Tires, speed ratings, costco
#1
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Tires, speed ratings, costco
Ok so here's what happened to me today.... ok well starting about 6 months ago when I bought 2 new tires.
I had a giant rock in one of my rear tires and they were pretty worn so I got 2 new Michelin pilot sport A/S 3 tires. I wanted to get them from Costco based on their tire finder recommendation (and price) but they didn't have them in stock and I needed them right away. I went to another shop nearby, paid a lot more, and got the same times.
Fast forward and I have front tires that need to be replaced so I order 2 new Michelin pilot sport A/S 3+ tires from Costco and go today to have them put on. Once they get started they tell me they can't touch my rear tires (their policy is to put new tires on the rear if you get only 2) because they are not the proper speed rating. It turns out the first set of Michelins I bought were V rated tires, and Costco says they should have not been put on my car at all, and that we will not move them to the front. I didn't even realize at the time I requested the tires from the local shop that they were only V rated and that this would ever be an issue. The Costco tech seemed like he knew what he was doing and I don't think he was trying to screw me or anything. He said normally Michelin allows you to drop 1 speed rating, but not when they are Z rated tires, and of course W and Y are both technically Z rated because they are over 149MPH.
Is this crazy to anyone else? Should I go to the shop that put V rated tires on my car and try to get my money back?
Thanks for any advice!
Clint
I had a giant rock in one of my rear tires and they were pretty worn so I got 2 new Michelin pilot sport A/S 3 tires. I wanted to get them from Costco based on their tire finder recommendation (and price) but they didn't have them in stock and I needed them right away. I went to another shop nearby, paid a lot more, and got the same times.
Fast forward and I have front tires that need to be replaced so I order 2 new Michelin pilot sport A/S 3+ tires from Costco and go today to have them put on. Once they get started they tell me they can't touch my rear tires (their policy is to put new tires on the rear if you get only 2) because they are not the proper speed rating. It turns out the first set of Michelins I bought were V rated tires, and Costco says they should have not been put on my car at all, and that we will not move them to the front. I didn't even realize at the time I requested the tires from the local shop that they were only V rated and that this would ever be an issue. The Costco tech seemed like he knew what he was doing and I don't think he was trying to screw me or anything. He said normally Michelin allows you to drop 1 speed rating, but not when they are Z rated tires, and of course W and Y are both technically Z rated because they are over 149MPH.
Is this crazy to anyone else? Should I go to the shop that put V rated tires on my car and try to get my money back?
Thanks for any advice!
Clint
#2
![In-Out](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/inout.gif)
#3
Senior Moderator
Get 4 new tires from Costco
Thread closed.
Thread closed.
#4
Senior Moderator
sounds like a bunch of baloney...
If it was a load rating I could understand, but the speed rating is worthless for 98% of drivers. Are you planning on going near 140MPH in the near future with these tires? If not, you will have no worries or issues.
For the future, you can buy tires from discount tire direct on ebay (beats tirerack prices most of time) and get them installed at a local discount tire. Much better service, nearly tax free and you get the right product without being upsold.
If it was a load rating I could understand, but the speed rating is worthless for 98% of drivers. Are you planning on going near 140MPH in the near future with these tires? If not, you will have no worries or issues.
For the future, you can buy tires from discount tire direct on ebay (beats tirerack prices most of time) and get them installed at a local discount tire. Much better service, nearly tax free and you get the right product without being upsold.
#5
The DVD-A Script Guy
Costco's pretty strict about that stuff for sure. But I wound't bad mouth them that much since for the tires they sell they are very competitive. I always see my local Costco hand torquing lug nuts rather than running fully on with an impact wrenches. They also once dinged one of my rims and told me before I even got the car back. They payed in full for a new wheel from the dealer and actually gave me the old one back saying "...just in case you ever need it" Other shops that have hacked wheels always respond with "we didn't do that, it was like that when you got here!"
#6
Senior Moderator
I'm Notnsure if he's bad mouthing Costco so much as misplacing the blame.
Shitty shop did you wrong, Costco won't fix said wrong (they are in the right to do so ) . I doubt you have any recourse with the old shop now so just get 4 new tires (from a proper shop no less) and call it a day
Shitty shop did you wrong, Costco won't fix said wrong (they are in the right to do so ) . I doubt you have any recourse with the old shop now so just get 4 new tires (from a proper shop no less) and call it a day
#7
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Yeah guys I'm not badmouthing Costco at all. I actually learned something from them today. Although I do believe their tire selector gave me the option of a V rated tire for my car at some point ultimately the blame falls on me and I believe the other shop as well because they should know better than anyone what tires can go on my car.
i don't plan on going 140mph (or 186mph) any time soon but I like to go with what the manufacturer intended to have on the car when it comes to tires. I guess I'm just a little shocked that I just spent $400 on tires and now I'm spending $650 more.
I'm getting 4 new tires from Costco and going to the other shop to complain and see what I can get out of them since I still need an alignment and I have 2 barely used tires to trade.
i don't plan on going 140mph (or 186mph) any time soon but I like to go with what the manufacturer intended to have on the car when it comes to tires. I guess I'm just a little shocked that I just spent $400 on tires and now I'm spending $650 more.
I'm getting 4 new tires from Costco and going to the other shop to complain and see what I can get out of them since I still need an alignment and I have 2 barely used tires to trade.
Trending Topics
#8
Dude, you're buying TIRES at Costco? What do you expect, someone that knows what they are doing?
1. Buy TIRES from tirerack. Period.
2. Have said tires shipped to a reputable installer, and installed.
3. Win.
1. Buy TIRES from tirerack. Period.
2. Have said tires shipped to a reputable installer, and installed.
3. Win.
#9
Senior Moderator
What's wrong with buying tires at Costco?
#10
Speed ratings aren't just for "top speed" - they also factor load capacities, and uniformity under stress.
While not illegal, it is improper and not recommended to put lower speed rating tires than what the OEM calls for.
The more you know: AGCO Automotive Repair Service - Baton Rouge, LA - Detailed Auto Topics - Can I Substitute A Lower Speed Rated Tire
While not illegal, it is improper and not recommended to put lower speed rating tires than what the OEM calls for.
The more you know: AGCO Automotive Repair Service - Baton Rouge, LA - Detailed Auto Topics - Can I Substitute A Lower Speed Rated Tire
#11
4th Gear
Rim fitment: Please help?
i want these rims but not sure if they will fit due to the hub bore..
RIM SIZE:18x9.5
OFFSET: +30
BOLT PATTERN: 5x114.3
HUB BORE: 73.1 or 57.1
RIM SIZE:18x9.5
OFFSET: +30
BOLT PATTERN: 5x114.3
HUB BORE: 73.1 or 57.1
![](http://shop.sdmotorworks.com/images/3d0fab_32bbf84cd61a40eca9a08d4092cd1ab3.jpg_srz_863_575_75_22_0.50_1.20_0.jpg)
#12
Nothing, if you already know everything you need to know before you walk in, and they won't be installed there. Costco/Wal Mart/Sears, those places are for people that drive Ford Tartus' cars. At least, that's my elitist tire/shopping/installation opinion.
The following 3 users liked this post by VisualEchos:
#14
Senior Moderator
![Thumbs Up](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/thumbsup.gif)
They're fine for the lower 99%er's
![Tomato](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/tomato.gif)
I went in asking for non-OEM specs on tires, they hesitated for a bit , but after busting out the old tire calculator online, they realized what was asking for was within a few percentage of the original diameter tire and gave in.
The following users liked this post:
VisualEchos (09-23-2016)
The following users liked this post:
Costco (09-23-2016)
#17
Suzuka Master
iTrader: (1)
There is no law that dictates the same speed rating tire be installed on the car.
There isn't even a law dictating that speed ratings be on tires.
Speed rating and load rating do not go hand in hand.
235/45-17-One can have a W speed rated tire with a load rating 97 (XL), or as low 93.
You'll find that these, shall we say discount stores, have wording:
The tire must meet all vehicle manufacturer’s safety standards and specifications.
Not a bad choice for the majority, lifetime rotation, balancing, repair along with free road hazard,
and comparable pricing, but as they provide no leeway from OEM specs, accept their guidelines or go elsewhere.
There isn't even a law dictating that speed ratings be on tires.
Speed rating and load rating do not go hand in hand.
235/45-17-One can have a W speed rated tire with a load rating 97 (XL), or as low 93.
