ELS weak sound?
#1
Racer
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Toronto
Age: 44
Posts: 415
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
ELS weak sound?
How is everyone finding the ELS system? I find the clarity and spatial qualities to be very good but it's not very loud unless I crank the sound...especially the subwoofer...not really getting any thump. I'm wondering now if something was damaged when the dealer installed my backup sensors (which requires removing the rear-right speaker).
#2
Instructor
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Granite Bay, CA
Posts: 115
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Playing DVD-As is weak as you describe.
When I play normal CDs, I have to turn the volume down about 5 notches to attain the same volume level as DVD-As or FM. XM is in between.
I get the most bass from the CDs as well. XM is second, then DVD-A, FM last.
Just the way the system is built I assume...
When I play normal CDs, I have to turn the volume down about 5 notches to attain the same volume level as DVD-As or FM. XM is in between.
I get the most bass from the CDs as well. XM is second, then DVD-A, FM last.
Just the way the system is built I assume...
#3
Racer
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Toronto
Age: 44
Posts: 415
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by bobq
Playing DVD-As is weak as you describe.
When I play normal CDs, I have to turn the volume down about 5 notches to attain the same volume level as DVD-As or FM. XM is in between.
I get the most bass from the CDs as well. XM is second, then DVD-A, FM last.
Just the way the system is built I assume...
When I play normal CDs, I have to turn the volume down about 5 notches to attain the same volume level as DVD-As or FM. XM is in between.
I get the most bass from the CDs as well. XM is second, then DVD-A, FM last.
Just the way the system is built I assume...
Maybe that's why. I'll test out a few CDs over the weekend. Thanks!
#4
Burning Brakes
Originally Posted by Boon
How is everyone finding the ELS system? I find the clarity and spatial qualities to be very good but it's not very loud unless I crank the sound...especially the subwoofer...not really getting any thump. I'm wondering now if something was damaged when the dealer installed my backup sensors (which requires removing the rear-right speaker).
I don't really have that same issue as you, the DVD-A's I play are generally loud on level 6, some may require higher levels, just the way they were recorded at the studio. Same with the CDs...
#5
Originally Posted by mav238
I don't really have that same issue as you, the DVD-A's I play are generally loud on level 6, some may require higher levels, just the way they were recorded at the studio. Same with the CDs...
#6
Racer
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Toronto
Age: 44
Posts: 415
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by mav238
I don't really have that same issue as you, the DVD-A's I play are generally loud on level 6, some may require higher levels, just the way they were recorded at the studio. Same with the CDs...
#7
Intermediate
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: California
Age: 57
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Boon
I just tried the aux input using my Treo650 and that was plenty loud with tons of bass. It's really only the DVD-As that sound weak. The discs I've played are "The Beatles - Love", "Metallica - Black Album", and "Moist - Machine Punch Through". Just waiting on my Crystal Method disc to arrive (supposed to be a great demo disc) to really test it out.
Trending Topics
#8
I took a TL from my office for a spin the other day. Coming from the base RDX system...i must say the ELS truly dissapointed me. In terms of sound level...not much louder and or intense than the RDX. CD's sounded really good...but i dont know, i felt like something was lacking and/or this system has been so hyped up i was just expecting spectacular sound. I have not heard the ELS in the RDX however.
#9
Originally Posted by MMike1981
I took a TL from my office for a spin the other day. Coming from the base RDX system...i must say the ELS truly dissapointed me. In terms of sound level...not much louder and or intense than the RDX. CD's sounded really good...but i dont know, i felt like something was lacking and/or this system has been so hyped up i was just expecting spectacular sound. I have not heard the ELS in the RDX however.
IMO
You need to hear the RDX els system. I did get a TL for a loaner one day and it had the ELS system and it did not sound as good as the rdx.
#10
2016 MDX Adv/SHAWD
its just another radio without dvd-a in my opinion. i mean yea its nice, clean sound, but not spectacular until you really test it out with a dvd-a
#11
TX JD
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Dalworthington Gardens, TX
Age: 70
Posts: 40
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
The image processing of the ELS makes up for less than stellar speakers and amps. When I got my TL, the quality of the sound was amazing, but it certainly lacked the punch and clarity of my medium-priced aftermarket system in my Legend (still using the factory audio unit). Same for the RDX. For those of you who also notice this, keep in mind that the watt rating is not RMS but peak and is at 10% distortion at that rating. The 5 channel amp is about 6 X 8 X 2, so you can imagine the lack of quality. As for the stock speakers, the MSRP prices from Acura are $24.73 for the 4 door speakers, $21.28 for the 2 tweeters, $22.10 for the center, $25.48 for the 2 satellites and $236.62 for the sub unit which includes the 8" sub, plastic box and separate amp. In the base RDX, the sub and box costs $68.50 since there is no amp. I have pulled one of the door speakers and it is lightweight junk. I'm amazed it gets the sound it does. Imagine what some decent speakers and amps could do for this system. I am planning an upgrade and my first decision for the front door, tweeter and rear doors is between Boston Acoustics Pro60 or Focal 165V2. Any thoughts?
#13
We just recently got our 07 RDX. I spent some time tweaking the radio/regular CD sound quality as the sound lacks dynamics even compared to our 2000 TL.
I can't comment on the DVD-A sound as none of the local CD stores even sell DVD-A anymore (need to get it from the Net). Sound is muffled bass, lack highs, and generally very flat. CD's that sound good in our TL sounds dead in the RDX. So, i definitely wanna hear how DVDA sounds.
I can't comment on the DVD-A sound as none of the local CD stores even sell DVD-A anymore (need to get it from the Net). Sound is muffled bass, lack highs, and generally very flat. CD's that sound good in our TL sounds dead in the RDX. So, i definitely wanna hear how DVDA sounds.
#14
I'm not very technology savvy, so I may not be reading the original question right, but a friend of mine did some adjustments to my stereo system from the original neutral settings. With the changed settings, I do get more of the subwoofer thump.
#15
ELS in RDX is better
I traded an 06 TL for my RDX. I think the ELS system in the RDX is much stronger, better spatial presence and sound quality over the TL. I hear things on my DVD-As that I didn't in the TL. I have no problems with bass response. My iPod also sounds great, however I use Apple Lossless for all the rips.
I agree with the other poster about Dire Straits/Brothers In Arms. An excellent DVD-A. I also recommend Santana/Supernatural, Seal and Queen/Night At the Opera - if you can find it. 'Bohemian Rhapsody' is so over the top it will Change Your Life.
I agree with the other poster about Dire Straits/Brothers In Arms. An excellent DVD-A. I also recommend Santana/Supernatural, Seal and Queen/Night At the Opera - if you can find it. 'Bohemian Rhapsody' is so over the top it will Change Your Life.
#16
/etc/car
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Carlisle, PA
Age: 43
Posts: 646
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Extremely disappointed with the radio. The XM codec has its own flaws, but it still has high end...FM/AM does not. Aux or CD sounds fine.
FM is hopelessly dull. AM is so bad that it sounds like a telephone conversation with low end. The head unit does not offer RDS or IBOC (HD) either. Radio is not supposed to sound this bad.
AM is allowed to use 10khz of bandwidth. If you have an older tube-type receiver with a good speaker or a newer wideband receiver (like the GE Superadio II) you'll see a clear and marked difference in AM. In fact, I bet most people would think it was FM. The head unit sounds like it's cutting it off at 3-5khz. Telephones are 300hz-3khz.
FM uses 15khz of bandwidth. Our head unit sounds like it's rolling it off at 10khz or it's applying de-emphasis twice. It also sounds like it clips high end on a strong signal source....it would sound like light crackling coming from the tweeters on local stations (from which you wouldn't get static).
If that little stub on the roof is our antenna, it's insufficient to pull in a radio station. A decent size antenna for FM reception is just over 6 feet.....most use a different style which is 2.5 feet...and a window antenna makes a "T" shape with each leg just under 2.5 feet (it can wrap around). They probably use a pre-amp on the RF input which is stupid....because it amplifies the noise, too.
There also seems to be some sort of a "static eliminator" DSP in there. It will roll back the high end when the signal strength gets weak to try and avoid having you hear static.
I drove a 2007 accord....that unit had AMAZING reception, with the exception of that anti-static DSP which made distant stations sound flat.
FM is hopelessly dull. AM is so bad that it sounds like a telephone conversation with low end. The head unit does not offer RDS or IBOC (HD) either. Radio is not supposed to sound this bad.
AM is allowed to use 10khz of bandwidth. If you have an older tube-type receiver with a good speaker or a newer wideband receiver (like the GE Superadio II) you'll see a clear and marked difference in AM. In fact, I bet most people would think it was FM. The head unit sounds like it's cutting it off at 3-5khz. Telephones are 300hz-3khz.
FM uses 15khz of bandwidth. Our head unit sounds like it's rolling it off at 10khz or it's applying de-emphasis twice. It also sounds like it clips high end on a strong signal source....it would sound like light crackling coming from the tweeters on local stations (from which you wouldn't get static).
If that little stub on the roof is our antenna, it's insufficient to pull in a radio station. A decent size antenna for FM reception is just over 6 feet.....most use a different style which is 2.5 feet...and a window antenna makes a "T" shape with each leg just under 2.5 feet (it can wrap around). They probably use a pre-amp on the RF input which is stupid....because it amplifies the noise, too.
There also seems to be some sort of a "static eliminator" DSP in there. It will roll back the high end when the signal strength gets weak to try and avoid having you hear static.
I drove a 2007 accord....that unit had AMAZING reception, with the exception of that anti-static DSP which made distant stations sound flat.
#17
Sounds good to me...
I'm really enjoying the ELS system. With most radio, XM, or CD music it sounds like a very good stereo system - I think the center channel really adds something that most of my previous auto systems never had. I've found that classical music actually comes through the best from radio/XM.
With DVD, the sound is often amazing - the Beatles' Love is terrific and try Sting's Brand New Day: it'll blow you away with surround. Michael McDonald's Motown is also an excellent DVD, with great separation of all channels. Diana Krall didn't impress me, although it may have been the music more than the sound.
Most of the time I'm listening on volume level 6-10, depending on ambient noise (moonroof, etc.) - but I'm not into headbanging sound most of the time.
I've used the AUX with my MP3 (a Sansa), and for some reason the signal/sound level is VERY weak - I have to turn up the volume to 20+ to equal the same sound as 6-10 from other sources.
I could see eventually upgrading speakers slightly, but I would never complain about the factory system....
With DVD, the sound is often amazing - the Beatles' Love is terrific and try Sting's Brand New Day: it'll blow you away with surround. Michael McDonald's Motown is also an excellent DVD, with great separation of all channels. Diana Krall didn't impress me, although it may have been the music more than the sound.
Most of the time I'm listening on volume level 6-10, depending on ambient noise (moonroof, etc.) - but I'm not into headbanging sound most of the time.
I've used the AUX with my MP3 (a Sansa), and for some reason the signal/sound level is VERY weak - I have to turn up the volume to 20+ to equal the same sound as 6-10 from other sources.
I could see eventually upgrading speakers slightly, but I would never complain about the factory system....
#19
Originally Posted by neo1738
im especially happy now that i learned how to make regular .wav and .mp3 16-bit into dvd-a 24bit
I still, for the life of me, don't notice any sound quality increase in DVD-A. For me, the 'wow' factor comes purely from the 6 channel separation, not the increased data bandwidth....
Mike
#20
that's what my impression was borrowing my wife's new RDX tech
Originally Posted by pdphill
The image processing of the ELS makes up for less than stellar speakers and amps. When I got my TL, the quality of the sound was amazing, but it certainly lacked the punch and clarity of my medium-priced aftermarket system in my Legend (still using the factory audio unit). Same for the RDX. For those of you who also notice this, keep in mind that the watt rating is not RMS but peak and is at 10% distortion at that rating. The 5 channel amp is about 6 X 8 X 2, so you can imagine the lack of quality. As for the stock speakers, the MSRP prices from Acura are $24.73 for the 4 door speakers, $21.28 for the 2 tweeters, $22.10 for the center, $25.48 for the 2 satellites and $236.62 for the sub unit which includes the 8" sub, plastic box and separate amp. In the base RDX, the sub and box costs $68.50 since there is no amp. I have pulled one of the door speakers and it is lightweight junk. I'm amazed it gets the sound it does. Imagine what some decent speakers and amps could do for this system. I am planning an upgrade and my first decision for the front door, tweeter and rear doors is between Boston Acoustics Pro60 or Focal 165V2. Any thoughts?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
mlody
5G TLX (2015-2020)
85
12-04-2019 02:11 PM
DerrickW
3G TL Performance Parts & Modifications
9
11-15-2015 05:52 PM