|
How quiet is the 2018 TLX on the highway?
2018 acura tlx. How quiet is it?
|
how can we relay that to you?
how can we describe how quiet a car is? not over text, we cant. Go to your local dealer and test drive one on the freeway |
THe only way to do this is if a current owner of an '18 TLX downloads an app that monitors/measures DB
then the tester would notate different decibels during different conditions - start up (windows closed) - idle (windows closed) - steady state driving (windows closed) - acceleration (windows closed) then do it all over again with the windows open then do it all over again with A/C engaged |
It's quieter than any previous Honda/Acura product, that's for sure. I'd say it's on par with a Lexus ES. A little bit less wind noise, a little bit more road noise (especially if you get the larger wheels).
|
Originally Posted by Johns54
(Post 16157511)
2018 acura tlx. How quiet is it?
The question is if it remains quiet after 2, 3 years I am not sure. I've only driven ones with less than 1000 miles. But it's definitely quieter than any Acuras before. |
Pretty quiet. Way ahead of the 4g TL in that department. Same with ride quality. The 2 things i hated in the 4g TL
|
If you've driven previous Hondas/Acuras which did pretty poorly with noise, and hashness, this is a completely different animal. Targeting N,V,H was a priority of theirs, and it really showed.
The only way you could see that for yourself though is to just go for a test drive. |
It was a nice upgrade in quietness and ride quality from my 2013 Accord EX-L. We have a 2016 CRV and it's a serious upgrade from that!
It may not be at the Lexus level but it's good for a Honda product. |
TLX is quieter than BMW etc... I mean, to get quiter than TLX (which is excellent in that regard) you'd have to step up to something like a high end Mercedes with the double pain glass. Last time I looked those went for about $150K?
Bear in mind that +3 dB difference is DOUBLE the noise since it's a logarithmic scale. So, if some of the cars are listed as only 2 db higher than the TLX, it's actually significantly louder. https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...d9e2f3047f.jpg
Originally Posted by CheeseyPoofs McNut
(Post 16158108)
It was a nice upgrade in quietness and ride quality from my 2013 Accord EX-L. We have a 2016 CRV and it's a serious upgrade from that!
It may not be at the Lexus level but it's good for a Honda product. |
Originally Posted by Christopher.
(Post 16158187)
TLX is quieter than BMW etc... I mean, to get quiter than TLX (which is excellent in that regard) you'd have to step up to something like a high end Mercedes with the double pain glass. Last time I looked those went for about $150K?
Bear in mind that +3 dB difference is DOUBLE the noise since it's a logarithmic scale. So, if some of the cars are listed as only 2 db higher than the TLX, it's actually significantly louder. https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...d9e2f3047f.jpg |
Originally Posted by hadokenuh
(Post 16158194)
The BMW 3 series is not known for quietness. The BMW 5 series is quiet. I said "Lexus and BMW 5 series" in my post.
https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...35b7e92b67.jpg The reason I used that chart, instead of one for a 5 series, is, that it was tedious going through reviews looking for them because most of the reviews do not include that chart, and I presume that the 7 series BMW is not inferior to the 5 series, in terms of luxury? And notice, as I said previously - you have to step up to a ~$100,000 Mercedes to reach superior road noise levels lower than the TLX. |
Originally Posted by Christopher.
(Post 16158187)
Huh? Actually Lexus is up to the TLX level - both tested at 67 db @70 MPH in Car & Driver test results for RX350 and RX450 - also, cars.com said this about the Lexus ES 350: "Where the ES 350 could improve is its noise level. The way the tires smack the road is loud and intrusive for a luxury car, and there’s off-putting road noise as the tires hum at highway speeds." Certainly not the case for the Acura TLX! |
Originally Posted by CheeseyPoofs McNut
(Post 16158238)
I'll admit it's been a few years since I've been in a Lexus - but that's always been a strong point for them. Frankly I'm a bit leery of the noise tests - so many variables involved - how does C&D make sure all the conditions are homogeneous for every car?
