High-pitched whine
#1
AcurAdmirer
Thread Starter
High-pitched whine
Anyone else have a high-pitched whining noise at 30-35 mph? It's faint, but definitely there. I thought at first it was like electrical interference coming through the radio, but it apparently isn't.
Not a huge deal, but I'm curious if anyone else hears it.
.
.
Not a huge deal, but I'm curious if anyone else hears it.
.
.
#2
wow - that sounds like the same thing that was on the RL - same speed range and sounds like coming from the radio
#3
Three Wheelin'
there is a high pitched noise that I get specifically when accelerating between 2nd and 3rd gear. But the noise I hear is most definitely an external engine sound as it's specific to RPM and still occurs even with all the electronics/radio off.
From what I've been able to tell, it's sounds specific to one of the fans in the engine when it gets to a very specific RPM. The sound is very mechanical and almost akin to a very small jet turbine engine. It quickly disappears after I reach above 3rd gear.
Not sure if this is what you're talking about it. I'll check tomorrow to see if mine comes in at the speeds your describing.
From what I've been able to tell, it's sounds specific to one of the fans in the engine when it gets to a very specific RPM. The sound is very mechanical and almost akin to a very small jet turbine engine. It quickly disappears after I reach above 3rd gear.
Not sure if this is what you're talking about it. I'll check tomorrow to see if mine comes in at the speeds your describing.
#4
Instructor
there is a high pitched noise that I get specifically when accelerating between 2nd and 3rd gear. But the noise I hear is most definitely an external engine sound as it's specific to RPM and still occurs even with all the electronics/radio off.
From what I've been able to tell, it's sounds specific to one of the fans in the engine when it gets to a very specific RPM. The sound is very mechanical and almost akin to a very small jet turbine engine. It quickly disappears after I reach above 3rd gear.
Not sure if this is what you're talking about it. I'll check tomorrow to see if mine comes in at the speeds your describing.
From what I've been able to tell, it's sounds specific to one of the fans in the engine when it gets to a very specific RPM. The sound is very mechanical and almost akin to a very small jet turbine engine. It quickly disappears after I reach above 3rd gear.
Not sure if this is what you're talking about it. I'll check tomorrow to see if mine comes in at the speeds your describing.
has anyone had the dealer evaluate this and offer a solution?
#5
Grandpa
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Virginia, Besieged
Age: 68
Posts: 7,596
Received 2,609 Likes
on
1,475 Posts
It's not disturbing me too much yet and I haven't done anything about it, but I can definitely hear it! :-)
I wondered like original poster whether it was coming from the Krell Audio, but I haven't investigated thoroughly.
The audio system feeds back a very nice sounding engine noise when engaging in certain activities. That's what it was designed to do, so to me it seems not beyond all conjecture that it is a slight feedback problem.
4900 miles now and still 50% oil life, so it'll still be a while before I get to the dealer to complain about it. It doesn't bother me enough to make a fuss but you are right...it is there!
#6
Three Wheelin'
personally I think it's the same injection fan that causes the "clacking" sound when the engine is running completely idle that's also making this high-pitched whistle/whine. I complained about this noise early on when I got my RLX as to me it sounds like an old engine with bad cyclinders and/or out of oil. The Service Center said it was the injection fan that I'm referring to and nothing could be done about it.
The injection fan follows the RPM, and if it's making that much noise at idle, then it's definitely going to make noise when it fires up and hits higher RPMs. Since it's only occuring at specific RPM's, then that's usually indication of a bad design / flaw in the rotation/oscillation of the fan at various RPMs
The injection fan follows the RPM, and if it's making that much noise at idle, then it's definitely going to make noise when it fires up and hits higher RPMs. Since it's only occuring at specific RPM's, then that's usually indication of a bad design / flaw in the rotation/oscillation of the fan at various RPMs
Last edited by holografique; 03-06-2014 at 10:59 AM.
#7
Grandpa
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Virginia, Besieged
Age: 68
Posts: 7,596
Received 2,609 Likes
on
1,475 Posts
I've been driving some kind of Honda since 1989.
To be honest, they've always had some engine noise that can be surprising if you've come to Honda from an American engine with hydraulic lifters.
Injector noise, sure. Valve clatter, sure. That's just what Hondas do. My B motors did it, my K motors did it, and all my J motors did it, even the RLX J Motor.
But, I've never even heard of an injector fan. LOL.... That's a new one on me.
To be honest, they've always had some engine noise that can be surprising if you've come to Honda from an American engine with hydraulic lifters.
Injector noise, sure. Valve clatter, sure. That's just what Hondas do. My B motors did it, my K motors did it, and all my J motors did it, even the RLX J Motor.
But, I've never even heard of an injector fan. LOL.... That's a new one on me.
Trending Topics
#9
Grandpa
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Virginia, Besieged
Age: 68
Posts: 7,596
Received 2,609 Likes
on
1,475 Posts
About 150 miles yesterday, and I didn't notice it a single time!
#11
Instructor
What the heck is an injector fan?! Never heard of such a thing.
By the way, I don't have the krell audio system, and I have the whistle/whine sound. Don't think it has anything to do with audio system. When i noticed it, I shut off the audio and heard it clearly between 2500-3000 rpms.
By the way, I don't have the krell audio system, and I have the whistle/whine sound. Don't think it has anything to do with audio system. When i noticed it, I shut off the audio and heard it clearly between 2500-3000 rpms.
#12
The Injector Fan is used to spread the magic HondaDust™ throughout the intake system and it provides improved economy and power.
