HIDs vs. Halogens
#41
Senior Moderator
#42
Suzuka Master
I don't think I've owned a car for the past four or five years that didn't come with HID's as an option. Exception being the Odyssey, the halos were replaced a couple of months later. Not too bright but much better than the standard halogens.
It looks pretty good as well.
It looks pretty good as well.
#43
Race Director
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Charlotte(home) /Raleigh (school), NC
Age: 35
Posts: 11,395
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I love my HIDs. The only thing I am not looking forward to is paying to replace them when they burn out.
However the majority of the roads I drive have a lot of lights.
However the majority of the roads I drive have a lot of lights.
#44
I drive a Subata.
iTrader: (1)
I mean, I totally understand that some people tend to dislike the HIDs due to its ability to blind the oncoming traffic....
But, the difference between the HIDs and halogens is HUGE in terms of ability in illuminating the road.... I dont get how you can like halogens better than the HIDs.... it's a no-brainer, i thought..
But, the difference between the HIDs and halogens is HUGE in terms of ability in illuminating the road.... I dont get how you can like halogens better than the HIDs.... it's a no-brainer, i thought..
#45
HID's FTW!
The only reason people complain about them is either they look straight into them, or the person driving the car with the HID's had them put in the car aftermarket, and they don't have a proper cut-off causing light to shine right in oncoming drivers eyes.
The only reason people complain about them is either they look straight into them, or the person driving the car with the HID's had them put in the car aftermarket, and they don't have a proper cut-off causing light to shine right in oncoming drivers eyes.
#47
Senior Moderator
I mean, I totally understand that some people tend to dislike the HIDs due to its ability to blind the oncoming traffic....
But, the difference between the HIDs and halogens is HUGE in terms of ability in illuminating the road.... I dont get how you can like halogens better than the HIDs.... it's a no-brainer, i thought..
But, the difference between the HIDs and halogens is HUGE in terms of ability in illuminating the road.... I dont get how you can like halogens better than the HIDs.... it's a no-brainer, i thought..
That said, it's an option that I don't seek out in considering a vehicle purchase (along with Navi and leather). If it happens to come with a pkg that I want (i.e.: the Touring pkg in my Murano) or its a freebee (i.e.: standard equip in my Maxima) then no problemo. But by itself for add'l$ , meh! pass.
#48
Drifting
I loved the hids on my 01 CLS, they were relatively new back then so it was great when oncoming traffic would flash their high beams at me, then I'd flash mine on at them and you could pretty much see right up their nose.
I was bummed that my Legacy GT did not come with them, but as mentioned the projector beams are just good enough to not make me replace them.
I was bummed that my Legacy GT did not come with them, but as mentioned the projector beams are just good enough to not make me replace them.
#49
My last 4 cars have had them so I'm definitely a fan, partly because they're more efficient than halogen (more light, less power consumption), and partly for asthetic reasons (they "look nice")
That said, the latest and best halogen technology is starting to approach the performance of D2S HID systems, which was certainly not the case back in the early 90's when HID started appearing. Yet halogen remains practically as simple and inexpensive as it's always been, so it's not going anywhere soon IMO.
They're starting to play with LED technology in headlamp applications also, which has it's own set of design and engineering challenges to contend with. I'm not convinced it's a truly viable headlamp technology. (Ideal for just about any other lighting system on a car though.)
That said, the latest and best halogen technology is starting to approach the performance of D2S HID systems, which was certainly not the case back in the early 90's when HID started appearing. Yet halogen remains practically as simple and inexpensive as it's always been, so it's not going anywhere soon IMO.
They're starting to play with LED technology in headlamp applications also, which has it's own set of design and engineering challenges to contend with. I'm not convinced it's a truly viable headlamp technology. (Ideal for just about any other lighting system on a car though.)
#51
Senior Moderator
My last 4 cars have had them so I'm definitely a fan, partly because they're more efficient than halogen (more light, less power consumption), and partly for asthetic reasons (they "look nice")
That said, the latest and best halogen technology is starting to approach the performance of D2S HID systems, which was certainly not the case back in the early 90's when HID started appearing. Yet halogen remains practically as simple and inexpensive as it's always been, so it's not going anywhere soon IMO.
They're starting to play with LED technology in headlamp applications also, which has it's own set of design and engineering challenges to contend with. I'm not convinced it's a truly viable headlamp technology. (Ideal for just about any other lighting system on a car though.)
That said, the latest and best halogen technology is starting to approach the performance of D2S HID systems, which was certainly not the case back in the early 90's when HID started appearing. Yet halogen remains practically as simple and inexpensive as it's always been, so it's not going anywhere soon IMO.
They're starting to play with LED technology in headlamp applications also, which has it's own set of design and engineering challenges to contend with. I'm not convinced it's a truly viable headlamp technology. (Ideal for just about any other lighting system on a car though.)
#52
on to the next one...
This may have been addressed, but all the HID's I've ever had or seen, have a distinct cut-off just below windshield level, thus, providing superior illumination projected to the area I need it, without blinding oncoming traffic. ...And while you have some control over the direction of the Halogen light, I don't believe it's generally as project-able as that of the HID's out there. (of course, there are some halogen projector headlights out there too) - but one could make the case that HID's are actually less blinding than halogen's based on that fact alone.
#53
This may have been addressed, but all the HID's I've ever had or seen, have a distinct cut-off just below windshield level, thus, providing superior illumination projected to the area I need it, without blinding oncoming traffic. ...And while you have some control over the direction of the Halogen light, I don't believe it's generally as project-able as that of the HID's out there. (of course, there are some halogen projector headlights out there too) - but one could make the case that HID's are actually less blinding than halogen's based on that fact alone.
#54
Someday, an RS6 Avant+
A good way to see the difference is on a rainy evening. For me, it seems the halogen light just washes out, while the HID provides better road illumination. Maybe its just me that notices this... ?
#55
I now drive an accord....
You realize your high beams were halogens correct?
#56
I now drive an accord....
Yes I have noticed this as well
#57
Senior Moderator
#58
In the Mid-South meow
iTrader: (2)
I have PnP 5000k HIDs in my Accord with reflector housings and I haven't had one person flash me yet, but I also took the time to read the Honda manual and aim them properly so they're not blinding people, which most people that put in PnP kits don't take the time to do or even know you're supposed to aim headlights in general.
The main reason I even considered a PnP HID kit for my Accord was because the headlight housing looked nearly identical to my 03 CL-S headlight housings, which were HIDs in reflector housings. In fact I had people flash me all the time in the CL-S, but again, not once yet in the Accord.
Although it's true there is more glare with them than a projector housing, overall it's not that bad and the increased light output compared to the yellowish OEM halogen bulbs is huge. I feel way more safe driving at night with the HIDs than with the stock halogens, and I can only imagine how much more important it would be if I lived in an area with a large deer population like in the N. East.
The main reason I even considered a PnP HID kit for my Accord was because the headlight housing looked nearly identical to my 03 CL-S headlight housings, which were HIDs in reflector housings. In fact I had people flash me all the time in the CL-S, but again, not once yet in the Accord.
Although it's true there is more glare with them than a projector housing, overall it's not that bad and the increased light output compared to the yellowish OEM halogen bulbs is huge. I feel way more safe driving at night with the HIDs than with the stock halogens, and I can only imagine how much more important it would be if I lived in an area with a large deer population like in the N. East.
#59
Drifting
#60
My car doesn't have HIDs that's why I hate riding in other people's car
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
rp_guy
Member Cars for Sale
9
07-16-2017 07:33 AM