Replacing alternator with OEM or rebuilt???
#1
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Replacing alternator with OEM or rebuilt???
I was already runnning late going over to a friend's house to watch the UFC tonight. I started the car and got a loud whine. It didn't sound like the usual power steering, sort of like torque converter. I ran it through the gears, power-braked, and determined it wasn't the transmission. I turned the wheel side to side and determined it wasn't the power steering. I also noticed the Navi screen had horizontal lines moving up and down.
I remembered last night as I was bedding in the brakes and running the car pretty hard that there was a slight electrical smell but with the smell of hot brakes and a very hot engine, transmission, and braking system I didn't think anything of it.
So I got my IR temp gun and shot the alternator and it was 260F at the "magnet area" in the center of the case. This is after about 3 minutes of idle run time. I left it running and got my volt meter and it had 12.5v with it running. Alternator is dead. I checked the temp one more time before shutting it off and it was 315F in another minute or two. I waited a second with the engine off to make sure it was likely a bad bearing and the stator/rotor rubbing on the housing and not an electrical problem with the battery back-feeding causing it to heat up. It started cooling off so I'm satisfied it's purely a mechanical problem. I disconnected the battery anyway. I didn't like the interference with the navi system, I can only imagine the potential havoc it might wreck on the ECU and sensors.
So the question is, has anyone run one of the rebuilt OEM Denso units? I'm 90% sure I'm going to go with a brand new unit, this car has to be reliable which brings me to the next question.... Is $325 the best I'm going to get for a new OEM alternator for this car??? That's pretty damn expensive. I found the $325 one at Delray Acura and just about everywhere else I look they're nearly $400. I posted this problem just to make sure I'm not overlooking some really cheap website where I can get it for half price.
I have a feeling $325 is going to be the best I'm going to get but I thought I would ask anyway.
I'm not totally against rebuilt as long as all bearings are replaced along with the regulator and all pertinent electronics. Basically as long as all of the wear/electronic items are replaced I would go rebuilt but my experience has been they replace just the failed part, throw some shiny paint on it and resell it for 3/4 the price of a new one.
Also for Majofo or anyone with an electronics background, any idea why/how there were issues with the navi because the alternator died? Can it supply "dirty" power from a simple failure like this? Just making sure I don't have more than one problem or something else didn't cause the failure. I had been tuning the audio system for over an hour prior with the key on and a charger to keep the battery up without running the engine.
I remembered last night as I was bedding in the brakes and running the car pretty hard that there was a slight electrical smell but with the smell of hot brakes and a very hot engine, transmission, and braking system I didn't think anything of it.
So I got my IR temp gun and shot the alternator and it was 260F at the "magnet area" in the center of the case. This is after about 3 minutes of idle run time. I left it running and got my volt meter and it had 12.5v with it running. Alternator is dead. I checked the temp one more time before shutting it off and it was 315F in another minute or two. I waited a second with the engine off to make sure it was likely a bad bearing and the stator/rotor rubbing on the housing and not an electrical problem with the battery back-feeding causing it to heat up. It started cooling off so I'm satisfied it's purely a mechanical problem. I disconnected the battery anyway. I didn't like the interference with the navi system, I can only imagine the potential havoc it might wreck on the ECU and sensors.
So the question is, has anyone run one of the rebuilt OEM Denso units? I'm 90% sure I'm going to go with a brand new unit, this car has to be reliable which brings me to the next question.... Is $325 the best I'm going to get for a new OEM alternator for this car??? That's pretty damn expensive. I found the $325 one at Delray Acura and just about everywhere else I look they're nearly $400. I posted this problem just to make sure I'm not overlooking some really cheap website where I can get it for half price.
I have a feeling $325 is going to be the best I'm going to get but I thought I would ask anyway.
I'm not totally against rebuilt as long as all bearings are replaced along with the regulator and all pertinent electronics. Basically as long as all of the wear/electronic items are replaced I would go rebuilt but my experience has been they replace just the failed part, throw some shiny paint on it and resell it for 3/4 the price of a new one.
Also for Majofo or anyone with an electronics background, any idea why/how there were issues with the navi because the alternator died? Can it supply "dirty" power from a simple failure like this? Just making sure I don't have more than one problem or something else didn't cause the failure. I had been tuning the audio system for over an hour prior with the key on and a charger to keep the battery up without running the engine.
