Transmission replacement tips
#1
Transmission replacement tips
Hi all. I've been reading these forums for years, but never had a topic to post until now. I have a 2015 TLX V6 tech. I've read all the post about the TLX transmission and I am still not getting anywhere with getting my transmission fixed. I've been to the dealership 4 times. In that time they have done the PCM, Idle relearn, software update, and something called a "hard relearn". There has been no change in my transmission shift quality. On the last visit they sent in snapshots of the transmission and the team in California says the car is "operating as designed" I finally got ahold of someone at Acura customer care and she was not very polite stating that there is no fix that can be done since the snapshots came back as normal. I told her I have driven with my service advisor and technician who both feel the rough shifts. I have also driven 2 other V6 TLX from the same dealer's lot that did not behave like mine. I understand that your computer shows the car may be fine, but you will never understand unless you drive this car. Her last words were, "I'll see if we can send out a technician to drive you car." Any tips on moving forward. Other than the shifts I enjoy the car, but I cannot drive this car for another 5 years with these abrupt shifts.
#2
Senior Moderator
How many miles? Have they also replaced fluid?
#4
Some Guy Who Loves Cars
A-HFanboy, I know what you're saying and feel your pain. This was my experience:
https://acurazine.com/forums/5g-tlx-.../#post16335795
https://acurazine.com/forums/5g-tlx-.../#post16336001
I left out one part of my story. The first day, I dropped off my car and a few hours go by before they call. Say they can't replicate it and there's nothing more they can do. I was like "Oh c'mon. How did you drive it?" They said through all revs, paddle shifting, automatic shifting, multiple stop & go. I insisted they hold onto it overnight so they could try again with cold tranny and cold air. They obliged, seemingly reluctantly. I lost sleep that night like "OMG my tranny is riding on them capturing this damn jerking around. What sensors are they using? What software?" At that point, it's totally out of your hands.
The next day, first thing in the morning, they call. Say it's fine. I was like "You and I must have different thresholds for getting our heads slammed into the headrest." I insisted they try it again, specifically letting the ACC accelerate after the traffic light turns green. Called back and says "Wow, that's bad." -- "YA THINK? Now imagine driving in rush hour traffic every day." Once they get snapshots (I don't know how many), which are required by the TSB, Acura will approve replacement.
You need to inform them exactly what shift point, car speed, engine RPM, IDS mode, exterior temperature, uphill/downhill, they need to replicate it. Tell them to use the paddle shifters to do so. Don't let anyone here tell you it's easy. Someone else a few weeks ago suggested you can walk into a dealer and ask for a new ZF9. Um, nope. I'll say it's worth the work to get a replacement. The ZF9 is still a lousy tranny with lousy behavior, but the replacement is much smoother and tolerable.
https://acurazine.com/forums/5g-tlx-.../#post16335795
https://acurazine.com/forums/5g-tlx-.../#post16336001
I left out one part of my story. The first day, I dropped off my car and a few hours go by before they call. Say they can't replicate it and there's nothing more they can do. I was like "Oh c'mon. How did you drive it?" They said through all revs, paddle shifting, automatic shifting, multiple stop & go. I insisted they hold onto it overnight so they could try again with cold tranny and cold air. They obliged, seemingly reluctantly. I lost sleep that night like "OMG my tranny is riding on them capturing this damn jerking around. What sensors are they using? What software?" At that point, it's totally out of your hands.
The next day, first thing in the morning, they call. Say it's fine. I was like "You and I must have different thresholds for getting our heads slammed into the headrest." I insisted they try it again, specifically letting the ACC accelerate after the traffic light turns green. Called back and says "Wow, that's bad." -- "YA THINK? Now imagine driving in rush hour traffic every day." Once they get snapshots (I don't know how many), which are required by the TSB, Acura will approve replacement.
You need to inform them exactly what shift point, car speed, engine RPM, IDS mode, exterior temperature, uphill/downhill, they need to replicate it. Tell them to use the paddle shifters to do so. Don't let anyone here tell you it's easy. Someone else a few weeks ago suggested you can walk into a dealer and ask for a new ZF9. Um, nope. I'll say it's worth the work to get a replacement. The ZF9 is still a lousy tranny with lousy behavior, but the replacement is much smoother and tolerable.
Last edited by someguy11; 05-08-2019 at 12:10 PM.