You'll find that these, shall we say discount stores, have wording:
The tire must meet all vehicle manufacturer’s safety standards and specifications.
Not a bad choice for the majority, lifetime rotation, balancing, repair along with free road hazard,
and comparable pricing, but as they provide no leeway from OEM specs, accept their guidelines or go elsewhere.
The following users liked this post:
csmeance (09-28-2016)
#18
Head a da Family
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: New Friggin Jerzy
Age: 69
Posts: 5,505
Received 561 Likes
on
393 Posts
My 2¢
.
.
#19
1. Buy the tires from a tire specialist.
2. Have them installed at an installation specialist.
If you're worried about having a problem with the tires, buy the warranty. But it has always been my experience that you won't have a problem if you buy good tires, and treat them with respect (monitor the tire pressure, and rotate properly).
#20
Registered but harmless
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Age: 59
Posts: 14,848
Received 1,112 Likes
on
766 Posts
This is no problem, if you like buying trash tires and getting raped, because that's what most local tire shops have to offer. Specialized is the way to go.
...
If you're worried about having a problem with the tires, buy the warranty. But it has always been my experience that you won't have a problem if you buy good tires, and treat them with respect (monitor the tire pressure, and rotate properly).
...
If you're worried about having a problem with the tires, buy the warranty. But it has always been my experience that you won't have a problem if you buy good tires, and treat them with respect (monitor the tire pressure, and rotate properly).
Tire Rack carries Nexen and some other no name tires I wouldn't want to use even for puttering around town.
The Costco installer also used a torque wrench installing the wheels on my TL after mounting and balancing the Pilot SS.
Costco is bad if an enthusiast wants to upsize the tires slightly or has non-OEM sized wheels, but good for most of the non-enthusiast public.
![2 Cents](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/2cents.gif)
How do you define or differentiate between a "tire specialist" and a "local tire shop"?
#21
Suzuka Master
iTrader: (1)
This is no problem, if you like buying trash tires and getting raped, because that's what most local tire shops have to offer. Specialized is the way to go.
1. Buy the tires from a tire specialist.
2. Have them installed at an installation specialist.
If you're worried about having a problem with the tires, buy the warranty. But it has always been my experience that you won't have a problem if you buy good tires, and treat them with respect (monitor the tire pressure, and rotate properly).
1. Buy the tires from a tire specialist.
2. Have them installed at an installation specialist.
If you're worried about having a problem with the tires, buy the warranty. But it has always been my experience that you won't have a problem if you buy good tires, and treat them with respect (monitor the tire pressure, and rotate properly).
There's a shop in Bordentown that the owner attended the modified events when they were run in Flemington, still in business and when I purchased the Yokohama's years ago they were actually less than the Tire Rack price.
Tire Rack installers are not I would call specialists, at least some of the installers listed in my area as I'm very familiar with their operation and some leave a lot to be desired.
#22
![Smile](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#23
Head a da Family
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: New Friggin Jerzy
Age: 69
Posts: 5,505
Received 561 Likes
on
393 Posts
This is no problem, if you like buying trash tires and getting raped, because that's what most local tire shops have to offer. Specialized is the way to go.
1. Buy the tires from a tire specialist.
2. Have them installed at an installation specialist.
If you're worried about having a problem with the tires, buy the warranty. But it has always been my experience that you won't have a problem if you buy good tires, and treat them with respect (monitor the tire pressure, and rotate properly).
1. Buy the tires from a tire specialist.
2. Have them installed at an installation specialist.
If you're worried about having a problem with the tires, buy the warranty. But it has always been my experience that you won't have a problem if you buy good tires, and treat them with respect (monitor the tire pressure, and rotate properly).
.
.
#24
![](https://c2.staticflickr.com/2/1555/25949237210_37492ced33_o.png)
Tail Happy. by Andrew Thompson, on Flickr
#26
I check the torque on all my lug nuts after I leave Costco and for the past several years they have always been wrong, way wrong.
I have been buying tires from them for over ten years. They are convenient for me.
But they will over tighten lug nuts with their impact wrench and then check with a torque wrench to make sure that the lugs nut are at least over specified torque.
They will say to me that since their air pressure is set to 90psi that their torque wrenches can't go higher in torque than that.
