Geico seems to be the cheapest in Florida. I requested a quote from State Farm and All-State and when they called me back and asked me how much I pay, they said "we suggest you stick with Geico". When I had my 99 CL, I had a major accident and more speeding tickets than i could count...my monthly payment for full coverage (Comp and Collison) plus rental and tow was $29/month. However, it did go up when I bought the TL a few months back

 

Well i have USAA, can non-military get insured by USAA?

I love the customer support, always get an American that i can understand on the other end of the line. I have claimed 2 different times over the last 10 years on my Taurus SHO both times it was very simple and my premiums only went up acouple of dollars.

For my Acura i do pay 102 a month, which seems a lil high to me. I haven't had a ticket or any traffic violations in 7 years. I might have to call and see if i can get that lowered. I can't really comment on other companies because i've only had one insurance provider since i've been driving for 10+ years