#5
Hi all. I've been reading these forums for years, but never had a topic to post until now. I have a 2015 TLX V6 tech. I've read all the post about the TLX transmission and I am still not getting anywhere with getting my transmission fixed. I've been to the dealership 4 times. In that time they have done the PCM, Idle relearn, software update, and something called a "hard relearn". There has been no change in my transmission shift quality. On the last visit they sent in snapshots of the transmission and the team in California says the car is "operating as designed" I finally got ahold of someone at Acura customer care and she was not very polite stating that there is no fix that can be done since the snapshots came back as normal. I told her I have driven with my service advisor and technician who both feel the rough shifts. I have also driven 2 other V6 TLX from the same dealer's lot that did not behave like mine. I understand that your computer shows the car may be fine, but you will never understand unless you drive this car. Her last words were, "I'll see if we can send out a technician to drive you car." Any tips on moving forward. Other than the shifts I enjoy the car, but I cannot drive this car for another 5 years with these abrupt shifts.
#6
A-HFanboy, I know what you're saying and feel your pain. This was my experience:
https://acurazine.com/forums/5g-tlx-.../#post16335795
https://acurazine.com/forums/5g-tlx-.../#post16336001
I left out one part of my story. The first day, I dropped off my car and a few hours go by before they call. Say they can't replicate it and there's nothing more they can do. I was like "Oh c'mon. How did you drive it?" They said through all revs, paddle shifting, automatic shifting, multiple stop & go. I insisted they hold onto it overnight so they could try again with cold tranny and cold air. They obliged, seemingly reluctantly. I lost sleep that night like "OMG my tranny is riding on them capturing this damn jerking around. What sensors are they using? What software?" At that point, it's totally out of your hands.
The next day, first thing in the morning, they call. Say it's fine. I was like "You and I must have different thresholds for getting our heads slammed into the headrest." I insisted they try it again, specifically letting the ACC accelerate after the traffic light turns green. Called back and says "Wow, that's bad." -- "YA THINK? Now imagine driving in rush hour traffic every day." Once they get snapshots (I don't know how many), which are required by the TSB, Acura will approve replacement.
You need to inform them exactly what shift point, car speed, engine RPM, IDS mode, exterior temperature, uphill/downhill, they need to replicate it. Tell them to use the paddle shifters to do so. Don't let anyone here tell you it's easy. Someone else a few weeks ago suggested you can walk into a dealer and ask for a new ZF9. Um, nope. I'll say it's worth the work to get a replacement. The ZF9 is still a lousy tranny with lousy behavior, but the replacement is much smoother and tolerable.
https://acurazine.com/forums/5g-tlx-.../#post16335795
https://acurazine.com/forums/5g-tlx-.../#post16336001
I left out one part of my story. The first day, I dropped off my car and a few hours go by before they call. Say they can't replicate it and there's nothing more they can do. I was like "Oh c'mon. How did you drive it?" They said through all revs, paddle shifting, automatic shifting, multiple stop & go. I insisted they hold onto it overnight so they could try again with cold tranny and cold air. They obliged, seemingly reluctantly. I lost sleep that night like "OMG my tranny is riding on them capturing this damn jerking around. What sensors are they using? What software?" At that point, it's totally out of your hands.
The next day, first thing in the morning, they call. Say it's fine. I was like "You and I must have different thresholds for getting our heads slammed into the headrest." I insisted they try it again, specifically letting the ACC accelerate after the traffic light turns green. Called back and says "Wow, that's bad." -- "YA THINK? Now imagine driving in rush hour traffic every day." Once they get snapshots (I don't know how many), which are required by the TSB, Acura will approve replacement.
You need to inform them exactly what shift point, car speed, engine RPM, IDS mode, exterior temperature, uphill/downhill, they need to replicate it. Tell them to use the paddle shifters to do so. Don't let anyone here tell you it's easy. Someone else a few weeks ago suggested you can walk into a dealer and ask for a new ZF9. Um, nope. I'll say it's worth the work to get a replacement. The ZF9 is still a lousy tranny with lousy behavior, but the replacement is much smoother and tolerable.
#8
Summer is Coming
Did you look at the TSB? Is your car in the replacement VIN range? If so the replacement (at this point) should not take much effort. If the car is outside the VIN range, good luck. Acura claims these car had a hardware difference in the transmission and operate 'normally.' They made a further change in 2016 and beyond that made a further improvement. I have one of those late 2015 transmissions. It does not hard shift like early model transmissions, but it does suffer from slow/delayed shifting. Acura will not replace it. They think slow/delayed shifting is fine.
The following users liked this post:
9SpeedTran (05-09-2019)
#9
Some Guy Who Loves Cars
You go through the buying process: research, test drive, negotiate, get a loan, pay TTL, sign the dotted line and drive away. Then after driving for a month, you realize the transmission is hot garbage, VCM is a noisy shaky mess and the car vibrates on the expressway (for some). They say "take it back." I say "nah bro." They can feel free to waste their money, but I'm not taking a trade-in for $thousands less than I just paid, eat the TTL, establish a new loan and pay another round of TTL. That's nuts. Instead, I chose to bring my TLX back to Acura six times and counting, including once to replace the transmission, to make this car what it should have been when it was built. There is a really good car hiding behind all these issues.
Last edited by someguy11; 05-09-2019 at 08:43 AM.
#10
Did you look at the TSB? Is your car in the replacement VIN range? If so the replacement (at this point) should not take much effort. If the car is outside the VIN range, good luck. Acura claims these car had a hardware difference in the transmission and operate 'normally.' They made a further change in 2016 and beyond that made a further improvement. I have one of those late 2015 transmissions. It does not hard shift like early model transmissions, but it does suffer from slow/delayed shifting. Acura will not replace it. They think slow/delayed shifting is fine.
#11
I can't tell if these users and their comments are serious or just trolling. I think they're serious, which means they're either incredibly wasteful (likely) or filthy rich (probably not). Ignore them.
You go through the buying process: research, test drive, negotiate, get a loan, pay TTL, sign the dotted line and drive away. Then after driving for a month, you realize the transmission is hot garbage, VCM is a noisy shaky mess and the car vibrates on the expressway (for some). They say "take it back." I say "nah bro." They can feel free to waste their money, but I'm not taking a trade-in for $thousands less than I just paid, eat the TTL, establish a new loan and pay another round of TTL. That's nuts. Instead, I chose to bring my TLX back to Acura six times and counting, including once to replace the transmission, to make this car what it should have been when it was built. There is a really good car hiding behind all these issues.
You go through the buying process: research, test drive, negotiate, get a loan, pay TTL, sign the dotted line and drive away. Then after driving for a month, you realize the transmission is hot garbage, VCM is a noisy shaky mess and the car vibrates on the expressway (for some). They say "take it back." I say "nah bro." They can feel free to waste their money, but I'm not taking a trade-in for $thousands less than I just paid, eat the TTL, establish a new loan and pay another round of TTL. That's nuts. Instead, I chose to bring my TLX back to Acura six times and counting, including once to replace the transmission, to make this car what it should have been when it was built. There is a really good car hiding behind all these issues.
#12
But since OP isn't in financial situation to do so (wasn't stated in 1st post), then it's either live with it or move on to something else (less expensive) if Acura won't address issues.
#13
If OP really "cannot drive this car for another 5 years with these abrupt shifts" but loves "everything about the car, and there isn't any other vehicle I want to drive" and if Acura won't fix issue, then replace it for one without transmission issues.
But since OP isn't in financial situation to do so (wasn't stated in 1st post), then it's either live with it or move on to something else (less expensive) if Acura won't address issues.
But since OP isn't in financial situation to do so (wasn't stated in 1st post), then it's either live with it or move on to something else (less expensive) if Acura won't address issues.
The following 2 users liked this post by A-HFanboy:
a35tl (05-09-2019),
steve_97060 (05-09-2019)
#14
Not being snarky. You asked for advice, I offered some. Didn't know your financial situation at the time so
If you're still working with Acura to fix problem, then wait it out. If Acura won't do anything then personally I'd move on.
If you're still working with Acura to fix problem, then wait it out. If Acura won't do anything then personally I'd move on.
#15
Some Guy Who Loves Cars
If OP really "cannot drive this car for another 5 years with these abrupt shifts" but loves "everything about the car, and there isn't any other vehicle I want to drive" and if Acura won't fix issue, then replace it for one without transmission issues.
