AcuraZine - Acura Enthusiast Community

AcuraZine - Acura Enthusiast Community (https://acurazine.com/forums/)
-   Car Talk (https://acurazine.com/forums/car-talk-5/)
-   -   The Jetta has been living a double life (https://acurazine.com/forums/car-talk-5/jetta-has-been-living-double-life-973946/)

Predatorbird 10-20-2018 08:06 AM


Originally Posted by oonowindoo (Post 16316367)
You are only 50% correct. It is a plug and play kinda thing and you can remove it when you visit dealership.. but IF you blow up your engine and you want the dealership to fix it under warranty, they will tell you that you had aftermarket tuning software.
Some people say JB4 and others are 100% detectable if the dealer runs a log and some say they never had any issues. So i guess it depends on the dealer, if they want to find it, they will.

This is correct. If you were to blow the engine, the dealer can investigate further than just the flash count and see you were running more boost. I raced my friend the other day with a manual GTI with JB4. From a roll, he got the initial jump and i slowly pulled on him. The JB4 is a pretty serious piggy-back setup that will run with OTS tunes.

kurtatx 10-20-2018 09:23 AM


Originally Posted by oonowindoo (Post 16316367)
You are only 50% correct. It is a plug and play kinda thing and you can remove it when you visit dealership.. but IF you blow up your engine and you want the dealership to fix it under warranty, they will tell you that you had aftermarket tuning software.
Some people say JB4 and others are 100% detectable if the dealer runs a log and some say they never had any issues. So i guess it depends on the dealer, if they want to find it, they will.

I know I have read in multiple places that the dealership can see if you tune. Some sort of encryption is broken or something.

Flipster23 10-20-2018 02:45 PM

Adam, CTs-V is on my list along with scat pack, but then I’ve been eyeing Lifted Tundras, and other shit. But I really need a daily.

1killercls 10-22-2018 08:41 AM


Originally Posted by kurtatx (Post 16316589)
I know I have read in multiple places that the dealership can see if you tune. Some sort of encryption is broken or something.

Correctomundo. Exactly why no tune on my Audi until February 2019. Then? Stage 2. :)

kurtatx 10-22-2018 09:09 AM


Originally Posted by 1killercls (Post 16317246)
Correctomundo. Exactly why no tune on my Audi until February 2019. Then? Stage 2. :)

Definitely. I have a while to wait before I can tune the S4 but I am definitely looking forward to it.

TylerT 10-22-2018 09:31 AM

S4s are such good rounded cars from factory. I'm sure you're enjoying the hell out of it.

Is the turbo easily accessible in these cars? I know they aren't top mounted, but are they under the IM? Behind the motor?

TacoBello 10-22-2018 09:38 AM

Yes, except for the terrible understeering Audi’s face when pushed through a corner. There’s no getting around the engine being so far forward in their cars. The sport diff helps, but doesn’t eliminate it. FWD characteristics in a car that is anything but.

kurtatx 10-22-2018 09:42 AM


Originally Posted by TylerT (Post 16317301)
S4s are such good rounded cars from factory. I'm sure you're enjoying the hell out of it.

Is the turbo easily accessible in these cars? I know they aren't top mounted, but are they under the IM? Behind the motor?

They're in the V in the V6.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...401328f5f4.jpg

TylerT 10-22-2018 09:48 AM


Originally Posted by TacoBello (Post 16317321)
Yes, except for the terrible understeering Audi’s face when pushed through a corner. There’s no getting around the engine being so far forward in their cars. The sport diff helps, but doesn’t eliminate it. FWD characteristics in a car that is anything but.

Yeah because, we're all looking for oversteer in our everyday commutes :rofl:

A few years back at an autocross event, I rode in a B8 S4 with a sport differential and it had no problems with some lift off oversteer / rotation. It wasn't as quick as my S2000, but it certainly wasn't far behind - like any Audi, you definitely need to adapt your driving style ... it'll never be like a knife edge M3 / something with RWD / LSD. :co:

I feel like most owners who decide on actually buying an S4, they want a comfortable highway rocket .. you know, where you spend 99% of your time.


rockstar143 10-22-2018 09:50 AM

:tomato:
Adam's post sounded like someone that read a lot of online reviews on it and didn't have a lot of Audi experience.
I am not sure about all that stuff but I can tell you I am pretty sure my A3 would handle exceptionally well around curves...oddly enough.

TylerT 10-22-2018 09:52 AM


Originally Posted by kurtatx (Post 16317326)

Well, that's convenient AF :rofl:

That doesn't not seem hard to replace or modify.