Here is some further reading: How does C/D Test Cars? From that link: "Sound Level Vehicle noise that makes its way into the passenger compartment can greatly affect a car's character. To measure it, we use a hand-held Brüel & Kjær Type 2236 sound-level meter. First, we use the VBOX to determine the speedometer reading that corresponds to a true 70 mph. Then we position the microphone close to the driver's right ear and measure the sound at idle, at full throttle, and when cruising at 70 mph. Sound level is measured in decibels with the A-weighting scale (dBA), and we average the sound level in two directions to minimize the effect of wind. And as you'd expect, the higher the number, the louder the noise." Pretty solid test method I'd say? |
Since we are comparing the 5 series; lets add the RLX.
Originally Posted by RLX-SPORT-HYBRID
Good Morning! I downloaded a db measuring app on my phone this morning and tested it to see what I showed. Here is what I saw:
|
Originally Posted by Christopher.
(Post 16158201)
Well, is the 5 series better than the 7 series? Because the 7 series is slightly inferior to the TLX :
https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...35b7e92b67.jpg The reason I used that chart, instead of one for a 5 series, is, that it was tedious going through reviews looking for them because most of the reviews do not include that chart, and I presume that the 7 series BMW is not inferior to the 5 series, in terms of luxury? And notice, as I said previously - you have to step up to a ~$100,000 Mercedes to reach superior road noise levels lower than the TLX. Speaking of the test numbers, I just want to point out that the dBA is not telling everything. What we don't want to hear is road/wind/tire noise. What we do want is engine/exhausted noise, well at least some of us here. So the dBA reading might also include the engine noise ... |
Originally Posted by justnspace
(Post 16158261)
Since we are comparing the 5 series; lets add the RLX.
|
I must say that I am fascinated that the V6 is 1db quieter than the 4. It would be easy to conclude that it just revs lower. But at 60mph at 1500 or 2000rpm, you would be hard pressed to notice a difference.
Proof that V6 *are* smoother? like if any proof was needed. Or maybe different tires? Possible too. Mine is incredibly butter smooth and the ride is great. At least the poor Good Year tires give that. |
I'm @ around 70,000 miles on mine and it still rides quiet. My 3G TL was a rattle-fest by this time, but the TLX may have one intermittent buzz in it somewhere that currently I don't hear. I'm also on my 2nd set of tires which is a different brand/model than the first set that came with the car (both sets were touring tires). Even though I despise Acura for the transmission, the 2 best qualities about this car have been the highway mileage (just got 36-38 mpg on a drive from Dallas to Nashville and back) and the road noise.
|
2yrs and 36k miles later, my TLX is still quiet. The only thing making it loud are the shitty Bridgestone tires will I'll be getting rid of soon.
|
It's VERY quiet! And I love it... :-)
One of the reasons why I chose the 2018 TLX Elite SH-AWD A-Spec was because of how quiet it was. OK, it was not any scientific test but when I compared my test drive with the TLX A-Spec to the other test drives that I did with the MB C300, Volvo V90, Volvo XC60, Audi Allroad, Audi Q5.... none of them compared to the quietness of the TLX A-Spec. I have had the car for 2 months now and I just love it more and more! :-) |
Originally Posted by hadokenuh
(Post 16158304)
I haven't driven the 7 series before so I don't know but like you said I also presume the 7 is not inferior to the 5. I am very surprised with the numbers vs. the TLX. I thought the TLX is very quiet but am surprised that it even beats the 7.
