Defend the RL!
Thread Starter
Racer
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 412
Likes: 0
Defend the RL!
Ok. That title may be slightly misleading, but what I'm looking for are you as the owners to say why I would want a TL or to address the things I see as a concern.
I'm considering another Sedan to compliment our M35, and the RL could be it... or the GS... or even an M5, but I'm not looking to compare those.
Ok, here's what I like about the car:
AWD is awesome.
I like the subdued looks. It's nice, but not flashy which appeals to me.
Comfortable.
The stereo is solid for factory.
Nice nice nice Nav system and voice recognition.
Good blue tooth features.
All around good package and picking up an '05 for $42K is an excellent deal.
Ok, here are my concerns:
1) Leather: Does it wear as poorly as the TL's leather or is it different? We had a '05 TL and the leather wears very poorly. Wrinkles, etc. I was very disappointed.
2) Lack of DVD video of any kind. I have a 2 year old. No entertainment system of any kind? My M35 plays DVD video in the nav screen while you're parked. There's also a rear option. And you can plug in RCA jacks to a rear set of plugs that will go through the system and the nav screen (external DVD player or game system, etc.) There is a hack I did that allows you to view while driving which comes in handy w/ my passenger and/or kids.
Is there a way in the RL to enjoy video DVD's? I really like listening to video DVD's myself while driving... like Seinfelds that I know so well, that the screen action doesn't matter, just the audio.
3) No cooling seats... WTF? Nothing to defend here, but I can't believe they don't have this. I live in Houston... it's a big item.
4) Back sensors or camera? I saw the sensors as an add-on. Is that a dealer installed option? If so, that's a negative.
5) Resale... I'm imagining it's very bad since the new car sales are slow w/ the RL
6) Build quality... our TL had a lot of rattles as do a lot of TL's. Is the RL in the same boat?
I'm considering another Sedan to compliment our M35, and the RL could be it... or the GS... or even an M5, but I'm not looking to compare those.
Ok, here's what I like about the car:
AWD is awesome.
I like the subdued looks. It's nice, but not flashy which appeals to me.
Comfortable.
The stereo is solid for factory.
Nice nice nice Nav system and voice recognition.
Good blue tooth features.
All around good package and picking up an '05 for $42K is an excellent deal.
Ok, here are my concerns:
1) Leather: Does it wear as poorly as the TL's leather or is it different? We had a '05 TL and the leather wears very poorly. Wrinkles, etc. I was very disappointed.
2) Lack of DVD video of any kind. I have a 2 year old. No entertainment system of any kind? My M35 plays DVD video in the nav screen while you're parked. There's also a rear option. And you can plug in RCA jacks to a rear set of plugs that will go through the system and the nav screen (external DVD player or game system, etc.) There is a hack I did that allows you to view while driving which comes in handy w/ my passenger and/or kids.
Is there a way in the RL to enjoy video DVD's? I really like listening to video DVD's myself while driving... like Seinfelds that I know so well, that the screen action doesn't matter, just the audio.
3) No cooling seats... WTF? Nothing to defend here, but I can't believe they don't have this. I live in Houston... it's a big item.
4) Back sensors or camera? I saw the sensors as an add-on. Is that a dealer installed option? If so, that's a negative.
5) Resale... I'm imagining it's very bad since the new car sales are slow w/ the RL
6) Build quality... our TL had a lot of rattles as do a lot of TL's. Is the RL in the same boat?
Thread Starter
Racer
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 412
Likes: 0
One other thing that's huge...
If you can play a DVD Video while driving, you can listen to live concert DVD's and just not watch for obvious reasons, but you can enjoy great music. I have several video concert DVD's that I can listen to in the Infiniti.
If you can play a DVD Video while driving, you can listen to live concert DVD's and just not watch for obvious reasons, but you can enjoy great music. I have several video concert DVD's that I can listen to in the Infiniti.
Suzuka Master
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 5,682
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
1) Leather: Does it wear as poorly as the TL's leather or is it different? We had a '05 TL and the leather wears very poorly. Wrinkles, etc. I was very disappointed.
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
2) Lack of DVD video of any kind. I have a 2 year old. No entertainment system of any kind? My M35 plays DVD video in the nav screen while you're parked. There's also a rear option. And you can plug in RCA jacks to a rear set of plugs that will go through the system and the nav screen (external DVD player or game system, etc.) There is a hack I did that allows you to view while driving which comes in handy w/ my passenger and/or kids.
