAYA Swap
I cannot seem to find a definitive answer before trying to do it myself first hand but I was curious if anyone has gone the extra mile to keep the power steering speed sensor from the 02 stock TL trans by swapping the bell housing over to the 07 BAYA trans case? Or is looping the power steering line back to the rack really no big deal?
#2
Suzuka Master
iTrader: (1)
Personally, as was mentioned by others in the FAQ AV6 thread, I don't think I have seen anyone ever specifically document that they have done this here.
Reason being is because it is the '...looping of the steering line back to the rack...' that is listed as the quick alternative (on the attachment below if you have not already read it) to the issue for those TL-P folks like yourself.
You would be the first, if you follow through.
Last edited by zeta; 11-29-2023 at 04:00 PM.
The following users liked this post:
El Jefe (11-29-2023)
#3
10th Gear
Thread Starter
You probably won't get one, in the short term, because this forum is like , and most with this TL-P dilemma have moved on.
Personally, as was mentioned by others in the FAQ AV6 thread, I don't think I have seen anyone ever specifically document that they have done this here.
Reason being is because it is the '...looping of the steering line back to the rack...' that is listed as the quick alternative (on the attachment below if you have not already read it) to the issue for those TL-P folks like yourself.
You would be the first, if you follow through.
Personally, as was mentioned by others in the FAQ AV6 thread, I don't think I have seen anyone ever specifically document that they have done this here.
Reason being is because it is the '...looping of the steering line back to the rack...' that is listed as the quick alternative (on the attachment below if you have not already read it) to the issue for those TL-P folks like yourself.
You would be the first, if you follow through.
Currently looking into 07 BAYA tech books for bell housing removal to just compare difference with TL procedure for theory before going head in. Ive got the Acura book(s) but for the accord, not able to find the bell housing part thru 800 pages of transaxle stuff for accord online.
#4
Suzuka Master
iTrader: (1)
^
If you want, maybe reach out to DP01TL since he is the latest TL-P'er to have performed the AV6 swap.
Not sure if he did the 'loop back', but probably, so he may be able to give you his personal opinion on whether the PS is different enough to warrant what you have in mind?
Doing BAYA swap this weekend... - AcuraZine - Acura Enthusiast Community
If you want, maybe reach out to DP01TL since he is the latest TL-P'er to have performed the AV6 swap.
Not sure if he did the 'loop back', but probably, so he may be able to give you his personal opinion on whether the PS is different enough to warrant what you have in mind?
Doing BAYA swap this weekend... - AcuraZine - Acura Enthusiast Community
Last edited by zeta; 11-29-2023 at 04:55 PM.
#5
10th Gear
Thread Starter
^
If you want, maybe reach out to DP01TL since he is the latest TL-P'er to have performed the AV6 swap.
Not sure if he did the 'loop back', but probably, so he may be able to give you his personal opinion on whether the PS is different enough to warrant what you have in mind?
Doing BAYA swap this weekend... - AcuraZine - Acura Enthusiast Community
If you want, maybe reach out to DP01TL since he is the latest TL-P'er to have performed the AV6 swap.
Not sure if he did the 'loop back', but probably, so he may be able to give you his personal opinion on whether the PS is different enough to warrant what you have in mind?
Doing BAYA swap this weekend... - AcuraZine - Acura Enthusiast Community
#6
In regards to swapping the bell housing, trust me, I looked into it. Per a guy that rebuilds these transmissions all the time, he stated that the probability of the shafts, oil passages, gearsets and everything else being "on the money" for you to swap the bellhousing is basically NIL.
The output gearing changed, the shaft locations are different, etc, etc... He said you could end up machining new shafts and possibly modifying the older bellhousing, but in reality it only takes a single new shaft in a place the old one doesn't have it and or vice-versa (old shaft that the new one doesn't have) and you are screwed.
Basically they "fixed" the older design, which means they made enough changes to not even consider the effort. And since that means cracking the case apart you are looking at a full rebuild to accomplish it anyways, which means measureing endplay on shafts and everything else. The mess alone to look into it made me say, "screw it". Well that and the transmission i used was a rebuilt unit already.
Trust me, I am one to not want to "give up" features and options. It killed me to have to decide to go the AV6 route... But, once I got into it I noticed the guy that butchered my car previously broke the mounting ear off the speed-sensitive steering pump and it was just "in there" without being retained... I was more than a little pissed to see that.
Honestly, now that we have been driving the car for the past few months, I don't regret doing the AV6 swap at all.
The output gearing changed, the shaft locations are different, etc, etc... He said you could end up machining new shafts and possibly modifying the older bellhousing, but in reality it only takes a single new shaft in a place the old one doesn't have it and or vice-versa (old shaft that the new one doesn't have) and you are screwed.
Basically they "fixed" the older design, which means they made enough changes to not even consider the effort. And since that means cracking the case apart you are looking at a full rebuild to accomplish it anyways, which means measureing endplay on shafts and everything else. The mess alone to look into it made me say, "screw it". Well that and the transmission i used was a rebuilt unit already.
Trust me, I am one to not want to "give up" features and options. It killed me to have to decide to go the AV6 route... But, once I got into it I noticed the guy that butchered my car previously broke the mounting ear off the speed-sensitive steering pump and it was just "in there" without being retained... I was more than a little pissed to see that.