Speaking of the test numbers, I just want to point out that the dBA is not telling everything. What we don't want to hear is road/wind/tire noise. What we do want is engine/exhausted noise, well at least some of us here. So the dBA reading might also include the engine noise ... In my experience BMW’s are not exactly known for being quiet and moreover known as the “drivers machine” or something like that. So just because the TLX is quieter than a BMW really doesn’t say much. Furthermore doesn’t the A-spec pump in artificial engine noise or is that only in certain modes? How does that affect test results? With all that said, I think Acura put a lot of effort with their latest crop of vehicles and therefore I am not surprised that they are getting much quieter. Sidenote: I really really want to ride in something like a rolly royce or bentley mulsanne, I want to know what it feels like to ride in a nearly silent car. |
Originally Posted by RDX10
(Post 16158657)
In my experience BMW’s are not exactly known for being quiet and moreover known as the “drivers machine” or something like that. So just because the TLX is quieter than a BMW really doesn’t say much. Furthermore doesn’t the A-spec pump in artificial engine noise or is that only in certain modes? How does that affect test results? With all that said, I think Acura put a lot of effort with their latest crop of vehicles and therefore I am not surprised that they are getting much quieter. Sidenote: I really really want to ride in something like a rolly royce or bentley mulsanne, I want to know what it feels like to ride in a nearly silent car. |
Originally Posted by Nexx
(Post 16158685)
stop, seriously, just stop. i get it. you love your Kia.... but stop doing everything you can in your soul to discredit the TLX.
How about you stop. We get it, you sell Acuras. I don’t own a Kia and also maybe you can’t read properly but nowehere did I discredit the TLX, infact I even said Acura is really trying hard and I’m not surprised they are so quiet. So kindly fuck off and go bug someone else. |
Originally Posted by RDX10
(Post 16158689)
How about you stop. We get it, you sell Acuras. I don’t own a Kia and also maybe you can’t read properly but nowehere did I discredit the TLX, infact I even said Acura is really trying hard and I’m not surprised they are so quiet. So kindly fuck off and go bug someone else. |
Originally Posted by Nexx
(Post 16158694)
wow so hateful. speaks volumes.
|
Originally Posted by RDX10
(Post 16158699)
Cool story. bye now.
|
uhhh, fellas..... back on topic of DB's... please.
i'm dying for some one to download the DB app on android or iOS to replicate the RLX test. ya know, something other than magazines.... i'll do it for my 2006 TL and then we can compare! |
Tires, weather conditions, road conditions, etc etc., all play a factor into a reading. There's no way to scientifically quantify how quiet a ride is compared to another ride unless you compare them in lab situation. I'm sure C&D does their best but it's not science, simply a point of reference.
All that said - the TLX is pretty quiet by my ears! |
I have a loud exhaust. i'm fully expecting it to be louder than any other car. LOL
|
Originally Posted by justnspace
(Post 16158808)
uhhh, fellas..... back on topic of DB's... please.
i'm dying for some one to download the DB app on android or iOS to replicate the RLX test. ya know, something other than magazines.... i'll do it for my 2006 TL and then we can compare! I was on topic. You saying you want further results not from a magazine is also “discrediting the TLX” apparently. But in all seriousness, I am with you 100% and would love to see how quiet the RLX is because apparently it’s supposed to be super quiet. Also like cheesey was saying, tires tires tires. I notice enormous differences in my cars whenever I swap out tires. It’s funny how we just get accustomed to the loud tires as they wear without realizing it but then a swap to new tires produces a massive difference to my ears. This is just a long way of saying I read the RLX has special rims that are supposed to reduce wind noise so I’d love to see how effective they really are. |
Originally Posted by RDX10
(Post 16158657)
In my experience BMW’s are not exactly known for being quiet and moreover known as the “drivers machine” or something like that. So just because the TLX is quieter than a BMW really doesn’t say much. Furthermore doesn’t the A-spec pump in artificial engine noise or is that only in certain modes? How does that affect test results? With all that said, I think Acura put a lot of effort with their latest crop of vehicles and therefore I am not surprised that they are getting much quieter. Sidenote: I really really want to ride in something like a rolly royce or bentley mulsanne, I want to know what it feels like to ride in a nearly silent car. Believe it or not, I've been in and driven (briefly) a Roll Royce Phantom. I think it was a 2013 model. It was dead silent and smooth even on broken street. It accelerated very quickly too. Kind of like the top of the line Lexus except it's much better in every way. |
This is just a long way of saying I read the RLX has special rims that are supposed to reduce wind noise so I’d love to see how effective they really are |
you can see it here:
Originally Posted by LimeLight
In an effort to reduce cabin/road noise, Acura uses a polypropylene Helmholtz resonator that encircles the center portion of the inside of the wheel - this is supposed to significantly lower middle frequency noise.
