Can $2350 Beat Acura Engineering?
#1
Can $2350 Beat Acura Engineering?
Given the $2350 difference in base MSRP from the TL-P to the TL-S, what could you do with the extra $2000 (deduct a little for the 17 in. wheels, etc.) to make the TL-P turn as much or more horsepower and torque as the TL-S?
Can it be done? Can this group beat the Honda engineers?
Forget about the exotics like nitro or pulling all of the sheet metal to reduce the weight. Answers must be something reliable and maintains the integrity of the car.
Can it be done? Can this group beat the Honda engineers?
Forget about the exotics like nitro or pulling all of the sheet metal to reduce the weight. Answers must be something reliable and maintains the integrity of the car.
#5
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: houston,tx
Posts: 1,348
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
With type S, you get perforated leather, VSA, wheels, suspensions on top of the engine...a lot more than $3000 difference if you were to do it to a TLP afterwards.
#6
Plus with the TL-S, all that power is under warranty. To get a TL-P to the power of a TL-S, you're risk your warranty. At any rate, the TL-S has a flatter torque curve than the TL-P, IIRC.
#7
Safety Car
If you want to try and put all the S parts on a TL-P, for less than $2000, fat chance. You can do it with other stuff, like people said, but if you are gonna stay at the TL-S level of power, get one of those, if you want more, you can then mod the TL-S with the I/H/E
Trending Topics
#8
Blown is Best
A TL-P with I/E/H will get close to a TL-S but you're topped out on what you can do. TL-S has a higher starting point and lots more potential. For example, headers for a TL-P are only worth 15HP at the top of the RPM range. TL-S gets 25-30HP for the same mod.
#9
yeah i'm bored.
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: clifton, nj
Age: 44
Posts: 3,128
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
if power is your only concern, im sure it can be done.
but, for the relatively small money difference, you get the 17in wheels, the perforated leather, the better suspension, the extra hp, vsa, AGEAN BLUE PEARL, and the really cool shift knob
best money i ever spent
but, for the relatively small money difference, you get the 17in wheels, the perforated leather, the better suspension, the extra hp, vsa, AGEAN BLUE PEARL, and the really cool shift knob
best money i ever spent
#10
I notice most of the proposed solutions are exhaust system based... good start but quite inferior... we have an experiment cooking in SC that I'll keep you posted.
I initially posted the question because my shop in SC has bumped two 2000's and 1 1999 TL-P from 225 hp to 293 by shaving the heads 2 1/2 degree from tdc in a geodesic radiant pattern and installing a high output r/t cam. All of the cars came in due to broken the timing belts and required significant repair, but we figure (my senior mechanic has 23 years of exp. with Honda) that we could do the same job on a non-timing belt job for $799.
But to be fair, we tried the same cut on a TL-S from a friend of ours and was able to generate 300 hp on the dyno. It's not as big of a jump in the TL-P, but it's more overall. We think the higher initial compression and manifolds of the TL-S doesn't lend themselves to the higher percentage of output as the TL-P. Both engine mod realized a 5% increase in fuel efficiency.
Nevertheless, maybe we'll get lucky and Acura will pick-up our mods in the 2005 versions.
I initially posted the question because my shop in SC has bumped two 2000's and 1 1999 TL-P from 225 hp to 293 by shaving the heads 2 1/2 degree from tdc in a geodesic radiant pattern and installing a high output r/t cam. All of the cars came in due to broken the timing belts and required significant repair, but we figure (my senior mechanic has 23 years of exp. with Honda) that we could do the same job on a non-timing belt job for $799.
But to be fair, we tried the same cut on a TL-S from a friend of ours and was able to generate 300 hp on the dyno. It's not as big of a jump in the TL-P, but it's more overall. We think the higher initial compression and manifolds of the TL-S doesn't lend themselves to the higher percentage of output as the TL-P. Both engine mod realized a 5% increase in fuel efficiency.
Nevertheless, maybe we'll get lucky and Acura will pick-up our mods in the 2005 versions.
#11
2011 SH-AWD 6MT
Originally posted by 2ONPAR5
I notice most of the proposed solutions are exhaust system based... good start but quite inferior... we have an experiment cooking in SC that I'll keep you posted.
I initially posted the question because my shop in SC has bumped two 2000's and 1 1999 TL-P from 225 hp to 293 by shaving the heads 2 1/2 degree from tdc in a geodesic radiant pattern and installing a high output r/t cam. All of the cars came in due to broken the timing belts and required significant repair, but we figure (my senior mechanic has 23 years of exp. with Honda) that we could do the same job on a non-timing belt job for $799.
But to be fair, we tried the same cut on a TL-S from a friend of ours and was able to generate 300 hp on the dyno. It's not as big of a jump in the TL-P, but it's more overall. We think the higher initial compression and manifolds of the TL-S doesn't lend themselves to the higher percentage of output as the TL-P. Both engine mod realized a 5% increase in fuel efficiency.
I notice most of the proposed solutions are exhaust system based... good start but quite inferior... we have an experiment cooking in SC that I'll keep you posted.
I initially posted the question because my shop in SC has bumped two 2000's and 1 1999 TL-P from 225 hp to 293 by shaving the heads 2 1/2 degree from tdc in a geodesic radiant pattern and installing a high output r/t cam. All of the cars came in due to broken the timing belts and required significant repair, but we figure (my senior mechanic has 23 years of exp. with Honda) that we could do the same job on a non-timing belt job for $799.
But to be fair, we tried the same cut on a TL-S from a friend of ours and was able to generate 300 hp on the dyno. It's not as big of a jump in the TL-P, but it's more overall. We think the higher initial compression and manifolds of the TL-S doesn't lend themselves to the higher percentage of output as the TL-P. Both engine mod realized a 5% increase in fuel efficiency.
You increased hp from 225-293 with less than $1000. If I had enough money I would be asking how soon I could bring my car down to SC.
Seriously parts and labor only cost $800? And an increase in fuel efficiency?
Am I dreaming?
#12
(my senior mechanic has 23 years of exp. with Honda) that we could do the same job on a non-timing belt job for $799.
I hope he does not have a family.....cuz if the performance gain is real, he will be working 18 hours a day doing the mods for a few thousand TL-P's.
Let us know when you are ready !!!
I hope he does not have a family.....cuz if the performance gain is real, he will be working 18 hours a day doing the mods for a few thousand TL-P's.
Let us know when you are ready !!!
#14
I should clarify... $799 covers the cam and related parts and NOT the 18 hours of labor. I was wondering if people thought the MOD was valuable enough to shell out the $2K difference between the TL-P and TL-S.
#15
yeah i'm bored.
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: clifton, nj
Age: 44
Posts: 3,128
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
okay, let's move past this "$2,000 difference between the tlp and tls" cuz its pretty irrelevant. no ones going to go to the dealer and buy a tlp with plans of upping the power to tls range by driving it to SC.
1) what would you estimate as the total cost, including labor?
2) does anyone with a little better mechanical knowledge than me know of any downsides with the work this guy is talking about?
3) i'd assume this would pretty much nullify acuras recently extended tranny warranty
4) how does changing the cam effect vtec?
sounds like a good plan, keep us posted on any further developments.
ps..not trying to be a d!ck, just trying to get some details
1) what would you estimate as the total cost, including labor?
2) does anyone with a little better mechanical knowledge than me know of any downsides with the work this guy is talking about?
3) i'd assume this would pretty much nullify acuras recently extended tranny warranty
4) how does changing the cam effect vtec?
sounds like a good plan, keep us posted on any further developments.
ps..not trying to be a d!ck, just trying to get some details
#16
Safety Car
Originally posted by 2ONPAR5
I notice most of the proposed solutions are exhaust system based... good start but quite inferior... we have an experiment cooking in SC that I'll keep you posted.
I initially posted the question because my shop in SC has bumped two 2000's and 1 1999 TL-P from 225 hp to 293 by shaving the heads 2 1/2 degree from tdc in a geodesic radiant pattern and installing a high output r/t cam. All of the cars came in due to broken the timing belts and required significant repair, but we figure (my senior mechanic has 23 years of exp. with Honda) that we could do the same job on a non-timing belt job for $799.
But to be fair, we tried the same cut on a TL-S from a friend of ours and was able to generate 300 hp on the dyno. It's not as big of a jump in the TL-P, but it's more overall. We think the higher initial compression and manifolds of the TL-S doesn't lend themselves to the higher percentage of output as the TL-P. Both engine mod realized a 5% increase in fuel efficiency.
Nevertheless, maybe we'll get lucky and Acura will pick-up our mods in the 2005 versions.
I notice most of the proposed solutions are exhaust system based... good start but quite inferior... we have an experiment cooking in SC that I'll keep you posted.
I initially posted the question because my shop in SC has bumped two 2000's and 1 1999 TL-P from 225 hp to 293 by shaving the heads 2 1/2 degree from tdc in a geodesic radiant pattern and installing a high output r/t cam. All of the cars came in due to broken the timing belts and required significant repair, but we figure (my senior mechanic has 23 years of exp. with Honda) that we could do the same job on a non-timing belt job for $799.
But to be fair, we tried the same cut on a TL-S from a friend of ours and was able to generate 300 hp on the dyno. It's not as big of a jump in the TL-P, but it's more overall. We think the higher initial compression and manifolds of the TL-S doesn't lend themselves to the higher percentage of output as the TL-P. Both engine mod realized a 5% increase in fuel efficiency.
Nevertheless, maybe we'll get lucky and Acura will pick-up our mods in the 2005 versions.
#17
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Vancouver, BC
Posts: 1,876
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This mod has excellent potential....anyone here wanna be a guinea pig and report back on this mod after its done? Like one guy said, if this mod is for real, lots of TLers will be lining up to get this done.
#23
As soon as we can package it without giving away the store. We got to get a web site going and possible license out the mod to other mechanics around the country. More to come.
#24
4dr & I like it that way
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: San Diego
Age: 40
Posts: 1,612
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
sounds good, be sure to post on www.acura-cl.com people on that board seem to be more performance oriented than here
flame away but you guys know its true :o
flame away but you guys know its true :o
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Nitin
Car Parts for Sale
4
09-30-2015 08:22 PM
Mike Bertram
2G TL (1999-2003)
9
09-10-2015 09:27 AM