Honestly, now that we have been driving the car for the past few months, I don't regret doing the AV6 swap at all.
The following users liked this post:
zeta (11-29-2023)
The following users liked this post:
El Jefe (11-30-2023)
Trending Topics
#9
Suzuka Master
iTrader: (1)
Well, the best solution for me was just to leave the bypass hose at 100% (ie, no restrictor on it, full flow). The steering needs a little muscle at low speeds, but even the wife doesn't mind it at all. It is VERY driveable and there are no surprises on the highway. For safety it is the best solution I do believe. Also, I am going to be doing another fluid exchange on teh steering when I redo the timing belt and waterpump. With the bypass hos in place the way it is the entire system should flush properly. I had the issue of the bypass side not flushing at all because the wheels were not turning the first time I followed the factory service manual procedure and the remaining black fluid contaminated the new fluid I just put in the system. I was NOT happy with brand new fluid looking dark brown (yeah the fluid that was in teh car after 229k miles was black as pitch). So when I do the other work I will be putting on a new power steering belt and redoing the fluid in teh pwoer steering system once more.
Honestly, I am sure there is a "perfect orifice size" to put into the bypass hose to get it to feel identical to the Type-S steering. I would imagine it is closer to the bypass outlet size (on the inlet to that hose, which is smalelr than the outlet tube) than the hose size is. I would say about 9/10 the size would be a good start, going down to 4/5 the size as the smallest... Anything smaller than that runs the risk of the car being too twitchy on the highway at speed, which, especially in winter, could be asking for an accident. A small change at lower speed is all that is needed to make it perfect. With it full open it just feels a bit "heavy".
Honestly, I am sure there is a "perfect orifice size" to put into the bypass hose to get it to feel identical to the Type-S steering. I would imagine it is closer to the bypass outlet size (on the inlet to that hose, which is smalelr than the outlet tube) than the hose size is. I would say about 9/10 the size would be a good start, going down to 4/5 the size as the smallest... Anything smaller than that runs the risk of the car being too twitchy on the highway at speed, which, especially in winter, could be asking for an accident. A small change at lower speed is all that is needed to make it perfect. With it full open it just feels a bit "heavy".
#10
10th Gear
Thread Starter
In regards to swapping the bell housing, trust me, I looked into it. Per a guy that rebuilds these transmissions all the time, he stated that the probability of the shafts, oil passages, gearsets and everything else being "on the money" for you to swap the bellhousing is basically NIL.
The output gearing changed, the shaft locations are different, etc, etc... He said you could end up machining new shafts and possibly modifying the older bellhousing, but in reality it only takes a single new shaft in a place the old one doesn't have it and or vice-versa (old shaft that the new one doesn't have) and you are screwed.
Basically they "fixed" the older design, which means they made enough changes to not even consider the effort. And since that means cracking the case apart you are looking at a full rebuild to accomplish it anyways, which means measureing endplay on shafts and everything else. The mess alone to look into it made me say, "screw it". Well that and the transmission i used was a rebuilt unit already.
Trust me, I am one to not want to "give up" features and options. It killed me to have to decide to go the AV6 route... But, once I got into it I noticed the guy that butchered my car previously broke the mounting ear off the speed-sensitive steering pump and it was just "in there" without being retained... I was more than a little pissed to see that.
Honestly, now that we have been driving the car for the past few months, I don't regret doing the AV6 swap at all.
The output gearing changed, the shaft locations are different, etc, etc... He said you could end up machining new shafts and possibly modifying the older bellhousing, but in reality it only takes a single new shaft in a place the old one doesn't have it and or vice-versa (old shaft that the new one doesn't have) and you are screwed.
Basically they "fixed" the older design, which means they made enough changes to not even consider the effort. And since that means cracking the case apart you are looking at a full rebuild to accomplish it anyways, which means measureing endplay on shafts and everything else. The mess alone to look into it made me say, "screw it". Well that and the transmission i used was a rebuilt unit already.
Trust me, I am one to not want to "give up" features and options. It killed me to have to decide to go the AV6 route... But, once I got into it I noticed the guy that butchered my car previously broke the mounting ear off the speed-sensitive steering pump and it was just "in there" without being retained... I was more than a little pissed to see that.
Honestly, now that we have been driving the car for the past few months, I don't regret doing the AV6 swap at all.
#11
10th Gear
Thread Starter
Type S Rack
#12
But, it all worked out well, I ended up replacing all the solenoids with Rostra units (shift solenoids, linear pressure solenoids, etc), replaced the remaining sensors (pressure, temperature, speed, etc) with new Honda units all on a rebuilt BAYA with less than 12k on it (I think there was actually only about 6-8k on the rebuild). I added in an external transmission cooler and a transmission fluid thermostat to control flow to the external cooler. I kept the original fluid "heater" (the Acura versions are stainless steel and nice units) as I drive the car in winter.
Then I went off the deep-end on a stereo installation and a remote start/alarm installation... Glutton for punishment I guess.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
MaxBeast4Z
2G TL (1999-2003)
2
05-13-2020 05:22 PM
CedNBHTL
3G TL Audio, Bluetooth, Electronics & Navigation
9
02-22-2007 11:22 AM