Comparision: 06 TSX AT Loaner vs. my 04 AT with SC
#1
Rep'n Taxbrain.com
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: N. Cali-forn-i-a
Age: 44
Posts: 7,075
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Comparision: 06 TSX AT Loaner vs. my 04 AT with SC
I'm at about 48,500 miles now on my 04 AT/CGP with Supercharger. I'm right at the end of warranty, so I brought my TSX in to take care of the trunk harness recall and a problem that I recently had with one of the door locks sticking. They gave me a 06 AT/PWP/Navi as a loaner. I've been driving it like I stole it and I thought I would post some impressions.
Performance:
Well coming from a TSX with engine mods and Supercharger it's hard to really make a comparision. The 06 model has more umph then my 04 TSX did when it was stock though. I was driving it hard like I usually do with my car and although it's definitely not even close to as fast, it was still better than I though it would be. On the freeway I could tell my SC TSX would blows the doors off of the loaner, but that's expected. Overall I think it has sufficient power and I was still able to take off on many cars that I encountered. The Vtec on the 06 is very nice and the engagement is more noticeable than the older models. I think an 06 with a Hondata reflash with Icebox/Header/Hiflow cat would be a close to ideal setup.
Sound:
This is one of the first things I noticed. The 06 seems to have a more distinct exhaust tone then my TSX when it was stock. I like the sound of it. Definitely very nice!
Handling/Ride Quality:
The car actually handles very nicely stock. It takes corners well and you don't feel like you're in a car that is super high or anything. The bumps were a lot harsher than I thought they would be with stock suspension. It helps me realize how good the Tanabe Suspension actually is. My car on Tanabe and 225/40 18's is probably only a little worse in terms of ride comfort. I'll have to drive some more to really determine this, but this is my initial impression.
Navi:
Very nice navi system. This is the first time that I've really gotten to play with it alot. It has a nice display and I like the use of the joystick and the colors. I like the ease of use. It was very easy to find a gas station or restaraunt, and I like how it can sort by distance from you location. Also the calendar and calculator are cool features. I wish you could control the fan speed without having to go to the onscreen menu, but that's just a minor inconvience. The Zagat ratings and descriptions are cool, although I found out that they didnt' have very many ratings in my area. I think it would be very useful in big cities like SF though. Overall it's a very nice system. I still don't regret not getting the navi model though. I just don't use navi very often and I've found that I'd rather just let the navi screen turn off or go to the audio screen. Also, I like my setup because of the integration of the multiple audio/video entertainment sources.
XM radio/stereo:
I switched out my entire system about a week after getting my TSX, so I really haven't heard a stock TSX in a long time. Overall I think the stock system actually sounds pretty good. It was bumping pretty good and it sounds a lot of better than I remember. The XM radio is cool too. I like the integration with the factory HU. Very nice song info and large screen.
MID:
The gauges are cool and I like how it tells you what kind of mileage you are getting at the moment. Definitely an improvement over the 04/05. I haven't paired my phone to it yet and not sure if I will since I don't have an owners manual. Is it hard to pair your phone and/or phonebook?
Well, I have the car for one more day, so I'll post some more comparisions if anything comes to mind!
Performance:
Well coming from a TSX with engine mods and Supercharger it's hard to really make a comparision. The 06 model has more umph then my 04 TSX did when it was stock though. I was driving it hard like I usually do with my car and although it's definitely not even close to as fast, it was still better than I though it would be. On the freeway I could tell my SC TSX would blows the doors off of the loaner, but that's expected. Overall I think it has sufficient power and I was still able to take off on many cars that I encountered. The Vtec on the 06 is very nice and the engagement is more noticeable than the older models. I think an 06 with a Hondata reflash with Icebox/Header/Hiflow cat would be a close to ideal setup.
Sound:
This is one of the first things I noticed. The 06 seems to have a more distinct exhaust tone then my TSX when it was stock. I like the sound of it. Definitely very nice!
Handling/Ride Quality:
The car actually handles very nicely stock. It takes corners well and you don't feel like you're in a car that is super high or anything. The bumps were a lot harsher than I thought they would be with stock suspension. It helps me realize how good the Tanabe Suspension actually is. My car on Tanabe and 225/40 18's is probably only a little worse in terms of ride comfort. I'll have to drive some more to really determine this, but this is my initial impression.
