Selling the Audi S4 and thinking of getting a Forester 2.5XT 5MT
Trending Topics
ROFL, nice 
I have no choice. My student loans are kicking my ass and I took a 15% paycut this year.
I need to be responsible and unfortunately that means selling the Audi while it still has value and isn't bleeding me dry on repairs.

I have no choice. My student loans are kicking my ass and I took a 15% paycut this year.
I need to be responsible and unfortunately that means selling the Audi while it still has value and isn't bleeding me dry on repairs.
One's in Cali and the guy wants $17k for it with 43k miles. Has a STi Intercooler, COBB DP, etc. That's a pretty good deal. If it's still available when I sell my car, I may see what I can do about it.
Since I want AWD and a MT that will fit my dogs for under $20k, my options are limited. Since I'm looking to keep it a while (I have to this time since I'm jacking up my student loan payments every month to pay them off sooner)
Not much in that range with those features.
If I go auto then I have more options but they become less interesting to me.
If I don't go Forester, I'm looking at a FX35 (2005).
Any other suggestions are appreciated. Nothing German as the point is to find something less expensive to maintain than what I already have.
Would like:
AWD, MT, room for my dogs, under $20k used.
The new TSX wagon should be nice as well as the CTS wagon. I couldn't drive a Forrester on principle! 
*edit* You and I posted at the same time Charlie. Obviously my suggestions do not meet your criteria. Still nice though!

*edit* You and I posted at the same time Charlie. Obviously my suggestions do not meet your criteria. Still nice though!
But a 2.5XT 5MT does 0-60 in about 5.8 seconds, has AWD, and I can throw the dogs in the back and not worry about them barfing all over my seats.
So, while yes, I guess it's a lesbianmobile there's not a whole lot out there as an alternative.
Even if I decided to get an Audi Avant, I'm looking at a 2005 2.0T at best and I'm back to the $125/hr labor rates and stupid shit failing

Really, a 6MT Avant would be the perfect solution here. I could pull out my RNS-E and I already have the wheels for it.
It's just A4s of that vintage have issues.
NP ... Believe me, if I could afford a $45k car I definitely wouldn't buy a Forester.
But a 2.5XT 5MT does 0-60 in about 5.8 seconds, has AWD, and I can throw the dogs in the back and not worry about them barfing all over my seats.
So, while yes, I guess it's a lesbianmobile there's not a whole lot out there as an alternative.
Even if I decided to get an Audi Avant, I'm looking at a 2005 2.0T at best and I'm back to the $125/hr labor rates and stupid shit failing
Really, a 6MT Avant would be the perfect solution here. I could pull out my RNS-E and I already have the wheels for it.
It's just A4s of that vintage have issues.
But a 2.5XT 5MT does 0-60 in about 5.8 seconds, has AWD, and I can throw the dogs in the back and not worry about them barfing all over my seats.
So, while yes, I guess it's a lesbianmobile there's not a whole lot out there as an alternative.
Even if I decided to get an Audi Avant, I'm looking at a 2005 2.0T at best and I'm back to the $125/hr labor rates and stupid shit failing

Really, a 6MT Avant would be the perfect solution here. I could pull out my RNS-E and I already have the wheels for it.
It's just A4s of that vintage have issues.
that can do what you ask.
I own a Subaru, I'm just trapped in a man's body. Just find the turbo, and slowly purchase the go fast bits later, or go this route: 2004 Forester 5MT
It may not be a turbo, but you get the rest and it's very affordable. And in your spot, affordable may be what you need.
You're not thinking wrong for wanting the top lesbaru model
that can do what you ask.
I own a Subaru, I'm just trapped in a man's body.
Just find the turbo, and slowly purchase the go fast bits later, or go this route: 2004 Forester 5MT
It may not be a turbo, but you get the rest and it's very affordable. And in your spot, affordable may be what you need.
that can do what you ask.
I own a Subaru, I'm just trapped in a man's body. Just find the turbo, and slowly purchase the go fast bits later, or go this route: 2004 Forester 5MT
It may not be a turbo, but you get the rest and it's very affordable. And in your spot, affordable may be what you need.
If you guys saw what my Springer Spaniel does to my Audi, you'd probably give me less grief about the Lesbaru
Very similar situations...I recently got rid of my B7 A4 and got an '07 FXT. Guess you could call it coming out of the closet 



What I like:
Space (fit 4 dogs with the seats down)
AWD
Versatility
Gigantic Moonroof
Cheaper insurance
Mod Potential (It's basically a high WRX)
Dislike:
Gas hog
Fabric interior (terrible with dog hair)
Turbo lag
4 speed Auto tranny (5 MT's were very hard to find)
Rattles
I'm getting married this month and got a mortgage earlier this year, so we had to cut costs. I did a lot of research before deciding on the Subie and to me it was a good compromise from the Audi. I eventually mod my cars in some way or form and the Forester is a great platform for that sick habit.