|
Originally Posted by hadokenuh
(Post 16158945)
I had a 2008 528i and my family currently has a 2013 535i. They are both very well insulated against wind/tire/road noise. Engine noise is what makes it "noisy". The inline 6 engine is very smooth as I remember.
Believe it or not, I've been in and driven (briefly) a Roll Royce Phantom. I think it was a 2013 model. It was dead silent and smooth even on broken street. It accelerated very quickly too. Kind of like the top of the line Lexus except it's much better in every way. Yes exactly! This was what I was trying to say earlier but then the rabid fanbois came in and started bitching as usual. My comment about BMW’s being the “drivers machine” was to imply that the noise it makes is intended to enhance the drive, be it engine or exhaust noise so I don’t personally associate BMW’s with quiet. Oh my god that’s so cool that you got to drive a rolls! Literally a goal of mine is to be able to do that someday (not to own, but at least drive/ride in one), I am so curious to know what it feels like. I’ve been in quieter “mainstream” luxury vehicles and I’m sure that doesn’t hold a candle to a rolls royce so I want to experience the odd sensation of being in a practically silent car. I wonder if I’d get irritated after a short while.
Originally Posted by justnspace
(Post 16158949)
yes, the ILX and RLX has a band wrapped around the barrel of the wheel. the band has holes in it.I believe the holes emit noise (frequency) to cancel out other noises (frequencies)
|
I enjoy it too. Some may not agree with my outspoken personality (idgaf), But I really love cars and all the engineering feats that go into making a car! thus why I'm everywhere on the forums, because I like to learn.
I too, thought it was a wheel design, as thats what Acura led me to believe, until someone posted that picture in the RLX forums. |
Originally Posted by justnspace
(Post 16158982)
I enjoy it too. Some may not agree with my outspoken personality (idgaf), But I really love cars and all the engineering feats that go into making a car! thus why I'm everywhere on the forums, because I like to learn.
I too, thought it was a wheel design, as thats what Acura led me to believe, until someone posted that picture in the RLX forums. Lol I’m not ashamed to state that I am obsessed with AWD systems. Spent 2 weeks reading and watching videos on SH-AWD when I first learned about it and totally agree, I am fascinated with how cars work and can spend hours learning about simple things. |
if you understand how something works, you can operate it correctly and clean/service it correctly!!
I wonder about fluid mechanics a lot and how it affects transmissions and other parts of the car! I wonder if the TLX would benefit from different fluid? as Acura and other tend to skip over that and blame it on other things |
Originally Posted by RDX10
(Post 16158939)
I was on topic. You saying you want further results not from a magazine is also “discrediting the TLX” apparently. But in all seriousness, I am with you 100% and would love to see how quiet the RLX is because apparently it’s supposed to be super quiet. Also like cheesey was saying, tires tires tires. I notice enormous differences in my cars whenever I swap out tires. It’s funny how we just get accustomed to the loud tires as they wear without realizing it but then a swap to new tires produces a massive difference to my ears. This is just a long way of saying I read the RLX has special rims that are supposed to reduce wind noise so I’d love to see how effective they really are. |
Another thing, I know the TLX was the first Acura to use acoustic foam. Not sure if any of the newer models use them now.
|
Where is the acoustic foam placed? in the body panels or in the interior?
|
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:19 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands