Is it just me or does the 1-2 shift have really bad lag....
#1
Racer
Thread Starter
Is it just me or does the 1-2 shift have really bad lag....
im talking full out gunning the car.... when it comes time for the 1-2 shift, the car bogs for like a quick second.... drops to 4800 rpm and taking a half second lag to climb.... its a very obvious problem for me and when my friends drive it too.... it kills the cars acceleration to 60mph by at least .1-.2 sec.
#3
Originally Posted by Un-Kut
im talking full out gunning the car.... when it comes time for the 1-2 shift, the car bogs for like a quick second.... drops to 4800 rpm and taking a half second lag to climb.... its a very obvious problem for me and when my friends drive it too.... it kills the cars acceleration to 60mph by at least .1-.2 sec.
Still, the 1-2 shift is difficult to finesse because the ratio gap is so large. 2nd gear really should have been shorter (e.g. less of an RPM drop), but then an additional shift would have been required to get to 60 mph, which would cost some precious magazine bragging rights.
#5
Racer
for me I found it to be smoother and quicker to turn off the traction control. whenever I shift from 1st to 2nd in higher rpms, the stock michellins try to slip so traction control cuts power and I get thrown forward. turning off the traction control improved the acceleration greatly, at least for me.
#7
Originally Posted by synthetic
no it's not just you and you can purely blame the Drive-By-Wire for that.
It's the most annoying, disgusting and frustrating thing about the TSX.
No other car has this problem.
It's the most annoying, disgusting and frustrating thing about the TSX.
No other car has this problem.
Trending Topics
#8
Originally Posted by rb1
If you shifted near the redline (not sure exactly where the VTEC cut-over is, but I think its in the upper 5000's), then the VTEC was in high-cam before the shift, and drops to low-cam after the shift. I'm not sure you're feeling lag as much as the kick-in-the-back of the VTEC in high-cam is gone.
Still, the 1-2 shift is difficult to finesse because the ratio gap is so large. 2nd gear really should have been shorter (e.g. less of an RPM drop), but then an additional shift would have been required to get to 60 mph, which would cost some precious magazine bragging rights.
Still, the 1-2 shift is difficult to finesse because the ratio gap is so large. 2nd gear really should have been shorter (e.g. less of an RPM drop), but then an additional shift would have been required to get to 60 mph, which would cost some precious magazine bragging rights.
http://www.sportcompactcarweb.com/ed..._technobabble/
#9
Racer
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by gftgrill
for me I found it to be smoother and quicker to turn off the traction control. whenever I shift from 1st to 2nd in higher rpms, the stock michellins try to slip so traction control cuts power and I get thrown forward. turning off the traction control improved the acceleration greatly, at least for me.
traction control has nothing to do with it since its off when this happens
#11
Originally Posted by khmy2nr
The DBW on the new SI is even worse. Yes it is very annoying !!!
http://www.honda-tech.com/zerothread/1703810
#13
#14
Racer
Originally Posted by Un-Kut
traction control has nothing to do with it since its off when this happens
if I have traction control on then the car lunges forward, if I have it off the tires squeel and I continue forward without problems.
but during normal driving the rpms drop slowly, but I've gotten used to it and don't notice it.
#15
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Georgia
Age: 59
Posts: 761
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
OK, I am missing something, I guess. What does the "rpm hang" have to do with bogging when you go from 1 to 2? When you fully engage 2nd gear, the rpms will have to match your speed!
I'm more inclined to agree with gftgrill -- if you go from 1 to 2 with the stock tires, you'd probably bark them, except that the traction control or vsa will take over and kill your power for you.
Yeah, I don't mind the difference in how it handles the rpms as far as the slow drop between shifts. And when I press the accel., I get good response; this is what I thought was the problem when people said "lag", that maybe their throttle response wasn't what they expected or something.
I'm more inclined to agree with gftgrill -- if you go from 1 to 2 with the stock tires, you'd probably bark them, except that the traction control or vsa will take over and kill your power for you.
Yeah, I don't mind the difference in how it handles the rpms as far as the slow drop between shifts. And when I press the accel., I get good response; this is what I thought was the problem when people said "lag", that maybe their throttle response wasn't what they expected or something.
#16
Racer
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by vidgamer
OK, I am missing something, I guess. What does the "rpm hang" have to do with bogging when you go from 1 to 2? When you fully engage 2nd gear, the rpms will have to match your speed!
I'm more inclined to agree with gftgrill -- if you go from 1 to 2 with the stock tires, you'd probably bark them, except that the traction control or vsa will take over and kill your power for you.
Yeah, I don't mind the difference in how it handles the rpms as far as the slow drop between shifts. And when I press the accel., I get good response; this is what I thought was the problem when people said "lag", that maybe their throttle response wasn't what they expected or something.
I'm more inclined to agree with gftgrill -- if you go from 1 to 2 with the stock tires, you'd probably bark them, except that the traction control or vsa will take over and kill your power for you.
Yeah, I don't mind the difference in how it handles the rpms as far as the slow drop between shifts. And when I press the accel., I get good response; this is what I thought was the problem when people said "lag", that maybe their throttle response wasn't what they expected or something.
have you been reading ANYTHING in this thread?
#17
Pro
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Lawn Giland - New York
Posts: 695
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by gftgrill
ok, but for my car, turning off the traction control when reving that high in first got rid of the "bog" that you said you had.
if I have traction control on then the car lunges forward, if I have it off the tires squeel and I continue forward without problems.
but during normal driving the rpms drop slowly, but I've gotten used to it and don't notice it.
if I have traction control on then the car lunges forward, if I have it off the tires squeel and I continue forward without problems.
but during normal driving the rpms drop slowly, but I've gotten used to it and don't notice it.
Even then you have to shift just right for the lag not to happen
#18
Racer
Originally Posted by Un-Kut
have you been reading ANYTHING in this thread?
Originally Posted by Un-Kut
im talking full out gunning the car.... when it comes time for the 1-2 shift, the car bogs for like a quick second.... drops to 4800 rpm and taking a half second lag to climb.... its a very obvious problem for me and when my friends drive it too.... it kills the cars acceleration to 60mph by at least .1-.2 sec.
1. the vsa is kicking in and preventing the tires from spinning by cutting fuel to the engine.
or
2. your rpms are way too far from what they need to be for 2nd gear to engage smoothly. if this is the case, try not dumping the clutch during the shift, ride the clutch a little longer like you would from a stop.
during heavy acceleration I think that most of have found that the traction control does "bog" the motor to prevent the tires from slipping. turing off the vsa allows the tires to spin and keeps the motor from "bogging".
and I hate to break it to you, but if this "bogging" is "killing" your acceleration to 60 by .1-.2 seconds, then you probably should consider a different car. Must of would probably aggree that we couldn't notice a .1-.2 second difference in acceleration.
#19
I can't find my garage
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: SoCal
Age: 35
Posts: 4,688
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by SirWaWa
#20
Originally Posted by mltk53
nice vid about the fix. i wonder if the hondata on the tsx makesit any quicker too. hmm~wont know till i get one.
anyone have the reflash? is this problem fixed?
#21
I really hate how soccer moms in their mini-vans takes off faster than me from a dead stop or when other cars are up my butt cuz I launch so slow. Maybe someone can find me a vid of how to launch the TSX.
#22
Senior Moderator
iTrader: (2)
Originally Posted by ninjamyst
I really hate how soccer moms in their mini-vans takes off faster than me from a dead stop or when other cars are up my butt cuz I launch so slow. Maybe someone can find me a vid of how to launch the TSX.
Note the VSA is on.
#24
So, if that 1-2 gap in gearing is the issue, do people with 225/45-17's find it's less of a problem?
I've been trying to see if this problem is reduced with a "cold" engine, and while I think it is, my car lives in a garage and I still let it warm up, and I've been less than scientific about testing. Has anyone found that the throttle body coolant bypass mod makes any difference?
I've been trying to see if this problem is reduced with a "cold" engine, and while I think it is, my car lives in a garage and I still let it warm up, and I've been less than scientific about testing. Has anyone found that the throttle body coolant bypass mod makes any difference?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
SidhuSaaB
3G TL Problems & Fixes
18
05-30-2020 12:40 AM
rp_guy
Member Cars for Sale
9
07-16-2017 07:33 AM
Hines57
Car Parts for Sale
0
09-24-2015 01:58 PM