What I like:
Space (fit 4 dogs with the seats down)
AWD
Versatility
Gigantic Moonroof
Cheaper insurance
Mod Potential (It's basically a high WRX)
Dislike:
Gas hog
Fabric interior (terrible with dog hair)
Turbo lag
4 speed Auto tranny (5 MT's were very hard to find)
Rattles
I'm getting married this month and got a mortgage earlier this year, so we had to cut costs. I did a lot of research before deciding on the Subie and to me it was a good compromise from the Audi. I eventually mod my cars in some way or form and the Forester is a great platform for that sick habit.
I'm going to hold out for the 5MT FXT if I can ... Has anyone done a 5MT -> 6MT swap?
But, you would definitely save on insurance cost, especially for 2008 or older models. It's funny, my insurance classifies my 2007 as a station wagon, but it classifies the '09+ models as an SUV.
As for 6 speed swaps, I heard it's been done before, but it's expensive and can be problematic. Most people are satisfied with the 5MT.
Besides a 5MT, were you looking at Sports XT or Limited XT models? There are big cosmetic differences between the two.
19-20 combined? Yeah, you're not going to get much better fuel savings going to an XT Forester. It uses premium fuel and most owners report anywhere from 20-24mpg combined driving (City/Fwy). Not much of an improvement over the S4's V8.
But, you would definitely save on insurance cost, especially for 2008 or older models. It's funny, my insurance classifies my 2007 as a station wagon, but it classifies the '09+ models as an SUV.
As for 6 speed swaps, I heard it's been done before, but it's expensive and can be problematic. Most people are satisfied with the 5MT.
Besides a 5MT, were you looking at Sports XT or Limited XT models? There are big cosmetic differences between the two.
But, you would definitely save on insurance cost, especially for 2008 or older models. It's funny, my insurance classifies my 2007 as a station wagon, but it classifies the '09+ models as an SUV.
As for 6 speed swaps, I heard it's been done before, but it's expensive and can be problematic. Most people are satisfied with the 5MT.
Besides a 5MT, were you looking at Sports XT or Limited XT models? There are big cosmetic differences between the two.
If I could buy this guy's car right now and carry two until my S4 sold I'd do it:
2007 FXT 5MT with STI and Cobb upgrades - 43k miles for $17k
NICE. That's a great Forester and the price is right with all those upgrades. Plus he's swapped his turbo for a VF43 from an '07 STi. Not the biggest or best, but a good step up from stock and good for longevity. I wonder what numbers he's putting down? Nice sleeper for sure with very tasteful upgrades/mods.
Plus, if it makes a difference, it's an '07 which means it has butt warmers/heated seats. Subaru deleted from the 2008 XT sports...I love my seat warmers.
Plus, if it makes a difference, it's an '07 which means it has butt warmers/heated seats. Subaru deleted from the 2008 XT sports...I love my seat warmers.
Curious, why not a Legacy GT Spec B?
Very similar situations...I recently got rid of my B7 A4 and got an '07 FXT. Guess you could call it coming out of the closet 



What I like:
Space (fit 4 dogs with the seats down)
AWD
Versatility
Gigantic Moonroof
Cheaper insurance
Mod Potential (It's basically a high WRX)
Dislike:
Gas hog
Fabric interior (terrible with dog hair)
Turbo lag
4 speed Auto tranny (5 MT's were very hard to find)
Rattles
I'm getting married this month and got a mortgage earlier this year, so we had to cut costs. I did a lot of research before deciding on the Subie and to me it was a good compromise from the Audi. I eventually mod my cars in some way or form and the Forester is a great platform for that sick habit.




What I like:
Space (fit 4 dogs with the seats down)
AWD
Versatility
Gigantic Moonroof
Cheaper insurance
Mod Potential (It's basically a high WRX)
Dislike:
Gas hog
Fabric interior (terrible with dog hair)
Turbo lag
4 speed Auto tranny (5 MT's were very hard to find)
Rattles
I'm getting married this month and got a mortgage earlier this year, so we had to cut costs. I did a lot of research before deciding on the Subie and to me it was a good compromise from the Audi. I eventually mod my cars in some way or form and the Forester is a great platform for that sick habit.
can't believe I totally forgot about the LGT wagon! 
I would approve of that
but same thing, good luck finding an LGT 5MT wagon, I think they discontinued the LGT wagon in the US altogether in 2007. It's one of my favorite wagons of all-time

and obligatory dog pics:


I would approve of that
and obligatory dog pics:










