New car-itis!!
08-10-2009, 08:07 PM
#1
Punk Rocker
Thread Starter
New car-itis!!
Ok, I know you guys hardly ever see any "what car should I get" threads so I figured I'd be unique!
Anyway, the new car bug is hitting rather hard right now (as it does every 6 months or so) and I'm thinking of trading in my G37 (again). I definitely want to try something German this go-round and am thinking BMW, BMW, BMW (all these guys with new M3's are getting me thinking). So here's my short list (in order of preference):
1. 08-09 BMW M3 coupe
2. 08-09 BMW M3 coupe
(fiancee says it ain't happening)
3. 09 BMW 335i coupe
4. 08-09 Audi S5
(fiancee kicks me in the balls)
5. 09 Audi A5
6. 06-07 Porsche 911S
Anyway, just testing the waters. I checked out an 08 M3 at Tom Bush BMW yesterday and it was friggin awesome. My price range tops out at around $47k so I think I might either order a new 335i or wait around until the end of the year and try to get a deal on a slightly used M3. What you guys think???
Anyway, the new car bug is hitting rather hard right now (as it does every 6 months or so) and I'm thinking of trading in my G37 (again). I definitely want to try something German this go-round and am thinking BMW, BMW, BMW (all these guys with new M3's are getting me thinking). So here's my short list (in order of preference):
1. 08-09 BMW M3 coupe
2. 08-09 BMW M3 coupe
(fiancee says it ain't happening)
3. 09 BMW 335i coupe
4. 08-09 Audi S5
(fiancee kicks me in the balls)
5. 09 Audi A5
6. 06-07 Porsche 911S
Anyway, just testing the waters. I checked out an 08 M3 at Tom Bush BMW yesterday and it was friggin awesome. My price range tops out at around $47k so I think I might either order a new 335i or wait around until the end of the year and try to get a deal on a slightly used M3. What you guys think???
08-10-2009, 08:10 PM
#2
Senior Moderator
C6 vette 
Trending Topics
08-10-2009, 09:04 PM
#9
Suzuka Master
CPO Porsche Carrera S or Corvette Z06 
I had a tough time choosing between the two myself.
But honestly if you don't need rear seats at all, 335i and M3 wouldn't be really that much of an evolution of your G37S. Also check out 996 GT2s/GT3s, prices have been really low lately.
Lotus Elise SC?
I had a tough time choosing between the two myself.
But honestly if you don't need rear seats at all, 335i and M3 wouldn't be really that much of an evolution of your G37S. Also check out 996 GT2s/GT3s, prices have been really low lately.
Lotus Elise SC?
Last edited by nokiaman; 08-10-2009 at 09:08 PM.
08-10-2009, 09:35 PM
#12
Suzuka Master
I would AT LEAST take a 997 C2S for a drive before ordering a 335.
08-10-2009, 09:54 PM
#15
Suzuka Master
08-11-2009, 01:01 AM
#17
08-11-2009, 07:05 AM
#18
Ok, I know you guys hardly ever see any "what car should I get" threads so I figured I'd be unique!
Anyway, the new car bug is hitting rather hard right now (as it does every 6 months or so) and I'm thinking of trading in my G37 (again). I definitely want to try something German this go-round and am thinking BMW, BMW, BMW (all these guys with new M3's are getting me thinking). So here's my short list (in order of preference):
1. 08-09 BMW M3 coupe
2. 08-09 BMW M3 coupe
(fiancee says it ain't happening)
3. 09 BMW 335i coupe
4. 08-09 Audi S5
(fiancee kicks me in the balls)
5. 09 Audi A5
6. 06-07 Porsche 911S
Anyway, just testing the waters. I checked out an 08 M3 at Tom Bush BMW yesterday and it was friggin awesome. My price range tops out at around $47k so I think I might either order a new 335i or wait around until the end of the year and try to get a deal on a slightly used M3. What you guys think???
Anyway, the new car bug is hitting rather hard right now (as it does every 6 months or so) and I'm thinking of trading in my G37 (again). I definitely want to try something German this go-round and am thinking BMW, BMW, BMW (all these guys with new M3's are getting me thinking). So here's my short list (in order of preference):
1. 08-09 BMW M3 coupe
2. 08-09 BMW M3 coupe
(fiancee says it ain't happening)
3. 09 BMW 335i coupe
4. 08-09 Audi S5
(fiancee kicks me in the balls)
5. 09 Audi A5
6. 06-07 Porsche 911S
Anyway, just testing the waters. I checked out an 08 M3 at Tom Bush BMW yesterday and it was friggin awesome. My price range tops out at around $47k so I think I might either order a new 335i or wait around until the end of the year and try to get a deal on a slightly used M3. What you guys think???
08-11-2009, 07:36 AM
#19
Safety Car
911, ya dumbo
1. you have an itch every 6 mo. to upgrade your car. stop meeting your goals half way! get a true sportscar.
2. you already have a sedan and truck.
