AcuraZine - Acura Enthusiast Community

AcuraZine - Acura Enthusiast Community (https://acurazine.com/forums/)
-   3G RDX (2019+) (https://acurazine.com/forums/3g-rdx-2019-454/)
-   -   savagegeese 2019 Acura RDX Review | The Best Acura in 15 Years (https://acurazine.com/forums/3g-rdx-2019-454/savagegeese-2019-acura-rdx-review-%7C-best-acura-15-years-976939/)

crxb 02-04-2019 09:06 AM

savagegeese 2019 Acura RDX Review | The Best Acura in 15 Years
 
savagegeese RDX Review


Sounds 02-04-2019 09:30 AM

Where is that blue light coming from? I kinda like it.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...d2292f5eff.png

JB in AZ 02-04-2019 09:56 AM

I have never seen a review from this person. It is a fairly thorough review. He never mentioned which package he was reviewing, other than it had SH-AWD, unless I missed it.

I disagree with his comments on the true-touch pad, however. Did this guy do a review on a Lexus with their awful touch pad/cursor? Just try to use that one while driving. Enough said.

Thanks for posting this review. I enjoyed it.

MI-RDX 02-04-2019 10:14 AM

One point he made that I 100% agree with is a 10-speed trans is a bit much for this platform. The engine has more than enough torque/hp that an 8-speed (or maybe even a 7-speed) would make for a less 'busy' driving experience without having a significant, or any, downside on performance - although it may have a slight impact on mileage. This is something I mentioned to my sales rep on the first test drive.

cm2021 02-04-2019 11:20 AM


Originally Posted by JB in AZ (Post 16376816)
I have never seen a review from this person. It is a fairly thorough review. He never mentioned which package he was reviewing, other than it had SH-AWD, unless I missed it.

I disagree with his comments on the true-touch pad, however. Did this guy do a review on a Lexus with their awful touch pad/cursor? Just try to use that one while driving. Enough said.

Thanks for posting this review. I enjoyed it.

It's an Advance based on the wood trim, HUD, and price.

TheLevelOne 02-04-2019 11:47 AM


Originally Posted by Sounds (Post 16376793)
Where is that blue light coming from? I kinda like it.

White LEDs in my Advance. I think he has external blue lighting to get that effect in his shop. Don't think this has the stock Advance wheels on it either. I find the outside exterior/interior shots he used could use better lighting overall.

Regards -------------------------

Sounds 02-04-2019 11:49 AM


Originally Posted by TheLevelOne (Post 16376902)
I think he has external blue lighting to get that effect in his shop.

I think you're right. I thought it was new ambient lighting and I got excited. ;)


Tom2 02-04-2019 12:01 PM

Good review overall, but no mention of the navigation shortcomings (no ability to manually zoom, no address book, etc...)

Njbrandon 02-04-2019 12:41 PM


Originally Posted by Sounds (Post 16376905)
I think you're right. I thought it was new ambient lighting and I got excited. ;)

Didn't you hear V1.1.2 brings configurable LEDs ... haha j/K

JB in AZ 02-04-2019 01:04 PM


Originally Posted by cm2021 (Post 16376883)
It's an Advance based on the wood trim, HUD, and price.

Right, I knew which package it was, it's just that he didn't mention it...most other video reviews I have seen mention this, and the differences between the available "packages". I guess this was my point.

JAB00 02-04-2019 01:06 PM


Originally Posted by JB in AZ (Post 16376816)
I have never seen a review from this person. It is a fairly thorough review. He never mentioned which package he was reviewing, other than it had SH-AWD, unless I missed it.

I disagree with his comments on the true-touch pad, however. Did this guy do a review on a Lexus with their awful touch pad/cursor? Just try to use that one while driving. Enough said.

Thanks for posting this review. I enjoyed it.

I think it's an Advanced. However those wheels aren't standard on the Advance trim. The stock wheels are very plain. Those look like 20 inch wheels that one sees on the A-Spec. If the Advance came with wheels like this I probably would have picked it in black over my A Spec RDX.