Is there a way in the RL to enjoy video DVD's? I really like listening to video DVD's myself while driving... like Seinfelds that I know so well, that the screen action doesn't matter, just the audio.
Is there a way in the RL to enjoy video DVD's? I really like listening to video DVD's myself while driving... like Seinfelds that I know so well, that the screen action doesn't matter, just the audio.
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
3) No cooling seats... WTF? Nothing to defend here, but I can't believe they don't have this. I live in Houston... it's a big item.
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
4) Back sensors or camera? I saw the sensors as an add-on. Is that a dealer installed option? If so, that's a negative.
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
5) Resale... I'm imagining it's very bad since the new car sales are slow w/ the RL
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
6) Build quality... our TL had a lot of rattles as do a lot of TL's. Is the RL in the same boat?
'06 RL
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 819
Likes: 1
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
6) Build quality... our TL had a lot of rattles as do a lot of TL's. Is the RL in the same boat?
Thread Starter
Racer
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 412
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by WhitePearl_RL
I think you have made up your mind already. No reason for me to defend the RL.. it is nice to not see another RL everyday 
along with a nice track car like an Elise or S2000.
OR
Get an M5.
I'm truly not sure which way I'm going to go. I've done similar searches on the GS as well. Since we own an M35 already, I'm not on those boards doing this.
Trending Topics
Instructor
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 110
Likes: 0
From: San Francisco East Bay
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
Ok. That title may be slightly misleading, but what I'm looking for are you as the owners to say why I would want a TL or to address the things I see as a concern.
I'm considering another Sedan to compliment our M35, and the RL could be it... or the GS... or even an M5, but I'm not looking to compare those.
Ok, here's what I like about the car:
AWD is awesome.
I like the subdued looks. It's nice, but not flashy which appeals to me.
Comfortable.
The stereo is solid for factory.
Nice nice nice Nav system and voice recognition.
Good blue tooth features.
All around good package and picking up an '05 for $42K is an excellent deal.
Ok, here are my concerns:
1) Leather: Does it wear as poorly as the TL's leather or is it different? We had a '05 TL and the leather wears very poorly. Wrinkles, etc. I was very disappointed.
2) Lack of DVD video of any kind. I have a 2 year old. No entertainment system of any kind? My M35 plays DVD video in the nav screen while you're parked. There's also a rear option. And you can plug in RCA jacks to a rear set of plugs that will go through the system and the nav screen (external DVD player or game system, etc.) There is a hack I did that allows you to view while driving which comes in handy w/ my passenger and/or kids.
Is there a way in the RL to enjoy video DVD's? I really like listening to video DVD's myself while driving... like Seinfelds that I know so well, that the screen action doesn't matter, just the audio.
3) No cooling seats... WTF? Nothing to defend here, but I can't believe they don't have this. I live in Houston... it's a big item.
4) Back sensors or camera? I saw the sensors as an add-on. Is that a dealer installed option? If so, that's a negative.
5) Resale... I'm imagining it's very bad since the new car sales are slow w/ the RL
6) Build quality... our TL had a lot of rattles as do a lot of TL's. Is the RL in the same boat?
I'm considering another Sedan to compliment our M35, and the RL could be it... or the GS... or even an M5, but I'm not looking to compare those.
Ok, here's what I like about the car:
AWD is awesome.
I like the subdued looks. It's nice, but not flashy which appeals to me.
Comfortable.
The stereo is solid for factory.
Nice nice nice Nav system and voice recognition.
Good blue tooth features.
All around good package and picking up an '05 for $42K is an excellent deal.
Ok, here are my concerns:
1) Leather: Does it wear as poorly as the TL's leather or is it different? We had a '05 TL and the leather wears very poorly. Wrinkles, etc. I was very disappointed.
2) Lack of DVD video of any kind. I have a 2 year old. No entertainment system of any kind? My M35 plays DVD video in the nav screen while you're parked. There's also a rear option. And you can plug in RCA jacks to a rear set of plugs that will go through the system and the nav screen (external DVD player or game system, etc.) There is a hack I did that allows you to view while driving which comes in handy w/ my passenger and/or kids.
Is there a way in the RL to enjoy video DVD's? I really like listening to video DVD's myself while driving... like Seinfelds that I know so well, that the screen action doesn't matter, just the audio.