But since OP isn't in financial situation to do so (wasn't stated in 1st post), then it's either live with it or move on to something else (less expensive) if Acura won't address issues.
But since OP isn't in financial situation to do so (wasn't stated in 1st post), then it's either live with it or move on to something else (less expensive) if Acura won't address issues.
If push comes to shove and you love the car, but Acura won't replace the tranny, you have three options:
-live with it
-trade it in for a different TLX (by then, you'll probably hate Acura too much to choose this option)
-trade it in for something less expensive - you still take price hit, but you won't pay it out of pocket, it just gets rolled into the trade transaction (your TLX purchase mistake nets you a less valuable vehicle)
Those are three really lousy options for any new owner. For long time Honda/Acura owners or shoppers who chose a TLX for Honda reliability, reputation and quality, the need to potentially trade in your new/certified/slightly used car may be a totally foreign concept.
Last edited by someguy11; 05-09-2019 at 12:22 PM.
#16
Update
Since I last posted I worked my way up the chain and was able to get a regional parts manager (or some one with a title similar) who came out to drive my car. According to my service advisor he “instantly” felt my rough shifts and has approved me for a replacement transmission. My car is at the dealer now waiting for replacement.
Side note: I’m in a ‘19 aspec 4 cylinder. It’s a fun car.. just wish it had a bit more power.
Side note: I’m in a ‘19 aspec 4 cylinder. It’s a fun car.. just wish it had a bit more power.
The following users liked this post:
9SpeedTran (06-21-2019)
#17
Moderator
Since I last posted I worked my way up the chain and was able to get a regional parts manager (or some one with a title similar) who came out to drive my car. According to my service advisor he “instantly” felt my rough shifts and has approved me for a replacement transmission. My car is at the dealer now waiting for replacement.
Side note: I’m in a ‘19 aspec 4 cylinder. It’s a fun car.. just wish it had a bit more power.
Side note: I’m in a ‘19 aspec 4 cylinder. It’s a fun car.. just wish it had a bit more power.
The following 2 users liked this post by Curious3GTL:
A-HFanboy (07-11-2019),
CheeseyPoofs McNut (06-23-2019)
#19
Some Guy Who Loves Cars
Since I last posted I worked my way up the chain and was able to get a regional parts manager (or some one with a title similar) who came out to drive my car. According to my service advisor he “instantly” felt my rough shifts and has approved me for a replacement transmission. My car is at the dealer now waiting for replacement.
Side note: I’m in a ‘19 aspec 4 cylinder. It’s a fun car.. just wish it had a bit more power.
Side note: I’m in a ‘19 aspec 4 cylinder. It’s a fun car.. just wish it had a bit more power.
#20
Congrats and way to be tenacious about it. It’s totally worth the improvement. Still an imperfect and awkward ZF9, but much smoother, quieter and roadworthy. I think you’ll be happy with it. Post an update here after you drive your new tranny for a couple days. Nice work!
#21
Some Guy Who Loves Cars
Thanks! The car is like night and day. I still find myself anticipating that 2-3 hard shift, but its so smooth now and getting better with time. Only issue I still have is I still have a small vibration around 35-40 mph. It's minor and the car self corrects. I've read on here or another forum that it's possibly the motor mounts. I'll bring it up to my service advisor next time I go in.
The vibration you have now around 38mph is VCM. You can research what has been discussed ad nauseam here, Pilot or Odyssey forums. It's the drone/rumble in your ears, floorboard and steering column as if a helicopter was hovering 20' above your roof. Motor mounts won't fix it - those are an easy suspect to blame for the bigger problem, which is engine vibration caused by cylinder deactivation - a "feature" that your car has and cannot be disabled or deactivated. The only way to stop VCM is with an aftermarket tool like VCMuzzler or S-VCM. I have one. It works great. Haven't had a single rumble since installing it. That VCM drone is another problem with the TLX for which Acura should be absolutely ashamed.
#22
They need to resynch the active engine mounts after replacing the transmission.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Ahmed Nomaw
2G CL (2001-2003)
38
07-20-2017 04:06 PM
VanyDotK
Car Parts for Sale
7
12-11-2008 08:09 AM
SuperTrooper169
Car Parts for Sale
1
08-29-2007 10:51 AM
jwaters943
3G TL (2004-2008)
11
06-27-2004 12:20 AM