I have had the ATLP in my closet since i think Nov. and I havent even painted it yet lol, but for some reason I see it bulky and stuff, I been thinkin about putting it in the black market to trade with someone that has a sarona.. Which do you guys like better?

 

ATLP V1...only because I have one

 

i got one from ebay which fits perfect and looks great, colormatched and shipped for 75! email: bmwoemshop168@gmail.com

 

Fail for not posting pics

 

+1....I got one recently and it looks pretty good. I'll post up pics later since I haven't had the chance to take pics with it on yet.

 

same here, the others were just too big for my taste.

 

I have the Sarona Roof Spoiler and I personally like it alot especially that it has the tapers on the ends that mimic the gutter rails that are on our cars roof like, which kinda makes it look like our cars have a factory installed Roof Spoiler. Just my opinion.

 

 

Would anyone wanna trade their sarona for my atlp?

 

Same here

 

IMO the Sarona looks better. i sold my ATLP and got the Sarona. its not on the car yet tho cause i need to shave it down and im to lazy.

 

What is the website to get this? 75 bucks is pretty decent considering sarona wants 300...I've been wanting one for a while but can't forsee spending 300 right now, but 75s cool...it looks good too??

 

just ordered one from ebay...68 shipped......and painted asm

 

another subjective question.....

but for me, atlp v1 < sarona < atlp v2 ......why? because the v2 has the sexiest overhang

atlp v2:





let's keep the comments about the mirrors/wheels to a minimum....

 

^ lol okayyyy; i dont really want to comment on that atlp v2 spoiler till i see pics of someone with sarona spoiler, but from that angle the atlp v2 just doesn't seem to flow with the lines of the car. thats just me

 

here's mine. Sarona roof wing





a closer look, roof wing and OEM type-s trunk deck lid spoiler





an even closer look









you guys be the judge. which flows better?

for me.................... Sarona > all other roof wings.

 

I voted for the Sarona since its look has grown on me over time. ATLP v1 was nice, but I think I outgrew it. ATLP v2 is just plain hideous due to it's bulkiness. The Sarona is unnecessarily expensive, and it should come painted for the price that they are charging for it.

I went with the eBay special myself since I was on a strict budget. It was the most bang for the buck.

 

winner
now that looks hot. sarona does flow better with the tl. im sold

 

sarona all the way

 

sarona looks great IMO. it seems to flow better with the car. the atlp v2 looks too bulky.

 

I agree with this. 300 for the Sarona...unpainted is overpriced.

Thanks for the pics jptl04, that first pic was what I was really looking for.

 

Im still debating on keeping it, but heres what i got so far.....

 

^^^^
too far away can't even tell what it looks like! What is it atlp? or sarona?

 

looks like atlp its hangs over much more than the sarona

 

atlp v2

 

100% Agree... Sarona is the best, but you'd have to shave and paint it... and for the price, it should already come that way!

Ebay special FTW!

 

i have 06 civic sedan roof spoiler on mine those other ones are too big mine sits nice and flat

 

I have to say ATLP V1 or Sarona. I got way too good a deal on my ATLP to pass up.

 

just picked up a sarona off craigslist already painted wdp to bad i had 2 wait 3 hours for the seller

 

sorry for starting up this thread again but i really need some help here. when you guys talk about "shaving" down the sarona, what exactly do you mean? i just bought my sarona and it is sooo uneven with the top of the roof. i noticed how everyone elses sits nice and flush with the roof line. where exactly must i be shaving down on the sarona spoiler? do i shave it down from the top or from the bottom where it mounts? logic tells me to shave it from the underside but i dont want to have to guess on such an expensive spoiler. lol. id rather just do it right the first time with some proper guidance from you guys.....please help explain where exactly i must begin shaving, what areas, and also, exactly how much shaving will be necessary. thanks to all you guys in advance for any help you can throw my way.

 

for those of you who have the Ebay version of the roof spoiler can you post a few pics ?

 

Sarona no doubt

 

http://www.ebay.ca/itm/PAINTED-ACURA...#ht_6741wt_752

 

dead thread dead

 

I like the sarona roof wing a lot! It make it stands out a lot! Now i got a general idea what that would look like on the 4g TL!

 

So which one are you getting J.

 

Looks like NEITHER!
Honestly, the cost is so high and I'm not SOLD on loving any of them yet...that W212 one is really nice, I do admit though. Just perusing a bit.

J.

 

This?



Doesn't it look like Sarona? well.. a bit neater

 

Yeah, I like that lower profile, I like it angled back more than up, if that makes sense. Initially I was hellbent on trying to mimick the CSL upward shape, but I'm not sure yet. Going with the ebay oembmwspoiler one would be cheapest and easiest way to do it.

 

I got you
But being angled back might make it less noticable on a black TL