3) No cooling seats... WTF? Nothing to defend here, but I can't believe they don't have this. I live in Houston... it's a big item.
4) Back sensors or camera? I saw the sensors as an add-on. Is that a dealer installed option? If so, that's a negative.
5) Resale... I'm imagining it's very bad since the new car sales are slow w/ the RL
6) Build quality... our TL had a lot of rattles as do a lot of TL's. Is the RL in the same boat?
Suzuka Master
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 5,349
Likes: 3
From: Lower Nazzie, Pa
you can listen to the audio from DVD videos...just no image.
the thing that does suck with the m35/45 is that the dvd-A/player is separate from the 6-disc indash (so in effect, you have a 6-disc changer + 1 dvd audio/video player in the armrest storage).
the thing that does suck with the m35/45 is that the dvd-A/player is separate from the 6-disc indash (so in effect, you have a 6-disc changer + 1 dvd audio/video player in the armrest storage).
office monkey
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 1,052
Likes: 0
From: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted by vp911
Well, I just drove the car - and it seems in the cold weather the dash is making rattling noises. 
My previous IS300 had no rattles during warm weather but would get one near the driver dash vent in the cold.
Cold weather there? It's been very warm here. This past Saturday it was May warmth.
Instructor
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 159
Likes: 0
From: SF Bay Area
I had a Legend and 2000 RL previously. The leather in both showed very little signs of wear after 100k and 85k for the two cars, nor did they have any rattles. My 05 does not have any rattles and I am very impressed with the leather. The interior is why I purchased this car. As far as rear seat DVD goes, buy one of the 9" or 7" portables that have the adaptor to hook to the head rest. You can use it in any car or plane also.
One thing not to over look is the safety rating. I was scanning through the media reviews thread and saw that the 05 RL was one of only 5 cars to receive perfect crash test scores from both rating agencies. I also saw a post from someone here who walked away from a horrible looking crash that totalled the car. You don't always think about that when purchasing, but it should play into the evaluation.
Kris
One thing not to over look is the safety rating. I was scanning through the media reviews thread and saw that the 05 RL was one of only 5 cars to receive perfect crash test scores from both rating agencies. I also saw a post from someone here who walked away from a horrible looking crash that totalled the car. You don't always think about that when purchasing, but it should play into the evaluation.
Kris
Suzuka Master
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 5,682
Likes: 2
Originally Posted by kgd
I had a Legend and 2000 RL previously. The leather in both showed very little signs of wear after 100k and 85k for the two cars, nor did they have any rattles. My 05 does not have any rattles and I am very impressed with the leather. The interior is why I purchased this car. As far as rear seat DVD goes, buy one of the 9" or 7" portables that have the adaptor to hook to the head rest. You can use it in any car or plane also.
One thing not to over look is the safety rating. I was scanning through the media reviews thread and saw that the 05 RL was one of only 5 cars to receive perfect crash test scores from both rating agencies. I also saw a post from someone here who walked away from a horrible looking crash that totalled the car. You don't always think about that when purchasing, but it should play into the evaluation.
Kris
One thing not to over look is the safety rating. I was scanning through the media reviews thread and saw that the 05 RL was one of only 5 cars to receive perfect crash test scores from both rating agencies. I also saw a post from someone here who walked away from a horrible looking crash that totalled the car. You don't always think about that when purchasing, but it should play into the evaluation.
Kris
Advanced
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
From: San Antonio, TX
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
Not true at all. I'm not sure if I want to get either: RL, Infiniti M, or GS
along with a nice track car like an Elise or S2000.
OR
Get an M5.
I'm truly not sure which way I'm going to go. I've done similar searches on the GS as well. Since we own an M35 already, I'm not on those boards doing this.
along with a nice track car like an Elise or S2000.
OR
Get an M5.
I'm truly not sure which way I'm going to go. I've done similar searches on the GS as well. Since we own an M35 already, I'm not on those boards doing this.
M5? If I thought I could afford it, I would trade the Rl in a minute. My wife is on here 3rd BMW (3 and 5 serious and now an X3) They drive great and I would love the 500 h/p
Thread Starter
Racer
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 412
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by johnhayd
scott- In your M35, If you don't have a back seat lcd screen ( and do have the journey/tech packages), can you listen to DVD-video while driving? Or does the car have to be stopped to even LISTEN to the DVD-VIDEO? thanks.