R J Poseidon 6 02-04-2019 01:20 PM


Originally Posted by JAB00 (Post 16376949)
I think it's an Advanced. However those wheels aren't standard on the Advance trim. The stock wheels are very plain. Those look like 20 inch wheels that one sees on the A-Spec. If the Advance came with wheels like this I probably would have picked it in black over my A Spec RDX.

I believe these are the Tech 19's painted black.

I have them on my MDX:​​​​​​​

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...cb8c591c54.jpg

RDX10 02-04-2019 08:00 PM


Originally Posted by crxb (Post 16376785)

I agree with him. This definitely is the best Acura in at least 15 years. It's exciting because it is a precursor for what is to come!


Originally Posted by JB in AZ (Post 16376816)
I have never seen a review from this person. It is a fairly thorough review. He never mentioned which package he was reviewing, other than it had SH-AWD, unless I missed it.

I disagree with his comments on the true-touch pad, however. Did this guy do a review on a Lexus with their awful touch pad/cursor? Just try to use that one while driving. Enough said.

Thanks for posting this review. I enjoyed it.

This is Savage Geese, I've seen MANY of his reviews. He's actually one of my favorites. He's very thorough and more than that he's also very fair and unbiased. He also tends to throw in a little bit of dry humor which I appreciate.


Originally Posted by JAB00 (Post 16376949)
I think it's an Advanced. However those wheels aren't standard on the Advance trim. The stock wheels are very plain. Those look like 20 inch wheels that one sees on the A-Spec. If the Advance came with wheels like this I probably would have picked it in black over my A Spec RDX.

This is definitely an advanced packaged RDX but those are not A-Spec wheels. Those are accessory 20" wheels. IMO these look good but the A-Sepc wheels look the best. Definitely better than any wheels Acura or Honda has made in at least a decade. Unfortunately these accessory wheels cost like $3500!!! So not an affordable update by Acura standards.

MrJames 02-04-2019 09:39 PM

Wheels are the 19" glint black alloy wheels that are shown as a $2,000 option on the build page. Notice more Advance reviews using accessory wheels now. Acura seems to have gotten the hint that stock Advance wheels are horrendous.

Tony Pac 02-04-2019 10:18 PM

I watch his reviews and he is pretty well known.

But this was his best car review...In terms of production cost details and attention to detail = Amazing!

I can't wait for TLX with similar features.

GW208 02-04-2019 11:04 PM


Originally Posted by JB in AZ (Post 16376816)
I have never seen a review from this person. It is a fairly thorough review. He never mentioned which package he was reviewing, other than it had SH-AWD, unless I missed it.

I enjoyed the review also JB but did you notice the oil sample bottle at 3:30 in the video, what's up with that? Maybe I've just been reading the CRV forum too much but was that some kind of under the radar dig at Honda or something?

knhellesky 02-04-2019 11:09 PM


Originally Posted by Sounds (Post 16376905)
I think you're right. I thought it was new ambient lighting and I got excited. ;)

So...did this review convince you to jump on the RDX yet Sounds?

RDX10 02-05-2019 01:16 AM


Originally Posted by MrJames (Post 16377304)
Wheels are the 19" glint black alloy wheels that are shown as a $2,000 option on the build page. Notice more Advance reviews using accessory wheels now. Acura seems to have gotten the hint that stock Advance wheels are horrendous.

Whoops sorry thought they were 20's. I recall someone saying they were $3500. Canadian prices maybe?

Ok so I now see what my mistake was. These wheels are $2700 here in Canada and they have a wheel that goes for a whopping $3900!!!!!!!!!! I've never seen this wheel before.

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...8274f7d66c.jpg



Originally Posted by GW208 (Post 16377331)
I enjoyed the review also JB but did you notice the oil sample bottle at 3:30 in the video, what's up with that? Maybe I've just been reading the CRV forum too much but was that some kind of under the radar dig at Honda or something?