3. surely the best bet, financially. if you tend to take depreciation hits with constant car upgrades, than why would you want a car like a 335 that is going to tire you a year from now? plus, buying a 911 will force you to buy used. better bang for buck.
4. you need a financial advisor
1. you have an itch every 6 mo. to upgrade your car. stop meeting your goals half way! get a true sportscar.
2. you already have a sedan and truck.
3. surely the best bet, financially. if you tend to take depreciation hits with constant car upgrades, than why would you want a car like a 335 that is going to tire you a year from now? plus, buying a 911 will force you to buy used. better bang for buck.
4. you need a financial advisor
Last edited by ThermonMermon; 08-11-2009 at 07:41 AM.
08-11-2009, 08:34 AM
#20
dɐɹɔ ǝɥʇ ʇɐɥʍ
As much as I love the 997 I would not get an early 997 carrera(non-S) with a tiptronic transmission. My main complaint about used 911's is that it is nearly impossible to find a car optioned exactly as you would order it new, there are too many options. That said I absolutely love driving the 997, one of the few pricey cars I've driven that I actually felt was worth the money. They are reliable, fun to drive, relatively practical and fairly durable.
If a 911 fits in your lifestyle and budget presently I would not hesitate to investigate further. It's one of those cars that you look back at owning and relish the experience, good luck!
If a 911 fits in your lifestyle and budget presently I would not hesitate to investigate further. It's one of those cars that you look back at owning and relish the experience, good luck!
08-11-2009, 09:16 AM
#21
Instructor
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: NYC
Posts: 118
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Great Minds Think alike:
My Current Car: 08 G35x
My Next Car: 2010 - 2011 M3 (Euro Delivery)
My Following Car After that : 911
If I was in your shoes at the current moment 08 M3 Coupe, I see those going as low as 45K, very tempting.
My Current Car: 08 G35x
My Next Car: 2010 - 2011 M3 (Euro Delivery)
My Following Car After that : 911
If I was in your shoes at the current moment 08 M3 Coupe, I see those going as low as 45K, very tempting.
08-11-2009, 09:18 AM
#22
Changin bulbs since '73
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Chi-town burbs
Age: 50
Posts: 8,111
Likes: 0
Received 12 Likes
on
4 Posts
we have a disease!
As much as I love 911's the M3 or a 335 is the better choice. Much more practical, and as far as I remember this car is your DD. The trunk and back seat space is great in this car.
Between 335 and M3 ... first I would go used. There are great deals out there. I think You can pick a used 08 or maybe even an 09 M3 ....This car is unbelievable. I like it a lot better then the 335....but the 335 isn't bad by any means. I did not like the manual tranny in the 335. The M3 suspension is amazing, that and the sound of that v8 do it for me everyday! the pros for a new 335 would me the new I drive and WAAAY better gas mileage...it is pretty fast as well.
Good luck!
08-11-2009, 11:26 AM
#26
Safety Car
08-11-2009, 11:31 AM
#27
My Garage
08-11-2009, 11:40 AM
#28
Safety Car
guess it's opinion based, but i treat cars like assets. i would only abuse a car if it was leased...or once the cost of resale fell below cost of repairs (thats when you know youre stuck with her until she dies...like most of our CLs)
Last edited by ThermonMermon; 08-11-2009 at 11:45 AM.
08-11-2009, 12:07 PM
#29
Suzuka Master
Why treat it like an asset when what you're going after is the extra available performance? Everyone should buy a 328i then since it offers more than enough power for daily duties. I'm not saying one should driving at WOT or at break-necking speeds but I've always been a firm believer even if you buy a Ferrari or Lamborghini let alone a Bimmer, you should put some serious miles onto it.
08-11-2009, 12:20 PM
#30
The sizzle in the Steak
911
08-11-2009, 12:25 PM
#31
Safety Car
Why treat it like an asset when what you're going after is the extra available performance? Everyone should buy a 328i then since it offers more than enough power for daily duties. I'm not saying one should driving at WOT or at break-necking speeds but I've always been a firm believer even if you buy a Ferrari or Lamborghini let alone a Bimmer, you should put some serious miles onto it.
...sorry for side tracking...
08-11-2009, 12:31 PM
#32
My Garage
guess it all depends on the definition of "driving the hell out of it"
08-11-2009, 02:30 PM
#36
Punk Rocker
Thread Starter
Yeah, my heart is really set on an M3 but I just don't see it happening financially. I'm not planning on doing anything until the end of the year anyway so maybe the prices will be a bit lower by then....
08-11-2009, 02:46 PM
#38
Ask Surfer Rick... he is rollin a 911 as a DD, if I am not mistaken... I see a buncha M3's around here but I dont know anyone who using one as a DD...
...oh, yeah... I vote for the 911... classic lines, good reliability, fast... and probably alot less of a hurt on your wallet when something goes wrong...
...oh, yeah... I vote for the 911... classic lines, good reliability, fast... and probably alot less of a hurt on your wallet when something goes wrong...