#2
Rev High; Drive Happy
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Scarborough, Ontario
Age: 34
Posts: 4,076
Received 398 Likes
on
332 Posts
Your alternator was probably running but sending either weak current or in fluxes of current. Sort of similar to a dying battery, where lights are dim or flickering even.
its been a while so i forgot the structure and the rebuild procedures of alternators and stators... But the repair job isn't entirely all that hard. Identify the faulty piece and replace. So, yes, odds are you wont find an alternator with new parts. Just replaced parts.
i was also lead to believe that most replacement alternators are actually rebuilt alternators too. But, that's replacement and not "brand new".
as for price, im not sure what they go for. But if you're finding it for less than the average 400 then it seems like a reasonable deal to me
its been a while so i forgot the structure and the rebuild procedures of alternators and stators... But the repair job isn't entirely all that hard. Identify the faulty piece and replace. So, yes, odds are you wont find an alternator with new parts. Just replaced parts.
i was also lead to believe that most replacement alternators are actually rebuilt alternators too. But, that's replacement and not "brand new".
as for price, im not sure what they go for. But if you're finding it for less than the average 400 then it seems like a reasonable deal to me
Last edited by o4Komodo; 03-17-2013 at 03:29 AM.
#4
Suzuka Master
iTrader: (1)
I'd agree to stay away from the run of the mill aftermarket stores as I'ver encountered many problems with their rebuilt electrical units. Although many come with a lifetime warranty, it becomes quite annoying to do replacements after a short period of time. A few years ago, I pulled a remanufactured starter apart and the housing was filled with grease and shavings, not even cleaned.
Here's a new unit from Rock Auto:
USA INDUSTRIES Part # 511500 w/ Nippondenso 130 Amp (Only 1 Remaining) $182.79 $0.00 $182.79
USA Industries Starter/Alternator Features:
All components and housings are 100% new
All units state of the art computer load tested to simulate extreme operating conditions
Graphics packaging and unit shrink wrapped for zero shipping damage
Design improvements to surpass OEM standards and amperage ratings
If you're interested, here's the 5% Discount Code:
710F1AC6FB23
Expires: 03/24/2013
Here's a new unit from Rock Auto:
USA INDUSTRIES Part # 511500 w/ Nippondenso 130 Amp (Only 1 Remaining) $182.79 $0.00 $182.79
USA Industries Starter/Alternator Features:
All components and housings are 100% new
All units state of the art computer load tested to simulate extreme operating conditions
Graphics packaging and unit shrink wrapped for zero shipping damage
Design improvements to surpass OEM standards and amperage ratings
If you're interested, here's the 5% Discount Code:
710F1AC6FB23
Expires: 03/24/2013
Trending Topics
#8
Team Owner
Thread Starter
I'd agree to stay away from the run of the mill aftermarket stores as I'ver encountered many problems with their rebuilt electrical units. Although many come with a lifetime warranty, it becomes quite annoying to do replacements after a short period of time. A few years ago, I pulled a remanufactured starter apart and the housing was filled with grease and shavings, not even cleaned.
Here's a new unit from Rock Auto:
USA INDUSTRIES Part # 511500 w/ Nippondenso 130 Amp (Only 1 Remaining) $182.79 $0.00 $182.79
USA Industries Starter/Alternator Features:
All components and housings are 100% new
All units state of the art computer load tested to simulate extreme operating conditions
Graphics packaging and unit shrink wrapped for zero shipping damage
Design improvements to surpass OEM standards and amperage ratings
If you're interested, here's the 5% Discount Code:
710F1AC6FB23
Expires: 03/24/2013
Here's a new unit from Rock Auto:
USA INDUSTRIES Part # 511500 w/ Nippondenso 130 Amp (Only 1 Remaining) $182.79 $0.00 $182.79
USA Industries Starter/Alternator Features:
All components and housings are 100% new
All units state of the art computer load tested to simulate extreme operating conditions
Graphics packaging and unit shrink wrapped for zero shipping damage
Design improvements to surpass OEM standards and amperage ratings
If you're interested, here's the 5% Discount Code:
710F1AC6FB23
Expires: 03/24/2013
I didn't even think of the LKQ you listed. I practically lived at that place when I was young and broke, trying to keep the GN running. The owner would let me go in the back and pull parts myself and give me a discount, he probably felt sorry for me. I'm going to look around and see what they have as far as TLs.
#9
Racer
I've always the best sucess having the OEM starter/alternator units rebuilt at a rebuild shop that specializes in that only. Yours may not be rebuildable because of the heat it's been suffering but you could find a salvage one if you have the time to wait on shiping.
