mmcv6

Hi.
Plan to change out my new tires on my 06 tl auto with some better tires. I am debating between the Goodyear Eagle F1-GS-D3, and the Michelin Pilot Sport PS2?
Both are a max performance summer tire. I live in southern california i assume it would be ok for me?... Both are YR Rated... After checking reviews etc on tirerack.com both are great tires, both have been used on the tl. From what i gather the PS2 is quiet, and good, while the F1 looks hardcore but gets noisy later on. Also the PS2 from reviews last longer?... Treadwear on the Goodyear is 280 AA A, while the PS2 is 220 AA A ......
I can get the Goodyears with my stock tire trade in for about $573, if i get the PS2 i can get it with trade in for $633 about.
Road Hazard is $88 extra.
What do you all think?
thanks