Exhaust modification question
#1
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Exhaust modification question
Hey everyone, sorry if these questions have been asked already! I’m interested in doing HFPC’s and J-Pipe in my ‘10 6MT, however I live in an emissions state (RI) and I don’t want the exhaust too loud (so I definitely would not want a full cat back or mufflers) Would this setup pass emissions and be quiet enough to not be annoying or attract unwelcome attention?
#2
Drifting
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Salt Lake City, UT
Age: 42
Posts: 3,490
Received 849 Likes
on
605 Posts
I doubt you'll have a problem. I have the HFPC's and J-pipe on my '12 FWD and it easily passes emissions and isn't overwhelming noisy either. It gives a nice low growl but no rasp whatsoever. I ended up adding Magnaflows after that which added a bit of drone but I think it perfected the sound. I enjoy just a tiny bit of drone since it's a good indicator of RPM and load.
The HFPC's pass emissions, at least as far as the downstream O2 sensors are concerned. The exception might be if Rhode Island has a sniffer test. In Utah, they only inspect for emission related codes like P0420 and P0430 (catalyst efficiency). They no longer do a sniffer test where a sensor is placed in the tailpipe which measures various compounds like hydrocarbons and NOx. By going to a 600 cell to 200 cell cat (which is the difference between the stock cats on the SH-AWD and the HFPC's) it may increase those pollutants since the lower the cells, the less pollutants are neutralized. Also, if they do a visual check to make sure all your cat's are intact, a J-pipe that removes the 3rd cat could be a problem. That's very rare however. The inspector would have to know that the car has a 3rd cat which is unlikely. It's not like they're going to have some database of vehicles to make sure you have all your cats. But if you don't have a sniffer test there, I'd say you have a 99% chance of being just fine.
The HFPC's pass emissions, at least as far as the downstream O2 sensors are concerned. The exception might be if Rhode Island has a sniffer test. In Utah, they only inspect for emission related codes like P0420 and P0430 (catalyst efficiency). They no longer do a sniffer test where a sensor is placed in the tailpipe which measures various compounds like hydrocarbons and NOx. By going to a 600 cell to 200 cell cat (which is the difference between the stock cats on the SH-AWD and the HFPC's) it may increase those pollutants since the lower the cells, the less pollutants are neutralized. Also, if they do a visual check to make sure all your cat's are intact, a J-pipe that removes the 3rd cat could be a problem. That's very rare however. The inspector would have to know that the car has a 3rd cat which is unlikely. It's not like they're going to have some database of vehicles to make sure you have all your cats. But if you don't have a sniffer test there, I'd say you have a 99% chance of being just fine.
#3
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Awesome, that’s what I was hoping for! Does anyone know between the RV6 or XLR8 J-Pipe which one has more ground clearance? My car isn’t lowered but the roads blow here in RI! I think my plan is to wait until spring so I can get the J-Pipe/Hfpc’s and the K-Tuner all at the same time...I’ll do some research myself but anyone happen to know of a reputable exhaust shop in my area for the install?
#4
The inconvenient truth
The XLR8 has better ground clearance for sure. I have the RV6 and the car is lowered and the only ground clearance issue ive had is my driveway at home lol. But that's just because the sidewalk is higher than both the road and my driveway. Im fine if I come in on a bit of an angle.
Anyways you will love the HFPC/J-pipe combo. It sounds great when reving yet when driving normally (slow) you can't really tell the exhaust is modded at all.
Check this out.
Anyways you will love the HFPC/J-pipe combo. It sounds great when reving yet when driving normally (slow) you can't really tell the exhaust is modded at all.
Check this out.
The following users liked this post:
ExcelerateRep (10-10-2018)
#5
Intermediate
Thread Starter
The XLR8 has better ground clearance for sure. I have the RV6 and the car is lowered and the only ground clearance issue ive had is my driveway at home lol. But that's just because the sidewalk is higher than both the road and my driveway. Im fine if I come in on a bit of an angle.
Anyways you will love the HFPC/J-pipe combo. It sounds great when reving yet when driving normally (slow) you can't really tell the exhaust is modded at all.
Check this out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jsLxdQ8VmOQ
Anyways you will love the HFPC/J-pipe combo. It sounds great when reving yet when driving normally (slow) you can't really tell the exhaust is modded at all.
Check this out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jsLxdQ8VmOQ
Btw that sound is beautiful!
The following users liked this post:
ExcelerateRep (10-10-2018)
The following users liked this post:
ExcelerateRep (10-10-2018)
#7
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Thanks for the info guys! Looks like I might bring the car to XLR8 Performance to do the exhaust install as they are only 89 miles from me! Definitely going with the J-Pipe, but here is a noob exhaust question...RV6 has the HFPC's and XLR8 has a HFC, these are different parts right? I believe the XLR8 J-Pipe eliminates the 3rd cat, so I would want to couple that with the RV6 HFPC's as opposed to a High Flow Cat?
Trending Topics
#8
The inconvenient truth
Yes they are different products. These cars have 3 cats, 2 precats which bolt to the engine block and a third main cat that's under the car and part of the j-pipe. The XLR8 HFC is an option to replace the 3rd cat if you don't want to delete it completely. Which I don't know why anyone buying a j-pipe wouldn't want to delete the 3rd cat. The only company that makes a product to replace the precats is RV6 with either their High flow precats or precat deletes. That's why it wss so easy for me to decide to buy the RV6 jpipe as well. If they are the only company willing to make a product to replace the precats then im glad to support them as much as possible. Also they make some really nice stuff!
Last edited by dopeboy1; 09-30-2018 at 07:58 PM.
#9
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Yes they are different products. These cars have 3 cats, 2 precats which bolt to the engine block and a third main cat that's under the car and part of the j-pipe. The XLR8 HFC is an option to replace the 3rd cat if you don't want to delete it completely. Which I don't know why anyone buying a j-pipe wouldn't want to delete the 3rd cat. The only company that makes a product to replace the precats is RV6 with either their High flow precats or precat deletes. That's why it wss so easy for me to decide to buy the RV6 jpipe as well. If they are the only company willing to make a product to replace the precats then im glad to support them as much as possible. Also they make some really nice stuff!
#11
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Thanks to RV6's Black Friday sale, just placed my order for K-Tuner, J-Pipe & HFPC's for $1,471 including shipping! Now i just have to have patience until the spring for the installation, don't want to install this stuff right as winter is coming...
#12
How much did the RV6 Jpipe cost for Black Friday? I assume it includes the 3rd cat delete? I ended up picking up EndlessRPM's Jpipe for their Black Friday deal. They were super local to me so why not support my local vendor right? Even though it's not cat delete Jpipe so I'll need to pick up a test pipe, they claim the 2 piece design produces more power and it tucks up higher than other Jpipes for more ground clearance. And plus, since I live in an emissions state, if I fail, Ii can easily slap the cat back on for the inspection lol.
#13
Intermediate
Thread Starter
How much did the RV6 Jpipe cost for Black Friday? I assume it includes the 3rd cat delete? I ended up picking up EndlessRPM's Jpipe for their Black Friday deal. They were super local to me so why not support my local vendor right? Even though it's not cat delete Jpipe so I'll need to pick up a test pipe, they claim the 2 piece design produces more power and it tucks up higher than other Jpipes for more ground clearance. And plus, since I live in an emissions state, if I fail, Ii can easily slap the cat back on for the inspection lol.
Last edited by Jrc6MT; 11-30-2018 at 08:32 PM. Reason: wrong graphic posted
#15
The inconvenient truth
Awesome!!! Make sure to do a review of the difference you notice with the pipes and ktuner. Just pipes first and then once you've added ktuner if you would be so kind haha.
#17
Intermediate
Thread Starter
I actually got impatient looking at the KTuner box, and loaded the base tune for a stock TL, and I changed the VTEC engagement to 4,000 to see how the car responds and feels compared to before flashing...haven't driven it enough yet for an opinion but will report back soon! My plan in March is to install the pipes and reflash with the exhaust base tune immediately before driving it home, as I have no patience!
#18
Intermediate
Thread Starter
I actually got impatient looking at the KTuner box, and loaded the base tune for a stock TL, and I changed the VTEC engagement to 4,000 to see how the car responds and feels compared to before flashing...haven't driven it enough yet for an opinion but will report back soon! My plan in March is to install the pipes and reflash with the exhaust base tune immediately before driving it home, as I have no patience!
#19
Drifting
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Salt Lake City, UT
Age: 42
Posts: 3,490
Received 849 Likes
on
605 Posts
I've heard the ALTP cat-back is a great quality product, and can give a pretty good exhaust tone. However, I think the general consensus is that the J-pipe and HFPC/PCD's are a considerably better bang for the buck in terms of power/price. I'm sure the cat-back is better flowing and frees up some power but I don't think it's much, especially considering the price.
I have the stock exhaust (past the J-pipe) for my 4G but I installed a Tanabe on my 3G and never noticed much. I never dyno'd it, nor have I my 4G, but whatever gains there were weren't noticeable to the "butt dyno" whereas the HFPC's and J-pipe were at least noticeable. That's all subjective information, no real numbers, but that's been the general feeling around here for those that have done all the exhaust bolt-ons. Oh, I did install magnaflow's on my stock 4G but again, no noticeable change in power output. The thing is though, with a car putting out 280hp/305hp (depending on FWD vs SH-AWD), a small gain of 5-10hp is difficult to notice. That's a very small percentage, 1.5% - 3% or so which is difficult to detect unless you do multiple runs on a dyno with exact conditions between pre and post install. Let alone a butt-dyno. I don't believe that's a reason not to do it though, since things add up. But it's still difficult to tell the difference when only one mod or bolt-on is done.
I have the stock exhaust (past the J-pipe) for my 4G but I installed a Tanabe on my 3G and never noticed much. I never dyno'd it, nor have I my 4G, but whatever gains there were weren't noticeable to the "butt dyno" whereas the HFPC's and J-pipe were at least noticeable. That's all subjective information, no real numbers, but that's been the general feeling around here for those that have done all the exhaust bolt-ons. Oh, I did install magnaflow's on my stock 4G but again, no noticeable change in power output. The thing is though, with a car putting out 280hp/305hp (depending on FWD vs SH-AWD), a small gain of 5-10hp is difficult to notice. That's a very small percentage, 1.5% - 3% or so which is difficult to detect unless you do multiple runs on a dyno with exact conditions between pre and post install. Let alone a butt-dyno. I don't believe that's a reason not to do it though, since things add up. But it's still difficult to tell the difference when only one mod or bolt-on is done.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
ep3kid914
3G TL Performance Parts & Modifications
41
09-12-2015 05:54 PM
dbqkqh
3G TL Performance Parts & Modifications
8
11-17-2009 12:00 AM
Pizza4Everyone
3G TL Performance Parts & Modifications
1
07-30-2007 12:55 AM
highaltitude
2G TL Performance Parts & Modifications
5
05-16-2007 12:25 AM