Front Wheel Drive Vehicle's w/ Staggered Wheels: yay or nay?
#1
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Toronto
Age: 44
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Front Wheel Drive Vehicle's w/ Staggered Wheels: yay or nay?
My Fellow TL'ers, i'm losing sleep trying to find the perfect or near perfect wheels for my 3rd gen TL-S.
i love the staggered look on vehicles but everytime i call shops for quotes, or even discuss w/ my mechanics about my future plans, they all say the same thing. with the staggered wheel setup where the rear wheels are wider, is not good for the handling and other stuff that i can't remember right now. they said wider rear wheels are meant for rear wheel drive vehicles like the bmer's, g35's and whatnot...
now i've seen many 3rd gen's with the staggered look. i mean i drool when i see the pics but as far as handling and other concerns, is that legit? is it not worth the hassle to get wider wheels in the rears?
could one just have the same width, in my case 19" x 9.0 but just have a lower offset for the rear to have some minor staggered look?
thanks for any help and advice in advance....
i love the staggered look on vehicles but everytime i call shops for quotes, or even discuss w/ my mechanics about my future plans, they all say the same thing. with the staggered wheel setup where the rear wheels are wider, is not good for the handling and other stuff that i can't remember right now. they said wider rear wheels are meant for rear wheel drive vehicles like the bmer's, g35's and whatnot...
now i've seen many 3rd gen's with the staggered look. i mean i drool when i see the pics but as far as handling and other concerns, is that legit? is it not worth the hassle to get wider wheels in the rears?
could one just have the same width, in my case 19" x 9.0 but just have a lower offset for the rear to have some minor staggered look?
thanks for any help and advice in advance....
#4
Moderator
iTrader: (1)
I asked this question the other day.
My question was ....is there any concerns going staggered on a fwd vehicle?
and here is what they told me.
You'll have understeer but you probably can't feel it, unless you track your car.
Also you can't rotate your tires so tires would get expensive fast.
I say if you have the funds to keep replacing tires then go for it.
it'll satisfy your need to look staggered.
My question was ....is there any concerns going staggered on a fwd vehicle?
and here is what they told me.
You'll have understeer but you probably can't feel it, unless you track your car.
Also you can't rotate your tires so tires would get expensive fast.
I say if you have the funds to keep replacing tires then go for it.
it'll satisfy your need to look staggered.
#6
Instructor
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Southern California (OC)
Age: 46
Posts: 170
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Whatever handling differences would likely be negligible if you stagger. Personally, I wouldn't do it because staggering an FF doesn't make sense to me other than looks, and I'll take function over form.
It's your car so do what makes you satisfied.
It's your car so do what makes you satisfied.
#7
Moderator
iTrader: (3)
Personally I love staggered set-ups
Trending Topics
#8
Team Owner
I love the look.
As for the handling, you won't notice the extra understeer until you get to the limits. At 80% you will never notice it. Plus, you're adding overall traction with wider rear tires. Unless you know how to use oversteer to set the car in a corner, you're not missing anything.
Add a larger RSB and you just moved the balance back to neutral, problem solved.
People get so worried about the extra understeer when going staggered on a FWD yet half the board drives around with a 24mm RSB set on firm with a 25mm hollow 5at FSB not realizing that the car would oversteer at the limit.
Personally I would not do it but only because I know it's FWD and it would bother me to have the "RWD look" but that's just my preference. Many people I run into think the TL is RWD anyway. Out of everything Honda makes except for the S-2000 obviously, the TL is the most RWD looking car out there.
As for the handling, you won't notice the extra understeer until you get to the limits. At 80% you will never notice it. Plus, you're adding overall traction with wider rear tires. Unless you know how to use oversteer to set the car in a corner, you're not missing anything.
Add a larger RSB and you just moved the balance back to neutral, problem solved.
People get so worried about the extra understeer when going staggered on a FWD yet half the board drives around with a 24mm RSB set on firm with a 25mm hollow 5at FSB not realizing that the car would oversteer at the limit.
Personally I would not do it but only because I know it's FWD and it would bother me to have the "RWD look" but that's just my preference. Many people I run into think the TL is RWD anyway. Out of everything Honda makes except for the S-2000 obviously, the TL is the most RWD looking car out there.
#9
Don't forget the electronics...ABS, Stability control, etc.
They all go to hell with staggered. In wet situations,they may not function as they were designed, and put you into a wall.
It comes down to... are you willing to put your life, and others, at risk because you want to look cool and pretend you are smarter than the engineers at Acura?
They all go to hell with staggered. In wet situations,they may not function as they were designed, and put you into a wall.
It comes down to... are you willing to put your life, and others, at risk because you want to look cool and pretend you are smarter than the engineers at Acura?
#10
2007 TL
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Jacksonville, FL
Age: 38
Posts: 273
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Don't forget the electronics...ABS, Stability control, etc.
They all go to hell with staggered. In wet situations,they may not function as they were designed, and put you into a wall.
It comes down to... are you willing to put your life, and others, at risk because you want to look cool and pretend you are smarter than the engineers at Acura?
They all go to hell with staggered. In wet situations,they may not function as they were designed, and put you into a wall.
It comes down to... are you willing to put your life, and others, at risk because you want to look cool and pretend you are smarter than the engineers at Acura?
#12
2007 TL
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Jacksonville, FL
Age: 38
Posts: 273
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Are you actually basing what you're saying on reported issue's from people? Where did you get/assume this information from?
It seems that this is along the lines of "If you stretch tires then you are going to die because it's going to blow up!!!"
But yet there are ton's of people running stretch tires and not dying. There are ton's of people running staggered set-ups on a FWD car and not going out of control wrecking their cars.
Also how did people function without VSC and ABS? Did everyone just wreck and die?
It seems that this is along the lines of "If you stretch tires then you are going to die because it's going to blow up!!!"
But yet there are ton's of people running stretch tires and not dying. There are ton's of people running staggered set-ups on a FWD car and not going out of control wrecking their cars.
Also how did people function without VSC and ABS? Did everyone just wreck and die?
#14
Team Owner
As long as overall tire diameter is the same between all 4, there won't be problems with any of the electronic nannies.
#15
אני עומד עם ישראל
Personally, no. I have seen a 4g (FWD w/tech) look really clean with a staggered look.
#16
Are you actually basing what you're saying on reported issue's from people? Where did you get/assume this information from?
It seems that this is along the lines of "If you stretch tires then you are going to die because it's going to blow up!!!"
But yet there are ton's of people running stretch tires and not dying. There are ton's of people running staggered set-ups on a FWD car and not going out of control wrecking their cars.
Also how did people function without VSC and ABS? Did everyone just wreck and die?
It seems that this is along the lines of "If you stretch tires then you are going to die because it's going to blow up!!!"
But yet there are ton's of people running stretch tires and not dying. There are ton's of people running staggered set-ups on a FWD car and not going out of control wrecking their cars.
Also how did people function without VSC and ABS? Did everyone just wreck and die?
The TL/TL-S was not designed for this.
I haven't seen tons, or even one for that matter, and I travel quite a bit.
They certainly create a special look from what I have seen on this forum
If you want to take chances with something like staggering or stretching tires, go for it. Maybe it is not taking a chance in your opinion.
IMO, I won't be stretching tires, or staggering any time soon
To the OP: nay
P.S. In yesteryear, we were taught to pump the brakes to achieve the best results.
Do that today on an ABS system
Last edited by S PAW 1; 05-03-2010 at 07:12 AM.
#19
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Toronto
Age: 44
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
well i thank everyone for the feedback..
i think i found the best solution that will satisfy my taste buds....
i'm planning on purchasing SSR - Werfen GT-03 wheels. 19x9.0 all around. theres 2 things i love about this, 1 is the wheel is beautiful and 2. when you go on the website, i have the option to choose lip size for the same width wheel.. hence get the staggered look (more lipage in the rear) , less in front but no concerns.
i know it'll cost me a bit more as far as rotating tires but hey its not an arm and a leg
i'm looking at fronts 19x9.0(44mm offset) w/ a 30mm lip and rears 19x9.0(37mm offset) w/ a 55mm lip
does everyone think thats a good compromise?
i think i found the best solution that will satisfy my taste buds....
i'm planning on purchasing SSR - Werfen GT-03 wheels. 19x9.0 all around. theres 2 things i love about this, 1 is the wheel is beautiful and 2. when you go on the website, i have the option to choose lip size for the same width wheel.. hence get the staggered look (more lipage in the rear) , less in front but no concerns.
i know it'll cost me a bit more as far as rotating tires but hey its not an arm and a leg
i'm looking at fronts 19x9.0(44mm offset) w/ a 30mm lip and rears 19x9.0(37mm offset) w/ a 55mm lip
does everyone think thats a good compromise?
#20
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Toronto
Age: 44
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
now the question is, anyone know of any good wheel shops where i can purchase these at a good price? the msrp is about $950 a wheel!!!! damnit never fails, when i find something i really like, its always an arm n leg.
#22
Team Owner
Are you actually basing what you're saying on reported issue's from people? Where did you get/assume this information from?
It seems that this is along the lines of "If you stretch tires then you are going to die because it's going to blow up!!!"
But yet there are ton's of people running stretch tires and not dying. There are ton's of people running staggered set-ups on a FWD car and not going out of control wrecking their cars.
Also how did people function without VSC and ABS? Did everyone just wreck and die?
It seems that this is along the lines of "If you stretch tires then you are going to die because it's going to blow up!!!"
But yet there are ton's of people running stretch tires and not dying. There are ton's of people running staggered set-ups on a FWD car and not going out of control wrecking their cars.
Also how did people function without VSC and ABS? Did everyone just wreck and die?
Going staggered only affects handling balance. Adding the ever so popular 24mm RSB affects handling balance much more than a staggered setup will so I don't know what the big deal is. Staggered is not ideal in a FWD but with wider rear tires you're increasing traction, not decreasing traction. Sure, it will understeer more but it will have a higher limit before understeering. Besides, everyone talks about understeer being bad but every time I see a car oversteer the driver freaks out and causes a wreck or a spin anyway.
I like a little oversteer but I'm used to going sideways. For 99% of the people out there understeer is what you want. Keep in mind, people, you will feel no difference with a staggered setup until you take the car to the absolute limit which hardly anyone does.
I agree with the ABS statement. My personal preference is a car without the electronic nannies so I have full control over it.
#24
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Toronto
Age: 44
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#26
Advanced
i know i should not disclose this but i had a flat drove into the shop and they happened to have these rims that were used. i walked out out the shop paying only 700 for all 4... needless to say i got the best deal of my life and they didnt know what they had lol.
#27
you know, i use to kinda hate on the whole staggard on fwd cars. however sinc ei own a tl now and it dosnt really have much speed and i dont use it for speed or 1/4 like my previous cars. i look at it as "ALL SHOW NO GO" so who cares. I just like how it looks, i can care less how it performs as im personally not going to track it in any way. all looks for me with my tl (of course has to be good quality and etc) but no longer worried about aggresive spring rates or light wheels. just my opinion and a little about what i think ahha.
Edit: oh and if anyone is worried about the whole fwd thing. the saddest part is majority of the people that will look at your car will assume its rwd or not care, or not know lol.
Edit: oh and if anyone is worried about the whole fwd thing. the saddest part is majority of the people that will look at your car will assume its rwd or not care, or not know lol.
The following users liked this post:
GetLikeMe_TypeS (04-29-2013)
#29
Intermediate
#30
BANNED
iTrader: (33)
The following 3 users liked this post by SharksBreath:
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
nanos
Car Parts for Sale
26
11-12-2015 08:41 PM
Oakes
Wash & Wax
10
10-12-2015 11:17 AM
nuldabz
3G TL Tires, Wheels & Suspension
3
09-03-2015 05:49 PM