Jalopnik Rips Acura VTEC Commercial
So Jalopnik looked at the latest Acura commercial with the white TLX carving a canyon road while the salesman tells the guy he can feel the VTEC kick in. Now while I agree that this is horse crap, I disagree with the author when he says taking a test drive on canyon roads is bull. Living in So Cal, the 2 Acura dealers near me are with 5 minutes of Malibu Canyon and Muhlholland Drive. I've taken numerous test drives through there.
This Acura Ad Is So Crammed Full Of Horseshit I Can't Even |
Wow... I just read through his rant, and I think he has too much time on his hands. How do you, in a visual commercial, indicate how the drive feels? They need to do something to explain what's happening. The alternative would be "feel how fast it is"? I mean come on... it's a commercial.
And... I think he's overthinking what they are saying. You can definitely feel the VTEC kick in at 4500 RPM. I think that's what they are trying to convey... not that you can detect a minute change in valve timing. |
Okay.. C'mon guys.. Please tell me you don't see something wrong here:
https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...7beab7e9ce.gif Can people can have differing opinions about the car you bought? Also i think the commercial was tongue in cheek regarding the long-standing 'v-tec just kicked in yo' meme.. |
Originally Posted by thoiboi
(Post 15542030)
Okay.. C'mon guys.. Please tell me you don't see something wrong here:
https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/acurazi...7beab7e9ce.gif Can people can have differing opinions about the car you bought? Also i think the commercial was tongue in cheek regarding the long-standing 'v-tec just kicked in yo' meme.. I think the upshift surge might just be one of those faulty units? VTech, yo! |
Lol...I blame the marketing department.
|
Originally Posted by cu2wagon
(Post 15542039)
Admittedly I hadn't been keeping up with the TLX, but didn't they have a bunch of transmission problems?
I think the upshift surge might just be one of those faulty units? VTech, yo! "Its that kind of 'oh crap I need a new transmission' thrill" |
That is a funny rant, but he is correct about the paddle shifter.
|
Funny rant but Jalopnik is a German fanboy hangout. They basically trash any car that's not BMW, Mercedes or Audi.
|
Should have shown the up shift closer to the redline. That's more of a thrill.
|
Originally Posted by Kense
(Post 15542304)
Funny rant but Jalopnik is a German fanboy hangout. They basically trash any car that's not BMW, Mercedes or Audi.
|
Yahoo Front Page!
|
Originally Posted by Kense
(Post 15542304)
Funny rant but Jalopnik is a German fanboy hangout. They basically trash any car that's not BMW, Mercedes or Audi.
|
I shook my head the first time I see that ad with the "feel that vtec yo" comment. It is complete crap, especially since every make out there uses the same tech.
Lol on the revs climbing on the upshift. Noticed the revs, but never noticed which paddle he hit. Marketers 1 : engineers : 0. Honestly though, it's all much ado about nothing. It's a commercial designed to sell a product. If they showed the typical salesman accompanied test drive regardless of the make, it would be a total snooze fest. |
Originally Posted by Mr Hyde
(Post 15542733)
Lol on the revs climbing on the upshift. Noticed the revs, but never noticed which paddle he hit. Marketers 1 : engineers : 0. |
Originally Posted by TacoBello
(Post 15542355)
Or is it because BMW, Audi and Mercedes make ultra fun, hoonable cars that companies like Acura could never dream of. It's a website for car guys who like to drive- are you expecting a stellar review on the TLX? You can barely even find that here on AZ :tomato:
All excellent cars, but let's not deify them and demonize the TLX, an excellent car in it's own right. BTW, the majority of negative comments are from folks like you who don't own the car. |
Originally Posted by mapleloaf
(Post 15542897)
It's also a website for guys who think they are hip, performance drivers, and badge oriented, IMHO. I have driven all of these cars, and I'm sorry, there just isn't a big difference in fun. And hoonable is not a real #@$% word….but it is hip. My TLX 3.5 SH-AWD is fast, agile, and has the best AWD on the market for cars less than 100K. An Audi 4 equivalent is not more fun to drive, nor is a Mercedes 250-300 equivalent. A BMW 335 is faster (and considerably more expensive) and may be more fun to drive at the track….but guess what, 99.99 percent of us don't drive track or twisty canyon roads. They are all somewhat more likely to break down on the side of the road, a fact that I observe frequently in daily commutes.
