Bye bye Acura/Honda
#41
Team Owner
Do you really believe that a defect requires a recall, no, only safety defects are eligible for a NHTSA recall, so take a look at the number of safety defects and compare.
If one started listing defects found in cars, there would be an insurmountable amount, and reliability has nothing to do with a safety defect. One can have a perfect car and have a recall for a brake light switch but that doesn't diminish reliability.
Just a comparison on TSB's in 2008, Toyota Camry had 38 while the 2008 TL 15.
I'm not an Acura/Honda diehard, but doing the comparison as this is an Acura Forum.
If one started listing defects found in cars, there would be an insurmountable amount, and reliability has nothing to do with a safety defect. One can have a perfect car and have a recall for a brake light switch but that doesn't diminish reliability.
Just a comparison on TSB's in 2008, Toyota Camry had 38 while the 2008 TL 15.
I'm not an Acura/Honda diehard, but doing the comparison as this is an Acura Forum.
#43
Stay Out Of the Left Lane
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: SE Mass --- > Central VA --- > SE Mass
Age: 57
Posts: 8,963
Received 1,237 Likes
on
1,024 Posts
If you search this is unfortunately a fairly common occurrence. Two regularly reported symptoms are as follows:
HFL shows as constantly booting up on the MID when selected.
The console above the rear view mirror where the HFL module is located is and stays warm to the touch long after the car is turned off.
HFL shows as constantly booting up on the MID when selected.
The console above the rear view mirror where the HFL module is located is and stays warm to the touch long after the car is turned off.
#44
Instructor
They did when the IS redesign came out in 06. We had 3 at the dealership I worked at that needed to be jump started all the time because no one ever wanted to drive them. We finally had to give them away well below invoice at the end of the year.
I too enjoy the control I get from clutching and shifting in my TL, but the ISF does it better electronically. When in sport mode, contrary to most other cars, the ISF driver has so much control over the gear box they could bend the valves..... like manual tl users do when they shift from 6th to 3rd when trying to go to 5th on the highway on accident. Also contrary to most cars, it shifts instantly when you pull either shifter on the wheel to whatever gear you want. Heck, it even blips the throttle when downshifting, a skill most manual drivers have yet to master. What would the center console look like with another row of gears for numbers 7 and 8?
I don't think its a manhood issue, just things evolving to a better way.
I too enjoy the control I get from clutching and shifting in my TL, but the ISF does it better electronically. When in sport mode, contrary to most other cars, the ISF driver has so much control over the gear box they could bend the valves..... like manual tl users do when they shift from 6th to 3rd when trying to go to 5th on the highway on accident. Also contrary to most cars, it shifts instantly when you pull either shifter on the wheel to whatever gear you want. Heck, it even blips the throttle when downshifting, a skill most manual drivers have yet to master. What would the center console look like with another row of gears for numbers 7 and 8?
I don't think its a manhood issue, just things evolving to a better way.
Last edited by erg69; 06-08-2015 at 09:21 AM.
#45
Registered Bunny
They did when the IS redesign came out in 06. We had 3 at the dealership I worked at that needed to be jump started all the time because no one ever wanted to drive them. We finally had to give them away well below invoice at the end of the year.
I too enjoy the control I get from clutching and shifting in my TL, but the ISF does it better electronically. When in sport mode, contrary to most other cars, the ISF driver has so much control over the gear box they could bend the valves..... like manual tl users do when they shift from 6th to 3rd when trying to go to 5th on the highway on accident. Also contrary to most cars, it shifts instantly when you pull either shifter on the wheel to whatever gear you want. Heck, it even blips the throttle when downshifting, a skill most manual drivers have yet to master. What would the center console look like with another row of gears for numbers 7 and 8?
I don't think its a manhood issue, just things evolving to a better way.
I too enjoy the control I get from clutching and shifting in my TL, but the ISF does it better electronically. When in sport mode, contrary to most other cars, the ISF driver has so much control over the gear box they could bend the valves..... like manual tl users do when they shift from 6th to 3rd when trying to go to 5th on the highway on accident. Also contrary to most cars, it shifts instantly when you pull either shifter on the wheel to whatever gear you want. Heck, it even blips the throttle when downshifting, a skill most manual drivers have yet to master. What would the center console look like with another row of gears for numbers 7 and 8?
I don't think its a manhood issue, just things evolving to a better way.
![Tomato](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/tomato.gif)
![](http://home.arcor.de/wolkov.schitzkoy/microsoftjoy1.jpg)
The following users liked this post:
erg69 (06-08-2015)
#46
Three Wheelin'
Doesn't matter to me how good an auto trans is in manual mode, it will never give me the same level or experience that a real manual transmission does. A car also stops faster in neutral (trans disengaged) than it does in gear, and this is easy and quickly done with a manual. When in D on an auto trams you can also quickly hit the shift lever up into neutral in an emergency, but you lose this ability once in manual mode as most require a side step to engage manual mode.
#47
Instructor
Doesn't matter to me how good an auto trans is in manual mode, it will never give me the same level or experience that a real manual transmission does. A car also stops faster in neutral (trans disengaged) than it does in gear, and this is easy and quickly done with a manual. When in D on an auto trams you can also quickly hit the shift lever up into neutral in an emergency, but you lose this ability once in manual mode as most require a side step to engage manual mode.
We could also debate why mustard is good on a burger and should never be put on a hotdog. Really just personal preference I guess. Wait is that ketchup?
Last edited by erg69; 06-08-2015 at 11:27 AM.
#48
Three Wheelin'
I'll take one out for a spin, but in all honesty, autos are just boring after you get used to a manual, and I've driven plenty of autos with manual mode. It's just not the same (for me). And having lived in New England for over 20 years, the best control I've experienced over the vehicle *in certain situations* always came when the engine is completely disconnected from the wheels. Note ABS still works in neutral. Still easier to rock the car out of a snow ditch back and forth with a manual too, vs between D and R on an auto.
I agree that now a days systems like traction and stability control will most likely keep your butt on the road in an emergency situation better than us under manual control of the vehicle, and many times these systems control the power output and where it goes, so here you want everything engaged, but not always. Years ago I pulled out on the street to make a left turn and some nut came flying around the corner too fast to stop. I punched it to get out of the way (too late to stop or turn back) and traction control kicked in and cut my power. A system that's supposed to keep me safe almost got me killed. A quick dumping of the clutch and re-engagement of the gear as I hit the traction off button saved my life. I now only use these systems under inclement weather, and prefer to stick with manual transmissions (unless truck or suv). That's just me.
So, the ISF's engine always revs down faster than it can brake? That's the only way it can aid in braking. In either case, I meant more towards the IS lineup in general, as in an IS350, comparable to our TLs, and not a $60-$70k sports car like the F, where you would expect some sort of performance above the norm. Shit, I'd take a 458 Specialle any day no matter what transmission it comes with![Wink](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/wink.gif)
I would love to have an IS350 with a 6spd, or an F if I could afford one.
I agree that now a days systems like traction and stability control will most likely keep your butt on the road in an emergency situation better than us under manual control of the vehicle, and many times these systems control the power output and where it goes, so here you want everything engaged, but not always. Years ago I pulled out on the street to make a left turn and some nut came flying around the corner too fast to stop. I punched it to get out of the way (too late to stop or turn back) and traction control kicked in and cut my power. A system that's supposed to keep me safe almost got me killed. A quick dumping of the clutch and re-engagement of the gear as I hit the traction off button saved my life. I now only use these systems under inclement weather, and prefer to stick with manual transmissions (unless truck or suv). That's just me.
So, the ISF's engine always revs down faster than it can brake? That's the only way it can aid in braking. In either case, I meant more towards the IS lineup in general, as in an IS350, comparable to our TLs, and not a $60-$70k sports car like the F, where you would expect some sort of performance above the norm. Shit, I'd take a 458 Specialle any day no matter what transmission it comes with
![Wink](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/wink.gif)
I would love to have an IS350 with a 6spd, or an F if I could afford one.
Last edited by FamilyGuy; 06-08-2015 at 02:19 PM.
The following 2 users liked this post by FamilyGuy:
erg69 (06-08-2015),
NBP04TL4ME (06-09-2015)
#49
2006 NBP TL MT6/ 02TL-S
No matter how fancy, how ever many gears it has, dual stage clutches & however it shifts, doesn't an automatic transmission still have a torque convertor?
#50
Senior Moderator
#52
Suzuka Master
iTrader: (2)
They did when the IS redesign came out in 06. We had 3 at the dealership I worked at that needed to be jump started all the time because no one ever wanted to drive them. We finally had to give them away well below invoice at the end of the year.
I too enjoy the control I get from clutching and shifting in my TL, but the ISF does it better electronically. When in sport mode, contrary to most other cars, the ISF driver has so much control over the gear box they could bend the valves..... like manual tl users do when they shift from 6th to 3rd when trying to go to 5th on the highway on accident. Also contrary to most cars, it shifts instantly when you pull either shifter on the wheel to whatever gear you want. Heck, it even blips the throttle when downshifting, a skill most manual drivers have yet to master. What would the center console look like with another row of gears for numbers 7 and 8?
I don't think its a manhood issue, just things evolving to a better way.
I too enjoy the control I get from clutching and shifting in my TL, but the ISF does it better electronically. When in sport mode, contrary to most other cars, the ISF driver has so much control over the gear box they could bend the valves..... like manual tl users do when they shift from 6th to 3rd when trying to go to 5th on the highway on accident. Also contrary to most cars, it shifts instantly when you pull either shifter on the wheel to whatever gear you want. Heck, it even blips the throttle when downshifting, a skill most manual drivers have yet to master. What would the center console look like with another row of gears for numbers 7 and 8?
I don't think its a manhood issue, just things evolving to a better way.
#53
Stay Out Of the Left Lane
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: SE Mass --- > Central VA --- > SE Mass
Age: 57
Posts: 8,963
Received 1,237 Likes
on
1,024 Posts
The following users liked this post:
thoiboi (06-09-2015)
#54
Team Owner
#57
Stay Out Of the Left Lane
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: SE Mass --- > Central VA --- > SE Mass
Age: 57
Posts: 8,963
Received 1,237 Likes
on
1,024 Posts
![Tongue](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/tongue.gif)
#58
Senior Moderator
I think Acura OC was too young to get the reference..
![Why Me](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/whyme.gif)
#59
Team Owner
#60
Stay Out Of the Left Lane
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: SE Mass --- > Central VA --- > SE Mass
Age: 57
Posts: 8,963
Received 1,237 Likes
on
1,024 Posts
#61
No one understands me. That hurts.
#62
Senior Moderator
![Scratch](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/scratch.gif)
#63
Registered Bunny
![Tongue](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/tongue.gif)
Just kidding by the way, I'm sure the explanation can serve some.
![Thumbs Up](https://acurazine.com/forums/images/smilies/thumbsup.gif)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post