I replaced mine with color matched real leather from a local shop for about $100 3 1/2 years ago. It has held up perfectly and feels better than OEM. I wish I had the $$ to do the entire interior in real leather.
Welcome to the club...I had a local upholstery shop replace mine with real leather, color-matched, for about $120. There are cheaper options out there, but this guy did a fantastic job and it feels so much nicer than the vinyl that was on there before. Matched stitching and all, looks 100% oem.