I have heard (ahem...cough cough I did it cough cough) of a hack that allows me to now get full navigation control while driving as well as full video watching of the DVD on the Nav screen while driving. This comes in very handy with passengers in the car.
To all the other responders, thank you very much. I'm going to drive an '05 b/c they are at very good prices! I'm very tempted to get an RL (or GS or M35) and a track car as opposed to just getting an M5 and no track car.
The Japanese kick the Germans in the ding ding when it comes to electronic toys and gadgets in their cars. I am only considering BMW's 5 series b/c it has a V10... lol. I would take the RL, M35/45, or GS over the other 5 series almost all the time.
Racer
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 306
Likes: 0
From: SoCal
Scott, my humble opinions are in parens, for your enjoyment and/or rebuttal.
Originally Posted by Scott in Houston
Ok. That title may be slightly misleading, but what I'm looking for are you as the owners to say why I would want a TL or to address the things I see as a concern.
I'm considering another Sedan to compliment our M35, and the RL could be it... or the GS... or even an M5, but I'm not looking to compare those.
Ok, here's what I like about the car:
AWD is awesome. (yes, it is, especially when sparring with a G35 coupe)
I like the subdued looks. It's nice, but not flashy which appeals to me. (a classic sleeper car, IMHO)
Comfortable. (the seats are fantastic for long trips, and the rear is equally comfortable according to my passengers)
The stereo is solid for factory. (best I have had in my 30+ years of owning cars, and I am an avowed audiophile with a very nice home system)
Nice nice nice Nav system and voice recognition. (best in the industry, much better than the competition, IMHO)
Good blue tooth features. (works great with the right phones)
All around good package and picking up an '05 for $42K is an excellent deal. (it's the best bang for the buck on the market in this category)
Ok, here are my concerns:
1) Leather: Does it wear as poorly as the TL's leather or is it different? We had a '05 TL and the leather wears very poorly. Wrinkles, etc. I was very disappointed. (can't tell after only 5k miles)
2) Lack of DVD video of any kind. I have a 2 year old. No entertainment system of any kind? My M35 plays DVD video in the nav screen while you're parked. There's also a rear option. And you can plug in RCA jacks to a rear set of plugs that will go through the system and the nav screen (external DVD player or game system, etc.) There is a hack I did that allows you to view while driving which comes in handy w/ my passenger and/or kids.
Is there a way in the RL to enjoy video DVD's? I really like listening to video DVD's myself while driving... like Seinfelds that I know so well, that the screen action doesn't matter, just the audio. (check out the other threads that discuss this)
3) No cooling seats... WTF? Nothing to defend here, but I can't believe they don't have this. I live in Houston... it's a big item. (I live in Socal and have not noticed this as a problem this past summer)
4) Back sensors or camera? I saw the sensors as an add-on. Is that a dealer installed option? If so, that's a negative. (camera looks like it will be a relatively easy add-on using the 06 camera and an aftermarket i/f unit; sensors is even easier and potential DIY for those that are so inclined)
5) Resale... I'm imagining it's very bad since the new car sales are slow w/ the RL (only relevant if you plan to own the car for just a few years, which I am not)
6) Build quality... our TL had a lot of rattles as do a lot of TL's. Is the RL in the same boat? (by far the best fit and finish of any car I have owned or test driven, bar none)
I'm considering another Sedan to compliment our M35, and the RL could be it... or the GS... or even an M5, but I'm not looking to compare those.
Ok, here's what I like about the car:
AWD is awesome. (yes, it is, especially when sparring with a G35 coupe)
I like the subdued looks. It's nice, but not flashy which appeals to me. (a classic sleeper car, IMHO)
Comfortable. (the seats are fantastic for long trips, and the rear is equally comfortable according to my passengers)
The stereo is solid for factory. (best I have had in my 30+ years of owning cars, and I am an avowed audiophile with a very nice home system)
Nice nice nice Nav system and voice recognition. (best in the industry, much better than the competition, IMHO)
Good blue tooth features. (works great with the right phones)
All around good package and picking up an '05 for $42K is an excellent deal. (it's the best bang for the buck on the market in this category)
Ok, here are my concerns:
1) Leather: Does it wear as poorly as the TL's leather or is it different? We had a '05 TL and the leather wears very poorly. Wrinkles, etc. I was very disappointed. (can't tell after only 5k miles)
2) Lack of DVD video of any kind. I have a 2 year old. No entertainment system of any kind? My M35 plays DVD video in the nav screen while you're parked. There's also a rear option. And you can plug in RCA jacks to a rear set of plugs that will go through the system and the nav screen (external DVD player or game system, etc.) There is a hack I did that allows you to view while driving which comes in handy w/ my passenger and/or kids.
Is there a way in the RL to enjoy video DVD's? I really like listening to video DVD's myself while driving... like Seinfelds that I know so well, that the screen action doesn't matter, just the audio. (check out the other threads that discuss this)
3) No cooling seats... WTF? Nothing to defend here, but I can't believe they don't have this. I live in Houston... it's a big item. (I live in Socal and have not noticed this as a problem this past summer)
4) Back sensors or camera? I saw the sensors as an add-on. Is that a dealer installed option? If so, that's a negative. (camera looks like it will be a relatively easy add-on using the 06 camera and an aftermarket i/f unit; sensors is even easier and potential DIY for those that are so inclined)
5) Resale... I'm imagining it's very bad since the new car sales are slow w/ the RL (only relevant if you plan to own the car for just a few years, which I am not)
6) Build quality... our TL had a lot of rattles as do a lot of TL's. Is the RL in the same boat? (by far the best fit and finish of any car I have owned or test driven, bar none)
Thread Starter
Racer
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 412
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by WhitePearl_RL
Scott,
Is your 996 TT your current track car? I had considered a '03 X50 996 TT as a daily/weekend track car but decided to go with a 2LZ C6 Z06 instead.
Goodluck with your decision
Is your 996 TT your current track car? I had considered a '03 X50 996 TT as a daily/weekend track car but decided to go with a 2LZ C6 Z06 instead.
Goodluck with your decision
Yes, I track my 996TT. The problem is, it's expensive, and I've been doing it a while which means I'm faster, and that is scary. I need to get a car I care a lot less about if I go off in the wrong place.
The new Z06 is a nice car. It's performance is amazing. I'm not a fan of the looks or the interior though. GM just can't ever seem to get those things right for me. For the money, you can't beat it.
Acurafox, nice stuff. Thanks!
Instructor
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 155
Likes: 1
From: Virginia Beach, VA
I bet it is expensive to track that 996TT! I had bought a 1989 944 S-2 new and drove it till 1998 when I gave it to my son. You should see the stack of receipts I had for that car... it did everything from AutoX, SCCA, road challenges and back and forth to work. I was one of the few to drive their car to the track events. Good too see another true enthusiast
Instructor
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 236
Likes: 8
I have heard (ahem...cough cough I did it cough cough) of a hack that allows me to now get full navigation control while driving as well as full video watching of the DVD on the Nav screen while driving.
but I would sure like to know how the hack can
be done.
Maybe you can private message me on this?
Racer
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 466
Likes: 0
From: Katy, TX
Originally Posted by mrdeeno
you can listen to the audio from DVD videos...just no image.
the thing that does suck with the m35/45 is that the dvd-A/player is separate from the 6-disc indash (so in effect, you have a 6-disc changer + 1 dvd audio/video player in the armrest storage).
the thing that does suck with the m35/45 is that the dvd-A/player is separate from the 6-disc indash (so in effect, you have a 6-disc changer + 1 dvd audio/video player in the armrest storage).
For Scott in Houston: This is a great site for a pro-RL perspective and nothing wrong with that. For a site with a pro-M perspective visit www.infiniti-driver.com
Both cars have their advantages and disadvantages (there is no such thing as a perfect car). Continue your research and do extensive test drives in both to determine which one best addresses your own unique needs, wants, and budget with the fewest compromises. Good luck
Thread Starter
Racer
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 412
Likes: 0
msu79, thanks!
I see you're in Katy. I'm in Sugar Land.
I own an M, so I'm familiar very familiar and fairly active on an M board. Thanks for the recommendation!
I have until late January to decide, so I'll really take my time in the research. Right now, the GS, M, and RL are so close, it's a tough call! I think the price for the RL makes it very attractive though.
I see you're in Katy. I'm in Sugar Land.
I own an M, so I'm familiar very familiar and fairly active on an M board. Thanks for the recommendation!
I have until late January to decide, so I'll really take my time in the research. Right now, the GS, M, and RL are so close, it's a tough call! I think the price for the RL makes it very attractive though.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Yumcha
Automotive News
1
Sep 25, 2015 06:14 PM