Navi:
Very nice navi system. This is the first time that I've really gotten to play with it alot. It has a nice display and I like the use of the joystick and the colors. I like the ease of use. It was very easy to find a gas station or restaraunt, and I like how it can sort by distance from you location. Also the calendar and calculator are cool features. I wish you could control the fan speed without having to go to the onscreen menu, but that's just a minor inconvience. The Zagat ratings and descriptions are cool, although I found out that they didnt' have very many ratings in my area. I think it would be very useful in big cities like SF though. Overall it's a very nice system. I still don't regret not getting the navi model though. I just don't use navi very often and I've found that I'd rather just let the navi screen turn off or go to the audio screen. Also, I like my setup because of the integration of the multiple audio/video entertainment sources.
XM radio/stereo:
I switched out my entire system about a week after getting my TSX, so I really haven't heard a stock TSX in a long time. Overall I think the stock system actually sounds pretty good. It was bumping pretty good and it sounds a lot of better than I remember. The XM radio is cool too. I like the integration with the factory HU. Very nice song info and large screen.
MID:
The gauges are cool and I like how it tells you what kind of mileage you are getting at the moment. Definitely an improvement over the 04/05. I haven't paired my phone to it yet and not sure if I will since I don't have an owners manual. Is it hard to pair your phone and/or phonebook?
Well, I have the car for one more day, so I'll post some more comparisions if anything comes to mind!
#2
Rep'n Taxbrain.com
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: N. Cali-forn-i-a
Age: 44
Posts: 7,075
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
One more thing that I liked was the 06 steering wheel. It's a little smaller, thicker, and sporty than the 04/05 steering wheel. I would even consider a retrofit, but I know that would cost big dough, so it wouldn't be worth it.
#3
Originally Posted by Tsx536
Sound:
This is one of the first things I noticed. The 06 seems to have a more distinct exhaust tone then my TSX when it was stock. I like the sound of it. Definitely very nice!
This is one of the first things I noticed. The 06 seems to have a more distinct exhaust tone then my TSX when it was stock. I like the sound of it. Definitely very nice!
#4
アコードタイプSとくれば、喜びもひとし お。思わず投
The steering wheel itself only cost $424 just swap the 04 airbag
http://www.acuraautomotiveparts.org/...prddisplay.jsp
569188 007 1 WHEEL, STEERING (LEATHER) GRAPHITE BLACK 499.27 424.38
http://www.acuraautomotiveparts.org/...prddisplay.jsp
569188 007 1 WHEEL, STEERING (LEATHER) GRAPHITE BLACK 499.27 424.38
#6
Rep'n Taxbrain.com
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: N. Cali-forn-i-a
Age: 44
Posts: 7,075
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Originally Posted by Black_6spd
At first, I thought it was just my imagination. I guess this confirms it. The 06 definately has more of a growl under WOT. You could even notice it in one of the gay "TSX Diaries" videos.:ghey:
#7
Rep'n Taxbrain.com
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: N. Cali-forn-i-a
Age: 44
Posts: 7,075
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Originally Posted by lito
The steering wheel itself only cost $424 just swap the 04 airbag
http://www.acuraautomotiveparts.org/...prddisplay.jsp
569188 007 1 WHEEL, STEERING (LEATHER) GRAPHITE BLACK 499.27 424.38
http://www.acuraautomotiveparts.org/...prddisplay.jsp
569188 007 1 WHEEL, STEERING (LEATHER) GRAPHITE BLACK 499.27 424.38
Still, I don't think it would be worth the swap, it's not all that different.
Trending Topics
#8
Intermediate
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: houston
Age: 50
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Tsx536
I think an 06 with a Hondata reflash with Icebox/Header/Hiflow cat would be a close to ideal setup.
I had an 04 and now have an 06 - and have followed your addition of a s/c
If they every come out with a s/c for an 06 I will seriously consider it: but you comment about the the other mods gives me pause...
I question parting with 5 grand or so on a s/c an wonder why not just get a g35 or other...
what do you think the reflash ice header high flow will do for an 06 at?
#9
Rep'n Taxbrain.com
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: N. Cali-forn-i-a
Age: 44
Posts: 7,075
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Originally Posted by fintracity
I had an 04 and now have an 06 - and have followed your addition of a s/c
If they every come out with a s/c for an 06 I will seriously consider it: but you comment about the the other mods gives me pause...
I question parting with 5 grand or so on a s/c an wonder why not just get a g35 or other...
what do you think the reflash ice header high flow will do for an 06 at?
If they every come out with a s/c for an 06 I will seriously consider it: but you comment about the the other mods gives me pause...
I question parting with 5 grand or so on a s/c an wonder why not just get a g35 or other...
what do you think the reflash ice header high flow will do for an 06 at?
#11
Let me help you!
Originally Posted by Tsx536
I wish you could control the fan speed without having to go to the onscreen menu, but that's just a minor inconvience.