#11
Usually you can snag used OEM ones real cheap. Might be able to find one shipping close to you.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/06-07-08-HONDA-PILOT-ALTERNATOR-3-5L-6-CYL-4X4-/300865897725?pt=Motors_Car_Truck_Parts_Accessories&fits=Make%3AAcura%7CModel%3ATL&hash=item460d0144fd&vxp=mtr
I replaced a few alternators with used OEM's and never had an issue.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/06-07-08-HONDA-PILOT-ALTERNATOR-3-5L-6-CYL-4X4-/300865897725?pt=Motors_Car_Truck_Parts_Accessories&fits=Make%3AAcura%7CModel%3ATL&hash=item460d0144fd&vxp=mtr
I replaced a few alternators with used OEM's and never had an issue.
#12
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Oh, almost forgot, there is some sort of backfeeding going on. I decided to clean the garage out late last night so I hooked the battery up so I could have the stereo. After about an hour I checked the alternator and it was 115 degrees and everything around it was about 65 degrees.
#13
Team Owner
Thread Starter
I would go the used OEM route if they could guarantee low, low miles but reliability is the most important thing so new to me is worth the additional cost. I might take my old one apart to see what the damage is and specifically if it's rebuildable maybe into a slightly higher output. My system is very efficient and most of the time it's not drawing more than 100w total but a little more headroom wouldn't hurt. I actually wish there was a way to tweak the voltage, maybe .5V extra.
I've had a whine for a long time but it got louder overnight. I'm interested to see if drivability changes. It seems like most cars have close to 14v when running and this one has been at 13.5v for a long time.
I've had a whine for a long time but it got louder overnight. I'm interested to see if drivability changes. It seems like most cars have close to 14v when running and this one has been at 13.5v for a long time.
#14
:what:
I also use a local rebuilder. Ive known him for years and trust him implicitly. He knows I'm a gear head, so, he always has my old bearings, seals, regulators, brushes, stators etc laying out to show me what failed. I have built many myself, but getting the kits or even figuring out what kit it takes is a chore for someone like me. I've walked into his shop before and he said things like "Ok, that's gonna take a *blah blah blah* but I'm out of those and they are on back order, so I can take a bearing set out of a *blah blah blah* and brushes out of a *blah blah blah* and that regulator is pretty common so I probably have one of those laying around." His knowledge is impressive. Usually gives same day service and when he isnt busy he has pulled me around back and rebuilt things right in front of me. Electrically he can do in 5 minutes what would take me two hours of internet research followed by another two hours of labor then a week of waiting on parts that I broke in the process.
#15
Team Owner
Thread Starter
I also use a local rebuilder. Ive known him for years and trust him implicitly. He knows I'm a gear head, so, he always has my old bearings, seals, regulators, brushes, stators etc laying out to show me what failed. I have built many myself, but getting the kits or even figuring out what kit it takes is a chore for someone like me. I've walked into his shop before and he said things like "Ok, that's gonna take a *blah blah blah* but I'm out of those and they are on back order, so I can take a bearing set out of a *blah blah blah* and brushes out of a *blah blah blah* and that regulator is pretty common so I probably have one of those laying around." His knowledge is impressive. Usually gives same day service and when he isnt busy he has pulled me around back and rebuilt things right in front of me. Electrically he can do in 5 minutes what would take me two hours of internet research followed by another two hours of labor then a week of waiting on parts that I broke in the process.
#16
:what:
Some of them are our customers and I have to go in from time to time.....not cool.
I'm really tempted to be a dick and blame the alternator failure on the fact that you have the wrong battery in the car, but we both know that isnt the case.
#17
I see an extremely stable 14.2-14.3V almost 100% of the time. The alternator field never appears to turn off under low loads on this car like it did on my Accord.
13.5V is definitely a bit suspect if the meter is reasonably accurate.
Personally, I would take my chances with a high miles used OEM over a random rebuild. Most 'remanufactured' units are probably fine, but taking it somewhere to get it rebuilt it questionable.
13.5V is definitely a bit suspect if the meter is reasonably accurate.
Personally, I would take my chances with a high miles used OEM over a random rebuild. Most 'remanufactured' units are probably fine, but taking it somewhere to get it rebuilt it questionable.
#18
Team Owner
Thread Starter
I see an extremely stable 14.2-14.3V almost 100% of the time. The alternator field never appears to turn off under low loads on this car like it did on my Accord.
13.5V is definitely a bit suspect if the meter is reasonably accurate.