TacoBello 10-22-2018 10:26 AM


Originally Posted by rockstar143 (Post 16317343)
:tomato:
Adam's post sounded like someone that read a lot of online reviews on it and didn't have a lot of Audi experience.
I am not sure about all that stuff but I can tell you I am pretty sure my A3 would handle exceptionally well around curves...oddly enough.

yeah, so?! :tomato: :rofl:

Let me state for the record I am a big fan of the S4. Of any S4, for that matter. But let’s not pretend like it is God’s Gift to the automotive world. It does have some inherent short comings, like any vehicle does. I’ve never been one about all out speed... but I am crazy about my corners. And the constant reviews do make me ponder if I’ll ultimately be happy with it. I still need some much needed seat time before I decide one way or another.

Not sure how relevant it is comparing the A3 to the S4, though. Seems like an apples to oranges comparison. For one, the engine is smaller and lighter, making its effects on handling likely lower than an engine with two extra cylinders.

It’s not surprising more and more folk are switching from Acuras to Audis these days... they seem like the natural progression. The Audis are nicer in pretty much every regard and seem to keep the same handling characteristics that Acuras are known for. Audis are the upscale Acuras that Acura never built :rofl:

TylerT 10-22-2018 10:29 AM


Originally Posted by TacoBello (Post 16317415)


yeah, so?! :tomato: :rofl:

Let me state for the record I am a big fan of the S4. Of any S4, for that matter. But let’s not pretend like it is God’s Gift to the automotive world. It does have some inherent short comings, like any vehicle does. I’ve never been one about all out speed... but I am crazy about my corners. And the constant reviews do make me ponder if I’ll ultimately be happy with it. I still need some much needed seat time before I decide one way or another.

Not sure how relevant it is comparing the A3 to the S4, though. Seems like an apples to oranges comparison. For one, the engine is smaller and lighter, making its effects on handling likely lower than an engine with two extra cylinders.

It’s not surprising more and more folk are switching from Acura’s to Audi’s these days... they seem like the natural progression. The Audi’s are nicer in pretty much every regard and seem to keep the same handling characteristics that Acura’s are known for. Audi’s are the upscale Acura’s that Acura never built :rofl:

Lets not forget Audi's actually make power / torque .... Acuras never did that. :rofl:

rockstar143 10-22-2018 10:31 AM

Yeah, probably not relevant...but my only experience has been the A3 and that S5.
The S5, at the time, felt like the best driving car all around that I had ever driven. I mean, this was a
few cars ago but still...it was amazing.

Go drive one, Adam...I know you will need to get that out of your system at some point and I agree...curves are
where it's at...which really makes it suck to live in FL.

TacoBello 10-22-2018 10:31 AM

That, and they actually have a sport line up. Acura gives you shitty Aspec badges that do nothing for the car besides make it look sporty and people throw their entire paychecks at them...

“springs are 1.3% stiffer”

“OMG this car is a rocket ship now!”

:tomato:

TylerT 10-22-2018 10:33 AM

I don't want to muddy up kurtax's thread too badly, but the big reason why Acura has fell so far behind is because they haven't introduced FI into their performance line up.

J's A3 with a downpipe & tune would make short work of a new TLX A-spec and it has far less displacement :tomato:

TacoBello 10-22-2018 10:39 AM

Hey, we are still whoring about Audis in here, so I say it’s fair game!

Not gonna lie... you guys have made me realize that I’m likely being too much of a tool about the handling thing. There’s no such thing as one vehicle that is great at everything. If I want a handling monster, I should just pick up another toy specifically for that. And the more I think of it... I’m far more capable pushing an understeering car than an overtseering one... I grew up driving all FWD cars. I would drive my TL harder through corners than I would my supercharged Miata or Nismo Z.

The S4 would still reign for daily purposes though. Ugh... now why won’t the right color/option package show up for sale?!

TylerT 10-22-2018 10:45 AM


Originally Posted by TacoBello (Post 16317438)
Hey, we are still whoring about Audis in here, so I say it’s fair game!

Not gonna lie... you guys have made me realize that I’m likely being too much of a tool about the handling thing. There’s no such thing as one vehicle that is great at everything. If I want a handling monster, I should just pick up another toy specifically for that. And the more I think of it... I’m far more capable pushing an understeering car than an overtseering one... I grew up driving all FWD cars. I would drive my TL harder through corners than I would my supercharged Miata or Nismo Z.

The S4 would still reign for daily purposes though. Ugh... now why won’t the right color/option package show up for sale?!

We all want a swiss army knife garage - a car for every occasional (Cough, J, cough).

I would love a track monster to accompany my highway missile / daily .... in due time.

oonowindoo 10-22-2018 11:32 AM


Originally Posted by kurtatx (Post 16316589)
I know I have read in multiple places that the dealership can see if you tune. Some sort of encryption is broken or something.

I dont know how but they could.

Also it is kinda obvious if they ran a log and saw either you revved higher than Un-tuned cars, or more boost or many other things that an un-tuned Automatic car would never do..

I personally would only do tuning after my warranty is up or if i dont give a shit about $$.

oonowindoo 10-22-2018 11:34 AM


Originally Posted by TylerT (Post 16317337)
Yeah because, we're all looking for oversteer in our everyday commutes :rofl:

A few years back at an autocross event, I rode in a B8 S4 with a sport differential and it had no problems with some lift off oversteer / rotation. It wasn't as quick as my S2000, but it certainly wasn't far behind - like any Audi, you definitely need to adapt your driving style ... it'll never be like a knife edge M3 / something with RWD / LSD. :co:

I feel like most owners who decide on actually buying an S4, they want a comfortable highway rocket .. you know, where you spend 99% of your time.

I drive like i am delivering tofu in the AE86 every morning on my freeway onramp :D

rockstar143 10-22-2018 11:37 AM

I'm just saying sometimes people that blog have ulterior motives or skewed opinions and are comparing sniper rifle stats...meaning sure, maybe one car does it slightly better...but doesn't mean the Audi isn't the car for you and still amazing to take through corners.

One car not checking all the boxes is literally the reason I have a small fleet. :tomato:

TacoBello 10-22-2018 11:42 AM

I’m starting to even debate the wait to tune thing. It’s increidbly rare for a power train to fail within the warranty period. And if it does, it’s usually a well known design problem that happens across numerous cars. The S4 doesn’t seem to have any of that.

so you wait four or five years for your warranty to expire before tuning... why? If the car still has warranty and fails, it’ll cost you just as much as if the car didn’t have warranty and fails. In essence, you’re fucked either way. I wouldn’t tune a brand new car, but shiiiet, if it’s three years sold, you more than likely don’t need to worry about engine failures. And with that... wouldn’t it be better to put more boost on an engine with lower mileage, as opposed to higher mileage?

We we act like warranty is the end all be all, but really, should it be?

TylerT 10-22-2018 11:48 AM

I didn't hesitate throwing double the whp over stock at 133,000 miles ...

Knock on wood, rods haven't come knocking yet :teef:

TylerT 10-22-2018 11:49 AM


Originally Posted by oonowindoo (Post 16317542)
I drive like i am delivering tofu in the AE86 every morning on my freeway onramp :D

:rofl:


rockstar143 10-22-2018 11:50 AM

I think that you should enjoy the car without a tune for a bit anyway because anticipation is half the fun and it'll mean more to you than if you tune the fuck out of it and then get used to the power anyway.
Plus, the reason people wait is to not void warranty on the rest of the stuff that might not get buggered by the tune in those first 3 or 4 years.

TacoBello 10-22-2018 12:02 PM

Stage 1 tunes are safe. Stage 2 is a bit more worrisome, but still pretty damn safe. It’s not like guys are beefing up their transmissions or rear diffs and stuff at stage 2. And again, what’s the difference? You rather dump 10k into rebuilding your car when it’s 5+ years old, or doing the same when it’s 2-3 years old? Most would argue putting that kind of money into a car that’s worth even less as it ages is not the best idea. Unless your name is TylerT :D but I think it’s evident there aren’t a lot of people like that around.

I agree with enjoying the car stock at first... but shit, waiting for or five years isn’t changing anything. It really is a mind fuck thing.

And again... S4 power trains and drive trains seem pretty stout. They aren’t grenading themselves like the STi engines used to. If raising boost is going to cause a failure, it’s going to happen either way and will have to be dealt with in either case anyway.

and you don’t lose your entire warranty. You lose it for whatever has been modified. In this case, yes, engine warranty is gone. There isn’t any evidence to suggest that even a stage 1 tune will cause the drivetrain to fail.

TylerT 10-22-2018 12:12 PM

Really depends on your generation ... but, Suburus aren't known for having stout drivetrains when the power is turned up. Reliable? Yes ... but not strong.

Audi's tend to be overengineered and maybe a tad less reliable ...but I'm coming a believer. They have pretty stout transmissions / differentials / engines that you can throw power at without much worry. :shrug:.

Hell, there's still 5cyl 3B / AAN engines rolling around over 200,000 miles running 25+ PSI on larger turbos than stock - I'm not really in a financial position to be looking for one, but they are tempting .. despite how ugly / old they are :teef:

oonowindoo 10-22-2018 12:13 PM


Originally Posted by TacoBello (Post 16317549)
I’m starting to even debate the wait to tune thing. It’s increidbly rare for a power train to fail within the warranty period. And if it does, it’s usually a well known design problem that happens across numerous cars. The S4 doesn’t seem to have any of that.

so you wait four or five years for your warranty to expire before tuning... why? If the car still has warranty and fails, it’ll cost you just as much as if the car didn’t have warranty and fails. In essence, you’re fucked either way. I wouldn’t tune a brand new car, but shiiiet, if it’s three years sold, you more than likely don’t need to worry about engine failures. And with that... wouldn’t it be better to put more boost on an engine with lower mileage, as opposed to higher mileage?

We we act like warranty is the end all be all, but really, should it be?

It is your car. if you are willing to take the risk, you just have to justify the purchase to yourself.

rockstar143 10-22-2018 12:14 PM

lol...
don't waste any more energy pretending you're convincing us...you already made up your mind! Get your damn manual S4 and stage 2 tune it, bro! We support you!

kurtatx 10-22-2018 12:38 PM


Originally Posted by rockstar143 (Post 16317576)
lol...
don't waste any more energy pretending you're convincing us...you already made up your mind! Get your damn manual S4 and stage 2 tune it, bro! We support you!

S club has candy

1killercls 10-22-2018 02:26 PM


Originally Posted by rockstar143 (Post 16317343)
:tomato:
Adam's post sounded like someone that read a lot of online reviews on it and didn't have a lot of Audi experience.
I am not sure about all that stuff but I can tell you I am pretty sure my A3 would handle exceptionally well around curves...oddly enough.

:werd:

1killercls 10-22-2018 02:30 PM


Originally Posted by TylerT (Post 16317555)
I didn't hesitate throwing double the whp over stock at 133,000 miles ...

Knock on wood, rods haven't come knocking yet :teef:

My B7 A4 2.oT had 117k when I sold it. It had a Stage one tune since 38k. Never burned oil, ran like a raped ape.

rockstar143 10-22-2018 02:40 PM

1killerrapedape
:O
you are allowed one name change, IIRC.

TacoBello 10-22-2018 03:47 PM


Originally Posted by rockstar143 (Post 16317576)
lol...
don't waste any more energy pretending you're convincing us...you already made up your mind! Get your damn manual S4 and stage 2 tune it, bro! We support you!

It's pretty much a done deal, hahaha. I just have to find the right one!!!

For DD purposes, I'll just keep it stage 1 with maybe some bolt ons. It'll be by far the most powerful car I've ever owned, even at that. I also don't want to start beefing everything else up along the way also...

Modding isn't the same for me anymore as it once was. I prefer the OEM+ route for myself more these days than anything else.

Getting old sucks :sad:

oonowindoo 10-22-2018 04:01 PM

At least you are OEM+. I am 100% OEM now and not only that, I actually put my front license plate on my new car, which is something i have not done since my CL days.....

Talk about getting old...

SamDoe1 10-22-2018 04:19 PM

Remember that you can get an APR+ stage 1 tune that will retain your factory warranty. By retain I mean it'll void the warranty but APR will pick up the tab if the motor/trans/diff blows up. It does cost more but probably a good safety net. I plan on getting that for the R next year especially because the factory warranty is 6/72 bumper to bumper.

As far as tune now vs later, I'd wait at least a year or 10k before tuning a car. That number is totally arbitrary but by 1yr/10k miles, many of the potential gremlins will have worked themselves out and the chance of future problems have diminished. Especially so in a place with actual seasons to go through one whole cycle of hot/cold before stressing the car even more. Also, you wait a year, spend a bit more, and BAM, new car.

If you're buying used then disregard all of what I just wrote and turn the dial up.

rockstar143 10-23-2018 07:29 AM

If APR will pick it up, why not just go for it and start enjoying that extra 90 ft/lb now?
I'm (bi-)curious.

SamDoe1 10-23-2018 08:55 AM


Originally Posted by rockstar143 (Post 16318210)
If APR will pick it up, why not just go for it and start enjoying that extra 90 ft/lb now?
I'm (bi-)curious.

I just want everything to go through the full shakedown through all the seasons before I take the plunge. As an engineer, I really have an appreciation for how all this stuff can go wrong lol. Plus I enjoy it as is now and I don't need the extra 90ftlb for the winter... :rofl:

rockstar143 10-23-2018 09:00 AM

True that...
although fire wood is heavy!

TylerT 10-23-2018 09:27 AM


Originally Posted by SamDoe1 (Post 16318266)
I just want everything to go through the full shakedown through all the seasons before I take the plunge. As an engineer, I really have an appreciation for how all this stuff can go wrong lol. Plus I enjoy it as is now and I don't need the extra 90ftlb for the winter... :rofl:

More like, as an engineer you'd APPRECIATE another 90ftlb of torque. :bitelip:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:25 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands