Acknowledging Bad German Cars
#41
Originally posted by teombe
The current (1997-2003) 5-series automatic transmission is a General Motors HydraMatic EL540 (or something like that). It can also be found in the Cadillac CTS.
The current (1997-2003) 5-series automatic transmission is a General Motors HydraMatic EL540 (or something like that). It can also be found in the Cadillac CTS.
Now why on Earth would something like that take place???
#42
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: SF Bay Area, California
Posts: 880
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by MotownTSX
HOLY SH$TTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!! DID NOT KNOW THAT!!!
Now why on Earth would something like that take place???
HOLY SH$TTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!! DID NOT KNOW THAT!!!
Now why on Earth would something like that take place???
There was a time when Ford Lincolns had GM auto trannies that were also used in their own GM Cadillacs.
I'm not aware of anything bad or inferior about GM's auto trannies.
Another example of competitor sharing parts involve BMW and Chryzler. Together, they build 4 cylinder engines in Brazil. (They had arranged this before Daimler-Benz bought Chryzler.) The engine basis for the BMW Mini Cooper and the Dodge or Chryzler Neon are from the same source.
#43
More On
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Larchmont, NY
Posts: 4,388
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by teombe
The current (1997-2003) 5-series automatic transmission is a General Motors HydraMatic EL540 (or something like that).....
The current (1997-2003) 5-series automatic transmission is a General Motors HydraMatic EL540 (or something like that).....
#44
I bet they made GM promise not to tell anybody.
http://www.cadillac.com/cadillacjsp/...nsmission.html
http://www.gm.com/automotive/gmpower.../apps/5l40.htm
By the way, here are the other cars the transmission is currently used in:
BMW 3-Series
BMW 3-Series Sedan and Wagon
BMW 3-Series All Wheel Drive
BMW 5-Series
BMW X5 Sport Utility
BMW Z3 Roadster
Cadillac CTS
OPEL Omega
ROVER Range Rover
#46
The 5 speed transmission in the CTS has a notchier feel.
#49
Originally posted by TSXinCA
I couldn't agree with you more, autoXer. I had a 2001 Jetta GLX for 2 years. Supension, chassis, tranny etc all GREAT. Only 175 hp w/ the VR6, but in that tiny little frame that thing jammed. Handled well, very fun to drive w/ VR6 manual. Never had any problems with the engine or drivetrain. HOWEVER, I had one trim or electonic problem after another the entire time I owned it. At any given time I was frustrated by at least one problem, usually more than one. And just when one got fixed, something else would happen. Here is the list of problems I had, all in just under 2 years:
Replaced CD changer TWICE
Replaced window regulators TWICE
cupholder broke
center console lid broke
1 headlight died
BOTH brake lights died
at least 1/2 dozen loud rattles, all over the interior cabin
"check coolant" light kept coming on for no reason
power door locks malfuntioned intermittently
steering wheel controls for stereo malfuntioned intermittently
Most people I know with VW's had similar problems, altho not to the same high degree that I did. Seem to be much more problems with Jetta than Beetle or Passat, but I know of several people with those models who have had problems too. I will never guy another German car, they are just not made well IMO. VW'S ARE RATTLE TRAPS!!!
On the flip side, I know many, many people with Japanese cars (specifically Honda & Toyota) and very few of them have any problems. No car is perfect, but the statistics speak for themselves!!
I couldn't agree with you more, autoXer. I had a 2001 Jetta GLX for 2 years. Supension, chassis, tranny etc all GREAT. Only 175 hp w/ the VR6, but in that tiny little frame that thing jammed. Handled well, very fun to drive w/ VR6 manual. Never had any problems with the engine or drivetrain. HOWEVER, I had one trim or electonic problem after another the entire time I owned it. At any given time I was frustrated by at least one problem, usually more than one. And just when one got fixed, something else would happen. Here is the list of problems I had, all in just under 2 years:
Replaced CD changer TWICE
Replaced window regulators TWICE
cupholder broke
center console lid broke
1 headlight died
BOTH brake lights died
at least 1/2 dozen loud rattles, all over the interior cabin
"check coolant" light kept coming on for no reason
power door locks malfuntioned intermittently
steering wheel controls for stereo malfuntioned intermittently
Most people I know with VW's had similar problems, altho not to the same high degree that I did. Seem to be much more problems with Jetta than Beetle or Passat, but I know of several people with those models who have had problems too. I will never guy another German car, they are just not made well IMO. VW'S ARE RATTLE TRAPS!!!
On the flip side, I know many, many people with Japanese cars (specifically Honda & Toyota) and very few of them have any problems. No car is perfect, but the statistics speak for themselves!!
#50
Another example of competitor sharing parts involve BMW and Chryzler. Together, they build 4 cylinder engines in Brazil. (They had arranged this before Daimler-Benz bought Chryzler.) The engine basis for the BMW Mini Cooper and the Dodge or Chryzler Neon are from the same source.
MB is rapidly researching and testing 4-bangers out as I write this so they can give the BMW engine the boot. I heard that they are rather embarrassed to be sleeping with the enemy on this one.
And it is ChrySler. Not to nitpick, but it was bugging me...:P
#51
Originally posted by MotownTSX
How many times do I have to say this.....your pos Jetta is NOT a German car. It was probably made in Guadalahara or Cancun.......Volkwagen USA has the most calls for service out of every single maker that deals in the U.S. And it isn't even close...they are dead-last by many thousands...
How many times do I have to say this.....your pos Jetta is NOT a German car. It was probably made in Guadalahara or Cancun.......Volkwagen USA has the most calls for service out of every single maker that deals in the U.S. And it isn't even close...they are dead-last by many thousands...
bwhahaha..the guy has no clue... must have been conned by the salesman...that's like taking the reliability of mitsubishi,suzuki to conclude that japanese auto's are POS
#52
Advanced
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Sacramento, CA
Age: 54
Posts: 82
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by MotownTSX
How many times do I have to say this.....your pos Jetta is NOT a German car. It was probably made in Guadalahara or Cancun.......Volkwagen USA has the most calls for service out of every single maker that deals in the U.S. And it isn't even close...they are dead-last by many thousands...
How many times do I have to say this.....your pos Jetta is NOT a German car. It was probably made in Guadalahara or Cancun.......Volkwagen USA has the most calls for service out of every single maker that deals in the U.S. And it isn't even close...they are dead-last by many thousands...
The VW may be assembled in Mexico, but it is not a Mexican car. It is a German design, made by a German company. They're just outsourcing the assembly, but IT IS A GERMAN CAR.
#53
More On
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Larchmont, NY
Posts: 4,388
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Therm
.....P.S. how you you put another post's quote in your reponse?
.....P.S. how you you put another post's quote in your reponse?
BTW -- Once in a while something goes wrong and you have to fix it up. This would be a different thread, but....... I don't think anybody has ever mentioned it. What happens is, some stuff gets chopped off the top of the "quoted" portion, and a corrupt symbol is thrown in, and when you try to post your reply, it won't go -- you get a message telling you to "complete message field."
But don't worry about that too much for now. Just click "Quote," and you'll be good almost all the time.
#55
Originally posted by TSXinCA
Just about any car has parts made elsewhere or is assembled somewhere else. So by your logic there really is almost no such thing as a German car or a Japanese care, etc etc.
The VW may be assembled in Mexico, but it is not a Mexican car. It is a German design, made by a German company. They're just outsourcing the assembly, but IT IS A GERMAN CAR.
Just about any car has parts made elsewhere or is assembled somewhere else. So by your logic there really is almost no such thing as a German car or a Japanese care, etc etc.
The VW may be assembled in Mexico, but it is not a Mexican car. It is a German design, made by a German company. They're just outsourcing the assembly, but IT IS A GERMAN CAR.
#56
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: SF Bay Area, California
Posts: 880
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by MotownTSX
And it is ChrySler. Not to nitpick, but it was bugging me...:P
And it is ChrySler. Not to nitpick, but it was bugging me...:P
I've also noticed that some who speak British English also pronounce it with a "z" sound.
Let's just say it's my pet name for a company whose products I never admired--Chryzler. Ja!
#57
Originally posted by TSXinCA
Just about any car has parts made elsewhere or is assembled somewhere else. So by your logic there really is almost no such thing as a German car or a Japanese care, etc etc.
The VW may be assembled in Mexico, but it is not a Mexican car. It is a German design, made by a German company. They're just outsourcing the assembly, but IT IS A GERMAN CAR.
Just about any car has parts made elsewhere or is assembled somewhere else. So by your logic there really is almost no such thing as a German car or a Japanese care, etc etc.
The VW may be assembled in Mexico, but it is not a Mexican car. It is a German design, made by a German company. They're just outsourcing the assembly, but IT IS A GERMAN CAR.
#58
More On
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Larchmont, NY
Posts: 4,388
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It probably comes originally from the German name "Kreisler," like the famous violinist Fritz Kreisler (I figure maybe 2 other people here ever heard of him!). FWIW -- his name was always pronounced exactly like we here say Chrysler. But I think the authentic German way would be like a "z".
#59
Advanced
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Sacramento, CA
Age: 54
Posts: 82
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by MotownTSX
It's assembled in Mexico. Who cares about the design. If it falls apart (all the complaints are mechanical), it is because of poor assembly. VW Europe does not have this problem. The VWs in Japan are top-notch (expensive as well) and then I found out why: Japan gets 'em from Germany....go figure.
It's assembled in Mexico. Who cares about the design. If it falls apart (all the complaints are mechanical), it is because of poor assembly. VW Europe does not have this problem. The VWs in Japan are top-notch (expensive as well) and then I found out why: Japan gets 'em from Germany....go figure.
#60
Advanced
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Sacramento, CA
Age: 54
Posts: 82
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by gilboman
so since most stuff made in china (eg electronics) are either european in origin or US...would you call them US or European componets?? if you do then
so since most stuff made in china (eg electronics) are either european in origin or US...would you call them US or European componets?? if you do then
As for electronics, whatever company created, designed and coordinated manufacturing of the product is the one who "owns" it. It may be assembled in China, but that doesn't make it a Chinese product. Take Nike for example, just because those shoes you're wearing were made in some sweatshop in SE Asia, that doesn't mean Nike is an Asian company. Duh!
#61
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: SF Bay Area, California
Posts: 880
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by larchmont
It probably comes originally from the German name "Kreisler," like the famous violinist Fritz Kreisler (I figure maybe 2 other people here ever heard of him!). FWIW -- his name was always pronounced exactly like we here say Chrysler. But I think the authentic German way would be like a "z".
It probably comes originally from the German name "Kreisler," like the famous violinist Fritz Kreisler (I figure maybe 2 other people here ever heard of him!). FWIW -- his name was always pronounced exactly like we here say Chrysler. But I think the authentic German way would be like a "z".
A German "z" (the letter "tset".) is pronounced like an English "ts". Therefore, "Zimmer" would be pronounced something like "TSIMmer".
Therefore, the TSX should sound like "tsex", if it were a word. (Phfew! I'm back on topic, whatever that was!) I wish Acura had a better name for the favored car of this forum! It's a good reason to debadge, debadge, debadge! Afterall, its target audience is not the ghetto pimp!
#62
Therefore, the TSX should sound like "tsex", if it were a word. (Phfew! I'm back on topic, whatever that was!) I wish Acura had a better name for the favored car of this forum! It's a good reason to debadge, debadge, debadge! Afterall, its target audience is not the ghetto pimp! [/B][/QUOTE]
What is your def of a ghetto pimp?
What is your def of a ghetto pimp?
#63
More On
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Larchmont, NY
Posts: 4,388
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by TSXinCA
.....If you hire a Chinese cook in an Italian restaurant, do you now call it a Chinese restaurant?? Of course not!
.....If you hire a Chinese cook in an Italian restaurant, do you now call it a Chinese restaurant?? Of course not!
Actually I agree completely with Motown on his basic point. I wouldn't call the Jetta a "Mexican" car, and I've laughed a lot at the idea. But, let's not get hung up on what we'd call it. What we care about it how the car is. To most of us, the question of whether we call it a Mexican car or a German car is relevant only to the extent that it tells us something about how the car is.
In this case, I don't know if it does, but certainly it could. I'm tempted to say that it does, because we know that Jettas have had serious problems. But, I think, so have German cars that were built in Germany in the last few years.
I wouldn't call the U.S.-built Acuras "American" cars. But it does seem they've had more problems than the Japan-built Acuras, and that's worth knowing.
#64
Originally posted by TSXinCA
Many of the problems I experienced were design flaws, such as the window regulator was a plastic piece glued to metal (any moron can tell you you can't glue metal to plastic-it never holds!). Can't fault assembly for that, it was part of the German design. Also, the cupholders were poorly designed, and the gunk they use in the underside near the doors to protect against rust damage oozed out all over my driveway in the hot California summer becuase the design did not take into account anything other than cold weather driving. These are all design issues attributable to the German VW engineers. There were some assemply issues as well, but the majority were design issues. But either way I still don't see how you can call it a Mexican car just because it was assembled there. It was created and designed by a German company that also coordinates the foreign assembly operations, so it is a German car...period. If you hire a Chinese cook in an Italian restaurant, do you now call it a Chinese restaurant?? Of course not!
Many of the problems I experienced were design flaws, such as the window regulator was a plastic piece glued to metal (any moron can tell you you can't glue metal to plastic-it never holds!). Can't fault assembly for that, it was part of the German design. Also, the cupholders were poorly designed, and the gunk they use in the underside near the doors to protect against rust damage oozed out all over my driveway in the hot California summer becuase the design did not take into account anything other than cold weather driving. These are all design issues attributable to the German VW engineers. There were some assemply issues as well, but the majority were design issues. But either way I still don't see how you can call it a Mexican car just because it was assembled there. It was created and designed by a German company that also coordinates the foreign assembly operations, so it is a German car...period. If you hire a Chinese cook in an Italian restaurant, do you now call it a Chinese restaurant?? Of course not!
Call 'em what you will, but a Mexican VW is NOT close to a Euro VW. (but it's still a VW....:'( )
BTW....ever see what kind of warranties Euro auto companies give on Mexican-built cars? 24-36 months TOPS. That should tell you something....
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post