You could always use the voice recognition to change it..."fan speed 2"
Practically everything is accessible...there are even stuff that aren't listed in the manual. Like if you're in map mode and you're looking at the destination or some other location, and then you want to display your current location, you can say "where am I" lol...
#12
is cuteness
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: BOSTON.
Age: 37
Posts: 266
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by SoCaliTrojan
What do you mean? Having a separate dial for it?
You could always use the voice recognition to change it..."fan speed 2"
Practically everything is accessible...there are even stuff that aren't listed in the manual. Like if you're in map mode and you're looking at the destination or some other location, and then you want to display your current location, you can say "where am I" lol...
You could always use the voice recognition to change it..."fan speed 2"
Practically everything is accessible...there are even stuff that aren't listed in the manual. Like if you're in map mode and you're looking at the destination or some other location, and then you want to display your current location, you can say "where am I" lol...
#13
my acura sanctuary
Originally Posted by SoCaliTrojan
What do you mean? Having a separate dial for it?
BTW I have a 06 Non NAV and we get the fan speed button single button with UP/Down ^s.
#15
my acura sanctuary
Originally Posted by Tsx536
.... I think an 06 with a Hondata reflash with Icebox/Header/Hiflow cat would be a close to ideal setup.
I thought a Hiflow Cat was part of an aftermarket exhaust? you can do this without changing the exhaust. not looking to have something drown out my tunes or scarin babies is not my aim and bigger tips don't phase me.
so if moderate gains can be had and this is a simple bolt on, I'd consider it if it could be used with a stock exhaust on 06 MT with a reflash ofcourse
#16
Rep'n Taxbrain.com
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: N. Cali-forn-i-a
Age: 44
Posts: 7,075
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Originally Posted by subdued
Sorry for the newbeenessocity:
I thought a Hiflow Cat was part of an aftermarket exhaust? you can do this without changing the exhaust. not looking to have something drown out my tunes or scarin babies is not my aim and bigger tips don't phase me.
so if moderate gains can be had and this is a simple bolt on, I'd consider it if it could be used with a stock exhaust on 06 MT with a reflash ofcourse
I thought a Hiflow Cat was part of an aftermarket exhaust? you can do this without changing the exhaust. not looking to have something drown out my tunes or scarin babies is not my aim and bigger tips don't phase me.
so if moderate gains can be had and this is a simple bolt on, I'd consider it if it could be used with a stock exhaust on 06 MT with a reflash ofcourse
#19
Senior Moderator
I really don't think the wheel is any thicker than the 04/05. I made a point of testing that at the dealer a few weeks back and my hand wrapped around each equally. If it is thicker its really not by much at all. Altough those thicker sections at 10 and 2 are very nice.
#21
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Washington, DC
Age: 42
Posts: 851
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by fintracity
If they every come out with a s/c for an 06 I will seriously consider it
Decided I'm not gonna get one anyway. I only ever care about hp when I get caught up in the pissing match -- the TSX is plenty fast enough for me already.
#22
Rep'n Taxbrain.com
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: N. Cali-forn-i-a
Age: 44
Posts: 7,075
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Originally Posted by David Muny
How is that Valentine One treating you?
I really don't think the wheel is any thicker than the 04/05. I made a point of testing that at the dealer a few weeks back and my hand wrapped around each equally. If it is thicker its really not by much at all. Altough those thicker sections at 10 and 2 are very nice.
Just call a call from the dealership. The part didn't come in on time, so they're need to keep my car another day. This loaner is great and all, but I want my car back
Also, after driving someone I take back my statement saying that the Tanabe with my wheels/tires was very close to the stock ride comfort. I can tell that with the stock suspension the ride is definitely more "cushiony". It's not apparent on big bumps, but when you go a series of small bumps you can really tell.
Also, I'm pretty impressed with the amount of power that an 06 AT has. I had 5 people in the car today at lunch include a big ass 250 pound dude and the car still moved pretty well. I had to rev it up high to get moveing of course, but I don't mind.
#25
Originally Posted by jpt
...
I only ever care about hp when I get caught up in the pissing match -- the TSX is plenty fast enough for me already.
I only ever care about hp when I get caught up in the pissing match -- the TSX is plenty fast enough for me already.
#27
Racer
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Northern VA
Age: 44
Posts: 359
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by dom
I really don't think the wheel is any thicker than the 04/05. I made a point of testing that at the dealer a few weeks back and my hand wrapped around each equally. If it is thicker its really not by much at all. Altough those thicker sections at 10 and 2 are very nice.
I have a 2006 Steering Wheel with 18 miles on it for sale. I got the accessory metallic wheel at delivery that is why I am selling the OEM wheel.
2006 78501-SEC-A91ZA WHEEL, STEERING (LEATHER)
( GRAPHITE BLACK ) 2006 TSX 499.27
I am pretty sure it is interchangeable with 04/05 TSX's.
The 2004-2005 wheel is made of a lesser quality leather as well being thinner(2mm) and lacking reinforcements at 10 and 2 o'clock. The differences are reflected in its price.
78501-SDP-A51ZA WHEEL, STEERING
( GRAPHITE BLACK ) 2005 TSX 223.84
The rear finger grooves are cut different on the 2006, thus it feels noticeably thicker in many spots, and also the reinforcements at 10 and 2 are much thicker than other portions of the wheel.
If anyone is interested in the steering wheel, PM me, retail is $500, I am entertaining all mature offers..
#29
Intermediate
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: houston
Age: 50
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Tsx536
I think that mod combo would give the TSX about 25 whp and make the average TSX modder very happy with their car. For a serious modder that might want to drag race or visit the track then this setup might be lacking. But for someone who wants a car with a great balance of performance and good sound (not too quiet or loud) I think it would be close to ideal. There's enough mods there to give you that extra kick when you want to do some spirited driving, but still keep the car practical in terms of gas mileage, sound, comfort, and reliability. Your TSX wouldn't sound like a boy racers car but you would be able to take some of them if you encounter any
Do you have any feelings about how a SC will ultimately affect the long term reliability of your car? Also, have you though how re-sale might be affected?
#30
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Washington, DC
Age: 42
Posts: 851
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by fintracity
Do you have any feelings about how a SC will ultimately affect the long term reliability of your car? Also, have you though how re-sale might be affected?
As for reliability the biggest risk with the low-boost superchargers seen for the TSX so far is probably to the supercharger itself, and Comptech has been very good about standing behind their product, there's a thread somewhere about a few CTSCs that blew due to a design defect (bearings in the blower I believe) and Comptech replaced them free.
#31
Rep'n Taxbrain.com
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: N. Cali-forn-i-a
Age: 44
Posts: 7,075
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Originally Posted by fintracity
I also wonder what a SC would do to an 06 AT; probabaly a search item, but I also wonder what the basic installed cost of all of those mods would be vs SC installed costs - and how it compares dollar per HP.
Do you have any feelings about how a SC will ultimately affect the long term reliability of your car? Also, have you though how re-sale might be affected?
Do you have any feelings about how a SC will ultimately affect the long term reliability of your car? Also, have you though how re-sale might be affected?
Reflash $595
Random Tech Hi Flow Cat $295
Comptech Header $595
CAI Intake $205
Total $1690 (Labor Excluded) for about 15-25 whp
Comptech SC w/ SC reflash
Total $3650 (Labor Excluded) for about 50-55 whp
It's hard to really make a comparison without some dynos though. The power curves will also show a lot. Since the SC gives you close to max torque from 3K up, then that should probably be taken into account too.
In terms of reliability, I'm actually pretty confident in it with my car. I'm running a moderate boost, and I'm actually only boosting a small percentage of the time. It's when you try to start running high boost that causes more things to go wrong. I've had my SC on for about 15000 miles now and I recently heard of a S2000 owner who just reached 100,000 miles of Comptech SC ownership. Comptech gives a 3 year warranty with their SC, so that also helps.
In terms of resale, just like JPT said. It's a loss. Cars and mods are a bad investment. I will part out when I ready to sell, and I know that I would not get back full value for my mods. I went through this when I sold my modded civic, so it's no surprise to me. All my mods are purely for my own driving enjoyment.
#32
Have camera, will travel
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Federal Way, WA
Age: 63
Posts: 7,783
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Tsx536
All my mods are purely for my own driving enjoyment.
#33
Senior Moderator
Originally Posted by Tsx536
That's a good question. Here's a rough estimate
Reflash $595
Random Tech Hi Flow Cat $295
Comptech Header $595
CAI Intake $205
Total $1690 (Labor Excluded) for about 15-25 whp
Comptech SC w/ SC reflash
Total $3650 (Labor Excluded) for about 50-55 whp
It's hard to really make a comparison without some dynos though. The power curves will also show a lot. Since the SC gives you close to max torque from 3K up, then that should probably be taken into account too.
In terms of reliability, I'm actually pretty confident in it with my car. I'm running a moderate boost, and I'm actually only boosting a small percentage of the time. It's when you try to start running high boost that causes more things to go wrong. I've had my SC on for about 15000 miles now and I recently heard of a S2000 owner who just reached 100,000 miles of Comptech SC ownership. Comptech gives a 3 year warranty with their SC, so that also helps.
In terms of resale, just like JPT said. It's a loss. Cars and mods are a bad investment. I will part out when I ready to sell, and I know that I would not get back full value for my mods. I went through this when I sold my modded civic, so it's no surprise to me. All my mods are purely for my own driving enjoyment.
Reflash $595
Random Tech Hi Flow Cat $295
Comptech Header $595
CAI Intake $205
Total $1690 (Labor Excluded) for about 15-25 whp
Comptech SC w/ SC reflash
Total $3650 (Labor Excluded) for about 50-55 whp
It's hard to really make a comparison without some dynos though. The power curves will also show a lot. Since the SC gives you close to max torque from 3K up, then that should probably be taken into account too.
In terms of reliability, I'm actually pretty confident in it with my car. I'm running a moderate boost, and I'm actually only boosting a small percentage of the time. It's when you try to start running high boost that causes more things to go wrong. I've had my SC on for about 15000 miles now and I recently heard of a S2000 owner who just reached 100,000 miles of Comptech SC ownership. Comptech gives a 3 year warranty with their SC, so that also helps.
In terms of resale, just like JPT said. It's a loss. Cars and mods are a bad investment. I will part out when I ready to sell, and I know that I would not get back full value for my mods. I went through this when I sold my modded civic, so it's no surprise to me. All my mods are purely for my own driving enjoyment.
So any plans for more boost?
#34
Recovering SUV Addict...
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Pittsburgh
Age: 46
Posts: 204
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Resurrecting this thread...because I'm in the opposite situation now...
my new '06 has been in the shop for over a week now with paint issues (see my OEM Roof Visor thread), and they gave me an '05 with 9k miles on it...
I've gotta say, if I'd have driven an '05, I would not have purchased it. Granted this car is a Service Loaner that is probably rode pretty hard, I'm surprised in the difference between it and the '06. Now I see where all the complaints about the low end torque and accel from a stop come from. In my '06, I just have to press the gas pedal normally at a red light to accel, on the '05, I have to mash this sucker down.
And the steering wheel...the bumps on the '06 are sorely missed here, and it seems that the '05 wheel is thinner, and I don't like it. Also, I don't know if it's just in my mind or what, but the '06 seems to handle a bit tighter as well.
Overall, I'm disappointed with the '05, but I think most of it has to do with my comfort with the '06...but I'm pretty shocked at the differences being as pronounced as they are.
Before, with my '03 trailblazer, I drove an '05 and couldn't tell the difference at all, except for different molding on the airbag/horn and badge placement inside...but then again, when has GM actually refreshed a vehicle in a meaningful way?
my new '06 has been in the shop for over a week now with paint issues (see my OEM Roof Visor thread), and they gave me an '05 with 9k miles on it...
I've gotta say, if I'd have driven an '05, I would not have purchased it. Granted this car is a Service Loaner that is probably rode pretty hard, I'm surprised in the difference between it and the '06. Now I see where all the complaints about the low end torque and accel from a stop come from. In my '06, I just have to press the gas pedal normally at a red light to accel, on the '05, I have to mash this sucker down.
And the steering wheel...the bumps on the '06 are sorely missed here, and it seems that the '05 wheel is thinner, and I don't like it. Also, I don't know if it's just in my mind or what, but the '06 seems to handle a bit tighter as well.
Overall, I'm disappointed with the '05, but I think most of it has to do with my comfort with the '06...but I'm pretty shocked at the differences being as pronounced as they are.
Before, with my '03 trailblazer, I drove an '05 and couldn't tell the difference at all, except for different molding on the airbag/horn and badge placement inside...but then again, when has GM actually refreshed a vehicle in a meaningful way?
#35
Team Owner
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by Ronin317
Also, I don't know if it's just in my mind or what, but the '06 seems to handle a bit tighter as well.
Overall, I'm disappointed with the '05, but I think most of it has to do with my comfort with the '06...but I'm pretty shocked at the differences being as pronounced as they are.
Overall, I'm disappointed with the '05, but I think most of it has to do with my comfort with the '06...but I'm pretty shocked at the differences being as pronounced as they are.
#36
She said: it's GINORMOUS!
Originally Posted by Tsx536
They gave me a 06 AT/PWP/Navi as a loaner. I've been driving it like I stole it and I thought I would post some impressions.
#38
Still Lovin my 06
Originally Posted by Tsx536
I haven't paired my phone to it yet and not sure if I will since I don't have an owners manual. Is it hard to pair your phone and/or phonebook?
press the top phone button and say "phone setup" then it guides you through it.