NAV elevation?
Sorry, I don't have nav but if you do find out how to get the elevation I wouldn't put much faith in the numbers. The GPS units in everything but airplanes are pretty bad at resolving elevation. They're easily off by +/- 300-500ft.
I don't know the physics of it but I know that when I was in death valley my Garmin 76 told me I was 412' below sea level and my friends Magellan told us that we were 150' below sea level. We were actually at -282'.
I've seen even larger discrepancies at higher altitudes.
I've seen even larger discrepancies at higher altitudes.
Originally posted by pbanerji
Why is that? With enough satellites I would think that they would be dead on.
Why is that? With enough satellites I would think that they would be dead on.
Originally posted by kiteboy
GPS satellites are in low Earth orbit, which is 100-200 miles above ground. That means the vertical separation between the receiver and satellites is much smaller than the lateral separation (which could be tens of thousands of miles). Furthermore, all the satellites are roughly at the same altitude, in the same direction (up). Again, compared to the lateral difference, which could be in every direction and various distances. Since GPS uses triangulation for a position fix, the receiver has less range and separation to work with in the veritical (think of an inverted 3D pyramid that's not very high). As a result, there is more error in the vertical.
GPS satellites are in low Earth orbit, which is 100-200 miles above ground. That means the vertical separation between the receiver and satellites is much smaller than the lateral separation (which could be tens of thousands of miles). Furthermore, all the satellites are roughly at the same altitude, in the same direction (up). Again, compared to the lateral difference, which could be in every direction and various distances. Since GPS uses triangulation for a position fix, the receiver has less range and separation to work with in the veritical (think of an inverted 3D pyramid that's not very high). As a result, there is more error in the vertical.
Hmm... You may be right about most of what you said - I'm not sure. What I can say with some degree of certainty is that GPS satellites are NOT low earth orbit. So they circle the earth thousands of miles above it, not a couple of hundred miles.
From http://www.gisillinois.org/gps/GPSDEF/sat.htm:
The 24 GPS satellites (21 active, 3 spare) are in orbit at 10,600 miles above the earth.
From http://www.gisillinois.org/gps/GPSDEF/sat.htm:
The 24 GPS satellites (21 active, 3 spare) are in orbit at 10,600 miles above the earth.
Trending Topics
Originally posted by pbanerji
Hmm... You may be right about most of what you said - I'm not sure. What I can say with some degree of certainty is that GPS satellites are NOT low earth orbit. So they circle the earth thousands of miles above it, not a couple of hundred miles.
From http://www.gisillinois.org/gps/GPSDEF/sat.htm:
The 24 GPS satellites (21 active, 3 spare) are in orbit at 10,600 miles above the earth.
Hmm... You may be right about most of what you said - I'm not sure. What I can say with some degree of certainty is that GPS satellites are NOT low earth orbit. So they circle the earth thousands of miles above it, not a couple of hundred miles.
From http://www.gisillinois.org/gps/GPSDEF/sat.htm:
The 24 GPS satellites (21 active, 3 spare) are in orbit at 10,600 miles above the earth.
Re: NAV elevation?
Originally posted by pbanerji
Anyone know how to get current location elevation from the NAV?
Anyone know how to get current location elevation from the NAV?
Re: NAV elevation?
Originally posted by pbanerji
Anyone know how to get current location elevation from the NAV?
Anyone know how to get current location elevation from the NAV?
Originally posted by Dan Martin
Sorry, I don't have nav but if you do find out how to get the elevation I wouldn't put much faith in the numbers. The GPS units in everything but airplanes are pretty bad at resolving elevation. They're easily off by +/- 300-500ft.
Sorry, I don't have nav but if you do find out how to get the elevation I wouldn't put much faith in the numbers. The GPS units in everything but airplanes are pretty bad at resolving elevation. They're easily off by +/- 300-500ft.
Originally posted by Dan Martin
I don't know the physics of it but I know that when I was in death valley my Garmin 76 told me I was 412' below sea level and my friends Magellan told us that we were 150' below sea level. We were actually at -282'.
I've seen even larger discrepancies at higher altitudes.
I don't know the physics of it but I know that when I was in death valley my Garmin 76 told me I was 412' below sea level and my friends Magellan told us that we were 150' below sea level. We were actually at -282'.
I've seen even larger discrepancies at higher altitudes.
Actually, the altitude error would be the same as the longitute and latitude errors, about +/- 25 feet typically..... much worse before we turned off S/A (selective availability) about 5 years ago.
Originally posted by gpsiir
When did you do this test? With a couple of good receivers, you shouldn't see more than 50 feet of difference, usually much less today. (It's not uncommon to have accuracies of +/- 15 feet) If this was over 5 years ago, then S/A would have made that much worse......
When did you do this test? With a couple of good receivers, you shouldn't see more than 50 feet of difference, usually much less today. (It's not uncommon to have accuracies of +/- 15 feet) If this was over 5 years ago, then S/A would have made that much worse......
Originally posted by Dan Martin
Thanks gpsiir! What's the best way to check elevation accuracy? I'm curious to see how good my iQue is....
Thanks gpsiir! What's the best way to check elevation accuracy? I'm curious to see how good my iQue is....
Originally posted by Dan Martin
This was only in the summer. I wonder if it was because we were in a valley or if it was because both of our gps are fairly old. My GPS 76 has to be 4yrs+. I replaced it with an iQue shortly after and I'm hoping it's going to be a little more accurate.
This was only in the summer. I wonder if it was because we were in a valley or if it was because both of our gps are fairly old. My GPS 76 has to be 4yrs+. I replaced it with an iQue shortly after and I'm hoping it's going to be a little more accurate.
I always thought that the reason you couldn't get accurate elevation through a consumer model GPS unit is because that data isn't released to consumers... were as the military model have access to the full range of data. I know that more and more information is released now versus a few years ago... but I thought elevation was still hidden from consumer models.
Originally posted by DEVO
I always thought that the reason you couldn't get accurate elevation through a consumer model GPS unit is because that data isn't released to consumers... were as the military model have access to the full range of data. I know that more and more information is released now versus a few years ago... but I thought elevation was still hidden from consumer models.
I always thought that the reason you couldn't get accurate elevation through a consumer model GPS unit is because that data isn't released to consumers... were as the military model have access to the full range of data. I know that more and more information is released now versus a few years ago... but I thought elevation was still hidden from consumer models.
Originally posted by DEVO
I always thought that the reason you couldn't get accurate elevation through a consumer model GPS unit is because that data isn't released to consumers... were as the military model have access to the full range of data. I know that more and more information is released now versus a few years ago... but I thought elevation was still hidden from consumer models.
I always thought that the reason you couldn't get accurate elevation through a consumer model GPS unit is because that data isn't released to consumers... were as the military model have access to the full range of data. I know that more and more information is released now versus a few years ago... but I thought elevation was still hidden from consumer models.
So, all civilian GPS receivers got much more accurate. Whew, okay, as I said, civilian GPS units can only get the unencrypted GPS, as you might guess, that implies that the US military (and its allies) get GPS units that also receive and decrypt another GPS navigation signal, one that makes military units much more accurate (the actual numbers are, of course, classified). Bottom line, both civilian and military GPS receivers give you the same information (lat., long., altitude, very very very very very accurate time), but the military units have better accuracy on the positioning coordinates.Hope I didn't over-answer too much!
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
rp_guy
Member Cars for Sale
9
Jul 16, 2017 07:33 AM
navtool.com
5G TLX Audio, Bluetooth, Electronics & Navigation
31
Nov 16, 2015 08:30 PM