Personally, I would take my chances with a high miles used OEM over a random rebuild. Most 'remanufactured' units are probably fine, but taking it somewhere to get it rebuilt it questionable.
13.5V is definitely a bit suspect if the meter is reasonably accurate.
Personally, I would take my chances with a high miles used OEM over a random rebuild. Most 'remanufactured' units are probably fine, but taking it somewhere to get it rebuilt it questionable.
#19
AZ Community Team
FWIW, Bosch rebuilt units are OK for Honda/Acura's. They advertise what they replace (bearings, regulator, diodes,...) and I've used a couple. Little more expensive but worth it.
I would not get a used from the junkyard.
Also check Honda/Acura I know they do some rebuilt products, not sure about alternators.
If it smells burnt, then the field or stator may be toast and not worth rebuilding. I've replaced the alternator brushes on a handful of Honda/Acura's, they are a component you can buy (~$10) and replace.
I would not get a used from the junkyard.
Also check Honda/Acura I know they do some rebuilt products, not sure about alternators.
If it smells burnt, then the field or stator may be toast and not worth rebuilding. I've replaced the alternator brushes on a handful of Honda/Acura's, they are a component you can buy (~$10) and replace.
#21
Drifting
I waited a second with the engine off to make sure it was likely a bad bearing and the stator/rotor rubbing on the housing and not an electrical problem with the battery back-feeding causing it to heat up. It started cooling off so I'm satisfied it's purely a mechanical problem. I disconnected the battery anyway. I didn't like the interference with the navi system, I can only imagine the potential havoc it might wreck on the ECU and sensors.
Also for Majofo or anyone with an electronics background, any idea why/how there were issues with the navi because the alternator died? Can it supply "dirty" power from a simple failure like this? Just making sure I don't have more than one problem or something else didn't cause the failure. I had been tuning the audio system for over an hour prior with the key on and a charger to keep the battery up without running the engine.
Also for Majofo or anyone with an electronics background, any idea why/how there were issues with the navi because the alternator died? Can it supply "dirty" power from a simple failure like this? Just making sure I don't have more than one problem or something else didn't cause the failure. I had been tuning the audio system for over an hour prior with the key on and a charger to keep the battery up without running the engine.
#22
Team Owner
Thread Starter
FWIW, Bosch rebuilt units are OK for Honda/Acura's. They advertise what they replace (bearings, regulator, diodes,...) and I've used a couple. Little more expensive but worth it.
I would not get a used from the junkyard.
Also check Honda/Acura I know they do some rebuilt products, not sure about alternators.
If it smells burnt, then the field or stator may be toast and not worth rebuilding. I've replaced the alternator brushes on a handful of Honda/Acura's, they are a component you can buy (~$10) and replace.
I would not get a used from the junkyard.
Also check Honda/Acura I know they do some rebuilt products, not sure about alternators.
If it smells burnt, then the field or stator may be toast and not worth rebuilding. I've replaced the alternator brushes on a handful of Honda/Acura's, they are a component you can buy (~$10) and replace.
I'm worried there's something else going on. I was thinking about AC voltage. The alternator will also get hot if I hook the battery up to it, without starting the engine. Diode???
#23
Drifting
I don't know the entire design/setup of our alt systems, but I would assume there is some type of electrical fault within the housing if you have current flow when the engine is off. I am "assuming" the diodes and the regulator are internal on our cars and one of those is probably failed/shorted causing the heat and current draw.
#24
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Damnit lol. I'm second guessing myself.
Anyone know if the diode is built into the connector/harness or if it's in the alternator itself?
A bad diode causing the "dirty" power and apparent backfeeding of the alternator makes perfect sense right now. I would rather try my luck with a cheap diode first. Then again I don't want to pop the ECU or any other electronics with AC voltage.
HELP! LOL.
Anyone know if the diode is built into the connector/harness or if it's in the alternator itself?
A bad diode causing the "dirty" power and apparent backfeeding of the alternator makes perfect sense right now. I would rather try my luck with a cheap diode first. Then again I don't want to pop the ECU or any other electronics with AC voltage.
HELP! LOL.
#25
Team Owner
Thread Starter
It's for sure not the bearings. As soon as I unplugged the wiring harness the noise went completely away and so did the heat. At least I can dive to work and back. I turned on every electrical accessory the car has, along with the system and it runs fine. Alt isn't putting out obviously so I'm really glad I went with the Diehard Platinum battery now. I'm just hoping one or all diodes can cause this issue.