I did notice that too lol. He's very tongue in cheek like that. It is definitely is a dig at Honda for the 1.5T oil dilution problems. But I'm surprised he never said anything about it.

pcmcia 02-05-2019 02:55 AM

Anyone concerned about rusting? From the video, I can see a few parts of the undercarriage seems to be rusting already. I think he always half jokingly mentioned the knuckle is already rusting at 14:55. What are other part seems to have rust on them? Will this be a problem long term? Thanks!

Midnight Mystery 02-05-2019 04:18 AM

Best Acura in 15 years? That's a reach, but ok.

Stew4HD 02-05-2019 06:23 AM


Originally Posted by pcmcia (Post 16377376)
Anyone concerned about rusting? From the video, I can see a few parts of the undercarriage seems to be rusting already. I think he always half jokingly mentioned the knuckle is already rusting at 14:55. What are other part seems to have rust on them? Will this be a problem long term? Thanks!

There are some parts under there that are not painted and do have a layer of rust on them. I saw the same thing in past Acuras too. I was told by Acura's service department that there is nothing to worry about with those particular parts..

RDX10 02-05-2019 06:43 AM


Originally Posted by Stew4HD (Post 16377396)
There are some parts under there that are not painted and do have a layer of rust on them. I saw the same thing in past Acuras too. I was told by Acura's service department that there is nothing to worry about with those particular parts..

The rust is usually a micro layer thick on parts like those. Think about it in terms of your brake rotors rusting when you wash the car and don't drive it after. It's just surface rust and totally normal. Won't damage anything or go very deep.

RDX10 02-05-2019 06:44 AM


Originally Posted by Midnight Mystery (Post 16377385)
Best Acura in 15 years? That's a reach, but ok.

Why isn't it?

Tom2 02-05-2019 07:05 AM


Originally Posted by Midnight Mystery (Post 16377385)
Best Acura in 15 years? That's a reach, but ok.

Acura really hasn't made many good cars in the last 15 years, so I can't say he's wrong.

Tom2 02-05-2019 07:07 AM


Originally Posted by pcmcia (Post 16377376)
Anyone concerned about rusting? From the video, I can see a few parts of the undercarriage seems to be rusting already. I think he always half jokingly mentioned the knuckle is already rusting at 14:55. What are other part seems to have rust on them? Will this be a problem long term? Thanks!

From what I saw, it's just surface rust. Happens to every car that gets driven on salty roads. I wouldn't worry too much about it...

Dereileak 02-05-2019 07:22 AM


Originally Posted by pcmcia (Post 16377376)
Anyone concerned about rusting? From the video, I can see a few parts of the undercarriage seems to be rusting already. I think he always half jokingly mentioned the knuckle is already rusting at 14:55. What are other part seems to have rust on them? Will this be a problem long term? Thanks!

go to a dealer (any brand) and look under a new car that has been on the lot awhile, every car will get this, especially if you live in the rust belt or near the ocean, it’s normal

acuraada 02-05-2019 08:18 AM

I like this review quite a bit. Very detailed and covering stuff such as rev match and suspension details. His comments on the touchpad are not far off but just like other interface out there, you get used to it.

I have been an Acura fan since the Legends and Integras, I agree that this RDX is one of the best vehicle they have put out in a long time.

Tony Pac 02-05-2019 08:24 AM

He is not the first one saying that...one of my buddies is looking for a suv and he tested a few vehicles and he told me that RDX is definitely in his top 3.

R J Poseidon 6 02-05-2019 08:53 AM


Originally Posted by Midnight Mystery (Post 16377385)
Best Acura in 15 years? That's a reach, but ok.


Originally Posted by RDX10 (Post 16377404)
Why isn't it?

I'd say it very well could be after the '03 CL Type-S. It's sick.

SebringSilver 02-05-2019 09:01 AM


Originally Posted by RDX10 (Post 16377404)
Why isn't it?

Because NSX.

R J Poseidon 6 02-05-2019 09:25 AM

Oof, very valid point. I do love the new NSX....
...same year though! lol

I wouldn't mind a non-hybrid rear-wheel drive one though........ :drag:

jesser916 02-05-2019 10:41 AM


Originally Posted by JB in AZ (Post 16376816)
I have never seen a review from this person. It is a fairly thorough review. He never mentioned which package he was reviewing, other than it had SH-AWD, unless I missed it.

I disagree with his comments on the true-touch pad, however. Did this guy do a review on a Lexus with their awful touch pad/cursor? Just try to use that one while driving. Enough said.

Thanks for posting this review. I enjoyed it.

I've seen a few reviews from this guy. He's pretty well known.

JB in AZ 02-05-2019 10:45 AM


Originally Posted by GW208 (Post 16377331)
I enjoyed the review also JB but did you notice the oil sample bottle at 3:30 in the video, what's up with that? Maybe I've just been reading the CRV forum too much but was that some kind of under the radar dig at Honda or something?

NO, I hadn't noticed it, but on viewing it again...WOW! LOL Very subtle, an oil sample bottle with the words "Fuel Dilution?" on it. Best "Easter egg" ever! Of course, no one in their right mind would put a bottle with a dirty used oil sample in the console of their new RDX, but it is an obvious reference to Honda's 1.5L, which BTW was what I traded in for the RDX. FWIW, in 15,500 miles I never had any gas smell or rising oil levels.

JB in AZ 02-05-2019 10:48 AM


Originally Posted by jesser916 (Post 16377574)
I've seen a few reviews from this guy. He's pretty well known.

Hmm, next time I am thinking about a new car, I will look for his reviews! I have seen "Alex on Autos", and Redline, and a few others, but this is the first I've seen of Savage Geese.

Sounds 02-05-2019 10:48 AM


Originally Posted by knhellesky (Post 16377334)
So...did this review convince you to jump on the RDX yet Sounds?

I'm pretty darn close. I'm working on getting pricing from dealers as we type. :) How ''bout you?

2019RDX 02-05-2019 11:17 AM

My older brother has owned all three generations of the RDX. Hands down he says this is the best, but considering the price it could and should be better. Believe it or not, he buys his cars based on the sound systems more than anything else. I buy mine based on looks and engine options.

knhellesky 02-05-2019 02:48 PM


Originally Posted by Sounds (Post 16377583)
I'm pretty darn close. I'm working on getting pricing from dealers as we type. :) How ''bout you?

Sadly still on the fence. I got some time though...since I didn't really plan on getting a new vehicle til after summer. Or maybe I can wait and hope that the next years model will have folding mirrors and better wheels for the Advance trim. :wish:

Midnight Mystery 02-05-2019 03:40 PM


Originally Posted by RDX10 (Post 16377404)
Why isn't it?


Acura was making it's best cars 10 years ago.. So, the best Acura since the 3G TL, 2G RL, 1G TSX, 1G RDX, 2G MDX, 1G NSX, so on...


But it's the first good effort Acura has made in 5-10 years... It may be better becsuse it's more modern, but compared to what Acuta was producing from 2003-2008, it isn't as cutting edge, but still better than almost everything else...

Sounds 02-05-2019 03:55 PM


Originally Posted by knhellesky (Post 16377754)
Sadly still on the fence. I got some time though...since I didn't really plan on getting a new vehicle til after summer. Or maybe I can wait and hope that the next years model will have folding mirrors and better wheels for the Advance trim. :wish:

Sounds like a smart plan. :)

acuraada 02-05-2019 07:16 PM


Originally Posted by 2019RDX (Post 16377606)
My older brother has owned all three generations of the RDX. Hands down he says this is the best, but considering the price it could and should be better. Believe it or not, he buys his cars based on the sound systems more than anything else. I buy mine based on looks and engine options.

if the decision is based on sound system, then he should def buy the 2019 RDX. There is nothing else better than the 16 speaker ELS 3D surround system in this price range (+-10k)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:20 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands