As title states, can I fit 19x9.5 +35 on my 2004 MDX? I have the oem fender kit and want the wheels to be pretty flush to it, if not stick out a little for an aggressive look. Also, for tires, 255/50/19 should be fine right? or should I go a bit wider.

Worst case scenario, I'll just got 19x8.5 +35.

Next question is gunmetal or flat black, this is going on my Sage Brush Pearl. I'm leaning towards flat black.

 

You probably can fit 9.5" on your MDX, but honestly 19 x 8.5" is the best fit and look. I have 19 x 8.5" with 35 offset on 255/50/19s and they fit perfect. I don't have the fender kit, but it'll look great for sure. Here's my MDX:

 

Thanks, I looked at an old thread with your pictures and decided to go that route...19x8.5 +35. Now i just need to decided on tires.

 

That's one thing I don't like about 19s - the choice of tires. 20s have wayyy more choices and because of this, they are ironically less expensive.

You might want to price 19s versus 20s...in the long run, 20s may be cheaper.