All excellent cars, but let's not deify them and demonize the TLX, an excellent car in it's own right. BTW, the majority of negative comments are from folks like you who don't own the car. :) |
Originally Posted by mapleloaf
(Post 15542897)
It's also a website for guys who think they are hip, performance drivers, and badge oriented, IMHO. I have driven all of these cars, and I'm sorry, there just isn't a big difference in fun. And hoonable is not a real #@$% word….but it is hip. My TLX 3.5 SH-AWD is fast, agile, and has the best AWD on the market for cars less than 100K. An Audi 4 equivalent is not more fun to drive, nor is a Mercedes 250-300 equivalent. A BMW 335 is faster (and considerably more expensive) and may be more fun to drive at the track….but guess what, 99.99 percent of us don't drive track or twisty canyon roads. They are all somewhat more likely to break down on the side of the road, a fact that I observe frequently in daily commutes.
All excellent cars, but let's not deify them and demonize the TLX, an excellent car in it's own right. BTW, the majority of negative comments are from folks like you who don't own the car. You are correct, most the "haters" of the TLX are non TLX owners. |
Jalopnik was way cooler when it wasn't popular. I used to be on it all the time in 09-10 after that it got bad. Most people on Jalopnik just go with the popular ideas and dont really understand cars
|
Why is there a bias toward German cars?
I find them to be unattractive and hear they are not reliable |
Originally Posted by BC01191980
(Post 15543064)
Why is there a bias toward German cars?
I find them to be unattractive and hear they are not reliable |
No need to bash German cars just to defend Acura...lol
Germans do make great cars but yes they're "less" reliable and is more expensive to maintain. If someone was going to give me a TLX or a 335i for free? I'd pick a 335i everytime. |
Is it just me, or is pretty much every commercial out there like this? When was the last time you took your Nissan out to the middle of the desert and whipped the back end around? When was the last time you ordered a burger from McDonalds and had it look anything like the one on TV.
Bottom line, there's deception in advertising. Acura isn't the only one doing it. I could look at any commercial and point out similar issues. |
Originally Posted by advan031
(Post 15543108)
No need to bash German cars just to defend Acura...lol
Germans do make great cars but yes they're "less" reliable and is more expensive to maintain. If someone was going to give me a TLX or a 335i for free? I'd pick a 335i everytime. Have to agree with the criticism, it could have easily been harsher. |
Originally Posted by TacoBello
(Post 15542355)
Or is it because BMW, Audi and Mercedes make ultra fun, hoonable cars that companies like Acura could never dream of. It's a website for car guys who like to drive- are you expecting a stellar review on the TLX? You can barely even find that here on AZ :tomato:
|
Originally Posted by W.B.MASON
(Post 15543317)
No fan boi of either for various reasons. But the theoretical free question really would be a TLX with $25,000 or a 335i.
Have to agree with the criticism, it could have easily been harsher. |
Originally Posted by ucf_bronco
(Post 15543205)
Is it just me, or is pretty much every commercial out there like this? When was the last time you took your Nissan out to the middle of the desert and whipped the back end around? When was the last time you ordered a burger from McDonalds and had it look anything like the one on TV.
Bottom line, there's deception in advertising. Acura isn't the only one doing it. I could look at any commercial and point out similar issues. Have a look at this commercial for the Dodge Friggin Dart: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gogQLQNrDds "Take it to the track" "Never too much power" "a ground breaking car" etc etc. |
Originally Posted by CheeseyPoofs McNut
(Post 15543355)
Haha!
Have a look at this commercial for the Dodge Friggin Dart: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gogQLQNrDds "Take it to the track" "Never too much power" "a ground breaking car" etc etc. |
Originally Posted by thoiboi
(Post 15542030)
Also i think the commercial was tongue in cheek regarding the long-standing 'v-tec just kicked in yo' meme.. Anyway, the ad mentioned that vtec on the TLX is on both input and output regulating performance across a broad rpm range. For people who know, this is good news. For those who don't, you get the (over) reaction from the writer at Jalopnik. |
Originally Posted by W.B.MASON
(Post 15543317)
No fan boi of either for various reasons. But the theoretical free question really would be a TLX with $25,000 or a 335i.
Have to agree with the criticism, it could have easily been harsher. Agreed. I also think it plays on "inside" knowledge. |
Originally Posted by BEAR-AvHistory
(Post 15543551)
Yeah, some wag might have said a TLX or an Accord Touring & $10,000.
|
Or take a bus and save $50,000.
|
<p>
Originally Posted by oonowindoo
(Post 15543913)
Or take a bus and save $50,000.
|
Walking is better. You have to buy the bicycle.
|
You can just stay home and don't do anything and hide the money behind the fridge.
|
<p>
Originally Posted by oonowindoo
(Post 15543935)
Walking is better. You have to buy the bicycle.
Originally Posted by advan031
(Post 15543944)
You can just stay home and don't do anything and hide the money behind the fridge.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:52 PM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands