The dealer recommends that I replace my current tires with Michelin Energy MXV4 P205/60R16 91V BSW MXv4+; however, would there be a large difference in performance if I put Michelin Primacy 205/60R16 92 H MXV4 on instead?

 

Shouldnt be. Go here and compare them

http://www.tirerack.com/index.jsp

 

The Energey MXV4 is an all-season touring tire. The Primacy is a summer touring tire. Both of them sacrifice handling, cornering & traction for longevity and a cushy ride. The Primacy, being a summer tire, is not a decent choice for Chicago which tends to have quite a bit of snow in the winter.

Keeping in mind that you need actual snow traction, and seeing as you have a decent budget, I would recommend the following tires as far-better performance options. Keep in mind, your ride will be slightly harsher and noisier, but you'll have better handling traction IN ALL WEATHER CONDITIONS with this tire:


The brand-new Goodyear Eagle GT

If you insist on a touring tire, however, then these brand-new Kumho's look very promising:


The brand-new Kumho Ecsta LX Platinum

Good luck!

 

I hope your coming to the Chicago Meet on Aug 17th...
Check out the Meets section...