#13
This TSB explains the body plugs under the car that contribute to wind noise. I wonder if that is what you might be hearing. Mine were missing so I am taking into the dealer to install them. This is explained in the TSB TQI(total quality inspection) instructions that are used before delivering a car to the customer.
"
Install the Body Plugs
Install the four body plugs that are stored in the license
plate holder bag (in the trunk) as shown. If the body
plugs are not installed, the vehicle may have a difficult to-
diagnose wind noise.
#15
AcurAdmirer
Thread Starter
Actually, there is such a thing as injector fans. They direct cooling air over the fuel injectors. I don't know if our cars have them or not, though.
.
.
.
.
#16
#17
#18
Three Wheelin'
This TSB explains the body plugs under the car that contribute to wind noise. I wonder if that is what you might be hearing. Mine were missing so I am taking into the dealer to install them. This is explained in the TSB TQI(total quality inspection) instructions that are used before delivering a car to the customer.
"
Install the Body Plugs
Install the four body plugs that are stored in the license
plate holder bag (in the trunk) as shown. If the body
plugs are not installed, the vehicle may have a difficult to-
diagnose wind noise.
"
Install the Body Plugs
Install the four body plugs that are stored in the license
plate holder bag (in the trunk) as shown. If the body
plugs are not installed, the vehicle may have a difficult to-
diagnose wind noise.
The whole "injection fan" thing was specific to the "rattling" "clanking" sound that the engine makes when running full idle. I'll take a video of it and post it later so that it's clear what I'm talking about. the Service Center was the one that told me the noise was caused by an "injection fan". I'm not claiming to know what or if this is true, but that's what they told me. I only commented on this "injection fan" as it may be the same oscillating device that's causing the high-pitched whine that occurs between 30-35Mph.
#19
That's not the same issue. This issue directly follows the RPM of the engine when throttling through 30-35Mph and then immediately disappears. It's definitely a mechanically driven sound that is occurring as a result of something oscillating at high-speeds in the engine. Like I said previously, it sounds almost like a jet-turbine engine for the brief seconds that it appears.
The whole "injection fan" thing was specific to the "rattling" "clanking" sound that the engine makes when running full idle. I'll take a video of it and post it later so that it's clear what I'm talking about. the Service Center was the one that told me the noise was caused by an "injection fan". I'm not claiming to know what or if this is true, but that's what they told me. I only commented on this "injection fan" as it may be the same oscillating device that's causing the high-pitched whine that occurs between 30-35Mph.
The whole "injection fan" thing was specific to the "rattling" "clanking" sound that the engine makes when running full idle. I'll take a video of it and post it later so that it's clear what I'm talking about. the Service Center was the one that told me the noise was caused by an "injection fan". I'm not claiming to know what or if this is true, but that's what they told me. I only commented on this "injection fan" as it may be the same oscillating device that's causing the high-pitched whine that occurs between 30-35Mph.
#20
Three Wheelin'
anyways...
woropallo - I did not get the "issue" fixed per say. I eventually attributed it to the ANC system of the RLX and just accepted it for what it is.
What I did end up exhibiting longer term (and still have the issue) is the engine "chirping" noise that is addressed and discussed in TSB 14-025 "Timing Belt Chirp". It becomes less prevalent in winter and gets ALOT louder during warmer temperatures. I'll probably request to have it done during my next service.
Im curious to know more about this "actuator" problem. Is there a TSB for this? Thanks for sharing your experience and info on it.
Another annoying "noise" issue that was never properly resolved by Acura is the A/C moaning issue, which is very loud and also a "whistle" like sound that you can hear at all various RPM's emanating from the middle area of the dashboard. It was supposed to be fixed by TSB 13-026 "A/C Moans from the Engine", which I had performed on my RLX last year but the issue came back a week or so later. I have yet to try the DIY fix that was posted by a user somewhere on here, but honestly I dont have the time nor should I have to fix it myself with this type of car/price.
Last edited by holografique; 03-17-2015 at 08:01 PM.
#21
funny going back and looking at the attempts on this thread to make an ass out of me over something that actually does exist. And sales reps wonder why they get a bad rap sometimes. Maybe they should learn to trust and listen to their loyal customers a bit more...
anyways...
woropallo - I did not get the "issue" fixed per say. I eventually attributed it to the ANC system of the RLX and just accepted it for what it is.
What I did end up exhibiting longer term (and still have the issue) is the engine "chirping" noise that is addressed and discussed in TSB 14-025 "Timing Belt Chirp". It becomes less prevalent in winter and gets ALOT louder during warmer temperatures. I'll probably request to have it done during my next service.
Im curious to know more about this "actuator" problem. Is there a TSB for this? Thanks for sharing your experience and info on it.
anyways...
woropallo - I did not get the "issue" fixed per say. I eventually attributed it to the ANC system of the RLX and just accepted it for what it is.
What I did end up exhibiting longer term (and still have the issue) is the engine "chirping" noise that is addressed and discussed in TSB 14-025 "Timing Belt Chirp". It becomes less prevalent in winter and gets ALOT louder during warmer temperatures. I'll probably request to have it done during my next service.
Im curious to know more about this "actuator" problem. Is there a TSB for this? Thanks for sharing your experience and info on it.
#22
Three Wheelin'
hmmm, interesting. That's the P-AWS Actuator TSB, which I also had done early on and that is resolved for me. That issue also only cropped up during extremely slow speeds (5-10mph parking lot hunting speed). Interesting to see that you experienced it at somewhat faster speeds. I'm guessing maybe something more specific to the 2015 models...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post