But most 1/2" torque wrenches do about 150 ft-lbs of torque on 90psi.
I use my torque wrench to measure what Costco did and I usually find it close to 150 ft-lbs.
And I have checked the calibration of my torque wrench, and it is accurate.
So I just loosen and properly torque all my lug nuts.
I have been buying tires from them for over ten years. They are convenient for me.
But they will over tighten lug nuts with their impact wrench and then check with a torque wrench to make sure that the lugs nut are at least over specified torque.
They will say to me that since their air pressure is set to 90psi that their torque wrenches can't go higher in torque than that.
But most 1/2" torque wrenches do about 150 ft-lbs of torque on 90psi.
I use my torque wrench to measure what Costco did and I usually find it close to 150 ft-lbs.
And I have checked the calibration of my torque wrench, and it is accurate.
So I just loosen and properly torque all my lug nuts.
#29
Yes, Missouri.
A common back-road I drive weekly. Please note the slicks on the car, they're my Summer tires, and have been for years without issue
.
![](https://c2.staticflickr.com/2/1505/26760259475_f144d21fa6_o.png)
In Places of Light. by Andrew Thompson, on Flickr
A common back-road I drive weekly. Please note the slicks on the car, they're my Summer tires, and have been for years without issue
![Smile](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
![](https://c2.staticflickr.com/2/1505/26760259475_f144d21fa6_o.png)
In Places of Light. by Andrew Thompson, on Flickr
#31
I'm in Cape Girardeau, about 100 miles South of St Louis, and 250 miles East of you. Springfield is a fantastic area.
Another favorite road, just for fun.
![](https://c4.staticflickr.com/9/8326/8083628579_407413087f_o.jpg)
The Golden Fleece. by Andrew Thompson, on Flickr
Another favorite road, just for fun.
![](https://c4.staticflickr.com/9/8326/8083628579_407413087f_o.jpg)
The Golden Fleece. by Andrew Thompson, on Flickr
#32
Team Owner
Costco is the only place I know of that won't sell off-brand tires or install tires that don't meet vehicle OEM specs.
Tire Rack carries Nexen and some other no name tires I wouldn't want to use even for puttering around town.
The Costco installer also used a torque wrench installing the wheels on my TL after mounting and balancing the Pilot SS.
Costco is bad if an enthusiast wants to upsize the tires slightly or has non-OEM sized wheels, but good for most of the non-enthusiast public.![2 Cents](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/2cents.gif)
How do you define or differentiate between a "tire specialist" and a "local tire shop"?
Tire Rack carries Nexen and some other no name tires I wouldn't want to use even for puttering around town.
The Costco installer also used a torque wrench installing the wheels on my TL after mounting and balancing the Pilot SS.
Costco is bad if an enthusiast wants to upsize the tires slightly or has non-OEM sized wheels, but good for most of the non-enthusiast public.
![2 Cents](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/2cents.gif)
How do you define or differentiate between a "tire specialist" and a "local tire shop"?
#33
Team Owner
Road Hazard warranty isn't just for bad roads. I've used it twice with Costco, for the wife's car, after she picked up a nail in the sidewall (once), or a shard of jagged metal (once).
#34
Never had an issue in 30 years of driving. I guess it depends, again, on the roads you drive on.
#35
Senior Moderator
![Agree](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/agree.gif)
In FL I've had to use it on my 7-series more often than any car I've had here, maybe due to the XL load rating and lower profile tires 6 new tires through Discount Tire. Either way, an extra $60 now to save $60-$800 dollars over the next 40-50K miles, sign me up! The plan has paid off more for me than I've invested in it already by nearly a factor of 10! I'm a believer in it.
Also the nice thing about the insurance/warranty/certificates is that discount tire really will work with you on credits. Michelin offered me a paltry $200 towards a 2K set of PS2's for my 760 after the Pilot Sport A/S Plus 2 wore out in 12K miles and had a 40K mile warranty on them. Discount tire refunded me under the road hazard and got me into a new set of Continental DW for under $600 for all 4.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Syms
Car Parts for Sale
3
08-30-2016 08:07 AM
njresendez
Car Parts for Sale
10
07-18-2016 08:46 AM
IgottaTLyousomething
3G TL Tires, Wheels & Suspension
353
02-11-2016 02:06 PM