#26
Racer
i'm blessed to have a competent rebuilder in my area also, old gripey guy abt. my age but has a lifetime of experience doing alt,starters with tons of parts. These cars alternators almost always are repairable, the whining seems to usually be a diode, they're all inside the case.
#28
Team Owner
Thread Starter
I doubt it. The subs and amps are extremely efficient. The one time I measured with it slightly louder than I normally listen, it was only drawing 90w total. While there's 1200w available for the front stage, that's only brief spikes during transients but the average draw is very low. My old system used to cause headlight dimming but this one never has.
#29
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Replaced the alternator last night and all is well again. I am impressed with the DieHard Platinum for getting me to work and back last week with no alternator.
The car seems to turn over faster than it ever has on the starter but it might be because I got used to it turning over slower than normal last week. The lights seem brighter too but that could be for the same reason.
I forgot to buy a belt. This one is dried out pretty bad but I guess I'll wait until I do the timing belt in the next few weeks.
Thanks again to those that helped.
The car seems to turn over faster than it ever has on the starter but it might be because I got used to it turning over slower than normal last week. The lights seem brighter too but that could be for the same reason.
I forgot to buy a belt. This one is dried out pretty bad but I guess I'll wait until I do the timing belt in the next few weeks.
Thanks again to those that helped.
#30
For anyone else looking for an alt or just general info I've seen oem ones for bout $300 new and $200 for oem reman. Sometimes location is more important than a small different in price of course.
#31
Team Owner
Thread Starter
In my case it was a $100 difference in price so it was worth the wait especially considering I'm buying another toy (another GN) and since I have to buy the car with cash $100 is well worth the wait.
#32
Did you grid charge daily driving without an alternator?
I drove two vehicles without an alternator for about a week each. Both were fine for my then 50 mile roundtrip commute. I even did it a few times with headlights and traffic, but that was real sketchy once the battery was getting low. The car would be a trainwreck at high RPM.
Some people on ecomodder don't run alternators and just grid charge. It's a bit silly since the reduction in the battery lifespan will likely offset any quite minor fuel savings, and things like windows work poorly with the lower voltage. I suppose a lot of those people have roll up windows and almost no electronics anyways.
I drove two vehicles without an alternator for about a week each. Both were fine for my then 50 mile roundtrip commute. I even did it a few times with headlights and traffic, but that was real sketchy once the battery was getting low. The car would be a trainwreck at high RPM.
Some people on ecomodder don't run alternators and just grid charge. It's a bit silly since the reduction in the battery lifespan will likely offset any quite minor fuel savings, and things like windows work poorly with the lower voltage. I suppose a lot of those people have roll up windows and almost no electronics anyways.
Last edited by ZOMGVTEK; 03-26-2013 at 02:37 PM.
#33
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Did you grid charge daily driving without an alternator?
I drove two vehicles without an alternator for about a week each. Both were fine for my then 50 mile roundtrip commute. I even did it a few times with headlights and traffic, but that was real sketchy once the battery was getting low. The car would be a trainwreck at high RPM.
Some people on ecomodder don't run alternators and just grid charge. It's a bit silly since the reduction in the battery lifespan will likely offset any quite minor fuel savings, and things like windows work poorly with the lower voltage. I suppose a lot of those people have roll up windows and almost no electronics anyways.
I drove two vehicles without an alternator for about a week each. Both were fine for my then 50 mile roundtrip commute. I even did it a few times with headlights and traffic, but that was real sketchy once the battery was getting low. The car would be a trainwreck at high RPM.
Some people on ecomodder don't run alternators and just grid charge. It's a bit silly since the reduction in the battery lifespan will likely offset any quite minor fuel savings, and things like windows work poorly with the lower voltage. I suppose a lot of those people have roll up windows and almost no electronics anyways.
#35
Team Owner
Thread Starter
EXACTLY like that. Next time it's dead cold, start it and see if the alternator gets too hot to touch in just a couple minutes. I also had some barely noticeable lines in the navi. Not lines but "waves" as if there's noise in the system.
The following users liked this post:
powdbyrice (06-23-2013)
#36
great. well, not great, but at least i know the source.
i'll have to check the navi screen. i haven't noticed any other electrical issues, lights dimming etc.
oddly enough, the sound was not present when i drove the car today, but i'm sure it will be back.
thanks for the tips!
i'll have to check the navi screen. i haven't noticed any other electrical issues, lights dimming etc.
oddly enough, the sound was not present when i drove the car today, but i'm sure it will be back.
thanks for the tips!
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
asahrts
Member Cars for Sale
0
09-04-2015 05:55 PM