Crazy Bimmer

Sorry for the ghetto layout.

Street Spirit

Yeah, I've been seeing a lot of comparisons and articles in the paper the past month or so. I still don't think I'll ever sway too far from Nokian or Gislaved, although I have heard some good things about certain Michelin snows (mostly for ice).

subinf

Just in time. It was 74 degrees here today.

Will Y.

Winter tires??!

80*F-85*F here in LA/Orange County today depending on area, dropping to high 70s tomorrow, except at the beach where it'll be overcast and about 70*F.
We can just use "summer tires" all year.

mclarenf3387

Seems more like an advertisement for Michelin than a winter tire comparison. It is nice to see the differences between the categories of tires though.

I gotta get off my butt and order some winter tires soon before the snow hits. Tire rack has a good deal on Blizzack LM-25s right now.

jackolo

Yupp, they're clearing out the LM25s to make way for their new model, the LM60(?). I ordered and received my order from Tirerack within the week. Up here, it's well worth it to have a dedicated set of winters.

Costco

Winter tires? They actually make those?

I actually could have had my t-tops off today if I wanted! And I drive on my summer tires year-round too thankfully they do an amazing job in the wet. :ibsomeonementionstaxesandcostoflivingetc:

and finally now I know the purpose of HX MXM4s... terrible tires but I guess they had some all-around performance (including snow/ice) in mind.

vas25tl

I ran Blizzak WS-60's last Winter, they were amazing, handled great.

fsttyms1

Exactly my thought when i got that issue. To be fair they should have tested other snow tires from other manufacturers.

That said i personally love the Dunlop Wintersport M3 and 3D. A nice blend of performance and great snow traction. The tire isnt soft or squishy at speed.

LuvMyTSX

+1

I have the M3s and they are great. Feels a lot like an all season tire but much better in rain/snow/slush, quiet on the road, and mine are lasting longer than I expected. Plus, the whole tire is winter compound instead of half winter and half all season like the Blizzaks.

dallison

i have a set of michelin alpins for the winter that seemt o work very well. I bought them used last year and i can get a few more years out of them. They handle very well on dry pavement and on snow.

Everyone at work drives their 4x4 to work and i make it here before them in my fwd car..

I had run ws50 on my clp and they were nice, but they were a very soft tire and i had to reduce speed on dry corners. They were awesome on snow though.

dallison

c&d should test other cheaper tires also.

JS + XES

iTrader: (1)

winter tires? really??

Street Spirit

Big time.

"....And this article was sponsored by...."

Crazy Bimmer

Touche.

I thought the article proved its point about winter tires vs all seasons regardless of the brand.

Thats what i took from it.

fsttyms1

It did but it was a advertisement for the big marshmallow guy. They should have done it with multiple brands

The Dougler

iTrader: (1)

Great tire, I had the previous model WS-50 on my TL, thing felt like it was tank in all snow conditions. You have to be a little more cautious after a few years once you wear past the air bubbles that are injected into the rubber on the first 60% of the tread, they felt a little greasy then, but would dig through anything.

cmark

I have those Michelin Pilot Sport A/S+ so I'm anxious to see how they do this winter.

5o9

I'm not buying Michelin's statement that 1/3 of traction is attributed to rubber compound and 2/3 is tread pattern. Think this is why the tires that are manufactured in the tundra are so much better...

Way cold temps, allseason compound becomes hocky pucks

What works for me is mica or something in the compound, the snow sticks to the tire, and snow on snow traction is great

Rock2534

I read that article last week and couldn't believe they had anything good to say about the MXM4's, those came on my CL and I could hardly move in the snow with those. If they would have come out and said that the MXM4's were straight shit in the snow, I would give their report some credibility, anything less than that is biased in my opinion.

fsttyms1

but most tires with it it only goes part way thru the tread and once thru it the traction stinks, (like the blizzaks)

sho_nuff1997

iTrader: (2)

They did a great comparo for the summer tires, why not the winter tires?

Nonetheless, winter tires are a must and my car will never see a set of all-seasons.

5o9

^ You are right about the Blizzaks

I hear the Nokians go all the way through, will get them next time. Would have got them last time but nearly impossible to buy around here, called three dealers, not one of them even returned a quote! Think it was because what I wanted, they didn't have in stock, and they primarily sell other brands